@citta-alveare
Ty, to start with, I wouldâve loved to talk to you privately instead of doing this. You probably donât remember me and I donât blame you -- Iâm Nitro, and we talked quite a lot several years ago, back when the team was first looking for assistant moderators and I was one of them. I dropped off the face of the earth due to mental health problems and life problems, and I regret not communicating about that fact, but thatâs all rather beside the point now.
There were so many other ways you couldâve handled this. Not just this situation, but for YEARS. Let me just give you the benefit of the doubt and say that your decisions and intentions were reasonable on your end, and that the moderatorsâ perceptions of it are a result of poor communication and miscommunication. Iâm sure that part of this really is a result of communication issues. But in that case, it doesnât matter what your intentions and motives were; ultimately, itâs still your responsibility that things got this bad and that none of it was ever resolved. You are responsible for this mess, no matter how you spin it. And you canât frame yourself as âsolely responsible for Citta even existingâ without taking responsibility for things that have been festering under the surface for so long.
Iâm not trying to frame you as âthe devilâ. None of the moderators were trying to frame you as âthe devilâ. There is no black-and-white here. There is only the cold, hard facts: there were and are problems in the mod team, there have been for years, and all attempts to fully resolve them were stopped because you wouldnât actually resolve them. Forget about this particular blow-up, too -- again, this has been going on for years! I know for a fact it was the reason at least one former mod left, and I suspect it was a factor for several others. Because you couldnât bring yourself to take responsibility.
This doesnât make you evil or awful, strictly speaking. It makes you a terrible leader, though. And regardless of your intentions, you should have taken responsibility for and resolved these things that have been festering in the mod team for so long. If you wanted to do what was best for Citta, you should have found a real solution long ago. The fact is: you didnât, and these are the results. Thereâs no two ways about it. Things that could have been resolved were not resolved, and now the entire community is paying the price.
And your solution was to shut everything down. Okay, fine. But regardless of your feelings toward the community, they are the ones being hurt here more than anyone. More than you. Donât paint yourself as the victim when youâre the one, the ONLY one, who had the power to actually do anything about this. None of the former mods have EVER tried to slander you, and the way they handled this situation, before your retaliation, left you with as much dignity as possible, while also no longer refusing to be transparent with the community being hurt by your actions and inaction. (Or should I say âunableâ to be transparent, given your aggressive response to this.) There were some members who said things that I donât think they should have, dragging you through the mud preemptively, but donât frame this as if the moderators launched a smear campaign.
And in the end, even if it were a âsmear campaignâ, youâre still the one ultimately responsible. Youâre still the one who sat by and allowed these problems to grow to the breaking point instead of establishing an authentic and mutual understanding with the mod team. Youâre still the one whoâs never been willing to take responsibility or really listen and change yourself when there have been problems in the past. You can claim all you want that you âdidnât knowâ, but I know former moderators tried to talk to you about these kinds of issues, and are now being framed as having âconspired against youâ.
This isnât just based on the current (former?) modsâ word; this is something Iâve been partially aware of for a long time, and even then, the people who told me that never tried to slander you or frame it like youâre a terrible person. No one is out to get you, Ty! Youâre the only one that you have to blame for things getting this far.
Iâm not saying this because I think the worst of you. I think itâs frustrating, actually, because I remember talking to you at great length about things exactly like this issue. I know that youâre aware that communication is the only solution to issues like these, and that reacting like you just did is only going to make things worse. For yourself, for the community, for everyone. I donât know you well, but I fully believe that you know better. But I donât think you apply that thinking to yourself. Iâm sure you donât realize it, but you really need to take this time to think on your own actions and attitude toward the people around you. You donât seem willing to even try to understand anyone elseâs perspective on your words and actions.
You reacted incredibly abrasively to the mod team trying to sort out this mess and give the community a way to move forward, when your actions and lack of communication in locking them out of the account are what caused this; how else are we supposed to take that? What else are we supposed to think of you, and of the situation? Should we give you the benefit of the doubt just because you say so? You, the one who seems to have no intention of fixing things or trying to help the community move forward in any way? Who seems to have no concern for the outcome of this except indignation over how youâre being treated? Who, even now, wonât take responsibility or give any attention to trying to fix the situation? Respect is something you have to earn, not something given by rights of existing, and if there were ever any time you couldâve earned the whole communityâs respect, it would be in how you chose to handle this situation.
Instead, all youâve done is provide first-hand evidence for everything that the mod team has said about how youâve treated them over the years -- including accounts that I heard years ago. Repeated and unrelated accounts of this incredibly unkind treatment and your refusal to take responsibility are not a coincidence, and you no longer have any room to defend yourself.
You reacted to problems being unveiled by pinning all the blame on David and his actions. For comparison, he reacted to your response by admitting to previous problems, saying he was wrong, and expressing the desire to improve the situation and clear the air if anyone so desires. That is the mark of growth and maturity thatâs going to be required from you if you ever want to try to recover from this fallout in the future, and have healthy friendships with any of the people involved again. I really do hope that youâre able to reflect and understand the problems with how youâve handled things over the years. You might not be a âperpetratorâ, but youâre not the victim here. You have no right to frame it as such.
You need to grow, Ty, and the mod team and community need to grow without being smothered by someone who canât take responsibility for his own actions. Something that has already involved and affected the community for years has finally become public to the community. Weâre not here to play the blame game, and no one is trying to play the blame game with you -- the only thing thatâs happened is that youâre being forced to deal with consequences for your own behavior over the years. And thatâs not a fucking smear campaign.
Please, please, please, reflect on this and at least try to understand where things could have been different if you had acted differently. Iâm not fond of total defamation and stripping people of their dignity as a person, or of their potential to become better. You can become better. But youâre not going to manage it by being self-righteous.
Thank you for creating Citta; I really mean this. I met some of my closest friends because of it, directly or indirectly. I have a lot of really good memories from it, including getting to talk to you for a time and learning a bit about you. I wish it didnât have to die at the hands of its own creator because you wouldnât deal with these problems properly. But youâre the one who wanted so much credit for being responsible for Citta existing, so, fine -- youâll have to deal with being responsible for its death, too.











