the most ridiculous way that people try to justify philâs lesson for tommy is framing it like this is the Only Way That Tommy Is Going To Get Better. not because itâs actively hostile to Anyoneâs mental health (which it is), and not because itâs actively hostile to the abuse that tommy specifically went through (which it is), but because from a purely practical level we Already Know that itâs just dead wrong.
no matter what your beliefs on mental health and growth are, âvalue people not things <3âł doesnât do jack or shit when the mass murderer and abuser that just broke out of prison Fully And Completely has no qualms against using attachment to People against him.
at the disc war finale dream used the gambit with the fake discs (making tommy choose between them and tubbo) so he could find out which tommy would choose and use that attachment against him. tommy chose tubbo and so dream Almost Killed Tubbo. the attachments vault that dream made to control everyone on the server Included A Cage For Skeppy, because to dream People Are Exactly The Same As Items. what matters is the attachment to exploit.
and this is something thatâs always been present. he specifically sought out a deal with eret instead of just blowing up lâmanberg by himself because he wanted to use their attachment to eret against them. it hurt more because theyâd trusted and cared about eret. and heâd tried to do the exact same thing with jack when heâd first joined the server, bribing jack to betray them after heâd been let into lâmanberg (which he didnât).Â
exile was nothing But using peopleâs attachments to each other against them, Especially for tommy. using isolation to hurt him, convincing him that the people heâd genuinely loved and cared about Didnât love him and were better off without him, forcing tommy to grow attached to Him and using his friendship and kindness as a carrot on a stick to control tommyâs behavior and get his way, Etc.
likewise, he was using lâmanbergâs attachment to Tommy as a way to control and hurt them. tubbo tolerated dream in part because dream was his lifeline to tommy, even though dream was actively lying to him about tommy. forcing tommy away made them unstable and antsy, which in turn lead them to making poor choices that made them more vulnerable when dream was ready to destroy them.Â
and who could forget âcouldnât you have just burned the discs? couldnât you have just done it to me?â âoh this is much more fun.â
dreamâs involvement in doomsday was for his own fun. he knew technoblade was going to destroy it on his own anyways, heâd been specifically feeding into both sides of the conflict specifically Because he wanted that to happen. but tommy was going to be there, and watching his friends and home all burn and get hurt would be more painful for him than him experiencing those things himself. and isnât that just so Fun.
we know the disc war finale, we know the attachments museum. but itâs also worth noting that when tommy was going to kill him dream First tried to use tommyâs attachment to him to stop him. and when that didnât work he used tommyâs attachment to Wilbur.
and this behavior hasnât stopped in the slightest since his imprisonment. trying to dig for technoâs attachments while they were in prison together, using samâs attachment to tommy to try to convince sam to keep him alive, asking sapnap whose with him in kinoko kingdom and where it is while they were in a stand down. etc etc etc
tommy giving up his attachments, or picking and choosing his attachments wisely, or being ready to give up anything his has at a moments notice for the sake of things that are âmore importantâ will not help keep him safe from dream and will not protect his friends from dream. it will make his friends the easier target when dream wants to find a way to hurt and control him. which phil Would Know if he paid attention to what happens on the server.