Two Sides of the Same Story / Supergirl x Spiderman! Gender Neutral Reader
At CatCo Worldwide Media, Kara Danversâ a new reporter, struggles to adjust until she meets Y/n Parker, the staff photographer. Meanwhile, under their masks, Supergirl and Spider-Man begin teaming up across the city, developing a friendly rivalry and a strong bond. But what neither expected, was falling in love with each other in both lives.
Warnings: Slow burn. Mentions of blood. Fluff. âWill-they-wonât-theyâ trope.
Word count: 3579
A/n: Save me Bilquis Evelyâs Supergirl! (One of the best versions of her. Only comes in second to Dan Moraâs version). This was requested by an anon. Enjoy it!
The first time Y/n met Kara Danvers, she was standing awkwardly in the bullpen of CatCo Worldwide Media, clutching her notepad like a lifeline. She had that same deer-in-headlights expression every new hire wore when they realized how fast-paced the newsroom really was.
Y/n adjusted their camera strap and offered her a smile as they passed.
âNew?â they asked.
The blonde woman nodded a little too quickly, glasses sliding down her nose. âFirst day. Kara. Reporter.â She extended her hand, and the photographer noticed her grip was warm but unsure.
â[Y/N]. Photographer.â Y/n shook her hand firmly, watching relief flicker across her face. It wasnât much, but in the chaos of ringing phones and impatient editors, one friendly voice went a long way.
From then on, Y/n made a habit of helping her find her footing. Theyâd point out which printer never jammed, who brought the good donuts on Fridays, and which stories the editor actually read instead of skimming. The blonde laughed more easily around Y/n as the weeks went on, and soon their desks became an unofficial partnership zone: Karaâs scribbling away on articles, Y/n sifting through shots to match them.
But if anyone asked, theyâd both deny the way their conversations lingered too long, or how their eyes found each other across the room even when they werenât working together.
The bullpen noticed. Of course they did.
âââââââââ
At night, the story flipped.
The city skyline blurred as Spider-Man swung between buildings, camera traded for web cartridges. Another patrol, another late night. That was when they first ran into herâSupergirl.
The woman landed in a rush of red and blue, cape catching the moonlight as if she owned the night. The criminal sheâd just intercepted groaned on the pavement, unconscious.
Y/n perched on a lamppost, head cocked. âShow-off.â
The womanâs eyes snapped up, startled, then narrowed slightly when she saw the vigilante crouched there. âSpider-Man,â she said evenly, as though sheâd been expecting them.
âSupergirl.â Y/n shot back, pretending her presence didnât surprise them.
It started with simple team-ups. A bank robbery here, a runaway truck there. The two of them fell into rhythm easily, though they never admitted how much they liked having her around. The vigilante would tease the superwoman about her dramatic entrances, and sheâd roll her eyes at their constant banter.
Still, there was an unspoken respect. Supergirl had saved them more than once, and Spider-Man returned the favor just as many times. Rivalry, friendship, something warmer they refused to nameâit grew with every night.
âââââââââ
Back at CatCo, Kara leaned over Y/nâs desk one afternoon, pretending to show them her latest draft while she whispered, âSupergirl saved three people from a fire last night.â
The photographer raised a brow. âYeah? Spider-Man was there too. Guess theyâre making a good team.â
The blonde tried to hide her smile, and Y/n didnât even realize they mirrored it.
It became routine: sheâd gush about Supergirl, and theyâd deflect with mentions of Spider-Man. Both of them talked like outsiders, never realizing they were confessing to each other. Never realizing the warmth in their voices betrayed just how much they cared.
The bullpen noticed that, too.
The tension was everywhereâsubtle enough that both Kara and Y/n could ignore it, but sharp enough that everyone else couldnât. Jimmy raised his brows whenever he caught the pair lingering too close to the copy machine. Snapper grumbled about âoffice romances distracting people from deadlines.â Even Cat Grant herself, sharp-eyed as ever, smirked once and muttered, âFinally, some chemistry worth writing about.â
But the pair in question?
Y/n kept brushing it off. At least, they tried to. The problem was, they felt it twice over. At the office with Kara Danversâthe way sheâd laugh at their sarcastic comments, or the way she chewed her pen cap while deep in thought. And on the rooftops with Supergirlâthe way her determination lit up her face, or how her laugh came easily when their vigilante persona cracked a joke mid-fight.
It was maddening. Like two magnets pulling them in, not realizing they were the same one all along.
And maybe Y/n didnât know yet. Maybe Kara didnât either. But every night they fought side by side, and every day they worked side by side, the line blurred a little more.
It was only a matter of time.
âââââââââ
The newsroom hummed with its usual chaos: phones ringing, keyboards clacking, editors barking for copy like generals on a battlefield. Y/n had learned to tune it out, letting the world shrink to the lens in their hands. But today, it was different.
Kara leaned against their desk, balancing two cups of coffee, her blonde hair tumbling into her face as she offered them one.
âYou look like you need this,â she said with a sheepish grin.
Y/n raised an eyebrow. âAre you implying I look tired?â
The womanâs smile widened. âMore like overworked. Which, considering youâve pulled three double shifts in a row, isnât wrong.â
The photographer accepted the cup, trying not to notice how warm their fingers felt when they brushed the womanâs. âThanks. Youâre too nice.â
Kara shrugged, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear. âOr maybe Iâm just trying to bribe you into staying my partner on stories.â
It was meant as a joke, but the heat in Y/nâs chest wasnât joking at all.
Later that night, they were crouched on the edge of a fire escape, mask tugged into place, listening to sirens howl in the distance. The city had a rhythmâY/n knew when to wait and when to swing.
That rhythm broke with a familiar whoosh.
Supergirl landed beside them, cape fluttering against the wind. âBank robbery, three blocks down.â
Y/n smirked under the mask. âYou always know how to make an entrance.â
The woman shot the vigilante a sideways glance. âAnd you always stall for banter. Letâs go.â
The two of them moved like a single force. Where the woman soared, they swung; where they tangled goons in webs, the woman knocked weapons away like they were toys. By the time the cops arrived, the criminals were neatly tied up, one of them even dangling upside down from a lamppost courtesy of Spider-Manâs webbing.
Supergirl chuckled as she crossed her arms. âYou know, not everyone enjoys being strung up like that.â
The vigilante tilted their head. âNot everyone, sure. But admit itâyou laughed.â
The heroine's lips quirked, fighting a smile. âMaybe a little.â
âââââââââ
The next day, back at CatCo, Y/n found themselves at lunch with Kara in the nearly empty breakroom. The blonde was stirring sugar into her tea, staring at nothing in particular.
âYou ever meet someone,â she began carefully, âwho⊠just makes things easier? Like, they show up, and suddenly it feels like youâre not carrying everything alone?â
Y/nâs chest tightened, because they had. Every night. But they played dumb. âYou mean like a friend?â
âYeah,â Kara said, though the word sounded inadequate. âSupergirl has Spider-Man now. They're funny and frustrating and a little reckless, butâthey make her stronger. Braver.â She blinked quickly, as if realizing sheâd said too much. âI mean⊠at least, thatâs what people say.â
The photographer nearly choked on their ham sandwich. Sheâs talking about me.
Trying to cover, Y/n leaned back casually. âWell⊠Spider-Man probably feels the same. About Supergirl, I mean. They may act like a clown, but they never fought like that with anyone else. You can tell they⊠trust her.â
Karaâs eyes softened, and she looked at them like she wanted to say something more. But then her phone buzzed, dragging her back to the present.
âStory assignment,â she muttered, rising from her chair. âCome on, partner.â
That night, on a quiet rooftop overlooking the city lights, the pair of heroes caught their breath after a long chase.
Supergirl sat on the ledge, legs dangling. âYou know⊠I think youâre my favorite partner.â
Y/nâs throat tightened under the mask. âCareful. Iâll get a big head.â
The blonde-haired woman laughed softly. âNo, really. With you⊠it feels different. Like weâre⊠on the same wavelength.â
For a moment, they let the silence stretch, the city buzzing beneath their feet, her cape brushing against the vigilanteâs arm in the night breeze.
And all Y/n could think was: Sheâs saying the same thing Kara did.
Y/n didnât know how much longer the circle could go unbroken, but for now, neither of them moved to end it.
It was safer this way. Almost.
âââââââââ
The bullpen was unusually quiet that morning, the kind of quiet that only came after a night when half the city had been in chaos. Y/n had swung home barely in time to shower and change before work, their ribs still aching from a near miss with a collapsing wall.
Kara noticed immediately.
âYou look awful,â she blurted as the photographer slumped into their chair. The womanâs blue eyes widened, cheeks flushing pink. âIâI mean, you look tired. Like you didnât sleep.â
Y/n gave her a weak grin, rubbing the back of their neck. âRough night. Couldnât turn my brain off.â
The blonde frowned, studying the photographer with an intensity that made Y/n want to squirm. Kara had this way of looking through people, like she could see every crack they tried to hide.
âWell,â she said finally, âif you ever⊠want to talk about it, Iâm around.â Her smile softened into something earnest. âIâm a good listener.â
The thing wasâthey wanted to. Y/n wanted to tell her everything. But instead, they just nodded. âThanks, partner.â
That night, Spider-Man was late to a meeting with Supergirl. The vigilanteâs ribs still werenât fully healed, but they pushed themselves anywayâbecause she was waiting.
The two of them were halfway through chasing down a stolen van when it happened. A sudden burst of gunfire forced Y/n to swing hard to the side, and pain shot through their chest. Y/n lost their rhythm, miscalculating a web shot, and slammed into the side of a building.
âSpider-Man!â
Supergirl was at their side in an instant, steady hands catching the vigilante before they could tumble. Her eyes blazed with worry.
âIâm fine,â they rasped, even though they werenât.
âYouâre not fine.â The womanâs voice cracked, sharper than the vigilante had ever heard it. âYouâre hurt.â
Y/n tried to joke it offâbecause thatâs what they didâbut when her hand lingered against their arm, grounding them, the words died in their throat.
The woman couldâve pressed, couldâve demanded answers, but instead she just whispered, âDonât scare me like that again.â
âââââââââ
The next morning, Kara hovered by Y/nâs desk, fidgeting with her pen.
âYou disappeared last night,â she said casually, but her voice carried something beneath it. âI calledâuh, just to check inâbut it went straight to voicemail.â
The photographerâs pulse jumped. She called? Y/n forced a shrug. âPhone died.â
The woman gave them a searching look. âYou werenât⊠in trouble, were you?â
Y/n shook their head too quickly. âNope. Just clumsy me. Tripped over my laundry.â
Karaâs lips twitched, almost a smile, but her eyes lingered on them like she wasnât buying it. Like she was connecting dots Y/n didnât want her to.
Almost.
A week later, after another long night of patrols, Y/n found themselves swinging back toward their apartment when a red-and-blue streak intercepted them midair.
Supergirl hovered in front of the vigilante, arms crossed, expression firm. âYouâve been off your game. Distracted.â
Y/n bristled under the womanâs gaze. âIâm fine.â
âYouâre not,â she said softly. âAnd I donât know if itâs the same thing you donât talk about during the dayââ
Y/nâs heart stopped.
ââbut if you need help, Spider-Man, you can trust me.â
The air between the pair was charged with something unspoken, Supergirlâs blue eyes locked on Y/nâs through their mask lenses. For a dizzying second, the vigilante thought she might reach up and pull it away.
But the woman didnât. Instead, she floated back, voice quieter. âJust⊠donât shut me out.â
And then she was gone, cape vanishing into the night sky.
Y/n stood frozen on the rooftop, pulse hammering.
Because the truth was, they didnât want to shut her out. Y/n wanted her to know. Both of her.
And maybe she already started suspecting too.
âââââââââ
The day started with chaos. Not unusual for CatCo, but unusual for Y/n.
The city had been loud all nightâsirens, explosions, that constant pulse of dangerâand the vigilante had barely gotten an hourâs rest before showing up for work. Y/nâs hair was damp from the fastest shower of their life, and theyâd forgotten their tie. Worse, their side still ached from where debris had clipped them during the chase.
Kara noticed. Of course she did.
âYouâre limping,â the woman said as soon as Y/n slid into their chair.
The photographer forced a smile, lifting their camera. âHeavy equipment bag. Occupational hazard.â
Karaâs brows drew together. âYou should be more careful.â
Something in her voiceâgentle, but weightedâmade Y/nâs throat tighten. She sounded too much like Supergirl in that moment.
That night, after yet another patrol, Y/n made the rookie mistake of cutting through an alley to save time. The vigilante had their mask halfway pulled off, ribs screaming from another too-close encounter, when you heard:
âY/n?â
Y/nâs blood froze.
Karaâs voice.
The vigilante yanked their mask back down and vaulted onto the nearest fire escape, heart hammering, as the woman stepped into the alley. She wasnât in her Supergirl suitâjust Kara, clutching her bag against her shoulder, wide eyes scanning the shadows.
Y/n crouched above her, holding their breath.
âThought I sawâŠâ the blonde-haired woman murmured to herself, shaking her head. âNo. Thatâs impossible.â
Karaâs phone buzzed then, and she sighed, turning back toward the street. Y/n didnât move until the sound of her footsteps faded.
The vigilanteâs pulse only slowed when they realized how close theyâd come. One second later, and Kara would have known.
âââââââââ
Two days later, during lunch, Kara leaned over Y/nâs desk with that curious tilt to her head.
âYou ever think about⊠secret lives?â she asked.
The photographer blinked, trying to keep their voice casual. âWhat, like⊠leading a double life? Work during the day, vigilante at night?â
The corner of the womanâs mouth twitched, like theyâd hit too close to home. âExactly.â Kara fiddled with her glasses. âI just think⊠it must be exhausting. Keeping so much of yourself hidden. Especially from people youâŠâ Her voice faltered. ââŠcare about.â
Y/n stared at the blonde woman, words caught in their throat. She was talking about herself. But Y/n couldnât admit they were too.
âYeah,â they said finally, soft. âI think about that a lot.â
The silence between the pair was heavy, charged. For a moment, it felt like the world shrank to just the two of them, their truths hovering in the air between their desks.
And then Jimmy shouted across the room, shattering it.
Kara jumped, cheeks flushed. And Y/n busied themselves with their camera, trying to steady their breathing.
Later that week, Spider-Man and Supergirl stood side by side on a rooftop after chasing down a gang through the city. Both of them were winded, the night alive with neon glow.
The woman glanced at the vigilante, her cape rippling in the breeze. âSpider-Man⊠do you ever feel like youâre lying to the people closest to you?â
The question hit Y/n like a punch.
âAll the time,â they admitted, voice low.
Supergirl nodded, her jaw tightening. âMe too.â
There was a long pause. Her eyes met theirs through their mask lensesâopen, searching, like she wanted to strip away the mask right there and end the guessing.
Y/nâs hands twitched, tempted to tug the mask up themselves. To show her.
But neither of them moved. Not yet.
Instead, the vigilante said softly, âIf they knew⊠I just donât think theyâd look at me the same.â
The womanâs smile was sad, almost bitter. âI know exactly what you mean.â
And then the silence returned, deeper than before, holding all the words neither of them was brave enough to say.
They were getting closer. Too close. One day soon, the masks wouldnât hold.
âââââââââ
It wasnât supposed to happen like this.
The night had started like any otherâsirens, distant explosions, the city calling for help. Spider-Man and Supergirl had split up, trying to corner an armed tech gang whoâd stolen alien weaponry. It should have been routine.
Until it wasnât.
The blast came out of nowhereâan unstable rifle overheating in some thugâs hands. Y/n dodged too late, their web-line snapping as the explosion hurled them through a billboard and into the side of a building.
Pain exploded in their chest. They couldnât breathe. Their mask tore halfway off as they hit the rooftop hard, coughing through the smoke.
âSpider-Man!â
Supergirlâs voice cut through the chaos. A red-and-blue blur landed beside the fallen vigilante, hands trembling as she turned them onto their back. Spider-Manâs mask hung loose around their jaw.
And Kara froze.
Y/n saw it in her eyesâthe shock, the recognition, the world tilting all at once.
âY/NâŠâ she whispered, voice cracking.
For a heartbeat, Y/n thought about lying. Pulling the mask back up. Pretending. But they were too tired, too broken, too done with pretending.
âYeah,â they rasped. âItâs me.â
Karaâs hands hovered above their face, almost afraid to touch. âAll this timeâyouââ
Y/n forced a pained smile. âGuess that makes two of us, huh, Supergirl?â
The womanâs eyes widened, but Y/n saw the truth in themâshe knew the game was up. Slowly, like a curtain falling, Kara straightened and let the weight of her secret slip into the open.
âKara,â she whispered. âItâs Kara.â
The rooftop seemed to go silent, the city below nothing but distant noise.
The pair stared at each other, the pieces clicking into placeâevery smile at the office, every banter-filled fight, every moment theyâd thought was a coincidence.
It had always been her.
âYouâreââ Y/n started.
âYouâreââ Kara tried.
And then they both laughed, shaky and breathless, like two people finally waking up from a dream.
Karaâs hands were still pressed lightly against Y/nâs chest, grounding them. Her voice dropped, fragile but certain.
âIâve been⊠falling for you,â she admitted, words tumbling out like she couldnât hold them in anymore. âAt work, on rooftopsâI didnât even realize it was the same person. But itâs you. Itâs always been you.â
Y/nâs throat tightened. âFunny. I was about to say the same thing.â
The blonde-haired womanâs breath hitched, a laugh caught between nerves and relief. âYou mean it?â
The vigilante nodded, wincing against the pain but smiling anyway. âIâm pretty sure Iâve been in love with you twice over. Just didnât know how to tell you.â
The city lights painted Kara in gold, her blue eyes glassy with something sheâd been holding back for far too long.
And then she leaned down, brushing her lips against Y/nâs, soft but certain.
The kiss was gentle at first, tentative, like testing the truthâbut the warmth of it shattered whatever walls were left between them.
When Kara finally pulled back, her forehead rested against Y/nâs, her smile trembling but radiant.
âSo,â she whispered, âpartners?â
Y/n chuckled, coughing a little. âPartners.â
And for the first time, the word felt whole.
Bonus Chapter:
The Monday after the rooftop incident, Y/n and Kara walked into the CatCo bullpen together. Not side by sideâtoo obviousâbut close enough that Jimmy glanced up from his desk, smirked, and muttered, âTook you long enough.â
Y/n froze. And Kara nearly tripped over her own feet.
âWhatâwhat do you mean?â she stammered, pushing her glasses up her nose.
Jimmy leaned back in his chair, hands behind his head. âPlease. The way you two orbit each other? The coffee runs, the late nights, the âsecret smilesâ you think no one notices? Weâve all had a betting pool for months.â
Y/n blinked. âA what?â
Before Jimmy could elaborate, Snapper grumbled from across the room without looking up from his laptop. âJust get your stories in on time. I donât care if youâre dating, married, or eloping.â
Y/nâs face went hot. And Karaâs cheeks burned pink. The pair both hurried to their respective desks in awkward silence, though their hands brushed as they sat down. Neither of them moved them away.
Later that week, the city needed them both again. A bridge collapse, a stampede of cars, the kind of disaster that once wouldâve felt impossible alone.
But this time, Y/n and Kara didnât just fight side by sideâthey moved as one. Her strength, their agility, her precision, their webs. She caught falling debris while they pulled civilians clear. They finished each otherâs shouts, anticipated each otherâs moves.
When the dust settled, Supergirl turned to the vigilante, hair a mess, cheeks smudged with soot, and grinned.
âNot bad, partner.â
Y/n grinned back, tugging their mask up just enough to meet the womanâs lips for a quick kiss before swinging away.
The crowd that had gathered erupted into cheers. Someone even whistled.
Theyâd never live that down.
âââââââââ
At Y/nâs apartment later, the adrenaline gone, Kara sat curled up on their couch in her civilian clothes, sipping tea from the photographerâs favorite mug. Her glasses were off, hair loose, and she looked more like herself than she ever did in either role.
âYou know,â she murmured, âI think this might be the first time I feel like I can breathe. No masks, no lies.â She glanced at the photographer, smile softening. âJust⊠us.â
Y/n reached over, intertwining their fingers with hers. âYeah. Just us.â
There was silence thenânot heavy like before, but peaceful. The kind of silence that felt like home.
And for the first time since either of them had put on their masks, Y/n didnât feel like they were living two lives. They were living one. With Kara.









