!!!!! 6, 7 & 8 for carcar for the ship game!!!
(ask me about some ship headcanons!)
6. Which character developed feelings first? And is there a specific moment or way this could've happened?
7. Which character confessed their feelings first? And how was it? What did they do? How were they feeling?
8. What was their first date like?
this is such an interesting bunch of questions and I think Iām actually going to kind of answer them all together because at the end of the day they basically boil down to one of my fundamental carcar headcanons, which is that carlos believes saying something makes it real and oscar believes experiencing something makes it real.
so, case in point: feelings. to oscar, developing feelings is defined by the literal experience of Having Feelings. he might not recognize them for what they are in the moment, but once he does, he can retroactively be like āhuh, yeah, that was a Feeling, I guess.ā
carlos, on the other hand, is someone who has to label things. he can do friends things with someone and act like theyāre friends and talk like theyāre friends, but until he mentally files them in the āfriendā folder, they arenāt friends. similarly, he can like spending time with oscar and want to touch oscar and think about oscar in a way that most would not consider very just-friends-like, but until carlos consciously moves him into the folder labeled āfeelingsā in his head, none of those are Feelings. to label it as feelings is to cross the fucking rubicon from āguy whose presence i donāt hate/tolerate/actively enjoyā to āguy who i Like,ā and that semantic shift, i think, holds a lot more weight for carlos than for oscar
so what does this mean for the progression of feelings > confession > dating for carcar? well, my favorite configuration of carcar getting together is a FWB to lovers situation, so this is all written within that context, but I still believe it could be applied to a friends/rivals-to-lovers situation. that said, i think in quite a literal sense, that they start developing feelings at a similar rate. however, oscar is far quicker to identify his feelings as Feelings, and then is sort of comfortable waiting around in that liminal space of friends-with-benefits-but-maybe-not-just-that. externally, his behavior wouldnāt change much, but internally, heād be doing the mental calculus of āif I tell him, is this going to fuck things up between us? would that be something heās open to? how would he react?ā
for carlos, meanwhile, i think there is much less of a difference between acknowledging the feeling versus acting on the feeling. so the minute he mentally takes oscar out of the āfriendā folder and puts him in the āfeelingsā folder, that means carlos HAS to do something about it (remember the call carbono video where carlos was like, āif the guy doesnāt talk to you, new set of tyres immediatelyā? imo carlos is not a guy who silently pines and waits once he finally decides he wants something). so even if heās objectively having the exact same emotional experiences as oscar, he would be much more hesitant to label that experience as feelings. however, once he does make that switch, he is far less comfortable waiting around to act on those feelings, and so ultimately confesses first
ALL THAT BEING SAID, in my mind palace, oscarās truth is:
oscar developed feelings first (or at least at the same rate as carlos)
carlos confessed his feelings first, which oscar reciprocated equally as strongly
carlos developed feelings first (because if oscarās feelings were really Feelings first, he wouldāve shown outward interest/confessed before carlos had the chance)
carlos also confessed first, which oscar, if he reciprocated, did not reciprocate as strongly, or else oscar would have confessed first
once each of them realizes theyāve conceived the progression of their relationship in wildly different ways, they of course both think the other person is a total weirdo for handling it the way they did (āif you liked me before, why didnāt you tell me, oscar?ā āso, in your mind, the time we planned to hook up after australia but didnāt even get that far because i was so dejected and exhausted that you just made me dinner and held me for like an hour instead was just guys being dudes????ā)
and re: first datesāthis disagreement bleeds over into what each of them considers their first date. for carlos, their first date was the first time carlos said āI would like to go on a date with you,ā and oscar came over and they made dinner together and hooked up etc etc etc
oscar (correctly) points out that this is the like 9th or 10th time theyāve had dinner and hooked up and the only difference between this time and last 10 times is that this time carlos said āthis is a date.ā therefore, functionally, they have been dating for months. carlos disagrees vehemently until, in the middle of post-dinner foreplay, oscar says, well, if you insist we havenāt been on a date before, you should know I donāt put out on the first date, and carlos swiftly changes his tune