I dunno if you ever played Fire Emblem but if you have, has you seen the character Leda from FE Fortune's Weave? People online were saying that she resembles a Spanish Romani dancer and the game itself has a lot of Spanish influence.
Her dance in one of the trailers from 10 months ago had her dancing Flamenco apparently
https://www.reddit.com/r/fireemblem/comments/1u29bhn/leda_is_clearly_a_15th16th_century_spanish_romani/?show=original
I do play Fire Emblem! I haven't played any of the older games outside of the Tellius saga, but I've been actively following the series since Awakening. I love Three Houses and I'm really excited for Fortune's Weave, although I don't know if or when I'm going to be able to afford a Switch 2.
I noticed Leda right away, and I definitely think she may have been inspired by Spanish Romani culture to some degree. So far, the setting of Fortune's Weave seems to be based on various parts of Mediterranean Europe and North Africa. The map contains references to Aragon and Castile, implying that those regions may be pulling from Medieval Spain. Leda plays a vihuela, which is a Spanish string instrument from the 15th century. Obviously, early Romani arrivals in Europe are not very well-documented, but the diaspora most likely entered the Iberian Peninsula sometime in the 15h century as well. So, Leda is a traveling musician with Spanish cultural influence from around the right time period, and she's clearly designed as a person of color with brown skin. I think it's very reasonable to assume that she's gitana. As a person of gitano heritage myself, I'm obviously excited, but also nervous.
Fire Emblem is no stranger to Orientalism. These tropes and archetypes show up most often in exotic desert settings, as well as character classes such as the Dancer, Songstress, or Bard, which can easily overlap with gypsy tropes as well. Leda's design doesn't really read as flamenco to me, and I do think it's leaning into the usual Dancer/Songstress tropes. If I had to guess, I'd say a lot of the people who are assuming this character is Roma are responding to that imagery and conflating it with gypsy archetypes more than anything else. That doesn't mean they're wrong, but I think the conversations that are happening online are kind of irresponsible-- I keep seeing her being compared to la Esmeralda from the Disney Hunchback.
Because the Romani are uniquely diasporic and autochthonic, it is difficult to truly represent us in fantasy settings without the necessary context for the formation of our ethnicity and culture. It's especially frustrating when we're treated as a monolith, without any consideration for the fact that each vitsa has its own identity and history. That said, I do think that CalΓ© gitano culture, in particular, is really endemic to Spain and entwined with Spanish culture as a whole. In that sense, we may be one of the easier groups to represent, as long as you find a way to acknowledge that we are a racial minority that has contributed a lot to a country and a land where we aren't always treated fairly-- but that's going to require a lot more effort than "Esmeralda with a Spanish guitar."


















