How GRRM accidentally wrote Jaime as a repressed bisexual (or, why bi!Jaime supporters read it that way)
Itâs nigh impossible to go too long in the Jaime and/or Jaime x Brienne fandom without hearing talk of people headcanoning Jaime Lannister as being a bisexual disaster, but from where did this talk derive?Â
Interpretations of the text, of course! But what could be there, you say? How much so called evidence could there possibly be?
Now, I think we can all agree that any such textual evidence was unintentional on GRRMâs part; itâs more than quite likely that GRRM thinks heâs written Jaime to be a heterosexual man. That doesnât change what he wrote, though, nor how his writing can be interpretedâor, in this case, has been interpreted.
Bi Jaime headcanons were all born from endless textual bits of evidence concerning Jaime.Â
My fellow Jaime stans, let me introduce to you all the ways GRRM accidentally made Jam Lan far less heterosexual than he intended.
Unintentional Homoeroticism, Unintentional Homoeroticism Everywhere
There is a plethora of homoerotic imagery and wording throughout Jaimeâs interactions and thoughts with the men he has literary connections withâthe men he respects and admires, begrudgingly or openly, because he perceives them to be honorable. Those who read Jaime as bi half-joke that, because of the pattern of the sort of men heâs âinto,â heâs honorsexual. Though we joke, our humor and our interpretations are all born from the text itself, and how they can be read, especially if the reader isnât looking through a heteronormative lens. Letâs break âem downâin chronological order of Jaime meeting them/falling for them.
Jaime and Brynden Tully (or, slutty questions at dinner tables, with a side of silver fox thirsting)
Brynden âthe Blackfishâ Tully is example A, the one who started it allâJaimeâs first honorcrush, you could say. Dive in to the quote:
[Lysa Tully] had been a pretty girl, in truth; dimpled and delicate, with long auburn hair. Timid, though. Prone to tongue-tied silences and fits of giggles, with none of Cerseiâs fire. Her older sister had seemed more interesting, though Catelyn was promised to some northern boy, the heir of Winterfell ⌠but at that age, no girl interested Jaime half so much as Hosterâs famous brother, who had won renown fighting the Ninepenny Kings upon the Stepstones. At table he had ignored poor Lysa, whilst pressing Brynden Tully for tales of Maelys the Monstrous and the Ebon Prince. (AFFC, Jaime V)
This paragraph pretty much sums it up. Young Jaime found the Tully sisters to be attractive; he thought Lysa was pretty, but he was only legitimately attracted to Catelyn (weâll dive into that later on). And yet, he ignored them both to chat up their uncleâwho is quite likely to be gay himself, but thatâs another topic.Â
Now obviously, this wasnât written to have non-hetero subtext or connotationsâGRRM wanted to stress that Jaime hero-worshipped Brynden because of his fighting prowess and achievements on the battlefield, so much so that he ignored two pretty girls, even one he was actually attracted to, in order to speak with said hero.Â
But⌠the phrasing and wording of it all:
Her older sister had seemed more interesting [âŚ] but at that age, no girl interested Jaime half so much as Hosterâs famous brother. [âŚ] At table he had ignored poor Lysa, whilst pressing Brynden Tully for tales of Maelys the Monstrous and the Ebon Prince.
He ignored Lysa, a pretty girl, and Catelyn, the girl he was actually into, because no girl was more interesting than Brynden Tully. What a way to phrase that, right.
But that was pre-canon. What does Jaime think about Brynden currently?
[Brynden] Tully had a craggy face, deeply lined and windburnt beneath a shock of stiff grey hair, but Jaime could still see the great knight who had once enthralled a squire with tales of the Ninepenny Kings. (AFFC Jaime VI)
Enthralled. Do you know how strong of a word that is?
Letâs have Merriam-Webster define it:
Enthrall: to hold spellbound; charm Â
To hold spellbound. Jaime was spellbound by Brynden Tully. Charmed.
What an intense adjective to describe a teenâs hero worship. Itâs a word with heavy romantic connotations to it, far more appropriate to describe an infatuation, or romantic relationship. Youâd think GRRM would save such language for describing Jaimeâs feelings for Cersei, but no, GRRM used it for Brynden. LOL. Out of all the words GRRM could use to describe Jaimeâs attachment to Brynden, thatâs the one he chose? And weâre not supposed to read that as homoerotic? Byeeeeee
So, to revise Jaimeâs recollection concerning the time he ignored the Tully sisters to chat up their uncle: no girl was more interesting than Brynden Tully, the knight who Jaime was enthralled by. Â
Still not seeing it? Letâs look at the whole line:
[âŚ] but Jaime could still see the great knight who had once enthralled a squire with tales of the Ninepenny Kings.Â
Jaime can still see the knight who had enthralled his teenaged self. So you could say that if he still sees that man, even now, that means that he is⌠still enthralled by Brynden. Still spellbound. Still⌠charmed.Â
And can we talk about the whole paragraph?
Tully had a craggy face, deeply lined and windburnt beneath a shock of stiff grey hair, but Jaime could still see the great knight who had once enthralled a squire with tales of the Ninepenny Kings.
Thatâs a medieval way of saying âYeah you got older, but youâre still a snack.âÂ
Like. Jaime really out here saying that Brynden Tully has aged like fine wine. How hetero of him.Â
Also, haha, I looked up âcraggy,ââthe word Jaime used to describe Bryndenâs faceâon my computerâs dictionary, and, WELL:
BAHAHAHAHAHA
Jaime: Heâs old and rugged but in a SEXY way I mean have you ever SEEN a silver fox like this
So, revising again: No girl was more interesting to Jaime than Brynden Tully, the ruggedly attractive knight who Jaime was, and arguably still is, enthralled by.
You canât get any straighter than that, Iâd say. And somehow, when you breakdown Jaimeâs relationship Arthur Dayne, it only gets straighter.Â
Jaime and Arthur Dayne (or, symbolic virginity loss, ghosts living in Jaimeâs head rent free, and putting a ring cloak on it)
Arthur Dayne is the second honorcrush of Jaimeâs, but the most vital. As the man who knighted Jaime and mentored him, Arthur Dayne is Jaimeâs ultimate symbol for honor and the zenith of knighthood, and imperative to Jaimeâs characterization and story.Â
Heâs also the one who provides us with a shit ton of homoeroticism in Jaimeâs chapters, even years after his death, as Jaime thinks about him all the time.Â
And heâd held his own against the Smiling Knight, though it was Ser Arthur who slew him. What a fight that was, and what a foe. The Smiling Knight was a madman, cruelty and chivalry all jumbled up together, but he did not know the meaning of fear. And Dayne, with Dawn in hand ⌠The outlawâs longsword had so many notches by the end that Ser Arthur had stopped to let him fetch a new one. âItâs that white sword of yours I want,â the robber knight told him as they resumed, though he was bleeding from a dozen wounds by then. âThen you shall have it, ser,â the Sword of the Morning replied, and made an end of it. (ASOS, Jaime VIII)
Jaime reminisces about the first time he spent time with Arthur, when they fought the Smiling Knight and his goons. Similarly to Jaimeâs memories of Brynden, most of the language Jaime uses can be read as romantic in tone, or flowery.Â
What a fight that was, and what a foe.
Jaime is in awe of Arthurâs skill in battle. It reminds me of this:
Jaime had done many wicked things, but the man could fight! (AFFC, Brienne I)
Here, you could say Brienne is the young Jaime to a seasoned Jaimeâs Arthurâexpressing admiration for a more experienced warriorâs fighting skills in a dreamy or fangirlish manner. And while thatâs true, we canât forget the other connotations here. Considering the fact that Brienne is very much in love with Jaimeâand so, any admiration sheâd have for him is laced with sexual and romantic attractionâto have these lines be so similar does no favors for the âJaime is straight,â narrative GRRM thought he wrote.
And Dayne, with Dawn in handâŚ
This line is quite dreamyâyou can practically hear Jaime fangirl sigh while thinking it. Dreamy is the only way to describe it; you even have the ellipsis to seal the deal. An ellipsis, a tool writers use to show a character is lost for words. Again, language. A writer isnât going to put an ellipsis for no reason, especially in inner monologue. The ellipsis also implies that Jaime is stopping himself from full blown waxing poetic tributes about Arthurâshowing restraint, living in denial, as a repressed bisexual or gay man from a medieval society might.Â
While thinking of Arthur on the battlefield, at his bestâand, by a warriorâs standards, his most beautifulâJaime is lost for words. Lost for words, while reminiscing of Arthur, and how amazing he looked on the battlefield, holding his sword, Dawn.Â
Swords. Something we know is constantly used as a euphemism for penises in GRRMâs writing. It wasnât supposed to be one here, but, hey, with the dreamlike, fangirly energy exuding from this line, it does come to mind.Â
The outlawâs longsword had so many notches by the end that Ser Arthur had stopped to let him fetch a new one. "Itâs that white sword of yours I want,â the robber knight told him as they resumed, though he was bleeding from a dozen wounds by then. "Then you shall have it, ser,â the Sword of the Morning replied, and made an end of it.
Jaime has full recollection of a scene and conversation he wasnât even a part of from almost twenty years ago. Such a fixation, especially in fiction, is used to demonstrate a characterâs fanboyism, yes (and thatâs what GRRM was going for here, as well as showing that an older Jaime, in his trauma and bitterness, longs for what he considers the good old days, and is recollecting these events through a nostalgic lens) but more often than not, fixations such as this are usually reserved for romantic imagery. Jaime remembers how well Arthur won the battle by describing all the wounds the Smiling Knight had, and the Smiling Knightâs dialogue is remembered only to give Arthurâs witty reply context in Jaimeâs mind. Every word and sight is preserved within Jaimeâs memory to keep Arthur exalted as some angelic figure who remains pure, untainted, legendary, and unyielding in maintaining honor.
And if Arthur is an angelic figure, Jaime is his acolyte. Like an overzealous worshipper, Jaime sees Arthurâs state of being (or rather, the state of being Jaime believes him to have) as the standard so much that itâs gotten to the point of wanting to be him. And because that standard is impossible, he fails constantly. He uses the pedestal he has placed Arthur on to put himself downâremind him of how far he has fallen:
And me, that boy I was ⌠when did he die, I wonder? When I donned the white cloak? When I opened Aerysâs throat? That boy had wanted to be Ser Arthur Dayne, but someplace along the way he had become the Smiling Knight instead. (ASOS, Jaime VIII)
And even years after Arthurâs death, Jaime craves his approval:
He wondered what Ser Arthur Dayne would have to say of this lot. âHow is it that the Kingsguard has fallen so low,â most like. âIt was my doing,â I would have to answer. âI opened the door, and did nothing when the vermin began to crawl inside.â (ASOS, Jaime VIII)
Postmortem, Arthur has Jaimeâs undying love, his loyalty, his worship.Â
He also has Jaimeâs symbolic virginity.
It had been years since his last vigil. And I was younger then, a boy of fifteen years. He had worn no armor then, only a plain white tunic. The sept where heâd spent the night was not a third as large as any of the Great Septâs seven transepts. Jaime had laid his sword across the Warriorâs knees, piled his armor at his feet, and knelt upon the rough stone floor before the altar. When dawn came his knees were raw and bloody. âAll knights must bleed, Jaime,â Ser Arthur Dayne had said, when he saw. âBlood is the seal of our devotion.â With dawn he tapped him on the shoulder; the pale blade was so sharp that even that light touch cut through Jaimeâs tunic, so he bled anew. He never felt it. A boy knelt; a knight rose. The Young Lion, not the Kingslayer. (AFFC, Jaime I)
In vivid, romantic detail, with the most sensual tone and flowery language possible, Jaime tells us of his knighting, not too long after he and Arthur defeated the Kingswood Brotherhood. And these details are brimming with sexual and romantic imagery, even marriage symbolism.
First, the setting. Jaime was knighted in a sept, a Westerosi church. In our own world, most weddings are held in churches. The setting fuels the marriage imagery here, and is its backbone.Â
Then we get to Jaimeâs appearance. He is wearing white. White, the color of purity; a color associated with virginity in Western societies. Since Jaime was knighted before he had sex with Cersei in that inn on Eel Alley, itâs possible that Jaime was literally a virgin, hereâas, considering how important Eel Alley is to Jaime, it seems that that was the first time he and Cersei went all the way, so that means that most likely, Jaime was literally and metaphorically a virgin at the time of his knighting. Either way, in a knightly sense, Jaime is a virgin, as he is about to become one and receive his title.
White is also the color most brides wear to their weddingsâin our world, at least. The imagery reminds the reader of the traditions in our own world, whether or not itâs one in Westeros. So, by wearing white in a church, Jaime looks the part of someone about to be married. A virgin, awaiting their wedding ceremony.Â
Onto the actual knighting, where the sexual and marriage imagery intertwines. During a knighting, vows are made, just as vows are made during a wedding. The vows are similarâboth make promises of loyalty, honesty, faithfulness, and most importantly, devotion. And Jaime is devoted to Arthurâhe literally spends hours upon hours on his knees, awaiting Arthurâs arrival. He knelt so long that his knees bled open. Arthur even makes the blood symbolize he and Jaimeâs bond, saying that blood is âthe seal of their devotion.âÂ
And that seal works in a pure manner as much as a carnal one. The image of staying on oneâs knees for someone evokes both religious and sexual imagery. When most people pray, they do it on their knees⌠but, thereâs also another reason someone would stay on their knees so long theyâve bled for someoneâif theyâre giving oral sex.Â
The religious imagery of bleeding knees while praying checks out. Jaime does worship Arthur, in a way, far more than he does the actual gods of the Seven. Symbolism for praying to show Jaimeâs respect for knighthood, and especially Arthur, fits well, but also stresses his love for Arthur.Â
And the sexual imagery, well. Letâs look at the line in question:
When dawn came his knees were raw and bloody.
Arthurâs sword is named Dawn. Swords are metaphorical penises in ASOIAF more often than not. And dawn came. While Jaime was on his knees. So long that his knees had bled. Yeah. Read in a different light, that sentence can mean something way more explicit than intended.
Obviously, in the sentence itself, the dawn being referred to is the literal dawnâsunrise. But again, double speak. And if you combine this with all of the sexual imagery up next, it only becomes more potent.
So, Arthur knights Jaime. Letâs look at that quote closer:
When dawn came his knees were raw and bloody. âAll knights must bleed, Jaime,â Ser Arthur Dayne had said, when he saw. âBlood is the seal of our devotion.â With dawn he tapped him on the shoulder; the pale blade was so sharp that even that light touch cut through Jaimeâs tunic, so he bled anew. He never felt it. A boy knelt; a knight rose.
Arthur has Dawn wielded, and he uses it to knight Jaime. He is gentle when he touches Jaime with the sword, only using âa light touch,â and tries not to hurt Jaime, but Dawn is so sharp that it penetrates through Jaimeâs clothes and skin anyway. When looked through the âsword = penisâ lens, Arthurâs actions symbolize a man gently taking his loverâs virginity.Â
The lost virginity metaphor resides in the cut itself. Jaimeâs white tunicâwhite, the color of virgins and purity, the color of bridesâis slashed by Dawnâs gentle touch, and his shoulder bleeds. Blood that is most likely virginal in a literal sense, but most certainly in a metaphorical one, as it bleeds through torn white clothing, and the blood belongs to one who has just become a knight, something he hadnât been before.Â
Jaime also describes his wound from Dawnâs cut as âbleeding anew.â This evokes the imagery of one becoming undone in a physical and spiritual sense, one where the person in question has transcended beyond describable feeling. Itâs like a religious awakening, which coincides with the worship aspect Jaime has toward Arthur and knighthoodâbut also an orgasm, especially one experienced by someone who has never had one before (and Jaime is that someone, in this case, as heâs either a virgin, or at least sexually inexperienced). That sense of euphoria continues with Jaimeâs lack of awareness with the cut itselfâhe is in so much awe of what is happening that he never even felt the pain of the cut.Â
And after the state of becoming anewâwhich you could say is the afterglow of the knighting, the virginity lossâJaime says this:
A boy knelt; a knight rose.
After being penetrated with Arthurâs sword, and bleeding through his white tunic, he is no longer a boy. He is a knightâan adult. A man. In Westeros, people refer to male teensâboysâlosing their virginities as them âbecoming a man.â That Jaime sees himself as becoming a man after bleeding from Arthur Dayneâs metaphorical penisâ cut only supports the sexual undertones of lost virginity.Â
Iâd also like to point out that Arthur calls Jaime by his first name hereânot âmy lord.â This is vital. In this society, the highborn do not call each other by their first name unless there is a closeness between them, an intimacy, be it a platonic or romantic one. Considering the gentleness on display on Arthurâs part here, that he calls Jaime by his name shows the trust they share, specifically Jaimeâs love and trust in Arthur, and Arthurâs respect of that love and trust. It only further shapes the imagery of a man gently taking someoneâs virginity with someone he is close with.
In terms of imagery, Jaimeâs knighting is not unlike his swordfight with Brienne, which was filled with double-speak, marriage symbolism, and sexual innuendos. Just as Arthur cuts Jaimeâs white virginal tunic with his symbolic penis, so does Jaime cut Brienneâs inner thigh with his symbolic penis:
His point scraped past her parry and bit into her upper thigh. A red flower blossomed, and Jaime had an instant to savor the sight of her blood [âŚ] (ASOS, Jaime III)
Both young Jaime and Brienneâs virginal blood spill at the cuts, and in both instances, Jaime is enthralled by the bleeding. With Brienneâs blood, he âsavors the sight,â and with his own bloodshed he is so lost in wonderment that he ânever feltâ the cut.
Itâs both hilarious and beautiful that there are so many parallels with Jaimeâs knighting by Arthur to the sex and marriage metaphor that masquerades as Jaimeâs swordfight with Brienne. Brienne, who is Jaimeâs canonical love interest. Like. GRRM legit wrote Jaime to have similar sexual and romantic scenarios and imagery with his female love interest⌠and a man. You canât do that and just not expect me to see Jaimeâs bisexual energy. You just canât. The fact that both scenes work so well and are emotionally evocative just makes the whole thing even better.
Yep. With exaltation years after death, and the symbolization of marriage and lost virginity, Jaime and Arthur have a dynamic that is sensual, strong, devoted, and, most importantly for this metaâlacking heterosexuality.
Jaime and Rhaegar Targaryen (or, âNotice me, senpai!â plus way too detailed reminiscing)Â
Jaimeâs crush on Rhaegar isnât as prolific as the other dynamics listed in this analysis, but I still find it worth noting. Jaime respected Prince Rhaegar, and feels tremendous guilt over not being able to save him or his children, Rhaenys and Aegon.Â
But thereâs a bit of a crush energy to Jaimeâs views on Rhaegar. Hereâs Jaimeâs memory of the last time he and Rhaegar ever spoke.
The day had been windy when he said farewell to Rhaegar, in the yard of the Red Keep. The prince had donned his night-black armor, with the three-headed dragon picked out in rubies on his breastplate. âYour Grace,â Jaime had pleaded, âlet Darry stay to guard the king this once, or Ser Barristan. Their cloaks are as white as mine.âÂ
Prince Rhaegar shook his head. âMy royal sire fears your father more than he does our cousin Robert. He wants you close, so Lord Tywin cannot harm him. I dare not take that crutch away from him at such an hour.â
Jaimeâs anger had risen up in his throat. âI am not a crutch. I am a knight of the Kingsguard.â
âThen guard the king,â Ser Jon Darry snapped at him. âWhen you donned that cloak, you promised to obey.â
Rhaegar had put his hand on Jaimeâs shoulder. âWhen this battleâs done I mean to call a council. Changes will be made. I meant to do it long ago, but ⌠well, it does no good to speak of roads not taken. We shall talk when I return."Â
Those were the last words Rhaegar Targaryen ever spoke to him. Outside the gates an army had assembled, whilst another descended on the Trident. So the Prince of Dragonstone mounted up and donned his tall black helm, and rode forth to his doom. (AFFC, Jaime I)
What catches the eye is the immense detail. Just like Jaimeâs memories of Arthurâwhom we know he thirsted forâevery single detail of Rhaegar is immortalized in Jaimeâs brainâwhat Rhaegar wore, what the weather was like, exactly what was said. And it makes sense for Jaime to remember all of this so vividlyâthe Rebellion was an incredibly traumatizing time for Jaime, and it was the last time he ever saw Rhaegar alive.Â
At the same time, we have things like Jaime remembering that Rhaegar touched him, as well as his appearance. Itâs relatively innocuous things to remember so vividly without a hint of romantic connotations being there, and as such, probably wouldnât stand out in JonConâs recollections of Rhaegar, who was definitely in love with him.Â
Thereâs also the matter of Jaime begging Rhaegar to take him with him to battle. Jaime was understandably eager to get away from Aerys, but I think he also wanted nothing more than to protect Rhaegar, the prince that he loved and respected. The prince he wished he was king.Â
This particular line should be noted:
"Your Grace,â Jaime had pleaded, âlet Darry stay to guard the king this once, or Ser Barristan. Their cloaks are as white as mine.âÂ
Jaime calls Rhaegar âYour Grace,â the title meant for kings or queens, not princes. Itâs a strange thing, and, to my knowledge, no prince or princess is ever called âYour Grace,â in the entire series besides this one instance. Itâs most likely author error, as Jaime outwardly calling Rhaegar by the kingâs title is open treason, but in universe, it works at least for Jaimeâs character. He sees Rhaegar as his king, and he wants to leave with himâmaybe even die with him.
We also get a bit of âNotice me, senpai!â energy from the âtheir cloaks are as white as mine,â line. Jaime wants to prove his worth as a Kingsguard, but he also wants Rhaegar to see him. For someone who isnât a weeb and, therefore, isnât familiar with that trope (which seems to be more prevalent in anime than Western media) the connotation wouldnât click, but for me⌠I donât know, it just has that tone of the subordinate wanting their dreamy superior to take an interest in them.Â
Either way, on its own, Jaimeâs loyalty and oddly vivid memory of Rhaegar is standard hero worship, but when you combine it with everything else in this meta, itâs worth mentioning, and doesnât come off as straight as itâs meant to be.Â
Jaime and Ned Stark (or, villainous dick on the heroâs chest feat. obsession and boyfriend envy)
Jaime and Ned were a thing. On Jaimeâs end, especiallyâand by that, I mean that Jaime is fucking obsessed with the guy. Ned lives in Jaimeâs head rent free almost as much as Main Honor Boyfriend Arthur does.