Double Penalty
Pairing: Mike Webster x fem!reader
Summary: As you deal with the aftermath of your encounter with Mike, you two clash again. And how else to solve your differences than by a long and thorough⌠power exchange.
Word count: 2.5k
Warnings: DARK CONTENT, MDNI, minors and ageless do not interact, NSFW, explicit, rape/NON-CON, non-consent, dead dove do not eat, no physical description of the reader, mentions of female genitalia, AFAB reader, she/her pronouns used, degrading language, p in v, unprotected, creampie, praise kink, spitting, oral (f receiving), first draft, no beta, not proofread
DO NOT READ IF UNCOMFORTABLE WITH WARNINGS
I will delete/block all hate comments and tags. If you don't like the content, don't read it and feel free to block me. I am not responsible for the content you consume.
Notes: Continuation of Penalty, but can be read separately. I also have a rough idea for a third chapter.
Mike watched you wiping your tears from across the field, your teammates consoling you a little. At first, you tried lying, saying itâs the sun, the migraine, the period, but your friends knew better. He knew better. Mike gripped his clipboard, a frown marking his face. He hated seeing you like this. Against his better judgment, he decided to come closer.
âYou said it yourself, babes,â your best friend had her arm around you, moving tear-soaked strands from your face, âhe never wanted to fuck you. Itâs important, you know it is.â
You just nodded, that pain half-laugh momentarily escaping your mouth.
âI just didnât think it would hurt this bad,â you mumbled, trying not to burst into another crying fit. âWeâve been together for so long, and otherwise he was perf-â
âNo. Fuck no,â your friend immediately interrupted. âYour needs were not met. And you donât owe him a relationship just because he didnât force fuck you when you were tired or sick. And didnât you say that even when you did manage to do the nasty, heâd only cum jerking off? Come on, you owe yourself someone better.â
Mike had to admit, he wholeheartedly agreed. Someone better, how nicely put. Him.
âStop clucking,â Mike growled at you two, waving at your friend to get lost.
âCoach, no, please, sheâs really not-,â she tried, she really tried standing her ground for you, but you knew it was futile.
âDonât make me fucking tell you again.â
With that, she mouthed a pitiful sorry at you and made herself scarce. You wiped your tears, tried to fix your hair a little. You could have carried on with your relationship, pretending nothing happened, not provoke Mike anymore and then think of him every time your boyfriend managed to get his dick up for you.
Except you couldnât, for two reasons. First being that Mike wouldnât stop, provoked or not. Second, you werenât sure you wanted him to stop. The guilt was eating at you, absolutely, but there was also something freeing about the whole situation that Mike forced on you.
âIâm sorry, Coach,â you mumbled, your eyes momentarily drifting to his.
Mike didnât say anything, his expression unreadable. And then, just as you wanted to do more drills, he grabbed your face, holding your chin between his thumb and index finger, the rest of his long fingers pressing into your throat.
The reaction in you was immediate: breath hitching, heart beating, palms sweating⌠And pussy wetting.
Mike was looking at you from behind his glasses like he wanted to eat you or drag you into the locker room to fuck the tears out of you. Instead, his lips curved into a rather smug smile.
âGood girl,â he whispered, sending another pleasurable jolt through you.
It didnât take long for him to start screaming at you again when, not even forty-five minutes later, you kept missing your free kicks. Literally all of them would go wide over the net, not even close to the beam.
âStop over-extending your fucking leg!â Mike yelled, already halfway to you, watching you fumble yet another kick. âThese are rookie fucking kicks, what the fuck are you doing?â
You could hear him working himself into another hoarse throat situation, straining his vocal cords to the maximum. Not that you werenât frustrated with yourself and your lack of follow-through and precision, mangling something that usually came with such ease to you. You felt pathetic. You were pathetic.
Even your teammates were at a loss for words, probably ascribing your lack of performance to your temporary emotional upset. You just wanted Mike to stop screaming at you, because if he managed to get you in your usual state, you knew you wouldnât be able to keep your mouth shut.
âWhat now, Micha-,â you cut yourself off in the middle of the yell, swallowing the rest of his government name, reminding yourself he asked you not to use it.Â
âOther goal,â Mike growled, staring daggers at you. âNow.â
Just what you needed, spending the rest of the practice running drills with Mike. Alone.
âThis is all your fault,â you spat out bitterly, watching Mikeâs knuckles turn white and the clipboard caving under his grasp.
âShut. Up. Fucking brat.â
It wasnât that bad, actually, once you cooled off. Well, partially at least, still pressing your jaw shut, feeling the burn in your calf after repeated shots. You were tired, sweaty, and frustrated, and more tears threatened to burst out of you any second now. Luckily, the coach called the whistle, but before you even blinked in that direction, Mike crowded you.
Standing in front of you, making sure no one could see you from that side of the field, his eyes quickly darted around to see if anyone was paying attention.
Then, he turned back to you, brows furrowed, jaw clenched, and that flush spreading all over his face and neck.
âFrom now on, you will keep your mouth shut. You donât talk back, and you donât speak when I speak. Got it, angel?â his voice dropped on the last word to a throaty whisper.
You noticed how big his pupils were and how his lower left eyelid twitched. Mike took a step towards you, your nose almost touching his chest. Your breathing deepened again, and you looked up at him, wondering what he had on his mind.
âOpen your mouth,â Mike whispered, his voice making you tremble.Â
You had no idea what he wanted, but you obeyed. Slowly, you relaxed your jaw, eyes still trained on Mikeâs.Â
âMore,â he mumbled, his eyes falling to your lips, watching your tensed tongue resting behind your teeth.
When he was finally happy, he spat in your mouth without a warning. Wet warmth spread across your tongue, drops landing over your lips and around them.Â
Sharply inhaling through your nose, your eyes fluttered shut, overwhelmed and aroused.
âEvery time you open your mouth,â he watched you swallow every last drop, your tongue greedily dragging across your lips, âremember that only good girls get this.â
âYes, Coach,â your eyes were still closed, the musky scent of Mikeâs sweat still reaching your nose.
âOff you go then.â
**
âYou okay?â your teammates rallied around you in the locker room, some faces concerned, some curious, some rather smug.
âHm? Yeah, of course,â you dismissed them, but they still prodded.
âWhy did he grab your face like that?â one voice asked, and you couldnât really pinpoint who brought it up.Â
âHe did what?â another voice piped up, and suddenly everyone was crowding around you like you were a wise old grandmother telling a scary story to a bunch of wide-eyed children.
âUghh,â you growled, irritated to the bone. âI just struck a nerve, and he lost it a little. Whatâs new, right?â you laughed it off, putting on your best nonchalant face, shrugging.Â
The voices started again, everyone talking over each other, and not even your friend could tell them off. Clucking, as Mike said, was the correct word. You pinched the bridge of your nose, trying to breathe.
âAll right!â you finally yelled. âI get it, this is obviously taking too much attention from the game and the team. âI promiseâŚâ your eyes drifted from face to face, and then you looked at your captain, a woman you expected much more of than to allow these verbal offences, âthat I will set all my differences aside and talk to Mike. And now, if you excuse me, I need to cry a little bit more.â
It worked, their excitement immediately dropped in disappointment that you wouldnât trash Mike some more. You suddenly felt stupid for even doing so; venting in the locker room was common, but this personal beef you and Mike had for literal years had obviously been nothing but entertainment.Â
No one cared how much you suffered when his comments started, no one cared about your problems and issues; you were nothing but a class clown, a court jester. It washed over you, the wave of realisation, followed by sadness, disappointment, and emptiness.
You took a deep breath. No more.
**
It was two in the morning, and you were still tossing and turning, trying to sleep. Mike still hasnât kept up with his promise, and you started to believe he only said it in the heat of the moment.Â
Pulling your eye mask down your face, you turned around, happy that at least you didnât feel like crying anymore. And then you heard it, a beep and a door creak, but you still decided to pretend you were asleep, deep breathing and all.
Mike laid down next to you, gently, his arm enveloping you, immediately settling between your tits, before grabbing one.
âYou smell so good, angel,â he whispered against your neck, inhaling deeply. He was hard already, again, pressing his cock against your ass.
You finally stirred, trying to reach for your mask, but Mike caught your wrist.
âLeave it on,â he chuckled, his lips dragging over the strained muscles of your neck, enjoying the warmth of your skin.Â
âIâm gonna make you so happy, angel, I know I can,â Mike cooed, pushing his tongue in your slightly open mouth, teasing a breathy moan out of you.
âYes, Coach,â you mumbled between sloppy kisses, your hands dragging Mike closer and closer, until he was on top of you.
And then he started moaning, deep, throaty sounds that sent little jolts through your whole body, pooling heat directly in your pussy, tiny little spasms shocking their way through your abdomen.Â
His fingers, extended, drew a line starting at your throat, going lower, playing with your nipple, and even lower, slowly dragging over the thin fabric of your tank top, until he reached your panties, an obvious wet spot blooming.
He teased you through the soft cotton, his fingers pushing in a little, then dragging all the way up towards your clit, then back down again; you arched your back into Mike, begging in your mind for him to just move your panties to the side and stick his cock back in, and stay like that until morning, fuck you into the mattress.
âDid you wear these for me?â he teased, his fingers playing with the bow on your panties and sliding over the lacy parts.
âYes, Coach,â you whispered, enjoying the way his tongue dragged over your throat, your heart hitching even higher at the vibrations his chuckle made against your sweaty skin.Â
âGood girl.â
And then he slid lower, his lips leaving sticky wet kisses on your collarbone; somehow he managed to pull off your tanktop without disturbing the mask, his mouth immediately closing around your nipple, his teeth grazing it.
He grabbed both of your tits, pressing and massaging, and you couldnât do anything but moan, enjoying how much Mike wanted you.
âSo pretty when youâre so needy,â he breathed out, going lower and lower, until he reached your panties. Mike started sucking and teasing your clit through the fabric.
Your whole body writhed in pleasure as you reflexively pushed your hips towards Mikeâs mouth.
âLet me hear you, angel,â he mumbled, hastily removing your panties too, guiding both of your legs over his shoulders. He gently pushed one finger inside you, then the second one too, laughing at how greedily your pussy swallowed them.Â
You whimpered, jerking your hips, when he tried to push the third one.
âI know, angel, I know,â he cooed, âbut we need to stretch you properly, donât we? It barely fit the last time.â
He returned his attention to your clit, goading you towards the orgasm, feeling how your pussywalls started to tense and flutter around his fingers, listening to how your moans fell into needy whimpers; your hand grabbed his hair, and Mike couldnât help himself but moan against your pussy.
âYou taste so fucking good, angel, I canât get enough,â he mumbled, his thumb now drawing tight little circles over your clit.Â
âMike,â you moaned, overwhelmed, immediately biting your tongue. For a moment, you got scared heâd punish you, especially now since you were so close, that knot in your stomach threatening to explode.
âGood girl,â Mike moaned against your mound. âMy good girl.â
When he felt you coming, he immediately lowered his head, greedily lapping up your juices as your body trembled in the best orgasm of your life. You had no idea how loud you were or what exactly you were saying, so thoroughly overwhelmed and overstimulated. But Mike wasnât finished with you, far from it.
As your body relaxed, he pulled out his fingers, sucking on them, watching as your pussy glistened. You whined a little at a loss, but he replaced it with his cock soon enough, your legs still draped over his broad shoulders.
In one quick thrust, he pushed in and folded you up, hitting deeper than before. It was still a stretch, his big, fat cock spearing you in half. You whined in pleasure, begging Mike to fuck you hard.
âFuck, angel, I canât even think,â Mike kept snapping his hips, barely delaying his own pleasure to watch your tits bounce up and down and feel your nails against his skin. You lost all sense of time, tasting yourself repeatedly on Mikeâs tongue, your hands pulling at his hair and drawing blood on his shoulders, as you kept begging and begging.
âTell me youâre close,â Mike whispered, âbecause I want to flood your pussy so badly.â
âNo, Coach,â you mumbled in response, âIâm sorry.â
âOh, my poor baby angel,â he teased a little, âhow about you take that mask off, let me see those pretty eyes, hm?â
âPlease come into my mouth,â you begged, finally looking at Mikeâs flushed, sweaty face.
âWhat?â his hips stuttered, slowing down.
âI want to taste you, please,â you pulled him in another desperate kiss.
Mike tried, he really wanted to indulge you, but before your lips even touched, he started coming with long, hoarse grunts, his mind and body overcome by the amount of your desire for him. You could feel it, Mike emptying his balls, the hot sticky seed spilling in you, dripping out of you.
âIâm sorry, angel,â Mike mumbled, falling forward after freeing your legs from his feverish hold. âNext time, I promise.â His lips went back to the same spot where they were the last time, just behind your ear, as he started to suck tiny bruises into your skin.Â
You groaned.
âTell me I donât have to wait three to five business days again. Didnât you boast every night, angel, I want you to come around my cock every night?â you mocked him, imitating his manner of speech.
âBehave,â he breathed, somewhat amused.
âYeah, yeah,â you countered, rolling your eyes and pouting.Â
You could still feel his cum dripping out of you, sticking you two together, his hot breath on your neck making your nipples harden again. You were so insanely insatiable, needing Mike to go again, last longer, fuck all your holes, or at least the ones his cock could fit into.Â
âBehave,â he gritted out, his hand falling onto your throat.
You smiled smugly at him, suddenly feeling his limp cock twitching against your thigh.
If you like my writing, all interactions are greatly appreciated-`âĄÂ´-
Masterlist๨ŕ§
Tagging @sallymaywritings @californiablues88 @sem-ra @ghostlybfgf @nerdyinfluencertastemaker @risefallrise @cintoasted @aryaslittleneedle @fromirkwood @ctrlanthro @xyahx @alexjacobsgoodnight @moonlights-muse
taglist âĽď¸ here (or leave a comment!)
dividers by @strangergraphics
I'd rather read your Coach Mike fics than watch the World Cup, @orson-pope đ















