hihi you guys, i have another thing from my youtube here!! this time it's a deltarune cover!
okay. so for this cover, i mainly started with the piano-ish instrument you can hear at the beginning of the original track (i initially thought it was a sort of string instrument when playing through ch4 for the first time, but as it turns out it's just a piano with a higher attack!) a good portion of my time on this cover was mainly spent trying to layer a bunch of instruments on this part to try and get the sound as accurate as possible, which i rlly struggled with initially, as even though the initial instrument IS a piano, i felt that the pianos i was using from garageband didn't sound as "synthy" as the original (there's not rlly a good way to describe my issue with it here, so apologies if that doesn't make too much sense! all you have to rlly know is that i didn't think what i was doing initially sounded too accurate bc it sounded too much like a regular piano.) eventually i got a good collection of instruments layering this part to get something like the original's quality, but it definitely was a massive roadblock to getting started with this whole cover (i think i settled on like 2 pianos, 2 guitar-like synths, 1 vocal synth, and 1 bell synth.)
from there, i had to figure out how to apply the higher automation to that bit to actually make it.... you know, resemble the original. i initially tried to go for some volume automation shenanigans (i'd start with a lower track volume at the beginning of each note, then increase to the regular level about 3/4 of the way through the note and keep it there until the note ends, at which point the whole thing repeats.) this, obviously, was *very painful* to do, since i had to repeat this process for each note AND adjust it for the different volume levels of each instrument making up this part (which, again, that's like 6 instruments in total) to keep the mixing for that part consistent. and sure, i could copy paste the automation pattern, but for some reason garageband just..... gives up on the pattern actually copying over properly after a while?? like it just scrambles the whole thing for no reason.
and admittedly, all that would've been fine - i've done worse stuff with volume automation before - but garageband was weirdly consistent with just straight up crashing if i tried doing this for the cover, to the point that it corrupted my project file one time! so obviously that sort of forced my hand to find a more elegant solution, which i eventually did - envelopers! instead of doing volume automation by hand, i can just apply my enveloper (i'm using an ios app called flux mini 2) and just edit the attack directly (sort of? i'm still kinda unclear on the exact way envelopers work if it wasn't obvious lolol), and as long as each note is the same length (which the main piano bit for dark sanctuary very much is), it works perfectly!!
anyways, after this, a lot of the cover was (mostly, big exception coming up) smooth sailing! i added the bass parts for the cover in (it's just strings and an organ, the part itself wasn't actually too complicated either), put in some strings for the chorus section at the beginning and flute section at the very end (mostly just chords, but these were pretty difficult to figure out just by listening, so i used a very helpful deconstruction of dark sanctuary that i've linked in the youtube upload!), set up the lead instruments (just an oboe and bassoon playing the same part, followed by a two-voice string part repeating the melody of those two instruments, then flutes + violin + strings covering the melody/countermelody to the end), and did the little piano (no attack this time) harmonization/texture... thing part (i actually let an organ double this part bc i thought it blended the part rlly well into the whole sound when the choir/string chords are present, so it doubles the piano in the first choir section and at the very end.)
the next hurdle to the whole cover was (probably unsurprisingly, since i imagine most of you have heard dark sanctuary before) the choir. in the original song, this part is performed live by itoki hana - replicating the quality of that sort of performance with garageband instruments and midi was quite a difficult challenge!! i think i eventually got a kind of okay result by layering this string/vocal synth that i've been keeping in my custom instruments bank on garageband for a long time now (it's kind of my go-to whenever i'm doing vocals/any lead strings in my original songs, since it just sounds neat) and the "female choir morph" synth, but unfortunately it rlly doesn't hold a candle to the original performance.
not to mention, on top of finding instruments that can imitate that original's sound, i need to do a whole bunch of pitch bending to properly replicate the actual performance, and that would've been too painful even for me (for reference, that's two instruments that double a four-voice choir where each voice needs to slide to the next note, which all need to be done in an app where the process for performing pitch bends is literally just "go into the keyboard, switch your mode to pitch, hit record, put your finger on the digital keyboard and pray to the deity of your choice that your swipe across the keys resulted in a pitch bend that actually matched the tempo bc garageband cannot be bothered to quantize that bs. we're also gonna randomly increase the gain for the inevitable merge of choir parts that you have to do to fit in the maximum instrument limit for a project, so your final choir track will have weird volume inconsistencies for no reason. and we're cursing you with weird audio bugs and a chance to crash the app every time you reopen this project and hit play, because fuck you"). in short, the choir part in this cover is like, necessarily kind of mid compared to the original, as i unfortunately am only mortal and there's only so much you can do with garageband!! either that or i'm just stupid and missed something that could've made this whole thing way easier.......
and finally, we've got the percussion!! i actually rlly liked doing this part for this cover! it's nothing too fancy, i'll admit - just 3 layers of regular acoustic drumsets and some eq shenanigans to ensure that the tom drums rlly get their moment to shine in the choir sections (they only rlly feature in sections where everything's kind of making a lot of noise, so i figured they need a little boost so that they're not lost in the sound.) besides that, it was a pretty simple part to suss out from the original track! i will say that i did kind of try to give the percussion's rhythm a little more flavor by having a guitar synth blend into the percussion and imitate the tom drum rhythm with some blocky chords (i don't think it's actually that identifiable in the final cover, but trust me, it surprisingly added a lot of very crucial texture to the bass-mid section in the first choir section + the section right before the end where the violin and flute are performing the melody.)
beyond that, all that was left to do was to merge the instruments and percussion into their own separate tracks to make mixing a bit easier (instead of balancing every single track, i can just merge instruments into their individual parts, which i know sounds super basic, but like this is the first time i actually thought to do this so.......) and exporting the final track to audacity so that i can make sure that the track isn't peaking the audio and/or blowing out anyone's eardrums.
and that's it!! thanks for reading all this (at least i assume you did, idk i'm not your mom) and for listening, and i hope you all have a great rest of your day!!!!!













