Robby's Baking Therapy #18 Brownie Cake
Hello, every birdie. Oh boy. This recipe is definitely a memorable one. But before I start telling you about the recipe I want to tell you about my family. Just so that everyone involved doesn’t get confused.
I come from a large family. It consists of my parents, mom & pop. Yes, for some reason I call my dad pop instead. Coke is reserved for soda, even at a Pepsi-only place. I have 4 brothers. Yes 4 of them. In order from oldest to youngest, they are Ben, Noah, David, and Isaac. I am in order of age I would be between Noah and David. Then there is the “baby” of the house, my sister Sarah.
Okay, now that we have the names down I will present to you the biggest meltdown I have had in 2022.
For Noah’s birthday cake he told me that he wanted basically a Peanut butter and Jelly cake sandwiched between two brownies, that were shaped like cakes. Because he liked my brownies.
I agree with this. Forgetting one important factor. Brownie batter is different than cake batter.
For the Brownie batter, I used the Cooky Book from Betty Crocker for this recipe. This was probably another reason why this recipe didn’t really work. This was only my second time making this recipe.
The recipe and measurements will be down in the description below.
The ingredients you will need are:
After you have all of your ingredients together, you are going to preheat your oven to 350℉.
Next, you are going to mix together your shortening, sugar, eggs, and vanilla until they are all well combined.
In a separate bowl, you are going to mix together your dry ingredients. That includes your flour, cocoa, baking powder, and salt. And this mixture to the sugar-egg mixture.
Because I was planning on layer these I doubled it. So that it would fit two 9-inch cake pans. I baked it for 25-30 minutes. If you are using the standard 9x13 baking pan, then bake it for 30 minutes.
While that was baking, I attempted to make my frosting and filling. For the frosting, I made a peanut butter frosting.
I wasn’t using it in the recipe for this, I was kind of just winging it. I used Peanut butter, granulated sugar, a little margarine, and a little shortening. And I mixed them together. Added vanilla extract to it. And it tasted really good. Not too sweet, but didn’t really look like ABC- American Buttercream. I was perfectly fine with that because I don’t really care much for it. It is because of the focus point and not the cake.
When I got down with the frosting I put it in the fridge and took out the brownies from the oven. And let them sit on the table in the pins for 15 minutes.
While they were cooling I worked on the fruit filling. We had nectarines and strawberries in our house. So I made a “fast” compote. Cut them both up, put water and sugar into a pot and a little bit of cornstarch, and waited until this mixture thickened.
Once it had thickened I transferred it to a different bowl and let it set in the fridge for a while. That was fine because the brownies were not ready to frost. They were still slightly warm.
The brownies were removed from the cake pans, and they sat on a cooling rack for 30 minutes. And then wrapped with plastic wrap and put in the freezer for somewhere between 30 minutes to 1 hour.
After the brownies were completely done. I started frosting. Everything was going well. Or so I thought. I was trying to make sure that none of the fruit fillings was going to seep out.
Oh boy! This next step happened in both 5x speed and .0005 speed.
I went to put the top layer on and it seemed like it was going to work. But then… It split, in two. Right down the middle.
Oh my gosh. I started crying. I didn’t know what to do. I yelled for my mom because I had no idea what to do. My brain was not really working properly. I was having an extreme meltdown. Saying that I was a failure. Nothing ever works right.
Thankfully, my mom and my youngest brother; Isaac, were there with me. Making sure that I knew that I wasn’t a failure. My mom was there just trying to think about how to save this cake. And then Isaac remember a video from “How to Cook that” where this exact thing happened. She tells the person to make it into a trifle. And so that is what we did.
We have a pretty container, that we use for cranberry sauce at Thanksgiving. Mom cleaned it out, and we ended up making it look good. And thankfully, Noah was a sport about it. Understanding that things happen.
This recipe is probably going to stay with all of us for as long as we live. We are going to be like “remember the brownie meltdown of 2022.” Obviously, I am going to be laughing about this too. At the time it was not funny at all. But now, I think my reaction to this was kinda over the top.
I debated on if I should share this recipe with you all. And I decided that I would share it with you all for one reason, to make sure that we all know that baking is a science. Sometimes we are going to succeed in the experiment and sometimes we are going to fail. Failure when baking is not a bad thing. It happens, and as my family says “we don’t really care what it looks like, as long as it’s edible.”
And yes, as a baker that statement is hard to hear. Because you are spending hours wanting this thing to look good and you end up with something that doesn’t look good. You feel like you have wasted your time or even your day. But you didn’t do either. You spent your time working on something that your loved one, your friend, or your colleague would like.
So don’t give up on baking if you fail one or two times. It is okay and you are not a failure. You have to keep trying. And be the scientist that a baker is. A little after you have made the dessert think back to it. Analysis of what steps you might have missed, or gotten wrong. And then if you want to make the dessert again just add adjustments.
Thank you for liking and following. Feel free to check out the recipe down below. See you in the next recipe.
YOU ARE NOT A FAILURE! BAKING/COOKING IS SCIENCE! HAVE FUN!
Show the original author some 💖💖💖 Robby's Cookbook Collection
Here is a printable version of this recipe: on the blog
Please help me get a phone: by supporting me on Kofi / Patreon