On Trauma and Internalization
Remember how The Man in the Wall antagonized the Dreamers after The Sacrifice? Ordis had every right to be concerned about the negative psychological ramifications of our transference flow into Excalibur Umbra being inverted back into our own mind:
Ordis: “Operator, you need to stop this! You could suffer permanent harm from Umbra's memory. What if you internalize all this?”
A warning that fell upon deaf ears. But as it turns out, Ordis was cooking with his analysis.
Dreamer: “I killed him... Isaah.”
The Indifference: “Did you now? Is that how you remember it?”
The Indifference: “GOOD.”
The Man in the Wall finds our internalization of this memory as our own— the internalization of this trauma— as being good. It is framed as being a favourable turn of events for It. Why?
Well, thanks to Archimedean Margulis, we know that the intensity of their pain, the strength of their power, and their ability to control their power are all positively correlated to the amount of emotional distress they had suffered and the severity of psychological trauma they had endured during their time aboard the Zariman 10-0. This was the breakthrough Archimedean Margulis had been looking for. The mental and emotional state of her children governed their newfound abilities. This left her with a seemingly impossible goal: figuring out how to heal a mind ravaged by the unfathomable horrors it had been subjected to. And as Teshin revealed, Margulis had to get creative, because she could not find a way to sever their link to the Void.
Teshin: “Margulis lied to you: a lie of omission. She did not cure the Zariman children— she 'erased' them. My only hope is that truth still lingers inside you, buried within your mind. The power and the misery... of the Void.”
The children of the Zariman could not be cured in the traditional sense. However, knowing how their power worked, Margulis was able to suppress their Void power as much as possible by creating memory gates, sealing away all recollection of their time aboard the Zariman 10-0. It would weaken their Void connection to the point that the children would stabilize and could control their previously uncontrollable abilities. This was part one of her three part solution. First, seal the problematic memories to "dull [their] sensitivity to the Void". Next, put them into The Dream. Finally, link their minds to surrogate bodies that could contain their Void power such that they would be able to lead normal lives and eventually reintegrate into society.
Margulis: “This will stop the Voices from taking hold. You will have to dream, my angels. Dream... not of what you are, but of what you want to be.”
In The War Within, the Dreamers were able to break free of the mental hold The Twin Queens had on them during Continuity by undoing the memory blocks Margulis had placed on them. This caused their traumatic memories to resurface, and the Void power that had been suppressed along with them was able to manifest once more. This rediscovered power gave the Dreamers the strength needed to reject Continuity and cut their transference link to save themselves. As Teshin said:
“Your repressed memories and powers have returned, fused with your Tenno abilities, amplifying them. You've outgrown the cradle. Now your Transference is innate.”
But this increase in power came at the cost of now remembering the horrors and the trauma of the Zariman. And at the end of the quest, The Man in the Wall makes Its first canonical appearance. Why? Simple: the Dreamers had reestablished a proper connection with the Void. With this increase in their Void power, they were now once again visible targets for this entity. Operator Rell was able to trap one of its façades in a transference loop within his Warframe because he had never entered "The Long Dream". Unlike his fellow Operators, he was aware of this entity from the very beginning, unlike the other children who entered The Dream, allowing him to fight It to his very end.
The Indifference: “You mad at me, kiddo? Did you forget? You're nothing without me. You owe me.”
So, it's clear that trauma and pain are instrumental in both the strength of the Void within the Tenno and the ability of The Man in the Wall to manifest itself. At least, this is how the narrative presents it. So for The Man in the Wall, the Dreamers internalizing MORE trauma, trauma that does not rightfully belong to them, is great. It strengthens their power and also Its hold on them. This would explain why The Man in the Wall has instigated some of the most emotional quests out there and done so in a way that is intentionally emotionally damaging. Not only did these events go on to further traumatize the Dreamers, but the sequence of events that occur due to It leading them around eventually culminated in the opening of a Void portal big enough to attract the attention of (another form of) It in Sol, triggering a renewed attack by Its Murmur, who seek to strengthen the Threads of Khra, which would allow It to get a big enough foothold in reality to (presumably) break/pass through The Wall of Lohk. And as Teshin plainly states:
“The Void Angels are assaulting the Undercroft, tearing rents in its fabric. Undo what their claws have done. If the Void Angels break through the Wall, their Master will be freed. We cannot allow that to happen.”
Similarly, Archimedean Yonta offers:
“Something I wasn't sure existed has burst through the Albrecht Membrane, and right now the Zariman is plugging that hole. The Angels are clawing at the Albrecht Membrane, creating ruptures that will saturate the area with Void. Failure to seal those ruptures immediately will result in, well, total reality failure. Not good. This typically results in death.”
Teshin, alongside the Drifters in the Void, and the Holdfasts, alongside the Dreamers in the Zariman, are fighting a tireless war on two fronts, both with the same goal: to prevent The Void Angels from tearing through The Albrecht Membrane/The Wall of Lohk to keep The Man in the Wall from breaking through into their world. Meanwhile, the Cavia are fighting to prevent the Murmur from achieving the same result beneath the Entrati Void Research Enclave— the seat of the Void in material reality. Keeping this entity weakened and out of our reality is of paramount priority, emphasized across three major updates.
From what we see in Whispers in the Walls, although trauma, pain, and coldness seem to empower this being, love, compassion, and kindness seem to weaken and/or placate It.
This leads to the question I found myself asking in Jade Shadows. Did transferring into Jade result in the Dreamers internalizing what occurred in her final moments the way they did with Umbra? And if it did, was what they internalized a positive memory (à la the miracle of life from someone who fought hard to achieve it) or a negative memory (from being forced at bladepoint to give birth only to subsequently die during the childbirth... as a teenager).
I can't say which way the Dreamers would lean (from an endonarrative standpoint); however, I do know that this would be a fantastic tidbit to canonize and explore alongside the Umbra memory. If using the positive interpretation, it could be the antithesis to the internalization of killing “their son” (Isaah) by internalizing a new memory of “giving life to their son” (Sirius). This may very well have been the angle DE was going for (since Umbra is explicitly mentioned for the first time ever since The Sacrifice, immediately before this sequence of events occurs) even if the execution was left wanting. I think it would be so cool if the narrative doubles back and discusses this, its implications, and how even something as disconnected from The Man in the Wall as Jade Shadows could ultimately tie back into it, just like The Sacrifice, and finally talks about things like the negative internalized emotions associated with being forced to give birth at bladepoint only to die in the process as a teenager and how that has to be insanely damaging— to say nothing of the guilt you'd feel from not being able to save Jade despite all your effort (before dying with her). I'd also like to see us (preferably Loid or Lotus) properly address how The Man in the Wall seems to feed off of all this internalized trauma.
If The Indifference knew about what happened in Jade Shadows, Its Walls would be wet rn who said that!?.