Colour
Colour is extremely influential when it comes to our emotions, it can enhance and change our moods. When it comes to art, colour allows us to express our personalities and help evoke a particular mood/emotion towards our audience.
Drawing and painting software has become easier to use and accessible to almost everyone over the last decade. As a result many comics, illustrations, and graphic novels have been presented to us in colour rather than black and white. These types of artists would have had to hand draw and hand colour their work which was extremely time consuming and also involved quite a bit of skill to properly render the colour. I found this to be extremely interesting because I don’t know much about illustration and I assumed if one could draw that one could also colour; however, often times with lack of experience the choice of colour could make the work appear amateur and feel carelessly completed.
This is why I find Miriam Katin’s illustrations in We Are On Our Own to be extraordinary because of the tremendous amount of detail and effort behind them. The entire book was hand-drawn and shaded with pencil, which truly shows how raw and personal this memoir is. I feel very connected to her experience emotionally, while reading her experience during WWII the illustrations summoned a deep-rooted sadness within my gut. The monochromatic colour scheme intensifies this turmoil throughout the variations of dark and grey values. This decision–to limit colour really brings to life the truth, authenticity, and rawness of the horrific encounter both Miriam and her mother went through as they escaped Budapest during Hitler’s reign. I thought it was very clever and engaging of Katin to use black and white sketches to resemble her past (childhood in WWII) and pair this with coloured sketches to represent her life as a mother. Not only does the reader get a sense of time passing but we also feel a little light-hearted (we feel connected) when viewing the coloured illustrations because of how she strived to provide an environment for her children. I also found that the coloured sketches scattered throughout the memoir helped established this story as a reflection rather than a re-telling; which ultimately lets the audience know that this is a memoir, not a comic, autobiography, or graphic novel.
As a photographer, we are constantly regarding colour while we are composing a shot. We like to say that when you strip a photograph/image of its colour what you are actually doing is encouraging the viewer to focus on the subject and what is unfolding within the scene instead of focusing on the distraction and bias of colour. Initially I thought maybe this was what drove Miriam to make most of the book in black and white while also primarily setting the time of occurrence. After reading an interview with Miriam Katin and Professor Nicolas Verstappen conducted by du9, she revealed that her choices were “inspired by photographs from those years, especially the pictures of her father during the war” (Katin, 2009). Of course this made a lot of sense, but I still like to think that she intentionally chose a black and white aesthetic to give her audience a truthful emotional experience of her experiences as a war child.
Works Cited
Color vs Black & White: Five Reasons Why Color Comics Are Popular. 8 Feb. 2019, https://onedogcomics.com/2018/09/26/color-vs-black-white-comics/. Accessed 4 Nov. 2019.
This website opened up the world of technique for me when it comes to comics and colour. I had absolutely no idea that just because an individual can draw beautifully doesn’t mean they can also render colour in the same fashion, especially hand-drawn. This is why most mediums we experience today are provided to us in colour– because of advancements in painting and drawing software. Before this advancement artists would have to hand-drawn and hand-colour their master pieces, which not only was immensely time consuming but also required a lot of skill.
Miriam Katin. Jan. 2009, https://www.du9.org/en/entretien/miriam-katin1151/. Accessed 4 Nov. 2019.
This link provides an article published in du9 of an interview with Miriam Katin and Professor Nicolas Verstappen. In this interview we get a sense of some of the decisions Miriam made while working on her memoir We Are On Our On and why she made them. Verstappen and Katin discuss what led her to the medium of comics, what triggered her to write this memoir, and even how she feels about her citizenship. It was extremely helpful to gain an insight on what she is like as an individual but also as an artist and writer.
We Are on Our Own: A Memoir.15 Sept. 2006, http://umanitoba.ca/cm/vol13/no2/weareonourown.html. Accessed 4 Nov. 2019.
This excerpt from CM Magazine made a couple connections and links to the idea that Mariam Katin uses the black and white illustrations of her childhood and juxtaposes them with her life as a mother in colour. It goes on to explain and review a lot of the content within the memoir and provides a brief summary, but I was more interested in some of points created around why she choose black and white with bits of colour throughout to explain her experiences. One really intriguing point was made that the black and white aesthetic resembles the ghosts of her past but the colour represents her struggle to create a happy environment for her sons.














