you weren’t planning on falling in love, but what happens when both Spider-Man and Michael Kaiser swing into your heart? now you’re left torn, caught between the two— Spider-Man or Michael Kaiser?
creds banner from pinterest , divider from @/strangergraphics !
lily ❦⋆ : dedicated to @mixolya °❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・ for motivating me to complete this. ilyplsenjoy! 𝄞⨾𓍢ִ໋
not spoiler-free ! [ some manga spoilers ]
fluff / angst / mentions of blood and violence.
( using fem pronouns as it’s easier for me however feel free to imagine others )
status: completed 10-03-25
𝔰𝔱𝔞𝔯𝔱,
act 1 volume l
🕸️ 001 . hottie! underneath the mask
🕸️ 002 . please? no, MICHAEL KAISER!
🕸️ 003 . echoes! of the game
🕸️ 004 . fateful encounters
🕸️ 005 . caught! between the line
🕸️ 006 . between truths and lies
🕸️ 007 . shattered perceptions
🕸️ 008 . on the edge
🕸️ 009 . accidentally going viral over MICHAEL KAISER!
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
summary: you lived a perfectly ordinary life—until one day, you accidentally sent a love letter to RIN ITOSHI. everyone thought you had a crush on his older brother, when in reality, it was rin you were in love with all along.
inspired by Jenny Han’s ‘to all the boys i’ve loved before’.
# hand drawn dividers by @inklore
𝐢𝐧𝐜𝐨𝐦𝐢𝐧𝐠 ₗₒᵥₑ ₗₑₜₜₑᵣₛ 📨
💌 #one love letter mix-up.
💌 #two when the past comes running.
💌 #three nurse’s office.
💌 #four sae's younger brother.
💌 #five uncharted territory.
💌 #six coming home, in your arms, is the right place.
notes from lily ❦⋆ : fake dating with rin is what i didn’t know i needed .. hope you enjoy this mini-series! i wrote this because xokitty was trending on tiktok but i really enjoyed LJ’s story more 🥹💖 thank you for reading this til’ the end. <3
synopsis when the star football player Michael Kaiser shows up at your window injured, you tend to his wounds and uncover a deeper side to him. as secrets unfold and emotions rise, you find yourself questioning your growing feelings for him. wc 1.8k
as you skimmed through your textbook for the calculus exam you were struggling with, doubts swirled in your mind. you couldn’t shake the unease about inviting a stranger into your house. your study lamp was the only source of light in the dim room.
your thoughts were interrupted by a knock at the window.
you glanced over and saw a silhouette of a man outside. hesitant at first, you received a text “i’m here.” it was from kaiser. as soon as you opened the window, a gust of wind rushed in, followed by the sight of a shivering Michael Kaiser.
"did you really climb up a 15-story apartment? you could’ve just come through the front door."
you stepped aside, letting him in as he walked around your room, inspecting your bedroom. “nice room.”
“yeah, it’s nothing special, though.”
his gaze fell on your study table, where papers were scattered everywhere. “oh, what’s this? calculus? you’re struggling with this?” he hid a smirk behind his smile.
“hey! this is the only chapter i need help with, and my exam is soon”
as he stepped closer to the light, his face was illuminated, and for the first time today, you saw his features clearly.
“what’s that on your face?”
his eyes met yours, but before he could respond, you stepped closer, brushing your fingers over his cheek. you felt the cut and bruise.
he quickly pulled away, looking down, hiding behind his hoodie. “it’s nothing. just a cut from football.”
“no, it’s not nothing,” you insisted. “let me help you. i’ll go get it the first aid outside.”
as you carefully tended to his wounds, you couldn’t ignore how close his face was to yours. just as you were finishing up, he winced, and a rush of sympathy just hit you. this bruise seemed to cut deeper than just the surface.
“you know, normal people use the door,” you said, attempting to ease the awkward tension hanging in the air.
“yeah, but then i wouldn’t get to see that look on your face. totally worth it,” he replied with a faint grin.
you opened your mouth to respond but decided against it, letting the words hang in the silence. his eyes, however, never left yours.
“i know what you want to ask,” he said, breaking the quiet.
“what?” you asked, your voice softer than you intended.
“you want to know where i got all these bruises,” he said, his tone unreadable.
“i mean, yeah but if you don’t want to talk about it, that’s fine”
“just a rough game, tackles hit harder sometimes. it’s not a big deal.” he shrugs
“you’ve got bruises everywhere, and a broken rib the other day and i’m supposed to believe this is just soccer? what soccer have you been playing?”
he leans back slightly, smirking, “why are you so worked up over this? maybe i should get injured more often then?”
you shot him a look. “don’t even joke about that. do you think i want to keep patching you up every time you get yourself hurt?”
“i didn’t ask you to but maybe you secretly like it”
"yeah sure, i just watching you wince in pain," you teased, smacking his bicep lightly. but the way he flinched made you pause.
your brow furrowed. "wait are you hurt somewhere else?"
"no" he said quickly, but the way his hand instinctively clutched his arm betrayed him.
you shot him a pointed look, and he sighed in defeat. "fine."
slowly, he pulled off his hoodie, revealing a nasty injury on his arm. you breath hitched as you took in the sight—though it wasn’t just the wound that caught your attention.
this was your first time seeing his tattoo up close. the intricate blue rose tattoo on his arm was impossible to ignore, the way it seemed to almost bloom under the light. as you gently cleaned the wound, your fingers brushed against his skin, and your eyes lingered a second too long.
"cool, right?" his voice was softer now, almost playful.
you glanced up at him. "yeah but why a blue rose?"
he hesitated, a faint smile tugging at the corners of his lips. "honestly? i don’t really know. i got it after i started playing football. it just felt right."
there was something unspoken in his words, something that made your heart beat a little faster. but before you could press further, a loud knock echoed through the house, snapping the moment like a twig underfoot.
“oh no that’s my dad! you have to hide! and don’t leave this room”
he raised an eyebrow, clearly amused by your sudden panic. “your dad? is he one of those ‘clean my shotgun while i meet your friends type?”
you glared at him, shoving him toward your closet. “don’t test it. now go!”
“fine, fine relax schatz.” he scrambled to his feet, wincing slightly as he moved. “but if he asks, i came through the door like a normal person.” surrendering his hands in the air.
“just hide!” you hissed, practically shoving him inside. he ducked into the cramped space, grumbling under his breath about how tight it was.
the knock sounded again, louder this time. taking a deep breath, you smoothed your hair and rushed to open the door.
your dad stood there, holding a set of car keys. “hey, i left my keys at home and just wanted to let you know i’m heading out to work again. need anything when i come home?”
you forced a smile, trying to steady your heartbeat. “nope, i’m good! thanks.”
he frowned slightly, eyes narrowing as he glanced past you into your room. “are you okay? you seem... jumpy.”
“nope, not at all. actually, i was just doing yoga” you leaned casually against the doorframe, praying he wouldn’t notice the slightly ajar closet door.
“in the dark?” he asked calmly but still suspicious.
“yeah it’s just a girls thing hehe”
after a long moment, he shrugged. “alright. i’ll be back tomorrow morning, love you.”
as soon as the door closed behind him, you let out a breath you hadn’t realized you were holding. turning back to the closet, you yanked the door open.
“coast is clear”
he was sitting on the floor of your closet, holding one of your old basketball trophies. “didn’t know you played. pretty impressive.”
you grabbed the trophy from him, trying to hide the blush creeping up your cheeks. “just a past time hobby.”
you sat beside him despite the small space, the silence between you heavy but not unwelcome. for a moment, it was just the two of you, the closeness offering a strange sort of comfort.
“you have a nice dad,” he said softly, breaking the quiet.
“thank you,” you replied, glancing at him. “he works really hard, and i try my best to make him proud.”
he hummed in acknowledgment, leaning his head back against the wall. his gaze seemed far away, as if the room had disappeared around him. “my dad used to beat me up for every little thing i did, especially when we didn’t have any food.”
he words hit like a brick, cutting through the air with quiet devastation. your breath caught, and you turned to him, studying the way his expression stayed oddly calm, like he’d come to terms with it long ago or maybe just buried it deep.
“that’s awful i’m so sorry,” you whispered, unsure if anything you said could even begin to be enough.
je shrugged, offering a faint, bitter smile. “it was what it was. i guess some people aren’t meant to be dads.”
you hesitated, the weight of his words sinking into you. “but you turned out different. you’re not like him.”
he finally looked at you, his eyes softer now, as if your words had reached a part of him he didn’t let people see. “i try” he murmured, his voice almost inaudible.
“your calculus, let me help you with it” he whispered.
you blinked at the sudden shift in conversation, confusion written all over your face. “my calculus? are you seriously using my math homework as a distraction right now?”
“yeah as a reward for patching me up, i’ll help you. you can’t say no because i’m not leaving here until you understand derivatives.”
he sat up, and walked over to your the notes you spread out on the table.
in the past hour he has taught you, you catch yourself watching him more than your notes. the way his brows furrow in concentration, the way his voice softens when he's explaining something challenging.
"see? it’s not that hard," he says, leaning back and grinning.
shaking your head. "yeah, easy for you to say. you ace everything without trying."
"that’s not true," he counters, his tone lighter now. "i’ve got a lot going on, just like you."
you hesitate, noticing the way his grin fades slightly as he speaks. for a brief moment, his vulnerability peeks through again, and it stirs something unfamiliar in your chest.
"you know you’re not what i expected” you say without thinking.
he looks at you, curiosity flickering in his eyes. "what did you expect?"
you shrug, trying to play it off, trying to not get on his nerves “i don’t know. some overconfident star athlete who only cares about himself. but! you’re different."
he smirks, “glad to know i’m not a total cliché."
you find your heart beating faster, your mind racing with the realisation that maybe this isn’t just some casual friendship.
"why are you looking at me like that?" he asks, breaking the moment.
you blink, heat rushing to your cheeks. "looking at you like what”
he smirks, leaning closer. there it was, undenying gaze— intense, unflinching, and impossible to look away from. It was as though he could see right through you. you swallow hard, unaware of how close he is.
"maybe i should go," he says, but there’s hesitation in his voice.
and for the first time, you find yourself not wanting him to leave.
series MASTERLIST
notes from lily ❦⋆ : my fever went down so i decided to just post this, hope u enjoy & thank you for waiting!
i know kaiser didn’t really go to school but i feel like if he did then he would’ve been smart at everything…
TAGLIST
@mixolya @x3nafix @96jnie @tamashithe2nd @cookielovesbook-akie @yuiearyi @noomimi @stargirljas @jhsluvv @sof888a @livelaughloveshidou @swagkittybear @axquella @passw-0-rd @hwaassaa @bbladie @tofumiarchives @justanotherweeb666 @metaphorically-here @ravenbc @levihanmyotp @rybunnie @adrnmyknight @etherealrin @shosuki @90s-belladonna @wwastro @shr00mfairy [tell me if i missed out anyone’s name]
synopsis it’s the new year's while the city is alive with celebrations, the top trends on X are blue lock and the masked hero spider-man.
series MASTERLIST
notes from lily ❦⋆ : kaiser + spiderman ??!! sign mee tf upppp 🙋🏻♀️ (this was originally and supposedly to be rin, before i changed to kaiser...)
took a long hiatus just to make a brand new smau from a totally diff anime 😭 so sorry guys for making yall wait on the previous smau. so far no updates for thatt until i say so! thank u all!
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
synopsis you confront him about his hidden identity as spider-man, leading to a vulnerable moment where he admits his struggle with love. as the emotional connection deepens, a strange unease fills the room when the nurse lingers with an unsettling gaze. wc 1667
the hospital room hums quietly under the dim lights. kaiser leans against the pillows, mask discarded, revealing the exhaustion etched into his face. you should leave, visiting hours ended long ago but you can't. not when his usual cockiness has given way to something softer.
"you should go home," he murmurs, but his hand finds yours. his grip is weak, but the warmth sends a flutter through your chest.
"not a chance," you say softly, brushing a strand of blonde hair from his face. "you'll start climbing walls again the second i’m gone."
he huffs a weak laugh. "tempting."
for once, he doesn't fight your care. when you adjust the bandages, he just watches you, quiet and unguarded. it's that silence that pulls something raw from him.
"you really stayed," he says after a pause, voice softer. "even after everything."
"of course i did," you reply. "what, you thought i'd leave you to flirt with the nurses?"
a ghost of a smirk tugs at his lips. "jealous?"
"don't push your luck, kaiser."
“mihya.” he whispers, his voice barely audible.
“what?” you ask, not sure if you heard him right.
“earlier... you called me that. please, say it again.”
you pause, your heart suddenly racing at the vulnerability in his voice. “mihya,” you repeat softly, unsure of what’s happening but feeling an unexpected pull.
his gaze softens, and for a moment, it feels like the world around you fades. he looks at you, eyes wide with something raw and unspoken, as if he’s just let down a wall he’s been holding up for so long. “nobody has given me a nickname before.”
“well then mihya, let me be the first.”
his smile fades, and something more serious lingers in his gaze. "i'm not used to this. someone staying."
your heart aches at his honesty. without thinking, your fingers curl tighter around his. "well, you better get used to it. i'm not going anywhere."
his eyes soften in a way that makes it hard to breathe. "good," he murmurs, head tilting slightly toward you. "because if you left, i'd probably do something reckless."
"like what?"
"like this."
before you can respond, he leans in, brushing his lips softly against yours. the kiss is light and hesitant, like he's afraid to break whatever fragile thing has settled between you but when you don't pull away, his hand moves to the back of your neck, deepening it just enough to make your heart stutter.
"you're a terrible influence, spider-man." you whisper, your forehead resting against his and just for a moment, the danger outside the hospital walls feels a little farther away.
“but how did you know? what gave it away?” he asks, his voice tinged with curiosity.
“your tattoos, mostly,” you reply, trying to keep your tone steady. “and your injuries. you weren’t as careful as you thought. i’ve been thinking about it a lot, and everything started to fall into place. it all makes sense now.”
he looks at you, his expression unreadable for a moment. then, he exhales slowly, the weight of the silence settling between you. “you always were sharper than i gave you credit for,” he murmurs, almost to himself, before meeting your eyes again, the tension in the air thickening.
“i didn’t want you to know,” he admits, his voice quieter now, raw with unspoken fears. “i didn’t want to drag you into this mess.”
you stood away, your voice soft but resolute. “i’m already in it, whether you like it or not.”
he looks back at you, a mix of uncertainty, something softer, yet equally dangerous. "and what if I’m not the person you think i am?” he asks, his words heavy with something deeper.
“not this again, but then we’ll figure it out,” you reply, your gaze unwavering. “but i’m not walking away. not now.”
a flicker of vulnerability passes through his eyes, and he’s silent for a long beat. then, his lips curl into a faint smile, though it’s more weary than anything else. “you’re stubborn, you know that?” he says, almost in awe.
“maybe," you say with a small grin. "but i don’t mind being stubborn about this."
“i was bitten by a radioactive spider, and ever since i saw you at the stadium, i knew i had to get to know you better. when you caught me with the hoodie soaked in blood, and i watched you rush an injured man to the hospital, in that moment, i just… fell for you. i let myself get too close, too attached and i was already in too deep. but knowing the kind of man i am, one without the love of a family, one who finds solace only in soccer, i had to pull away. when i was spider-man, i felt invincible, like i could do anything. i felt reborn. i thought that with spider-man, i could love you and protect you. but instead, i just ended up putting you in danger.”
his words hang in the air, thick with the weight of his confession. you’re speechless for a moment, absorbing everything he’s said. slowly, you step closer, your voice quiet but steady. “you’re not the only one who’s afraid of getting someone hurt,” you reply, your eyes meeting his. “but running away, pushing me away, won’t keep me safe. it’ll just keep me distant.”
he looks at you, his eyes searching, as if trying to gauge whether he can trust what you’re saying. “to be honest with you,” he begins, his voice raw with vulnerability, “i don’t know how to love. i’ve been searching for it my whole life, and when i finally get close, i just push it away, and i—”
“mihya,” you interrupt softly, stepping closer. “stop rambling. i told you, i’m here. i’ll teach you how to love but only if you’ll let me.”
he stares at you for a moment, a mix of disbelief and hope flickering in his eyes. he opens his mouth, as if to say something, but the words seem to get stuck, as if there’s something holding him back.
then, suddenly, a third voice cuts through the silence.
“ahem.” the nurse clears her throat, and you glance up, the sound sharp in the otherwise still room. there’s something unsettling about her tone—too calm and too composed for the situation. “miss, you should really head home.”
you feel an odd chill in the air, a slight shift in the atmosphere, but you push it aside. still, the nurse's eyes linger on you for a moment longer than necessary, as though she’s studying you, almost calculating.
you glance over at mihya, who seems equally taken aback, his eyes flicking between you and the nurse, a frown forming on his face.
“righttt,” you mutter, trying to shake off the odd feeling, but the weight of the moment hangs in the air. “i’ll let you rest. we’ll finish this conversation later.”
he gives a small nod, his eyes still locked on yours, but there's an unspoken weight between you now. as you turn to leave, you feel his gaze follow you, the tension lingering in the air. “take care on your way home, mein Schatz.”
the nurse watches you leave, her gaze too steady, too sharp.
you pause, turning to face him, the sound of the german term of endearment catching you by surprise. his gaze is gentle, almost tender, as if he’s offering you a piece of himself he’s rarely shown.
"don’t think this is over," he adds, his voice carrying both a promise and a hint of vulnerability. “i’ll be waiting for you once i recover.”
you feel the weight of his words settle in your chest, a promise you want to believe, but the eerie feeling from the nurse’s gaze still lingers. you give mihya a small nod, trying to push past the unease. "i’ll be careful," you reply, though it doesn’t sound convincing, even to you.
even as you stood outside the door, the nurse’s eyes remain fixed on you, too steady, too sharp, like she's watching you leave for a reason. you turn to walk down the hallway, but with every step, that unsettling feeling grows, gnawing at you.
you pause, the weight of the moment pulling you back. something doesn't feel right.
turning back around, you find yourself walking back towards mihya’s room, feeling a strange pull to go back. when you step inside, the room is empty—mihya’s bed is untouched, the nurse gone as well.
but there’s something else.
the window is wide open. the cold night air rushes in, making the room feel even more hollow. you step toward it cautiously, noticing the curtains swaying slightly as if someone just left.
your eyes flick to the window, and that’s when you see it—a faint green flicker from below, glowing just beyond the edge of the building. you freeze. it’s almost imperceptible at first, like the shadow of a lightning strike without the thunder. another flicker—this time brighter, stronger. a green light cutting through the darkness.
your breath catches in your throat. the air around you feels heavier now, the chill from the window mixing with a rising sense of dread. you step closer to the window, peering out carefully, but the light vanishes as quickly as it appeared, leaving only the dim, cold streets below.
was it just a reflection? a trick of the light?
no. there’s no mistaking it. the green flickers came from the direction of the alley behind the building—too controlled to be random, too deliberate to ignore. your mind races, the pieces clicking together. it’s him. the green goblin.
what just happened?
your mind races, but you can't quite piece everything together. and yet, the echo of mihya’s words remains, a quiet promise hanging in the air.
“i’ll be waiting for you once i recover.”
despite everything, you feel like you can’t walk away just yet. not when you just got him back.
synopsis seen through kaiser’s pov: the photos should’ve been his. he remembers being there. holding your hand, whispering promises. but now, it’s all gone. rewritten. like he was never part of your story.
i thought so hard on this, look at the timestamps & compare
series MASTERLIST
notes from lily ❦⋆ : thank you all for reading 🫶🏼 i hope i did a good job on this, & i hope yall had fun reading this. shjsjeksk ineed2sleep
synopsis caught between playful banter and rising tension, a kiss ignites feelings too raw to ignore, but his self-doubt threatens to tear you both apart before it can begin. wc 948
“bro??? i lost three times in a row! how are you so good at literally everything?”
he smirked, setting down his controller and taking yours in his hands. “it’s easy. come here, i’ll show you.” his warm, bruised hands covered yours as he guided you.
“so, to speed up, you press this button here, and to slow down, it’s this one. got it? now give it a shot.”
you blinked, clearly distracted. “huh?”
he raised an eyebrow, unimpressed. “i said, try it out. i just taught you my tricks.”
“oh, okay,” you mumbled, trying to focus.
but he wasn’t convinced. “you didn’t listen to a word i said, did you?”
“i did!” you protested, fumbling to recall. “the decelerate button is here, and then the—”
before you could finish, he stepped closer, the proximity making your breath hitch. his voice was lower now, teasing. his breath brushed your lips.
as he lingered close, his gaze flickered from your eyes to your lips and back “you’re distracted again,” he said, “are you even trying to focus, or is it me?”
you swallowed, heat rushing to your cheeks. “i’m trying!”
“if you say so.” his fingers grazed yours briefly as he steps away from you.
“alright, one more round. if you lose again, maybe i’ll have to take over completely.”
you tried to focus on the screen, but the game blurred in comparison to the tension lingering between you. suddenly, the game ended, your character crashing into defeat yet again.
“game over,” he said with a laugh, leaning back triumphantly. “guess that’s four in a row.”
you groaned in frustration, throwing the controller down onto the couch. “i don’t even know why i bother.”
“maybe because you like losing to me," he teased, the smirk on his face infuriatingly charming.
shooting him a glare, you grabbed a pillow and tossed it at him. he caught it effortlessly, laughing as he leaned forward. "alright. i’ll let you win next time."
"yeah, sure," you muttered, but you couldn’t stop the small smile that tugged at your lips.
as his laughter subsided, the room seemed to settle into a comfortable silence. his teasing smirk softened, his eyes locking with yours in a way that made your breath hitch.
his gaze was steady on yours, the smirk fading into something softer, more vulnerable. he leaned in, his breath brushing against your lips, pausing just inches away. the world seemed to slow, your heart pounding in your chest as your eyes fluttered shut.
and then it happened, his lips met yours, tentative at first, but growing surer as the seconds passed. his hand found its way to your cheek, warm and grounding, while the other rested lightly on your waist.
just as you started to lose yourself in it, he abruptly pulled away, breaking the connection as his hands fell to his sides.
his expression had shifted entirely. the vulnerability you’d seen moments ago was now overshadowed by something else, like self-doubt. he stepped back, raking a hand through his hair.
“i—“ he started, his voice strained. “i shouldn’t have done that.”
you blinked, the sudden change throwing you off. “what?”
his jaw clenched as he avoided your gaze, his fists tightening at his sides. “you don’t understand. i’m not someone who deserves this.”
“michael,” you whispered but he just shook his head.
“you think i’m someone i’m not. it you knew everything about who i really am, you wouldn’t, you wouldn’t want this. you wouldn’t want me.” his voice cracked slightly, but he quickly masked it with a bitter laugh.
“stop,” you said firmly, reaching out to him, your hand brushing against his arm. “i don’t care about whatever you think makes you undeserving. i know who you are, and i’m still here anyway.”
he finally looked at you, his eyes searching yours like he was trying to find a reason to believe you. “you don’t get it,” he said, his voice quieter now. “i don’t want to hurt you.”
“michael,” you said softly, reaching for his hand, but he pulled away before you could touch him.
“i overstayed my welcome i have to go,” he murmured, his voice barely above a whisper. his eyes lingered on you for a moment longer, as though he wanted to say more but couldn’t bring himself to.
“huh? i don’t understand, where are you going?” your voice cracked as you watched him step back.
“i’m sorry, y/n” he said, his tone heavy with regret.
without another word, he turned and walked out, leaving you standing there, your chest tight with confusion and the ache of something left unfinished.
series MASTERLIST
notes from lily ❦⋆ : no more fever but the headaches is so bad omg 🙂
TAGLIST
@mixolya @x3nafix @96jnie @tamashithe2nd @cookielovesbook-akie @yuiearyi @noomimi @stargirljas @jhsluvv @sof888a @livelaughloveshidou @swagkittybear @axquella @passw-0-rd @hwaassaa @bbladie @tofumiarchives @justanotherweeb666 @metaphorically-here @ravenbc @levihanmyotp @rybunnie @adrnmyknight @etherealrin @shosuki @90s-belladonna @wwastro @shr00mfairy @pan-kojiwa @pctterheadd [tell me if i missed out anyone’s name]