Part of me feels like Jean Auel’s Earths Children series is a cautionary tale- directed at those in power in modern human society, mainly men. Yes the clan were “backwards” in a sense, but they also were closer to the earth and “die” with the Earth Mother bc they don’t receive the “gift of knowledge” as AMH do. But that gift that Ayla receives also leads to the subjugation of women, coming full circle back to the “backwardness” that the clan displayed. The clan is a reflection of the bad direction modern humanity has taken. It’s stated that at one point in the distant past the clan acknowledged women’s spiritual power, but that time had passed and now men subjugated women to keep their spiritual power in check. In a way, the clan used their knowledge to go backward, which humans today are also in danger of doing. Ayla is the messenger that there are two paths humanity can take. One of enlightenment and one of ignorance. But we are given the tools to choose while the clan were not, and they die out. The clan die out bc they refuse to change. Humanity today will die out the same way unless we become more enlightened.
@fan-of-the-cave-bear I would love to know your thoughts on this!
First things first, I'm so sorry it took me so long to see this! Thank you so much for tagging me! :) Anyway, on to my thoughts.
I really like your perspective on this, especially since Jean wrote these right off the tail of second wave feminism, which as a wife and mother at that time, was certainly thinking about these things.
I really like your point about Ayla's gift, I don't know if you meant her "gift of knowledge" in general or even her revelation about men being integral to the creation of children. I personally see Ayla's gift more as an ability to change rather than knowledge itself, as the Clan quite literally has too much knowledge. The difference is that they can't innovate or use anything they learn.
You can see towards the end of LoPC that men are ALREADY starting to question if they have to care about a child in their family if it might not be theirs biologically. You can already see what ignorance does to people. (to be clear they do have 'knowledge' of biological fatherhood now, but ignorance about what that means emotionally.)
The Clan being very strictly patriarchal is shown to be THE reason that the clan has been stunted, they literally cannot evolve, change, or grow to keep up with the Others. They say in the very beginning of CotCB that men and women of the Clan literally cannot live day to day life without each other, precisely because men have gone on so long not doing, "women's skills" that they are now incapable.
It's not hard to draw a parallel between that and men that call taking care of their own children "babysitting", or being incapable of taking care of their home when the wife is unable. Even the fact that the Clan men have a ritual to beg the spirits for a new home at the start which is forbidden for the women to see, purely because it would show that the men are not all powerful, proving that the entire system is fragile and ultimately made up (by the men).
I see the Clan as a cautionary tale against traditional values being held above change. Even if it is for the better, they are scared of change, because they literally can't do it.
It's reminiscent of how many things are upheld in today's society that are plain wrong or even hurtful to people, just because, "We've always done it like that."





















