Responses for Asking for Pronouns
I have decided to create a compilation of all of the responses to the asks that have been about asking for pronouns. I will edit this post as/ if more people comment.Ā
Anonymous:Ā How would one sign "pronoun", if there is a sign as opposed to fingerspelling? I know ASL doesn't use pronouns bc of indexing, but I'd still like to know how to ask someone "what are your pronouns?" in order to use the proper ones in text outside of ASL.
Signinggifs:Ā Iām pretty sure you have to fingerspell pronouns because of indexing
kynehalliforn: Iāve known people to sign it #PRO NAME
thecaitortot:Ā That makes sense because the sign for NAME is the same as the sign for NOUN and ASL profs use them interchangeably.The issue would then be how to communicate exactly what youāre asking without the person thinking you forgot their name. I would probably ask ā#PRONOUN YOU PREFER WHAT?ā Where the pound symbol shows the finger spelled word.
aslfan:Ā This can help and possessives here
imnotokaythanks:Ā My ASL professor (I live in AK, there are differences depending on where you are) said she would sign it YOU GIRL BOY WHICH because the āwhichā question leaves it open for them to say what they identify as
whimsicallioness: GLOSS: YOU IDENTIFY MAN WOMAN WHICH or YOU PREFERĀ āCATEGORYā *fs*SHE *fs*HE WHICH
signinggifs:Ā I was wondering about this, but that excludes nonbinary people and assumes that he/him/his are āmale pronounsā and she/her/hers are āfemale pronounsā which is not necessarily true.
pina-fiesta asked:Ā Bouncing off the pronoun question, but would it really matter in Sign? Everything I've learned up to this point has just been sort of pointing/signing at the subject, or using their name. And if you're continuously talking about one person, would you need to keep saying "him/her" anyway, or sign their name? It seems like something that would be a context clue type thing. I haven't learned a lot of sign, so I'm not entirely sure. Thanks!
signinggifs:Ā I have received a few questions about this and that is true and I think you did a good job of explaining it. I am assuming the person asking was asking for if they were hearing and would later need to use pronouns, or (as they said) if they were to need to write pronouns. Here is a link to a post I made about indexing and pronouns, but to properly learn more I highly encourage googling it.Ā
farfr0mn0rmal asked:Ā As far as I've learned, pronouns are irrelevant while signing. The pronoun question shouldn't need to be asked unless from someone who will verbalize later. I think simply fsPRONOUNS with the question indicator should be enough.
gameboygirl:Ā in the signing group I practice at (in MI, Ann Arbor area), we start each session asking for pronouns. We sign it ā[Sex/Gender] + Word.ā (So, for gender, we use the X hand, touch the side of the face on the cheekbone, then chin.)Usually the response would be, āI use female [sex/gender] words,ā āI like [gray/whatever] [sex/gender] wordsā
slightmayhem:Ā to avoid the āsheā āheā/ WHICH nonbinary exclusion, you could add OTHER. (YOU IDENTIFY MAN,WOMAN,OTHER, WHICH, etc) Ā Iāve also found a video iām not sure how widespread these signs are which is inclusive of multiple variants of nonbinary identities. Gender stuffs (video)












