Hi, I want everyone to know that Cyr is to blame for my villain arc here. I just wanted a nice and fluffy āfuture Dick gets to save past Jasonā with cuddles and happy endings, but Cyr ran wild and made it even more angsty. But you know what? FINE! Iāll PLAY! And Iāll make it everyobody elseās problem! You want me to be evil? Oh, I can be evil. WATCH ME.
See, Dick shrugs his shoulders and goes on the mission anyway. After all, how bad could it be? Future!Dick was probably just some kind of fraud anyway. And if he wasnāt? Well, he should have known not to try to change the past. There are RULES for that. No harm, no foul.
But then Dick comes back, and the desperate warnings of future!Dick are barely more than an afterthought by the time he passes out cold in his apartment in Blüdhaven. He just wants to sleep for⦠well, how about a week? That sounds nice. Afterwards heās gonna see what all the fuss with Jason was about.
And everything is normal. Dick goes to sleep, he wakes up, he treats himself to a long, hot shower and his favorite bowl of cereal afterwards. He crams his cellphone out of his pocket, powers it up and⦠huh, fine, ok. Maybe there was a bit of a crisis with Jason. Ten missed calls, three texts asking him to pick up the phone, and one more telling him to screw himself for not picking up the phone. No voice mails.
Dick groans because.. darn it, heās SO not in the mood for Jasonās teenage angst. He just got back from one hell of a mission. A mission to space. Heās allowed to have some time off, right?
But thereās this niggling feeling. The echo of future!dickās desperation and frantic attempts to get him to cancel the trip and⦠well. Dickās been working hard to improve his relationship with Jason anyway. He should probably go have a look what all the fuss was about. He wouldnāt put it past Bruce to have put his foot in his mouth again and wait for Dick to pick up the pieces.
Maybe, he thinks with a dry sense of humor, Jason even moved out, like Dick. Maybe he called to tell him heād move to Blüdhaven. Wouldnāt that be hysterical?
God, how naive Dick was. How stupid. Because he drives to the manor and itās like stepping into a house haunted by⦠something. Dick refuses to put a name to it. Heās just being paranoid. Maybe the blinds are all closed because Bruce wants to sleep in. Maybe all the gadgets strewn around the halls, abandoned and discarded, as proof of a busy night in town.
And itās fine. Itās fine. Thereās no reason to assume anything is wrong just yet (never mind that Alfred wouldnāt be caught dead letting the house go into such disarray. Never mind that Dick stumbled over several broken vases and shattered mirrors. Never mind that the manor looks like a poltergeist raged through its halls). Itās all fine. Dickās just gonna check up on Jason real quick, maybe have a small fight with Bruce or something, and pop back over to Blüdhaven for some well deserved rest.
But when he gets to Jasonās roomā the door is open. Itās never open. Jason keeps it closed religiously, asserting his safe space with vengeance. Dick still remembers the shiner the little shit left him with the first time he barged into his room unannounced. Remembers the screaming match he had with Bruce about it. Remembers feeling indignant and angry because Bruce had taken Jasonās side even though DICK was the one whoād been attacked. Remembers Alfred sitting him down and explaining about Jasonās life on the streets. Remembers feeling guilt and embarrassed and so, so ashamed of himself.
But the door is open, and Dickās stomach does that weird swooping thing butā itās fine. Itās all fine. Jason justā forgot to close it. Thatās it. Thereās no reason to assume this isnāt normal. Horses before zebras, and all that.
But then he calls Jasonās name, carefully sticking his head into the room ā he just wants to hear Jasonās voice, just a small little āget out, dickhead!ā would be enough alreadyā but instead the words get stuck in his throat because itās not Jason he finds. Itās Bruce, curled up at the foot of Jasonās bed. Looking beaten to hell and back, a five oāclock shadow on his face heās never seen before, with eye bags that look like he hasnāt slept for several weeks.
This doesnātā this isnāt right. This isnāt right. Nobody is allowed in Jayās room. Especially not without him there. And Jasonās room is always in pristine condition but now itā it looks like a hurricane razed through it. Only the desk is still orderly andā and thereās a⦠note? Thereās a note on it. But Dickā Dick canāt step inside the room. Not without Jayās permission. He canāt. Bruceā Bruce probably asked Jason before coming up. Because Jason is having a sleepover or something andā Bruceās room must be trashed or something. Right? Right??? And Jason and him had a monumental fight and now he feels guilty, right????
But he knowsā there must be answers down in the cave. Mission reports, telling him why Bruce is all banged up.
And he leaves the room. And he flees to the cave.
And as Dick looks at the footage of Bruceās cowl from Ethiopia, as he sees the glass case holding a burned and bloody Robin suit, as he reads the autopsy report and burns it into his memoryā-
All Dick can hear is the distorted, tinny voice of himself screaming over the phone. Pleading with him. Begging him to go home, to let someone else handle the mission. To go back and talk to Jason.
He screams and cries into the echoing silence of the cave until his voice gives it, cursing himself for failing another family member. For killing his baby brother.
He had the chance to prevent it, and yetā- and yetā-
It doesnāt get better. The guilt is eating him alive.
Dick learns to live with it. To work around the grief and the pain without letting it consume him entirely.
And Tim is there. Tim⦠Tim helps. Because Dick can focus on him now instead of his own failure. And sometimes, sometimes, in his own mind, he pretends that itās Jason at his side. That itās Jason smiling at him, babbling excitedly about a new case. Beaming at him when Dick shows him another move.
It doesnāt get better, but with time it becomes⦠bearable. He still looks at the last texts Jason sent him the day heā from that day. He still looks at them, still wonders. Still replays the phone call with his future self over and over, but he no longer has to wonder at the desperation in that voice. he knows it intimately now.
But with Timā with Tim, he will be better. This isā not a second chance. Because itās not about chances. Itās about how he let another family member die. Itās about how he may as well have pulled the trigger. Itās about how Tim is not allowed to die because if he doesā Dick is going to follow him.
And then Red Hood makes his bloody debut in Crime Alley, and everybody and their mother knows heās out for Robinās head.
And all Dick sees is red becauseā Joker will not take Jas- he will not take Tim like he did Jason. He wonāt let him.
(He dreams of the phone call every night now. He dreams of his future self, begging him to go home. He dreams of Jason in the rubble of that accursed warehouse, asking him why he didnāt.)
But easier said than done, because Dickā Dick severely underestimates Hood. They all do. But itās fine. Timās at Titans Tower now, on lockdown, with several metas to keep him safe, Bruce out hunting the crazy crime lord through Gotham like a blood hound, and Dick well on his way to joining Tim at the tower. It never hurts to have one more vigilante standing guard, right?
Except when he gets thereā itās to the Tower dark and silent, with his footsteps echoing like death along the walls. And all his mind is screaming is a cacophony of no-please-no when he sees the first smatter of blood against the sterile white of the floor.
And when he rounds the cornerā Hood has his knife pressed to Jaā to Timās throat. Andā and Dick canāt see if heās even still breathingā oh, god, please let him be breathing, please, please, he canātā not again. Not again.
(āYou need to go home! Screw the mission! You need to-ā)
And Hood laughs, and he draws the knife across Timās throat, and Tim goes down with a weak gurgle and Dick wants to die, please, pleaseā
But- but thereās not enough blood. Not enough for his arteriesā thereās still time. Thereās still hope. Please, please, anything but this. Anyone but J- Tim. Please.
So he bargains. He bargains with Hood āPlease, Robinās no fun anymore, see? But me? You can still make me scream. Please.ā
And Hood accepts. And Hood leaves Tim bleeding and broken on the floor as he lunges at Dick and plunges the needle into his neck butā but itās ok. Because even thoughā even though Hood may doā may do things to him nowā at least Dick got to see Timās chest move before the darkness pulls him under to the backdrop of Hoodās distorted laughter.
Itās ok. It doesnāt matter what happens to him now.
At least this time he didnāt fail.