V
āWhat we once enjoyed and deeply loved we can never lose, for all that we love deeply becomes a part of us.ā
ā Helen Keller
A/N: This is the final part of the interlude but not the last weāll see of Freddie. My Freddie/OC fic will be released later this year.
Warnings: curse words, mentions of parental abandonment, angst
Series Masterlist
Word Count: 4,200
The next two days moved slowly, not only in pace but in feeling. It was almost as if the world had been shifted slightly off its axis. Conversations lagged. Mornings bled into afternoons without clear boundaries. Time passed in small, domestic increments measured by bottles, naps, and the soft squeak of Ameliaās bassinet.
Fred was always there.
He wasnāt always holding Amelia, but he was never far from her. He lingered in doorways or hovered near the couch, pretending to occupy himself with something else while his attention remained fixed on the bassinet. Over the past several days he had become the first to stand when she stirred, the first to check the bottle warmer, and the first to glance at the clock and mutter quietly that she had eaten about two hours ago.
No one commented on it.
Auston and Tia kept themselves busy with packing. What had been meant to be a short stay in Toronto had stretched into nearly a month, and the reality of returning to Scottsdale loomed closer with every folded shirt. Their bedroom looked like a storage unit exploded inside it. Clothes from before lockdown mingled with the things Tia had brought from her old apartment. Taylourās outgrown shirts were stacked neatly into donation bags near the door. Even a small pile of newborn clothes Amelia had already grown out of had begun forming on the dresser.
Tia cleaned obsessively. She wiped counters that were already spotless and reorganized cupboards that didnāt need it. Pantry shelves were lined with quiet precision, labels facing outward. It was easier to control the physical space than the emotional one.
The envelope followed Fred everywhere.
What had once been pristine white now bore faint water stains and softened corners from condensation. Tia had stuck it to the refrigerator with a magnet, and now it lived permanently at eye level. It stared at him every time he made a bottle, every time he reached for formula, and every time he deliberately pretended not to notice it.
He knew it had to be opened.
But he also knew that once it was opened, everything would change. But it brought more than change. Whatever choice came after would be permanent. There would be no more temporary arrangements and no more living in the uncertain middle ground. Somehow, facing a screaming infant at two in the morning had been easier than facing that envelope.Ā
So he waited until the flights out of Toronto were booked and the apartment was filled with half-packed boxes. Until there was nowhere left to hide.
Amelia was awake in his arms when the moment finally came. Her eyes were wide and curious, her incredibly small fingers fisted into the fabric of his shirt. Fred rocked her gently, his thumb brushing absentmindedly across the soft curve of her cheek.
āYou want me to open it?ā Auston asked.
Fred didnāt look up. āMy hands are kind of full.ā
They both knew it was a lie. Fred had already mastered the art of doing almost everything one-handed while holding Amelia. This wasnāt about logistics. It was about distance. About fear.
Auston hesitated, then reached for the envelope. āOkay.ā
He pulled it from the fridge, tore it open, and unfolded the paper. Medical language filled the page - percentages, terminology, and clinical phrases that meant very little until suddenly they meant everything.
Tia was in the living room with Taylour, trying to sort toys into piles while he argued passionately that every single one needed to come back to Arizona with them. Their voices hummed in the background, unaware of what was unfolding in the kitchen.
Auston continued to scan the page.
Fred felt the shift immediately. It was subtle, but unmistakable. Austonās shoulders dropped just slightly, and the rhythm of his breathing changed. Fred wiped the corner of Ameliaās mouth where a thin line of drool had formed, his stomach sinking before the words were even spoken.
āSay it,ā Fred said quietly.
Auston looked up. āFredāā
āAuston,ā he interrupted, voice firm now. āSay it.ā
Auston swallowed and took a steadying breath. āItāās⦠itās negative.ā
Fred snatched the paper from his hands,Ā his eyes scanning desperately as though reading faster might somehow change the outcome.
0% probability of paternity.
Zero.
He stared at the number, waiting for something inside him to rearrange itself. Waiting for the rush of relief he had been anticipating for weeks.
It never came.
Instead, disappointment settled deep and heavy in his chest,Ā heavy and suffocating. He was supposed to feel free. Untethered. Vindicated. Instead, it felt like something had been taken from him before heād even admitted he wanted it.
āFred,ā Auston said gently. āIām⦠Iām really sorry.ā
Fred didnāt respond. His knuckles whitened around the paper as he continued staring at the line that had already made its decision.
Tia approached slowly from the living room. She had sensed the shift in the room before she had even heard the words. Moving carefully, she stepped closer and rested a tentative hand on his arm.
āIf you need anythingāā
āIf I need anything?ā Fred snapped. He turned so abruptly that Amelia startled in his arms. His voice rose, sharp and unfiltered. āWhat I needed was for this to be over weeks ago. For none of this to happen at all. But you couldnāt leave it alone. You had to drag your own issues into my life.ā
Tia recoiled as if she had been struck.
āYou forced this,ā he continued, anger spilling out now without direction. āYou forced me to stay involved. You wasted weeks of my life because you couldnāt handle the thought of me walking away after what your mother did years ago.ā
āHey!ā Austonās voice booms through the kitchen, Ameliaās eyes widening at the intrusion. āYou donāt get to talk to her that way.ā
Tia opened her mouth to respond, but the words never came. The shock left her momentarily speechless.
āWhy not?ā Fred scoffs. āItās the truth. She brought her mommy issues into my life, and now here we are.ā
Tiaās eyes were glossy, her breathing was unsteady. āI didnāt do this to hurt you,ā she finally said softly. āI did it because Amelia deserves the truth. You deserve-ā
Fred let out a bitter laugh. āAnd what did that get anyone?ā
He looked down at Amelia then, noticing the way her tiny fingers had curled tightly into his shirt. Something in his expression fractured.
āUnbelievable,ā he muttered.
Before either of them could stop him, he turned and headed for the door, grabbing Ameliaās bag as he went
āFredāā Auston started.
The door closed behind him with a force that rattled the frame.
A thick, disorienting silence settled over the apartment. For a moment, Tia didnāt move. She stood exactly where she was, staring at the closed door as if it might reopen, as if the moment could still be undone if she waited long enough.
It didnāt.
Her knees buckled suddenly, and she reached for the edge of the counter to steady herself. The sound that escaped her was small and broken, nothing like the words she had wanted to say.
Auston was at her side instantly. He wrapped an arm around her shoulders and pulled her against his chest, his hand moving instinctively to the back of her head. His jaw was clenched tight, anger simmering beneath the surface, but none of it was directed at her.
Down the hall, Fred walked quickly, his stride uneven, chest heaving as though heād just in from a hard workout. Amelia was tucked tightly against him, his arm locked around her far more protectively than necessary, as though loosening his grip even slightly might somehow cause her to disappear.
He had expected to feel relieved.
That was what everyone assumed this moment would bring. Relief. Freedom. Closure.
Instead, his chest burned with a sharp, unfamiliar ache. Anger tangled with grief, disappointment settling heavily in his gut. The cruelest part was the realization that he had only just begun to imagine a future he never thought he wantedāand it had been taken away before he could even decide whether to keep it.
Tia was still shaking. Auston didnāt answer immediately. He just held her a little tighter, letting her breathe through it.
She had never imagined Fred getting attached. From the beginning he had been clear that children werenāt part of his plan. He wasnāt supposed to want this. The DNA test wasnāt supposed to cause this kind of devastation. It was supposed to bring clarityāanswers that might someday allow Amelia to understand where she came from.
Fred deserved that.Ā
Amelia deserved that.
And what about Ameliaās real father?
The question surfaced suddenly and refused to leave. Didnāt he deserve to know she existed? Didnāt he deserve a chance to decide whether he wanted to be part of her life before she was placed somewhere else entirely?
Tiaās breath hitched as the questions piled up, each one heavier than the last. Tears welled, then spilled freely down her cheeks, unstoppable now.
āTia,ā Auston said softly, his voice steady even as he tightened his arm around her. āNone of this is your fault. Okay? None of it.ā
She shook her head slightly against his chest, not trusting herself to speak.
āHe knows that,ā Auston continued gently. āEven if he canāt see it right now. This just⦠hit him all at once. He never expected to want her. He never expected to feel this way.ā He paused, searching for words that could make sense of something none of them had anticipated.
Tia swallowed hard, nodding faintly.
She knew, logically, that this wasnāt on her. She hadnāt cheated on Fred. She hadnāt left a baby on his doorstep and disappeared. But she had pushed for the DNA test. She had insisted that he find out the truth, and that insistence had stretched the process out long enough for Fred to form a bond with a child who wasnāt his.
āHeās mad,ā Auston said quietly. āAnd I get why. I really do. But heās not mad at you. Not really. Heāll realize that. Heāll apologize. He just needs time to sort through it.ā
Tia wiped at her cheeks.
āI justā¦ā Tiaās voice cracked. āI wish there was something we could do. Something to fix it.ā
Auston sighed, resting his chin against the top of her head. āI know.ā
She hesitated before speaking again.
āI wish we could find Jessica,ā she whispered. āGet in contact with her. Sort all this out somehow.ā
Auston didnāt respond right away.
Not because he didnāt care but because the truth was complicated.
He didnāt have a way to reach Jessica. But he did know someone who was close to her. Close enough that, with a phone call or two, it might be possible to track her down.Ā
But that would mean taking control away from Fred yet again.
And Fred had lost so much of it already.
His life had been upended overnight. His future had been rewritten without his consent. Stepping in nowāstarting to search, to push, to solve things on his behalfāmight feel less like help and more like another decision made for him.
Auston tightened his arms around Tia slightly. āIf Fred wants that,ā he said carefully, āweāll help him. Any way we can.ā
Tia nodded, though the tension in her shoulders didnāt ease.
āBut it has to be his choice,ā Auston added quietly. āRight now, he needs to feel like he has some say in what happens next.ā
They stayed like that for a long moment, surrounded by the quiet aftermath of something none of them had expected. Answers might exist somewhere but they would have to wait until Fred was ready to look for them.
**
Fred was at their door at six in the morning.
Not knocking. Just standing there.
When Auston opened it, the sight of him made his stomach drop.
Fred looked like hell.
Deep purple shadows sat under his eyes, his cheeks swollen and blotchy in a way that didnāt come from sleep deprivation alone. His hair was unwashed and sticking up in directions that suggested heād spent the night running his hands through it. He was still wearing the same clothes from the night before, wrinkled and stretched, like heād slept in themāor hadnāt slept at all. The anger was still there, but it had dulled overnight. What remained beneath it looked fragile.
Grief.
Without a word, Fred stepped forward and pressed Amelia into Austonās chest, a little too abruptly. āI need to talk to Tia.ā He said, voice was rough as his throat was raw.
Auston adjusted instinctively, cradling Amelia as she slept peacefully, completely unaware of the chaos surrounding her. āKitchen,ā he said quietly, nodding down the hall.
Fred didnāt hesitate.
The apartment was still. No cartoons hummed in the background and no toddler chatter echoed through the rooms. Taylour was still asleep, and Felixāwho had woken them at 5:30 demanding a bathroom breakāhad already crawled back into bed.
Tia stood by the counter, hands wrapped around a mug she hadnāt touched.
Fred stopped a few feet away.
āHi,ā he said.
It came out small.
āHi,ā Tia replied, just as softly.
He swallowed, jaw tightening, eyes dropping briefly to the floor as if he needed to gather himself before he fell apart entirely.
āI am so sorry,ā Fred said finally. His voice cracked on the second word. āI was a complete jackass. I neverāneverāshould have blamed you for any of this. And bringing your mother into it?ā He shook his head, disgusted with himself. āThat was cruel and unfair. It crossed a line.ā
Tia didnāt interrupt. She just listened.
āThe truth is,ā he continued, āyouāve done more for me in the past few weeks than I can even process, let alone thank you for. You stepped in when you didnāt have to. You carried me through something I didnāt think I was capable of surviving.ā His voice dropped. āAnd I donāt think I ever actually said thank you.ā
āYouāre welcome,ā Tia said quietly, her breath shaky.Ā
Fred nodded once, his eyes glassy. āI got attached.ā He had felt this for a while but saying them out loud brought an unexpected feeling.
She met his gaze. āI know.ā
āI didnāt expect to,ā he continued. āI was so sure I wouldnāt. I kept telling myself I wouldnāt. And then somewhere along the wayā¦ā His throat tightened. āIt happened.ā
āThen you found out she isnāt yours,ā Tia finished gently.
He nodded.
āIt was the biggest gut punch of my life,ā Fred admitted. āBut that wasnāt the worst part.ā He looked up at her then, eyes burning. āThe worst part was realizing I was disappointed.ā Silence fell over the kitchen. āWhen we took that test, I wanted it to be negative. I wanted this whole thing to be a mistake, something I could walk away from without looking back.ā
Tia studied him for a long moment before speaking. āYou can still sign it,ā she said carefully. āThe birth certificate. You donāt have to be her biological father to do that.ā
Fred shook his head immediately. āI canāt.ā
He glanced down the hall, where he knew Auston was hovering, and asked. āWhat would you have done if two years ago you found out some other guy signed Taylourās birth certificate?ā
Auston stepped into the kitchen then, caught but unsurprised. āI⦠honestly donāt know,ā he said. āI wouldnāt have handled it well. Definitely wouldnāt be playing in the NHL anymore, possibly be in jail.ā
Fred nodded grimly. āExactly.ā He turned back to Tia. āI canāt go through all of thisāput her through all of thisājust to turn around and take her away from her biological father. The whole point of the DNA test was for both of us to get answers. If I sign it, this was all for nothing.ā
āYouāre right,ā Tia said softly.
Her gaze drifted to Amelia, who was sleeping peacefully in Austonās arms, completely oblivious to how many lives she had already changed. In the span of thirty days, that tiny child had carried an entire lifetimeās worth of emotions through the apartmentāshock, fear, hope, anger, attachment, and now loss.
The kitchen fell silent.
Morning light spilled across the floor in pale, quiet strips. Somewhere far below, the city hummed faintly, softened by lockdown and the early hour. None of them spoke. They had come so far in such a short time, and yet the next step felt larger than everything that had come before.
āI may have a way to get to Jess,ā Auston said suddenly.
Both of them turned toward him.
āThrough Aubrey,ā he added, the words coming out a little awkwardly but with deliberate honesty.
āAubrey?ā Tia asked, arching her brow.
āSheās Jessās friend,ā Auston explained. āWe went on a double date back in November.ā
Tia remembered it immediately.Ā
The memory arrived with surprising clarity: the way Auston had smelled like cologne when he walked into her apartment that night, the careful way he had styled his hair, the crisp shirt tucked neatly into dark jeans. He had looked put together in a way that had felt deliberate, like he was trying harder than usual. She had tried not to notice but her chest had felt tight all evening.
āAubrey,ā she repeated softly, offering a small, noncommittal shrug.
The name lingered in the airāan opening, a possibility.
**
Later that afternoon, there was a knock at the door.
It was faint. Almost tentative. As if whoever stood on the other side wasnāt entirely sure they belonged there.
Tia froze.
She knew exactly who it was, and she had absolutely no desire to be the one to answer it.
Unfortunately, Auston was currently on the living room floor, deeply committed to the architectural complexities of a blanket fort constructed from couch cushions and throw pillows. Taylour was crouched beside him, issuing increasingly detailed design instructions that Auston appeared to be taking very seriously.
Fred was down the hall in the spare room, the door half closed, Amelia tucked securely against his chest.
Since the moment Auston had called Aubrey and arranged a time for her to come by, Fred had barely left Ameliaās side. He fed her. Changed her. Rocked her through naps. When she stirred, he was there before anyone else could even move.
No one interrupted him. No one tried. Whatever this wasāwhatever goodbye he was bracing himself forāhe deserved the time.
The knock came again. Still gentle.
Tia exhaled slowly, squared her shoulders, and walked to the door. When she opened it, she forced a polite, careful smile.
āHi,ā she said, managing a polite, careful smile. āAubrey?ā
āYes.ā Aubrey blinked in surprise, clearly caught off guard. For a moment she glanced past Tia, as if double-checking the number on the door, wondering if she had somehow ended up in the wrong place.
āCome in,ā Tia said, stepping aside.
Aubrey entered and set her bag down near the entryway. She removed her mask, and the first thing Tia noticed was how beautiful she was. That shouldnāt have surprised her. Nearly every woman who seemed to orbit Austonās life carried that same effortless confidence. Still, it made something tighten quietly in her chest.
Then she noticed the similarities.
Dark brown hair, long and loose, falling past her shoulders.Ā Roughly the same height. A similar build. Even her clothesāsimple, understated, casual in a way that still managed to look deliberateāfelt oddly familiar. Under different circumstances, Tia thought they might have been friends.
And with that realization came another, sharper one.
She understood exactly why Auston had been drawn to her.
āThis is some of her stuff,ā Tia said, gesturing to the neatly assembled pile near the wall. Diapers. Pacifiers. Formula. Small stacks of folded clothes. The car seat. The bassinet. Everything Amelia had needed during the past month had been gathered neatly together.
Diapers. A bag of pacifiers. Formula. Clothes folded with care. The car seat. The bassinet. āIāll, umāIāll go getāā
āAubrey.ā
Auston jogged down the hall and stopped a few feet away, clearly sensing the tension before anyone said a word.Ā
āHow are you?ā he asked gently.
āIām alright,ā Aubrey replied. āMostly ā¦surprised.ā She glanced around the condo. āI didnāt know Jess was pregnant. When I saw her in March she wasnāt showing and then with covid, I only ever saw her over FaceTime. She never mentioned it. This is all very⦠shocking.ā
āYeah,ā Auston said lightly, trying to soften the air. āWe could say the same.ā
It earned a small, appreciative smile from Aubrey.
Aubrey went on to explain, she hadnāt seen Jess since lockdown. She spent a little time with her parents but at some point ventured back to the city. She wasnāt sure where Jessica was but she had a group of people helping track her down.
āThere are only so many places she could be,ā Aubrey said thoughtfully. Then she added, almost as an afterthought, āI also probably know who the father is. I could reach out if needed.ā
āIām going to go check on Taylour,ā Tia said quietly. She was already turning toward the hallway. As she passed Auston, she gave him a lookānot jealous or angry, but full of everything she didnāt say.
āIāll, uhā¦ā Auston cleared his throat. āIām gonna go get Fred.ā
As he turned to leave, Aubrey hesitantly asked. āIs that the girl?āĀ
Tia heard the question from the hallway and couldnāt help the soft smile that formed as she approached Taylour.
āYes,ā Auston answered, without hesitation. āThat is the girl.ā
Aubrey nodded slowly, a small smile tugging at the corner of her mouth. āGood. It was painfully obvious you were pining over someone. Iām glad it worked out.ā
āI am too.ā he said, smiling in relief.
āSheās really pretty,ā Aubrey added, almost reflexively.
Auston smiled, something warm and certain settling into his expression. āSheās a lot more than pretty.ā
āI would expect nothing less,ā Aubrey replied.
Auston flushed slightly, gave her a brief nod, and then disappeared down the hall, leaving Aubrey alone in the entryway.
A few minutes later Fred emerged from the spare room with Amelia tucked carefully against his chest. He moved slowly, deliberately, as if each step required conscious effort.
When he spoke to Aubrey, his voice was quiet and steady. He explained Ameliaās routines and habitsāhow she liked to be held, the way she fussed right before falling asleep, the way she preferred her bottle slightly warmer than recommended.
They were small details.
Intimate ones.
The kind of knowledge that only comes from long nights and careful observation.
Aubrey listened quietly, nodding as she absorbed every word.
Fred carried the boxes to her car himself, refusing help even when she offered. One by one he loaded diapers, formula, clothes, and the bassinet. The last physical evidence that Amelia had ever belonged in his life.ā
He stood there longer than necessary with Amelia in his arms, delaying the moment he would have to place her into the carrier. He memorized the curve of her cheek and the slow, steady rhythm of her breathing.
He didnāt say much.
There was nothing left to say.
Finally, the time came to buckle Amelia into her car seat. His hands shook badly enough that he had to stop once and close his eyes before trying again.
He checked the straps twice.
Then a third time.
āOkay,ā he whispered quietly to himself. āOkay.ā
Aubrey didnāt say anything. She gave him a gentle nod, then gathered her bag and hooked her arm through the handle of the car seat.
When the elevator doors finally closed behind Aubrey, the silence that followed felt enormous.
Fred stood there staring at the empty space where Amelia had been only seconds earlier. His arms still felt heavy with the memory of her weight, his body instinctively bracing for the small movements he had grown used to.
But she wasnāt there.
There would be no bottle to warm later.
No quiet pacing across the living room floor while she fought sleep.
No checking the bassinet in the middle of the night just to make sure she was still breathing.
He walked back inside in a daze.
He made it as far as the kitchen before the grief finally broke through.
The sound that left him was raw and unrestrained, ripped straight from his chest as weeks of exhaustion, fear, attachment, and loss crashed down all at once. His hand slammed against the counter in a desperate attempt to steady himself, but it did nothing to stop the shaking that had taken over his body.
Tia crossed the room without hesitation.
She wrapped her arms around him and held on as he cried, pressing his forehead against her shoulder like he had nowhere else left to fall.
āIām so sorry,ā she whispered, her voice thick with emotion.
Fred shook his head weakly, struggling to speak through the grief.
āI didnāt even want her,ā he choked. āI kept telling myself I didnāt want her.ā
His shoulders trembled again.
āBut somewhere along the wayā¦ā
His voice broke completely.
āI loved her.ā
Tia tightened her hold on him, letting him cry without interruption.
And for the first time since Amelia had been left on his doorstep, Fred allowed himself to grieve herānot as a responsibility or a complication, but as the child he had quietly fallen in love with and had just handed back to the world.
Taglist: If you are in this list you have expressed interest in the series (either through likes/reblogs or by asking), or I thought you may enjoy this. If you would like to be removed or added to the list send me an ask:
@nicoleloveshockey @ashloveshockey @heatherloves87 @je-ne-regrette-rien @callsign-denmark @izzielovesspace @starswin @elly-dx @yellowabc @ashleymarine @hockeyinaussie @monnbcĀ @lwstuff @itslivvd @m-1234






















