Regarding Petalkit's original closeness to Ravenwing.. Is it possible, had Mapleshade's secret and true father of her kits not been revealed, that Petalkit would've become a medicine cat?
If that happened how do you think Ravenwing would've felt/responded to learning the truth?
Honestly this is such a fun question!Â
It would have been possible, yes! But she would change her mind later.Â
Petalkit always struck me as a highly competitive kit, and if she felt her brothers were outshining her as warriors, she would shift priorities to become a warrior instead. In canon, she was the one most determined to keep practicing jumping so she could be as good as Birchface. To me, this showed signs of her desire to prove herself, and already setting herself a standard to meet, especially when Rabbitfur talked about Birchface. She was also the most aggressive kit, and I elaborate on this in this post.
I'd say, Petalkit would have gotten as far as being Ravenwing's apprentice, but become envious of her brothers training to be warriors. She would get bored fast and change her mind probably near the end of her apprenticeship, right before the trip to Moonstone. This would surprise and take Ravenwing aback. He'd be a little insecure at first, wondering what he was doing wrong because he was trying so hard to be a medicine cat Oatspeckle would be proud of. He'd be a little disappointed, but understanding in the end, encouraging her to follow what her heart says she should be. Petalkit says she wants to be like Birchface. He would sadly accept it. I mean, it made sense to him. He can be fairly reasonable when he’s not under extreme pressure and feeling the weight of the entire Clan in his paws.Â
Coincidentally, Patchkit would have realized he's not as cut out to be a warrior as he thought he’d be, and didn't enjoy it as much as he hoped. So whenever Petalkit would show Patchkit all the things she learned about being a medicine cat, Patchkit would think it's really cool. He would realize this is where he may fit better, so they swap mentors. Ravenwing gets Patchpaw, and Petalpaw gets whoever mentored Patchpaw.This would raise Ravenwing’s spirits again, happy that Patchpaw admired and was inspired by him and his craft.Â
So, after Ravenwing learns the truth, he would be incredibly conflicted. Bc now he KNOWS what each kit is like, their hopes, dreams, personalities and goals. They are not just kits anymore. They are young cats. The bond is deeper. At this point he would have had more experience being the new medicine cat, so his nerves at meeting Clan expectations would be less severe and urgent. He would still doubt them, question their loyalty (and Mapleshade’s) and even his own. But he has seen with his own eyes how dedicated the kits are to the Clan, and how highly Birchface is regarded by them. How Petalkit was just like him trying her best to be like Birchface and loyal to the Clan, while Ravenwing tried to be like Oatspeckle.
Ravenwing would spend more time carefully thinking about this instead of rushing to overcorrect himself. His interpretation of the omen may have been less antagonistic, bc with the time that had passed, cats had a chance to process their grief better and not be raw with emotions. He would actually ask himself, what would Oatspeckle have done?Â
So he actually would have spoken to Maplesahde in private first. He would still have exposed them, but not so impulsively, and this time he would be cooperative and open minded with Mapleshade.Â