you know what? i’m gonna say it. atla was a huge part of my childhood. it was definitely a step forward in regards to cartoons.
but the racial insensitivity is staggering. and i wanna talk about the amount of exploiting there is of south asian culture specifically. i’m south asian, indian specifically, and i grew up watching this show that was supposed to be “different” and “inspiring” for people of colour.
except there were little to no characters with dark skin who had importance and were explicitly made out to be south asian. that was fine. i was used to not seeing characters on television who looked like i did. except this show used my culture. they used my culture and they couldn’t even bother putting in good characters who looked like they remotely belonged to that culture, even if they were minor and not part of the gaang.
first of all, the show has a lot of influence from Hinduism—the word avatar (avatāra) itself means “descent” in Sanskrit, referring to the incarnation of a deity in human form. where did Hinduism originate?
indus valley, or what we now call pakistan, a south asian country. the entire concept of chi or prana, as it is referred to as in Hinduism, is a reoccurring theme in atla; your vital energy, your spiritual energy. this is another one of the religion’s influences on the show.
atla also talks about the seven chakras. this is another concept from Hinduism, and in the religion, they must always be unblocked for your prana (the term from Hinduism) or chi (the Chinese term which is used the show) to flow smoothly. chi is your life energy.
so. guess who helps aang out with his chakras?
right. this guy. the only blatantly south asian character we’ve gotten so far, and you wanna know why it’s so blatant? because he’s literally an indian stereotype. he’s the only obviously south asian character so far in the show and he’s a racist portrayal of enlightened practitioners of Hinduism. great.
oh, and before i forget—
do their foreheads look familiar? oh yeah, that’s because it’s literally copied off of this:
this is Shiva, the Hindu god of destruction. they used a religious symbol in Hinduism to make a couple characters look cool. well, combustion man and p’li both have these third eyes, so we can assume they are at least south asian coded—but what are their characters like?
villains. unhinged. insane. we don’t even know combustion man’s name—we just know he’s a contract killer who would murder a child for the right price. p’li wants to dismantle all forms of government and let the world reign free in chaos, and finally she is given a horribly grotesque death: she gets her head blown off.
for all of the culture references that are important pieces of this show, you’d think there’d be an area that has south asian people. there isn’t one. i’m not going to speak about the other loads of racism in atla because i don’t belong to those cultures, but here’s my two cents.
this show was written by white men who did the bare minimum. it’s nothing worth praising.
as an indian, i’d also like to elaborate here. the ATLA creators were inspired by lots of different Asian cultures, and them taking concepts from hinduism is not inherently bad. i would have been happy if they’d used the same concepts* if they had bothered to actually put indian/south asian representation in their show. like, you don’t get to cherry pick from my culture while also creating racist stereotypes for cheap laughs.
*and combustion man is gross, appropriative and racist no matter how you swing it lol. shiva may be the “god of destruction” but he is not meant to be evil/an assassin - he destroys the bad parts of the world. it’s literally bare minimum research. and this is not a forgotten god, he is a religious figure who is actively worshipped. white men do not get to bastardize him for fun.
look, ATLA is a product of its time. it does many good things. but we can’t just sit here and pretend it’s the “gold standard for representation in cartoons” when it’s just,,,,not.
sorry for hijacking your post OP but i have so many feelings about this
to further on everything these two excellent people have been saying:
i want to specifically talk about the whole concept of the avatar in this show. we know several things about the avatar in general
they are the balance between the spirit world and the human world
all avatars share the same soul, just lead different lives
they maintain peace and uphold justice and try to keep the seesaw of good and bad in the human world from tipping too far into evil
this whole concept is lifted directly from the Hindu god, Vishnu. Vishnu is the most powerful of the holy trinity because he is the preserver of life. one of the most famous aspects of his mythology is the “dasha avatara” or the ten avatars, wherein he is reincarnated ten times into the human world (he’s reincarnated a lot more but those are the most important), and each time, it’s to fulfill a need and restore balance to the world, just like the avatar in ATLA is supposed to do
ATLA lifted its bedrock from Hinduism, and the fact that the only south asian “representation” in it is bastardized, racist, & completely unacknowledged, is incredibly insulting
i love this show, but it has its problems, and we need to be able to recognize and accept that






















