Itâs My Fault
Request: Anon: Well sweet pea and the reader are in a relationship for a long time . She is best friend with fangs and was best friend with toni *before the pretty poisons*. One she just try to kill herself *like Hannah did in 13 reason why* because she this that all of this is her fault * that toni left and that fangs almost get killed twice* sweet pea safe her the last minute . He talks to her and they end up cundle or something like that.
A/N: Do not read if you are triggered by suicidal thoughts or actions.
Warnings: Mentions of Suicide, Pills, cursing
Beta: @wayward-river as always check out her stories she is incredible
Summary: Reader thinks that everything that has happened recently has been her fault, Toni leaving, not hanging at the Wyrm much, and Fangs almost getting killed. It becomes too much for her to handle luckily Sweet Pea catches her before anything can happen
Word Count: 2956
Y/N POV
This week had been rough between all the Serpent stuff Sweet Pea had been doing and not to mention not seeing Toni due to her quitting and making her own gang a few weeks ago. It felt like everything was slowly tumbling down ever since that day. You watched Toni walking down the hallway with her new girl gang all the thoughts coming back.
*Flashback*
âI want you to joinâ
âYou want me to what Toni!â
âJoin my gang Y/Nâ
âNo Toni, Not a chanceâ
âBut why not we could run the gang togetherâ
âDid you forget Iâm the Serpent Queen for the time being. The serpents are my family, Jughead, Sweet Pea, Fangs. They are your family too how could you just leaveâ
âYou shouldnât be the queen Y/Nâ
âWhat are you talking aboutâ
âThe serpents are not a family anymore I have been in the serpents longer I deserve to be queenâ
âWhat are you even talking about Toni?â
âDoesnât matter look if you want to join you can, but other than that Iâm out of the Serpents, Iâm doneâ
âWait what can I do to make you stay?â
âMake me queenâ
âI, I canât that isnât how it works and you know itâ
âWell then Iâm out, bye Y/Nâ you were shocked not able to stop her before she had turned and walked out.
*End Flashback*
âBaby girl, Y/N⌠Babe!â Sweet Pea broke you out of your thoughts.
âWhat? Sorry whatâs up Peaâ
âBaby are you okay?â
âYeah, yeah Iâm goodâ
âAlright, hey I wanted to tell you I wonât be at the trailer till later tonightâ
âOh? Everything alright?â
âYeah, of course, Fangs and I are hanging out at Pops you can come if you want I just know you told me you had that paper to writeâ
âYeah I do, Iâll just see you when you come home okay?â
âYeah I love youâ
âLove you too Peaâ You hung around the library finishing the little bit of work you had to do there and then you went to the trailer to finish the rest. Your thoughts kept racing with all the things that you could have done differently before Toni left, The things that you could have done to make her stay. A few hours after getting back you finished up the homework you had. You decided to make dinner for Pea in case they had left pops early. There were a lot of times they would end up at the quarry after pops and would entirely forget to actually get food. You heard rustling outside and opened the door to see Fangs and your boyfriend with cuts all over their faces.
âOmg what happened to you twoâ
âThe Pretty Poisons happenedâ
âThe pretty who now?â
âToniâs new gangâ Â
âThey beat you up⌠why?â
âAccording to Cheryl, they wanted to send a message. I called Jones apparently he tried getting Toni to rejoin but she wouldnât unless something happenedâ
âSo they beat you up for basically no reason â
âYepâ
âAlright well get in here Sweets, Fangs you too I wanna clean you up before you go homeâ
âYou donât have to I can clean up myself when I get backâ
âThereâs food on the stoveâ
âYou had me at food Y/Nâ
âThanks for cooking babeâ
âNo problemâ You cleaned Fangs up while he was eating so after he was done he left. It was now just you and Pea. You were cleaning the cuts but you felt so bad.
âIâm so sorry babe this is all my faultâ
âY/N this is not your faultâ
âIt is thoughâ
âNo, itâs not now drop it there babyâ
âOkay you're rightâ He wasnât though, it was your fault. It was your fault Toni left.
âHey babeâ
âYeah Pea?â
âWeâre going to the Wyrm tomorrow night to hang since we haven't in a little while you wanna come?â
âYeah of courseâ
*Time Jump to the Wyrm*
All day the only thoughts racing through your mind were of Toni and how much she had changed. Having her girls beat up the boys to prove a point it wasnât like her.
Jughead walked towards where you and Pea were standing.
âHow you feeling Sweet Pea?â
âJust a few scratches, you talk to Toni?â
âYeah, she had no idea it happenedâ Fangs walked up at that point.
âSo what she didnât know what Cheryl did?â
âNope not a clueâ
âDamnâ
âThatâs crazy though I thought it was âherâ gangâ
âI donât know Y/Nâ
âI guess itâs whatever Jugâ
âYou know whatâs weird?â
âWhat Fangs?â
âI mean I know Toni left us, but I kinda miss her I mean being here at the Wyrm and having her not be behind the bar or hanging out with us is so oddâ He was right and you knew it. The fact that you havenât hung out with Toni in weeks finally caught up to you. You had lost one of the only girlfriends that even existed in your life. You also pushed her out of everyone elseâs all because you wouldnât let her take your place. The anxiety welled up inside you pushing to nausea you got out of Peaâs grip and ran to the bathroom. He came following behind you and held your hair back.
âBaby whatâs wrong?â
âDid you eat before you drank?â You nodded as you kept throwing up. âI- I ateâ
âOkay maybe the food was badâ
âYeah, yeah must have beenâ You leaned your head back into his knee before he helped you stand up.
âLetâs get you homeâ you walked out of the bathroom hand in hand with Sweet Pea
âHey you good Y/Nâ
âYeah Fangs Iâm good just ate something weird I guessâ
âWeâll catch you guys later weâre going to go homeâ He walked you out the door of the Wyrm opening the door for you to get into his truck.
âBaby you donât have to leave, you were having a good time. I can get home by myselfâ
âI want to take you home, Iâm fine I had enough funâ
âAre you sure?â
âPositive babyâ You felt bad. Just like you ruined the group's friendships with Toni you had ruined the fun time that Sweet Pea was having.
*Monday*
You walked into school Monday hoping it would be a normal day, but apparently, Jughead had decided that we needed more Serpents, so he recruited the gargoyles. You didnât want him to, but what the King says has the rule over you, and honestly even if you did disagree he most likely would have listened. But you were not in the mood to argue and you were not in the mood to fight about anything. You were afraid of them to admit it. You had spied on them, they would have known it was you if Fangs hadnât covered. The day was going by pretty smoothly with only a few arguments breaking out. You were standing against your locker as you watched Sweet Pea as he walked towards you. He grabbed your hand leading you down the hallway.
âWhere we going?â
âJug called an impromptu meetingâ
âDonât we have a meeting tonight?â
âYeah but that is Serpent stuff this is something about a kid Red foundâ
âA kid?â
âYeah apparently no one knows who he is so I think he is gonna ask everyone to look into itâ
âAre you coming to the meeting tonight?â
âYeah, Iâm gonna meet you there like I said I have some homework to doâ You walked into the classroom standing in front of Sweet Pea as he sat on the desk.
âPea whereâs Fangs he never misses a meeting?â
âI donât know babe. Maybe he didnât get the memo he could be with Kevinâ
âTrueâ
âDonât worry about it we can always fill him in laterâ Jug had started the meeting but it wasnât long before you watched Toni burst through the door.
âJughead you need to come now Kurtz is going to kill Fangs!â You bolted out of your position following Jughead out the door. You ran into the hallway and looked up to where Fangs was shouting from. Kurtz had him hanging over the top of the steps.
âSweet Pea, Y/N, Jughead. Help me!â
âKurtz let him downâ Kurtz wasnât paying attention he was talking directly to Fangs.
âYou scared you dirty Serpent Spy. You're about to ascend. Youâll fly toâ Your thoughts began racing. It should be you it shouldn't be him none of this was his fault. He shouldnât have to die for something stupid that you did. You almost got caught and he took your place posing as the spy so you wouldnât get caught and now he was about to die. It should be you. Before you could process what was happening you saw Kurtz let Fangs go. Sweet pea pushed you out of the way and he and Jughead slid under Fangâs falling body breaking his fall before he could hit the floor. You ran over to all of them hugging them. None of them were badly hurt they were all just a little sore. But you knew it was your fault everything was your fault.
You felt the anxiety building again, the anger, the guilt, everything you ran out of the school. It was the end of the day anyway. You ran to the quarry the one place you knew you could be alone or so you thought. Upon arriving you saw a bunch of new Serpent initiates sitting around a fire, so you ran back to your trailer instead. You ran in grabbing a piece of paper writing I love you on it and you stuck it to the front door so Sweet Pea would know that you would love him forever. You slumped against the bathroom wall trying to get your thoughts and nausea to go away but nothing was working.
It was you who almost got Fangs killed not once but twice, Fangs protected you twice once from getting shot and once from falling from a staircase.  It was you who made Toni drop you as a friend, it was you who made her leave the serpents, it was you who made her drop everyone, it was you who made her leave everything behind. Everything⌠It was all you, it was all your fault⌠all of it. It would be better if you werenât here, better if no one had to deal with you. Everything went bad when it had to deal with you, if no one had to deal with you everyone would be happy and everything would be okay⌠it would all be okay if you just left.
You stood up grabbing the pill bottle from the cabinet pouring them out into your hand. You looked down at them before putting them into your mouth and swallowing with the water from the sink. You grabbed another couple swallowing them as well. You had to do it, you had to. You needed to do this for you, for your friends, your family. They deserved better than what you always brought to them, they all deserved better. You sat there back against the wall, watching the pills in your hand. You needed to leave them, needed to make it easier for them.
Sweet Peaâs POV
âGuys where is Y/N she should be here by now, have any of you talked to her?â
âNot meâ
âNope haven't seen her since this afternoon when she ran out of schoolâ
âYeah, she had homework to do, but donât you guys think it was weird that she would run out? I mean she texted me saying she was doing the work⌠but I donât knowâ
âI mean there still twenty till the meetingâ
âTrueâ I sat there leg bouncing up and down. I waited for her to come, waited and waited but she still hadnât gotten to the Wyrm yet.
âThis isnât rightâ I called her phone but it had no answer. âShe didnât answer her phone guysâ
âMaybe itâs off or on silentâ
âNo itâs our one rule we donât do that, I need to goâ I ran to my truck peeling out of the parking lot. I felt it deep down, I felt something was wrong. I hopped out of the truck as soon as I pulled in. The note on the door I love you. Something wasnât right and I knew for sure now that I saw that note. I burst into the trailer but I didnât see her. I saw the light under the bathroom door and tried opening it. But it was locked. I kicked it I didnât care. I saw Y/N sitting on the floor about to put pills into her mouth. I smacked the pills away. She picked the bottle up trying to put more into her mouth.
âY/N stop! "What the hell is this?" I kept trying to get the pills away but her grip was tight.
âNo, Sweet Pea stop! I need to. Leave me the hell alone!" She screams, struggling to free from my grip
"Baby, you can't do this, please. How many did you take? Come here!â I grabbed her not caring I shoved her over the toilet sticking my fingers into her mouth to make her gag. I was lucky she began throwing up I could see the pills land into the toilet. She kept throwing up. She finally stopped. I grabbed her bringing into my chest.
âY/N why! Why do that! Why!â
âI donât want to be here. I want it to be easier for everyone! I make everything worse!â
âWhat, what are you talking about?â
âMe Pea, everything is worse when Iâm aroundâ
âNo everything is so much betterâ
âStop lying!â
âIâm not baby why do you think everything is worseâ
Y/N POV
âSo many things. Like⌠Toni left because of me â
âNo babyâ
âYes, Pea she wanted to be queen, she wanted to make the Serpents better, and I wouldnât let her take my placeâ
âEven if you let her it wouldnât have happened Y/N that isnât the law it isnât possible for her to be queenâ
âButâŚâ
âNoâ
âFine, then there are other things too. I let Fangs almost get killed. Not once! Twice Pea, Twice!â
âBaby that isnâŚâ
âYes, it is Sweet Pea. He stepped in front of me when that gunshot rang out, and he got shot almost dying. He covered for me with the gargoyles leading to him getting held over that fucking balcony and almost dying. He has almost died twice and both times were my fault!â
â Listen to me Y/N! Listen to me! Nothing is your fault, none of it is your fault. Toni left, she chose to leave. She couldnât take your place that is now how the law works. Fangs cares about you he stepped in front of you, yes but you would have done the same for him. He went after you with the gargoyles but what you didnât know was that he was undercover too. No one knew because he was undercover until a few weeks ago when Jug started stuff to get the Gargoyles to join. Kurtz found out that is why he held him over the balcony not because of you. You donât bring negativity Y/N you bring beauty, and happiness, and good times. Baby girl if you left this world I wouldnât be able to handle it, and everyone would miss you so fucking much do you know that. Do you know how much you would be missed? Do you want to die?â
âI wanted to make it better for you, I want to live I want to be here with you foreverâ
âGood because baby I canât lose you and without you, it wouldnât be better it would be so much worseâ
âI love you Sweet Peaâ
âI love you too baby girl now letâs get you dressed and into bed because I need to hold you right nowâ
âWhy?â
âI could have lost you tonight, even thinking about that scares the shit out of me. It may be cheesy but I donât care. I want to hold you, To know that you are here with me. You scared me shitless when I opened that door and saw you with those pills. Baby promise me, Promise me that if you feel this way ever again even for a second that you will talk to me or at least hint at it to me because Y/N if I lost youâŚâ You saw a tear drop down onto his cheek.
âPea⌠stop, stop thinking about it, baby. I never wanted to leave you. I never want to leave you. I want you forever. Iâm sorry I scared you, I am so fucking sorry but I am here. I am here and I will always be here. We are forever Pea I promise you that. I fucking promise that I wonât leave you. I promise you because truly I donât know if I could handle it myself. I love you too much to even think about leaving youâ He smiled down at you taking your cheek into his hand and pressing a light kiss to your lips.
âWhat do you say we go cuddle?â
âI say yes, I will always say yes Pea⌠Alwaysâ He led you to the bed slipping off his jeans and sliding in beside you.
âIâm sorry Pea If you didnât come⌠â
âStop baby, donât think about that. We will get through this together okay, no more apologizing, none of this is your fault, none of it okay?â
âOkayâ Â

















