Can an opening quote be considered an unreliable narrator? Jacques Tourneur’s (or should that be Val Lewton’s) CAT PEOPLE (1942, Criterion Channel, TCM) opens with a quote from a book that doesn’t exist, “The Anatomy of Atavism” by Dr. Louis Judd (Tom Conway), warning that “sin cling[s] to the low places, the depressions in the world consciousness.” I suggest it’s unreliable because a) it labels the main character’s turning into a large cat when emotionally aroused a sin when the movie that follows makes it something more sympathetic, a curse inflicted upon the innocent as an accident of birth, and 1) Judd is presented as a condescending twit and, by the end, a sexual predator out to take advantage of what he sees as a traumatized patient. Who’s the sinner here? That ultimately destabilizing moment is the start of what can be seen as a queer odyssey, a product of gay screenwriter DeWitt Bodeen and the European sensibilities of producer Lewton, director Tourneur and cinematographer Nicholas Musuraca.
Ship’s architect Oliver Reed (Kent Smith) and commercial artist Irena Dubrovna (Simone Simon) meet cute at the Central Park Zoo. Her delicate aloofness fascinates the all-American boy, and before long they’re married, even though Simon believes she’s the descendant of Serbian cat people and will kill Smith if he tries to make love to her. Smith sends her to Dr. Judd to see if he can cure what he considers a delusion but in frustration starts falling for co-worker Alice (Jane Randolph), leading Irena to stalk her in a trio of beautifully constructed suspense scenes.
This was the first of nine low-budget horror films Lewton produced at RKO Studios, which — after hefty losses on Orson Welles’ two films — was trying to cash in on the Universal Pictures horror franchise. The studio dictated the titles; Lewton then had a free hand (though they imposed a few shots of slinking panther in one scene that aren’t as intrusive as some make them out to be). His interest in psychology, folklore and stoicism helped create a series of films whose horror lay not in gore or violence but rather in a creeping sense of dread, the fear the universe is just waiting for the chance to get us. There’s also a sense in many of a growing queerness that’s necessary to shake up our staid existence. It’s not just that Lewon snuck gay characters into many of his films, but rather that they destabilize our expectations.
In CAT PEOPLE, the destabilizing factor is Irena. Her kittenish beauty and exotic accent could be the dream of any young man, particularly relevant in 1942, when America’s youth were going off to war in foreign lands. But the dream has a harsher side. She’s a potentially destructive force, first in her inability to bow to the rules of a conventional marriage and then in her possessiveness when she thinks she’s losing Oliver to Alice. It’s fascinating that her curse has resonated not just as a horror trope but also as a representation of both lesbian and trans audiences. Lesbians seize on the moment during her wedding dinner when a glamorous, mysterious woman (Lewton regular Elizabeth Russell) addresses her in Serbian as “My sister.” For them, the threat of violence should Oliver make love to Irena reflects revulsion at the thought of heterosexual intercourse. Trans audiences have seen themselves in Irena’s body language, the way she physically withdraws during tense moments, as well as the physical transformation when she turns into a panther. She’s a woman whose transformation leads society to label has as other, as less than.
Bodeen has also written a poignant reflection of LGBTQ lives in a repressive society, at least as subtext. When Alice admits her love to Oliver, she says, “I know what love is. It's understanding. It's you and me and let the rest of the world go by. It's just the two of us living our lives together, happily and proudly. No self-torture and no doubt.” This is the kind of love denied to people like Bodeen. But when Oliver describes his love for Irena — “It’s a different feeling. I’m drawn to her. There’s a warmth from her that…pulls at me. I have to watch her when she’s in the room. I have to touch her when she’s near. But I don’t really know her. In many ways, we’re strangers” — it’s something darker and more secluded. It’s love for a stranger with whom you’re obsessed for reasons you can’t explain. It’s like the hidden love of gay men and lesbians in more repressive times.
One of the revolutionary things about CAT PEOPLE in 1942 was that it’s set not just in the present, but in familiar spaces. Musuraca’s shadow-drenched cinematography turns New York City into a mystical place. He creates a night world where Irena can shift from human to cat at will, and mundane locations — a walkway through the park, an indoor swimming pool, Oliver and Jane’s architectural office — become sites of horror. Until Irena attempts to attack them there, the latter has been shot rather flatly. But when she calls to see if Oliver’s there and later slinks around among the drafting tables, it’s suddenly a nightmare landscape, lit only by the illuminated drafting tables. In the world of Val Lewton, horror destabilizes what we view as normal. It’s in the places we move through every day without thinking. Or maybe it’s the attractive woman you see at the zoo or at the next restaurant table.