Danny's Recurring Identity Crisis pt 2
Ever since it was revealed that there's a ghost fighting super hero living in Amity Park in season 1 (Since at the start no one was differentiating one ghost from the next) But ever since the Inviso-bill fiasco, Danny became more vigilant with keeping his two sides separate.
Because people were looking more closely now.
That was after What You Want, meaning the Ghost Catcher most definitely picked up on the difference that Danny so evidently made within himself.
Hence why things became crazy in Identity Crisis with the device (It could also be a retcon from the creators, but I'd like to think there's a bigger picture here.)
What Danny intended was to make two of himself (Splitting himself like he'd seen Vlad do, he thought that's what it was) He thought that's what the Ghost Catcher did the first time.
As it did with Technus. Purging that which he possessed, or making two of what was there in the first place.
Let's talk about what the distinction between Phantom and Fenton actually means for Danny and why it was important for him in the first place.
Considering how loony their parents can be. Danny and Jazz started disassociating from the craziness of the Fenton household early on.
With Jazz psychoanalyzing everything and placing it all in neat little boxes she created and labeled herself. Touting herself as the only sane one in the house, looking after everyone, especially Danny, because only she could. Because she was the only normal one there was.
Danny started hiding himself. Making himself invisible in a crowd. Aiming towards the most mediocre of things. Like wanting to be part of the normal accepted crowd of kids. Going on dates. Hanging out with his friends. Liking the most obvious chick in school. Like, he was trying too hard with wanting a normal childhood experience.
All because both Danny and Jazz were fighting against their Fenton instincts. Ghost fighting and the mania that comes with being a Fenton was in them from the start. No matter how hard they tried to disassociate from it.
Their parents encouraged whatever they wanted, but hoped for the same passion and zeal that they had.
And wouldn't you know it, when given the chance. Both Danny and Jazz pull out all the stops and show just how much that Fenton DNA matters. They can't fight it. And with time, they don't even try.
The thing is that Jazz, once exposed to this life, went full in. Starting by saying it was for Danny's sake but she started to enjoy it after a while.
Danny, on the other hand, only let half of himself fully immerse in it. Saying that Danny Fenton was still human and mundane. As far away from the ghostly craziness as possible.
Except this mask slipped up from time to time when the situation asked for it.
Pirate Radio, anyone?
Danny took charge as himself. And his natural instincts and leadership shone through. One he tried to hide so much.
As the series progresses, he might have forgotten about what shallow things he wanted in season 1, like popularity and dating the hot girl.
Instead, he wanted down time with his friends without anything ghostly interrupting. And he wanted to date the pretty and kick ass girl who he genuinely liked to be with.
He's growing, right? (Not enough to see what's right in front of him, but sure.)
This still isn't what's right for him. He's still so fixated on separating his two selves that he doesn't even care that Valerie hates his alter ego and wants to kill him. So long as she likes Fenton, it's all good.
When that ship sails, not because of anything Danny does, but because Valerie chose for him. Danny starts to ponder on how he should go forward.
Another kick to the head, very much needed as it was, came in the form of Gregor. Making Danny realize his feelings for Sam. He's getting there, right?
But it's still through the lenses of Fenton. He wants the normal experience still.
Livin Large and Phantom Planet were continuations of a conflict that wasn't resolved in Identity Crisis, just delayed prematurely.
So when given an out, Danny reverses his powers. Thinking that now that his ghost powers are gone, so are the responsibilities that came with it. Any positive thing associated with that part of his identity, is lost.
He doesn't realize that fighting for the right cause wasn't something that his ghost powers could do. It was something he could do all on his own. But by cutting off that one vital part of himself, he became half of who he was.
Hence why calling what Sam and Tucker and Jazz did as quote unquote 'Bullying' him, is uncalled for. Because they never viewed Danny as two separate people. He was always one and whole to them. And when they saw him lose a vital part of himself, they were distraught.
Jazz was saddened, but it was her brother's choice.
Tucker was disappointed, but he'd support Danny.
Sam was angry, and she would say it to your face.
And she did. Sam never minced words with Danny. A quality of hers that he always admired. (Which was what he meant when he said this btw...)
He needs her to ground him. Tell it to him straight.
It wasn't the powers that made Danny a super hero. It was himself and his resolve to do the right thing that made him a superhero. And he had to realize that.
Mind you, this was in one episode.
His two sides. One that gives up on everything but the people he loves. And the side that will risk it all till the very end. Putting his life on the line to protect his town.
He's done it before too. In Reign Storm he would have died and he was willing to as well, if it meant getting rid of Pariah Dark.
This isn't a retcon or bastardization of Danny. It's this constant pendulum inside him that switches from all to nothing and back again over and over again.
He doesn't need Phantom to fight. And he realizes this after Sam pushes him to confront himself.
He goes from this...
To this...
He does all this without powers. He's a natural leader, always has been. And when he tells his friends to get in the escape pod when all the ghosts were after them, everyone listened. Sam lingered because that's just how these two operate.
Speaking of (since I'll bring up Sam and Danny any chance I get cause I love every aspect of their relationship and just how perfect they are for one another), when Danny gets his head on straight, without powers I might add, these two come to life again.
I see those smiles and I know what they mean. That's Sam for ya. She's his conscience and he needs her. (Something I'll talk about at length in another post, promise).
He gets his powers back, but he learned a valuable lesson as well.
No matter how much he wants to separate his two sides, he just can't. They are the same person. Him!
In the end, with his secret out to the world. There's no need for differentiating Phantom and Fenton anymore.
But he still realizes what he wants is what both sides of himself strived for.
He wants to fight evil and protect as many as he can.
But he also wants to experience life like a normal teenager too.
Finding a balance between these two is something he'll always struggle with, but that's life.
And with the end showing him with the globe of the world on his hands, showcasing how he protected the planet. It could be considered a nice sentiment, but at the same time an omen too.
It could be showing us that Danny now bears the weight of the world.
If given the chance to explore further (if ever) in the future. There could be multitude of stories. One of which Butch Hartman himself alluded to. Where Danny now seeks shelter in his ghost half.
So he tries it with himself. And we got two Danny's... just not the way he'd hoped.
The pendulum has swung the other way. Now he's going to take on everything. No matter the price. Which is a great plot point that I would love to see explored.
That's it. Hope you guys like these takes.
















