I read Alan Scott the Green lantern and as I went to log it I saw a review for issue 2 which tried to put a definitive label on Billie whether she is transgender, transsexual, a transvestite or a drag queen. Questioning that if she is transgender why would she have a moustache and if that wouldnât give her dysphoria.
I donât know why she needs a label? So you can find a place to define her in your mind? The point is that she is who she chooses to be and expresses herself in the way that she chooses to.
Definitive boxes and labels are something I see the queer community discuss all the time and I do think labels help to an extent and how people identify and express themselves, in a general sense. However, I donât think that labels are a requirement if she doesnât have a label does it really that deeply affect how you take in her character.
Iâm nb and for a long time I struggled identifying that because I thought that I had to be cis, trans man or that nonbinary meant I had to be androgynous all the time or I wouldnât be a âreal nbâ if I did anything that was particularly either way. I prefer to leave my own gender identity unlabelled for the most part because of that, Billie could very well be the same.
Iâm not going to say having such rigorous definitions limits the queer community but I think it creates a mental barrier into accepting whoâs who or what is what because they donât identify themself with a definition you know and are comfortable with. Billie could be a she/her gay man, she could be a trans woman, she could be a drag queen. The point of the comic wasnât what Billie was. Itâs who Billie is and if the way she expresses herself is with a moustache and makeup then all the good to her. The only definitive information we have about Billieâs identity is that she likes using She/her pronouns and why do we need any more.
Real queer people are complicated and having a character that doesnât neatly fit into a box is realistic and I enjoyed seeing.
I think in a way Alan is the same way, at the end of the comic Todd asks about Molly and Rose, he says he loved them and that Todd and Jennie were made for love. But he is still gay and not fluid, I really enjoyed this. Thereâs complexities and depths to this stuff that go beyond gold star gays or text book trans people and having that in media is a good thing on the whole. I think.