Chapter XXIII: (EXT) Ălenuil Everstar (Pt. II)
Mirkwood became quiet again after the skirmish with the Easterlings. I knew it would not last and my council prepared for war. The guards at the southern border were multiplied and my army spent their days preparing to fight. RandĂșmĂźr recovered but rather than return to the southern borders, he was appointed to council with AldĂĄros. With uncertainty looming, many elves decided to begin the long journey to Mithlond.
Elenadar sent his wife ElarĂan away with their sons SĂźrandĂr and SĂźrandor. Her sister, ElenlĂșin decided to accompany her. Her husband Elenatar sent his sons SĂlrandor and SĂ»lrandĂr. FĂ«aluin tried to convince Linurial to accompany them, but she refused to leave him.
At dawn, I watched a family tearfully say farewell once more. I thought back many centuriesânow wishing ĂlĂșriel had left with my mother and her father.
âI would never have left you,â I heard ĂlĂșriel say to me.
âMust you always read my thoughts,â I asked smiling. âThey are my last bastion of solitude.â
âYour thoughts are as loud as you are,â she said. âIf not more so.â
âI know I could never persuade you to go to Eldamar,â I said. âYou are too stubborn.â
âNo more than any other wife,â she said. âBut I am also the queen and I belong with my people.â
We looked at each otherâa wave of commonality washed over us.
âYou know of the attack by the Easterlings on our southern borders,â I asked.
âYes,â she answered. âFĂ«aluin told me not long after RandĂșmĂźr was brought in.â
âWhat do you think of it,â I asked her.
âI know you have reinforced the southern borders as it is the most likely to be compromised,â she said. âThat will not be enough, for the western borders' greatest weakness lies in the lack Beornings left to help defend it.â
She smiled and left me standing on the bridge in wonderment. As I prepared to go inside, SildĂŽr approached.
âSildĂŽr,â I said. âThe elf I wanted to see.â
âYes,â he asked.
âI think we should reinforce our western borders,â I said.
âIt is done,â he answered. âI have made ArawĂ« aware of it just now.â
âOh,â I said surprised. âHow did you know to do it?âÂ
âBy order of Queen ĂlĂșriel,â he said, smiling. He bowed and went on his way.
I smiled to myself as I went on about my duties. By the afternoon, I was in my study with EldĂŽr, Elranduil and ArdĂŽr discussing what had transpired evening last.
âThe presence of even a few Easterlings means that Dol Guldur may rise again,â Elranduil said. âThough they will not pass this way, evil rises and will come from many places.â
âWe are not nearly as vulnerable to attack as others,â EldĂŽr said. âThere is much trepidation about entering our borders. But whatever remains at Dol Guldur will only attack those beyond our borders. It is as much a curse as it is a blessing.â
âWhat remains at Dol Guldur is precisely the reason there is much trepidation,â Elranduil added. âYou know as well as I that we are no more or less vulnerable from an attack than anyone outside our borders."
âWe may be able keep some things at bay, but not others,â ArdĂŽr said, nervously. âFather, why can you not demand Mother to leave? If she left, I know NinyĂĄre would follow.â
âI cannot persuade ArdĂșin to anything she does not wish to do, son,â Elranduil said. âShould she decide to leave for Mithlond, it will be when she is ready.â
âWe need her,â I said. âThere are few ladies left to attend to the wounded. That is the reason she stays. For now, they are far safer within these halls than they are traveling to Mithlond.â
âThe numbers of elves willing to remain grows less and less,â EldĂŽr said.Â
âBetween here, Rivendell and LothlĂłrien, our numbers dwindle as war grows ever closer. They spoke of it when I returned from Mithlond after I saw Nimeithel and ValdĂșril on their way. CĂrdan spoke of many waiting upon his return from Dagorlad.â
âIt is good to know they are safe,â I said softly, thinking of my mother. âI want them to remember things the way they were, not as they have become.â
âThey lived through much worse, Thranduil,â he answered. âSo have I. I have come to realize that evil is as much a part of the world as good.â
âThere is far too much evil,â ArdĂŽr said. âIt is all around us.â
âIt is here to be heard,â I said. âThere is far more good in this world than evil, but it must speak louder to get our attention and we give it fully because it is easier to hear the howling of a warg than it is the fluttering of a butterfly. We should fear what we become from what frightens us. Fear is the life blood of evilâit cannot exist without it. We cannot give evil what it wants if we are to defeat it.â
âYou have become wiser with age, Thranduil,â FĂ«aluin said as he entered.
âPardon my intrusion, but you have more pressing issues to deal with just now.â
âWhat might that be,â I asked. âWhat could me more pressing than planning for war?â
âYou are needed in audience,â he said.
âWho seeks an audience with me,â I asked, wondering whom had come into my kingdom.
âI am afraid it is you that is being called to have an audience,â he said smiling.Â
âI was told that you must come straight away.â
âWho dares command me,â I said angrily.
âNenduĂźl and TĂĄrimĂ«,â he said. âThey are in their chambers waiting to speak to you.â
Immediately, I calmed down and light laughter filled the room. I looked at ArdĂŽr.
âDo you know what this is about,â I asked him.
âNo,â he answered, perplexed.
I left my study and went toward their chambers. As I approached, the guards opened the doors and I entered to find Nendußl and Tårimë standing with EÀrluin in the middle of the room together calmly.
âNenduĂźl. TĂĄrimĂ«. EĂ€rluin,â I asked. âIs something the matter?â
âWho are we,â NenduĂźl asked softly. âWhy are we different from others?â
âWhat do you mean,â I asked walking to them and kneeling before them. âWho told you that you were different?â
âAranduil,â TĂĄrimĂ« answered. âHe said that we were not like anyone else. So I hit him and sent him away.â
âTĂĄrimĂ«, that was not nice,â I said. âYou should never hurt anotherâespecially your cousin. I do not think he was teasing you.â
âThen it is true,â NenduĂźl said. âWe are different.â
âI do not want to be different,â EĂ€rluin said frowning.
âNo one likes us anymore,â TĂĄrimĂ« said sadly. âDo you like us?
âWhat are you saying,â I asked. Everyone loves you and so do I.âÂ
âThen why are we different,â NenduĂźl asked.
âYou are a boy,â EĂ€rluin said. âI do not want to be a boy.â
âYou will never become a boy, EĂ€rluin,â I began. âAnd you are not different, NenduĂźl. You are elves. Like Aranduil and AurĂel and all the other elves in the kingdom. But you also have some of your mother inside you as well. A small part of her will always be with you.â
âWe are mortal,â TĂĄrimĂ« said. âWe will die like Nana.â
âNo,â NenduĂźl said angrily âI do not want to die!â
âWhat is die, Ada,â EĂ€rluin asked.
âAda,â TĂĄrimĂ« asked. âYou are our Ada now?â Â
âAda and Nana,â EĂ€rluin said defiantly pointing at me.
That took my breath from me. How does one explain immortality to ones so young. I was given the responsibility of their care but tried to keep their parents in their memory.
âYou are,â NenduĂźl said. âOurs is not here. He left us with you. Now you are Ada.â
âYes,â TĂĄrimĂ« agreed. âMay we call you Ada?â
âIf you wish.â
âGood,â NenduĂźl said. âAre we going to die?â
âI do not want to die,â EĂ€rluin said. âWhat is die?"
âDie is when you sleep forever,â I said. âYou can never wake up.â
âLike our other Nana,â TĂĄrimĂ« said. âShe died.â
âWhat other Nana,â EĂ€rluin asked. âWhy is she died?â
âYour other Nana was ill,â I said as I struggled to explain things well beyond their understandingâeven as they tried to understand. âShe went to sleep, EĂ€rluin. Forever. That is what mortals do when they fall ill or grow old.â
âAre we mortal,â TĂĄrimĂ« asked. âIs that why we are different?â
âYou are not fully mortal, TĂĄrimĂ«,â I said. âThe smallest part of you is mortal. The part that comes from your mother.â
âWhat is mortal,â EĂ€rluin asked.
âIt is what we are not,â NenduĂźl said. âWe will never die.â
âElves can die as well,â I said. âBy many ways, NenduĂźl. But I will not let that happen to you or your sisters. You have my word.â
âThat is good,â TĂĄrimĂ« said.
âWhy do you say that,â I asked.
âBecause if we were to die, we would never see you again, Ada.â
They embraced me. I felt happier than I had in a very long time. I was in love with NenduĂźl, TĂĄrimĂ« and EĂ€rluin as I was with TarthĂŽn, Legolas and IsĂlriel.
âNow, go find Aranduil and apologize for hitting him,â I said to TĂĄrimĂ«. âI must go have a word with your Nana.â
âTĂĄrimĂ« hit him,â EĂ€rluin laughing. âShe hits like a girl.â
âEĂ€rluin,â I said. âGo on with your brother and sister.â
She giggled as she ran out of the room with her siblings. I stood up and walked into the hall to find ĂlĂșriel. I saw IsĂlriel speaking with ĂlenĂel, daughter of SildĂŽr. She was as beautiful as IsĂlrielâwith long golden hair and spritely blue eyes.
âYour Majesty,â ĂlenĂel said bowing.
âHello, Ada,â IsĂlriel said. âYou must be looking for Nana.â
âYes,â I said.
âHer Majesty is above us,â ĂlenĂel said, motioning upward.
âThank you, ĂlenĂel,â I said. âIsĂlriel.â
I continued to the end of the hall and up the spiral stairwell leading to the rooms above the thrones. I noticed evening was upon us as I could see eveningâs twilight revealing the  first stars of night. Several elves had begun the nightly ritual of lighting lanterns throughout the palaces. I glanced right to see ĂlĂșriel standing by a window overlooking roaring falls starting to gleam in star and lantern light. She was wearing a long white gown with long delicate sleeves of sheer muslin; her long waves flowing behind her. She turned to see me and smiled as I approached.
âIs there anything you cannot do,â I asked her.
âHow do you mean,â she asked.
âYou raise our children, command our armies, keep our court and somehow manage to always look breathtakingly beautiful.â
She smiled at me then started to laugh.
âOh, Thranduil,â she began. âYou are quite possibly the worst liar in all of Arda.â
âI am not lying, ĂlĂșriel,â I said. âI was paying a compliment to the queen.â
âTo what do I owe such flattery,â she asked.
âEverything,â I said, caressing her face. âThat is what you are to me.â
âAnd you are everything to me,â she whispered before I felt her lips on mine. Â
We allowed ourselves to escape the agony and pain we had endured for monthsâknowing it would not be long before I saw battle againâone last time.âââTKWR:BII The Saga of Thranduil (EXT. VER.) by J. Marie Miller 12-18-17
Images: ©2012, 2013, 2014. Warner Brothers Pictures. The Hobbit: The Unexpected Journey, The Hobbit: Desolation of Smaug, The Hobbit: Battle of the Five Armies. All Rights Reserved.















