I love your Charmed videos so much and had no idea you were the same person who also makes my favorite gifsets!!You speak so beautifully.
I'd love to hear your most truly unpopular Charmed opinions? A few of mine:
I genuinely prefer Phoebe/Coop to Phoebe/Cole despite (because of...?!) how little we actually saw of them.
One weird reason the first season is my favorite (in addition to other reasons you and your anon have mentioned in support of S1!): it feels the most Wiccan somehow? I'm not Wiccan but I find it interesting, and with every passing season the show drifted further away from exploring or even mentioning Wiccan concepts. It's such a shame because that's such a potentially fascinating, unique aspect of a show centered around witches!
I think we need more genuinely kind, earnest good guys as male leads so really WANTED to love Leo, but nothing about the character works for me - the writing, the acting, his often totally unnecessary role as a guide who doesn't really offer much that they can't find in the Book of Shadows anyway. Even more extremely unpopular: Piper acted like such a perpetually angry, bitter nag with him literally 90-95% of the time to the point where I'm like "does she even love him, or...?!"
Related to #3 but Piper is actually my least favorite of the sisters. She has amazing moments, but overall I just don't enjoy watching her. I THOUGHT I'd love and relate to her the most - not just because basically every Charmed fans adores her but because I too am an anxious introvert who's allergic to change and just wants a calm and peaceful life. I really tried, but I just found her a really unpleasant person more often than not, and her negativity and constant complaining made this otherwise spirited and fun show such a bummer sometimes (please don't be mad -- these are just my UOs and I know nearly everyone disagrees!) Anyway, Prue/Phoebe (if they'd kept Phoebe her S1-S2 self!) and Paige would be my ideal Charmed trio :)
I get that as the most intuitive, emotionally oriented sister who loves psychology and even enjoys writing (first spells, then advice columns!), Phoebe's job as an advice columnist SHOULD be perfect for her, but I just didn't enjoy that arc for her character---she stopped being the adventurous sister most enthused about being a witch and the unconventional and instead became kind of a generic rom-com career woman?! I don't know, I'd just rather her have had a "job" that kept her more in the weird supernatural realm, maybe by catching criminal demons alongside Darryl :)
Thanks for letting me vent! I can't wait to hear your UOs too :)
Thanks for the ask, Nonnie! So glad you enjoy my vids! As for Unpopular Charmed opinions, I'm not sure I have that many. Probably the biggest one is that I have no love for the Phoebe/Cole ship, in fact, I kinda don't like it at all!
By extension, I've never been a big Cole fan, which I know is highly unpopular. I also don't buy into this view that a lot of the fandom has that the Charmed Ones (and particularly Phoebe) treated Cole badly.
My extreme love for Prue has been unpopular at times, she wasn't always the most loved character.
I also hold the first season as my favourite, agree that it has the best Wicca vibes and atmosphere.