Calling Superman a story about immigration feels weird to me.
okay lemme explain.
So Clark is an alien and did immigrate to the planet illegally, his story has never truely felt like one of immigrants to me. For the main reason that he fits in and never truly grew up with his culture.
Immigration wasn't a choice for him, and growing up Clark doesn't really expeirence kryptonian culture.
Like his experience is probably closer to that of someone who was adopted from another country as a baby and so never learned how to speak the language or anything about thier culture. But even that feels weird to me because Superman fits in.
He is a white man, and he doesn't expeirence the same looks or questions that those adopted children get. And Clark will always fit in. He has the advantage in society, and can consider himself an american man without anyone questioning him. And I know his powers make it hard for him to fit in and all, and he does get told to go home and the like.
but he will never experience the same systemic xenophobia that a nonwhite immigrant who moved to another country in the middle fo thier life will feel.
Like I feel two really good examples of immigrant stories are more Martian Manhunter and Supergirl.
Because they both grew up surrounded by their culture and then were forced to adapt to this new way of life, and people will always see them as not human enough.
While Kara defintatly has it easier than J'onn it still is difficult to go to a new planet where you don't speak the language and be expected to fit in immidetly.
Also they are both refugees, so they don't have the option of returning home like some immigrants do.
I just want to add that if you as an immigrant feel that Clark's story is relatable then great! As a child of an immigrant and someone who has spent thier life caught between two places I relate more to those two than Clark, but I'm glad you relate to him. This is just my expeiernece as a second gen immigrant.













