YES, I'M NOW OFFICIALLY INSIDE TWISTED WONDERLAND!!
I'll tell you the truth, since EAH is full of werebeasts, I think Ruggie and Jack's hyena-wolf nature might just be the magic touch. Ruggie loves to steal and his hyena form could work so well for the Sheriff of Notthingam,just as the wolf form would aid Jack in his attempt to kill Robin Hood as in the very first ballad of Guy of Gysborn.
ANYWAYS I HAVE SOME OPINIONS ON WHERE THE KIDS WOULD FALL IN THE ROYAL/REBEL CONFLICT. Tell me what you think!!!
So, let's start by saying that I'm working from the assumption that we are in a situation at the beginning of the series where some characters who became could be Rebel,havent found the bravery yet so are listed as royals,so i think that:
Heartsabyul Boys: Riddle would be a royal for the same reasons as Lizzie, namely extreme loyalty and subservience to his mother and tradition.
Ace is obviously a rebel since he is the one who creates the first inflation in the dormitory, and with him,and with him Deuce since he had a difficult past probably sees the rebellion as a way to redemption.
Trey and Carter would be royals, the first out of solidarity with Riddle as he understands his situation, and the second because he is the third born so in fact he does not have any great burden of destiny.
Savanaclaw Trio: The savanaclaw trio would obviously all be rebels given their social disillusionment BUT, and that's why I proposed the Robin Hood thing, I think Leona would be very similar to Book! Sparrow where he is a rebel, but has enough disillusionment to make him a "fuck you,got mine" type,that doesn't care for Raven as a leader
Octaville Trio: The Octaville trio would be like the Lizzie/Maddie/Kitty trio where one is a royal, the other a rebel, but the conflict of interest is practically nil so it doesn't ruin their relationship. Azul is crazy as hell, so being the sea witch is fine for him + the little mermaid doesn't die in the original version, so he can basically be a mad scientist in peace. The Leech twins are rebellious, but more by nature than by ideology (like Melody), so they do their own thing but don't argue with Azul about it.
Scarabia Duo: This is a basic one, but obviously Jamil is a rebel and Kalim is a royal, and they're like Raven and Apple.
Pomenfiore Trio: The pomenfiore trio is complicated! In my opinion, Apel is a royal because, similarly to Blondie, he wants to climb the social ladder from within, so if someone gives up their place, he will replace them
Rook would be a royal, but in that specific way in which he is the Hunstman and respects the ideals of loyalty to one's master that Hunter's father boasts so much.
Vil is very difficult for me because I think he wouldn't mind being the evil queen haha. But at the same time I think he wants to get out of his shadow. I would say Rebel, but in a soft way
Ignihyde Duo: The Shroud brothers are Rebels because they are in a Cerise situation in which they pretty much have to be a rebel, since they did the big fuck up
Diasomnia Boys: So,#hot take but I think Mallus would be like Briar: He claims to be Royal but then acts like a Rebel! Given the importance of the Draconia family he want to keep the status quo, but in the long run his heart desire for rebellion and connettion.
Sebek is obviously a royal because he's Malleus's errand boy. Lillia instead he would be a rebel hoping to make Mallus stop doing something he will regret later. Silver would also be a rebel out of loyalty to Lillia