One year, I spent Christmas Eve in a bar on 34th street. It wasn't odd, I'm a Jew and wasn't really sure what to do or where to go, but knew I wanted to be around people. I sipped a bourbon and soda water and listened to the conversations going on around me. Occasionally someone would wish me a Merry Christmas, but for the most part they left me alone. It was a run-down place, the last of the worst neighborhood dives, where they lock the doors after closing and let everyone stay and smoke cigarettes inside. What they did have was a chimney, and on that cold December day, it was snowing, just a dusting, but it was not a pleasant time to be out. Inside, a roaring fire was keeping everyone warm and besides, there was free popcorn. At about nine thirty, the door blows open and that frozen wind comes whipping through the place, everyone stops as if the jukebox record skipped, but it didn't, it kept bellowing Bing Crosby at full volume, I was once told he used to get hammered and beat his kids. Anyway, this middle-aged guy comes in, wearing a suit, a ragged winter coat, and a small boy of about nine in tow. He sits at the end of the bar and orders a drink and the kid drags himself onto the stool next to him. The bartender says, “We can't have him here, it's against the law.” Meaning the young boy, even though the man was clearly too drunk to be served. But someone shouted from the fireplace, “Aw come on Harv, it's Christmas.” So Harv makes his face as sallow as possible, looks up to the heavens and pours himself a shot of whiskey before asking the boy what he'd like. “Do you have any hot cocoa?” Harv looks at the kid and smiles, “You know, I think I've been saving some for just this sort of occasion.” The drunk man slams down his drink and bangs the empty glass on the bar. “And when you get a chance, I'll have another.” The man said snottily. Harv ignored him and went about preparing the hot chocolate from a coffee making sitting warm waiting to make a fresh pot. The water came out hot and I could see those tiny marshmallows bubble to the surface as the water filled in around them. They were still dancing in the mug when he brought it to the boy. “Thank you, barkeep.” The boy said. Harv smiled, I could swear he almost blushed, but I'd never laid eyes on him before that night and had no idea what a blush looked like on his face. The father repeated his request, more rudely, “And I said I'll have another!” Harv just looked at him for a moment, then brought a bottle onto the counter without looking at it and poured into the man's glass and walked away. The man brought it to his mouth and coughed as he took a sip, “This is peach schnapps you barbarian!” the man said. Harv smiled, “yeah well, I figured as long as the kid was being an adult, I'd give you the kid's drink.” The man spit into the glass, “I'm not paying for this.” Harv put his hands on his hips, “Nobody's asking you to buddy. And if it weren't for the kid I'd throw you the hell out.” The man pushed the glass toward the edge of the bar, “Now where have I heard that line before? You seeing my wife on the sly?” Harv was beginning to look upset, “Now that's enough buddy, have some respect, at least for the kid. It's Christmas.” The man started to turn red, “He's not MY kid! It's Christmas, it's Christmas, so what, so I'm supposed to be a better person because some fat guy might write me off his list? Well I've got news for you, the only one who's list matters, just crossed me off, and gave me my walking papers, so there ain't going to be no Christmas for this guy, get it?” Harv looked ashamed, we all felt sort of ashamed. He pulled the whiskey bottle from under the bar and poured the man a fresh glass. “Sorry buddy, this one's on me.” The man didn't say a word he just sipped at it and looked sullen. The kid sipped at his hot chocolate and looked at the drunk man next to him, “Are we going home soon dad, I want to be there when Santa comes.” The man said nothing, “Dad?” The man's head slowly swiveled and in a condescending mock, sing-songed his way through a lilting impression of his son's high-pitched voice. “Go home, nobody's stopping you.”
“But Dad, Santa Claus.”
“Dad? Who's dad? There is no Santa Claus, he's made up, we made it all up. Be as bad as you want because there aren't any presents and there ain't no Santa Claus.”
“What about the ones under the tree?”
“What tree? They're going back, they're all going back. Things are going to change around here kid, we need to make some adjustments, we can't be spending money on frivolous things. Someone has to pay the rent.” Harv glowered down on the man, “I heard drinking helps.” The man's head swiveled on Harv, “Mind your own business pal. I'm not asking you for a gift.”
“You know they pay me to stand here, I'm not always this full of good will.”
“Not much by the looks of this place.”
“Allright that's it, you're cut off.”
“One more. Just one more and then I'll go.”
“I know I'm going to regret this.” Harv pulls the bottle out and fills the glass again. The man sips slowly this time, savoring the moments before heading back into the cold. The little boy gulps at his mug of cocoa, trying to finish it quickly, “Dad, hurry, Santa Claus...” The man slams his drink down on the counter and wheels on his boy, “There is no Santa Clause, that man at the mall, he's just a creepy old man who gets his jollies dreaming about sneaking in the houses of naive children! No Santa!” The bar went silent, except for Bing Crosby of course, you could have heard ice melting in a daiquiri. But from over by the fire a man in his sixties stands and walks over to the man and the boy. “Someone told me there was no Santa once too, it changed me forever. I walked around for years telling people, like I was an authority on the fraud of Santa Clause. I tried to crush the dreams of all the kids I knew, just like mine had been.” The drunk waved his hand at the man, “Yeah, yeah, tell your story drinking old timer, I've got my own problems.”
“Until that year I saw him.” The boy who had been on the verge of tears and could hardly look at his cocoa looked up at the older man. “I was quite a few years older than you, I had fallen asleep in front of the television watching the late movie. And I was awoken by a creaking board in the floor. Now mind you, he wasn't dressed like the man at the mall, no his clothes were drab, a brown almost burlap. He didn't have a great big beard.” The man mimed having a long beard with his hand and his chin. “He looked like a pretty normal guy.” The drunk man interrupted, “Yeah, let me guess, he looked like your lousy, good-for-nothing father. Well, this lousy, good-for-nothing father can't afford to play dressup. In fact, thanks for reminding me, I'll sell the tv too.” The old man ignored the drunk. “He was almost dressed as a hobo, but less dirty. He had a sack over his shoulder tied to walking stick, and his knit cap lay sideways over his head, floppy-like. I would have thought he was a burglar, except I saw him pulling things out of his sack and placing them under our tree. I was playing possum see; pretending to be asleep in case he was a burglar or something. But you see, he wasn't, he was the real Santa Claus, not some man in a big suit and bushy beard, but a man, like your father, like Harv, here, like me. So don't you worry young man, Santa will come through, he always does for good little boys, and you seem like a good boy to me.” The drunk started wobbling on his stool, “Yeah, good boy, if he's such a good boy, why doesn't he go out and get a god-damned job leave me alone. Hell, my wife used to work, maybe everybody should get jobs to support me and I can spend the next year here with Harv.” He laid his head down on the bar. Harv slid the glass away from him, “You been to a lot of bars tonight son?” The boy looked back to Harv, “Yessir, my dad, he's not such a bad guy really. Mom says it's only when he drinks, and well, lately he drinks a lot. But he's not a bad guy.”
“Sure kid, I know, I had one just like him. He was a hell of a guy as long as we didn't talk to him.”
“He's not as bad as all that. He doesn't hurt us or anything, he just gets sad a lot. Like you said mister, someone told him once there wasn't any Santa Claus and he believed it. And now, he's like this.”
“Let that be a lesson to the rest of you drunks, don't stop believing in Santa Claus, or I'm calling in all your tabs.” The bar roared with laughs, except for the drunk, and Bing Crosby who kept on singing. “Now kid, where do you live?”
“Oh we live in the Bronx, we were supposed to catch the train, but dad got into it with a transit cop, I guess my dad knew his mother better than he should of, or something like that. But anyway, they kicked us out of the station and we didn't have money to get back in.”
“You mean, your pop doesn't have any money on him?”
“Well, he's got a credit card, but I don't think that worked at the last place. It might work here though.”
“No, I very much doubt that kiddo.”
“Well, it looks like Santa is coming for your pop. What about you? What do you want? Another hot cocoa?”
“Geez, no, I can barely finish this one. I don't really know what I want. Does that make me weird?”
“Weird, nah, you're just a kid.”
“Yeah, but I think a lot of kids know what they want; bb guns, robots, action figures whatever, that kind of stuff. I just don't want any of that stuff. Or, at least, I don't know that I want it.”
“What kind of toys do you have at home?”
“The usual stuff; puzzles and legos. I don't need any more of that stuff.” A voice followed the flushing of a toilet, the man behind it was hiking up his pants and tightening his belt. “I remember being like that one Christmas. I think I was about ten, and I just didn't know what I wanted. My father asked over and over, but I kept saying the same thing, 'I don't know.' My mother warned me if I didn't ask for something I was getting nothing but clothes, including the handmade sweater my grandmother had already measured me for, man that thing was itchy, but warm, it's funny the things you miss.” The boy looked at the funny man, older, in a hawaiian shirt, holding a tropical drink with umbrellas pouring over the side. “I mean, clothes wouldn't be bad, but I have plenty of 'em. I'm not without anything.”
“Except sober supervision. Maybe we ought to call your ma. Hmm?”
“No, I don't want to upset her, she's taking care of my grandmother.”
“Okay, so who can we call?”
“I really don't know. If I had the money I could catch a taxi. We took one once, I think it was about thirty dollars.”
“Listen kid, if that's all you want for Christmas, I'm sure we could scrape together some money between these drunks and get you home safe. What you say, you bunch of souses! Let's take up a collection!” Everyone cheered, in a line, men walked up to bar and tossed dollar bills onto it, showering the kid in money, hell I tossed a tenner his way, it drifted off the counter and landed on the floor. Harv gathered it up for him and counted it, then counted it again and whistled. “Well kid, I hate to break it to ya, but there's well over fifty bucks here, looks like you're going to have to figure out how to spend the rest of it on your own.”
“I'll think of something, grandma always needs something.”
“You know something, nevermind your old man, you're a swell kid!”
“Thanks, thank you all!” Then the kid hopped off the stool and started to leave. Harv looked confused, “Hey kid, don't forget your old man!”
“I won't, I'll just hail down a cab and have the driver help me get him inside. I'll be right back.” The whole bar waited, there were murmurs, but the place was pretty silent. But after fifteen minutes, the kid never came back. Harv pulled the towel from his belt and threw it down on the bar, “Should've figured that kid couldn't catch a cab this time of night on Christmas. I'll just call one and he can wait in here. Merry Christmas guys!” Harv stormed outside to get the kid. After about ten minutes of silence, Harv stormed back in, with a confused look on his face. “The kids gone, I hope nothing happened to him.” Harv went behind the bar and shook the father awake. “Hey buddy, your kid's gone, we gave him cab fare home. You might want to get back there and make sure he made it.” But the man didn't stir, “Hey buddy, you hear me? Your kid beat it back to the Bronx.” The man's head wobbled to attention and his eyes darted back and forth in consciousness, “My kid, I don't have a kid.”
“What do you mean, that kid who was sitting next to you.”
“That kid who's been following me around all night? He got me kicked out of three bars before I got here.” At first none of us thought we heard him right, like he was still drunk, but when he said it again, “That kid, kept telling everyone his dad was a drunk, the more he talked the meaner everybody was to me. For a while I thought he was just in my head.” At that the man rested his head on the bar and drifted off to sleep. I already knew what most of the bar patrons were realizing, we had been hustled by a ten-year-old Grinch. But even though we got taken, I felt good about it. I felt like wherever that kid was headed, I had helped to make sure he got there safe. I looked down at my own shabby clothes, wreaking of cigarettes and booze, and was reminded of the story the first man told, about the normal looking Santa Claus, who just looked like a man, in shabby clothes, giving presents to a boy he didn't know.