“We don't need a Jaeger to be in Drift”

Like, when they're clearly communicating but not using a single word.

The entirety of the forbidden friendship scene, the little looks they keep sharing throughout the cartoon series, that moment when he breathed out and looked at Toothless before taking his first step with his prosthetic leg, like giving himself courage through his friend.

And cannot forget Toothless' looks of sass, exasperation, joy, determination.

And them just sharing that bestie™ look when Johann starts recounting stories neither wanna hear

Hmm, depends on when he gets these wishes.

I think if it was before he shot down Toothless, he would have wished to truly be that extra large boy with beefy arms and extra guts and glory one the side.

Hiccup has one very single minded goal in his life before he met Toothless, which was to earn the respect and love of his tribe and his Father. Once he had that, or at least believed he had the means to earn it, he would perhaps struggle to think up something else because...who was he after that? What did he want.

He wouldn't wish for the friendship or affection of the gang or Astrid, he would believe he'd have to earn those, so I think with his second wish he'd perhaps look towards his passions. Perhaps his second wish would be to be a great blacksmith and inventor.

And I think for his last wish, he would take time to reflect on it. Think more about how he could help the village. Crazy and contrasting to his first wish as it might be, I think Hiccup would wish for the dragon war to end. Despite the fact we would just have gotten a way to kill dragons and be a "true" Vikings, he's just that kind of guy.

If it was in Rtte era, I think his first and instantaneous wish would be to fully and 100% know and memorize al the knowledge the Dragon Eye holds, so that he could then destroy it and keep it out of hunter hands.

For the sake of the discussion, lets mak so that he can't wish for safety for all dragons ever. I think then he would wish for the ability to be able to convince and show everyone the truth about Dragons, about the wonderful benevolent nature of these once feared beasts. It wouldn't be instant peace from one moment to another, but for me that feels pretty Hiccup-y

I think he'd keep his last wish in his back pocket in case of an emergency, and would probably use when his friend get in great trouble, like maybe instantly healing Astrid's eyesight in Blindsided.

If it was in httyd 2 it would stuff that was happening at the time, like convincing Drago, maybe healing his arm for good measure, or when he sees his parents dancing he wishes for them to be happy together again for the rest of their lives and thus preventing A LOT of people shedding some tears(including some writers here i know)