Caught XIV (Arthur Morgan × f!reader)
Word count: 4.2k
Authors note: I AM SO SORRY GUYS, I KNOW I KEPT SAYING ID GET IT OUT BUT COLLEGE IS CRAZY
Special thanks to @iceman-kazansky! You're so sweet. I love the reposts, I hope you enjoy this one also! I know it was long awaited :)
Warnings: 18+, mentions of blood, swearing.
♡
Caught XIV
The camp was lit with voices and laughing around you whilst you sat unbothered on a log overlooking the lake you had so admired when you had first laid your eyes upon it.
The day had been one of your nicest yet. The Arthur had not been buzzing around for you only to have to swat away. No, rather it was peaceful.
You weren't being unattentive but the sound of soft footsteps still made you snap your head around to look at the person approaching.
The finest lady in camp. Dutch's favorite girl. The one you had no opinion on yet as most of the time neither of you looked each other's way. The way she appeared made it seem like she strayed away too far from her well to do family, but you couldn't tell if that was true or just what it looked to be.
Her skirt dressed the worn wood kindly as she sat with distance from you. Quite frankly you had not a clue on whether you should say something or leave her to her own but she decided for you.
"You're that other O'Driscoll, aren't you?" She questioned, her green eyes giving you only a second of grace before scanning the horizon of the lake.
It took you a moment, unsure of where she was going with this and distracted by the sudden sight of Arthur, who was making his way toward an idling Dutch on the shore of the lake, not too far from you. "Unfortunately."
Molly's eyes scan you up and down, a familiar look of disparage glinted in her gaze. "You seem close with Arthur." She stated outright rather bluntly.
Shaking off the stare she had given you and comprehending her bold words you replied in short, "I suppose it could look that way."
"I feel like you're trying something." Her irish accent shone through with her clearly disdained words.
It was an accusation not unaccustomed by yourself, and you weren't in the mood for more of it. "I have no power to propagandize that man. He's as stubborn as an ass."
It seemed if it wasn't Arthur, it was someone else. Would the O'Driscoll talk ever end? You felt as though you had proved yourself more than needed.
"Why haven't you and your sly little buddy left yet then?" Her interrogation had you slipping on your hat in preparation of departure.
"We're just looking out for our lives, miss. If it's not the law, then it's our former members." You made sure to emphasize the past tense. O'Driscoll's gang was certainly in the past for you, whether you wanted it or not.
With that, you got up and started walking away. Perhaps you'd take a trip to town, get away from camp for a while.
"I didn't say you could go?" She scolded with a bark of her voice.
Saying more could be bad, saying nothing could also be bad. So you chose silence, you didn't want trouble with Dutch's girl.
As you walked through camp with a stretch of your back, a hand stabbed at your ribs, a sensitive part that reminded you unfortunately, you were ticklish.
You hunched over with a gasp, your arms throwing themselves to your sides to defend from further attack. It was already evident who it was.
Dutch and Arthur strolled by you, Arthur with a slight smirk watching you. Dutch caught on and studied you for a second.
"Why don't you come along to fish, Mrs. O'driscoll? Arthur told me of your struggle last time." He chuckled after Arthur gave him a slight shake of his head, a warning to redact his offer.
Mrs. O'driscoll was a new one for sure. The nicknames seemed to come from a never ending stream of creativity you despised.
Was there any way that you could say no to Dutch? No was never to be said to Colm, and learning from that, you agreed. "Alright, as long as it delights Arthur."
"It does not particularly-" Arthur rumbles before he gets guided forward by an interrupting Dutch.
"Oh, he might jump out of his boots with excitement." He laughs with a pat to Arthur's back. Like father and son. It was cute, admittedly, to see notorious outlaws have such a bond.
Hosea was waiting for the pair, and now for you as he questioned your proximity to them. "She taggin' along as well?"
"She needs to see your flare with fishing, Hosea." Dutch proclaims with a grunt as he pulls himself up in his saddle.
"Alright, let me show you how its done then." With an aloof attitude and a nod, he leads the group out of camp.
The ride you had with the three of the men wasn't heavy with feelings of stress or worry on your part. Dutch spoke of the activities he wanted done down in this town, of the money the gang needed. It felt as though you were finally one of them.
Dutch was sure to tell you all that he wanted everyone to be on the down low. Just to snoop around for now. That was easy enough for you.
It wasn't long after you got close to the tracks that the quiet atmosphere of hooves and voices was filled with the thundering of a train.
"Looks like law up ahead." Dutch chimes, his words directing your eyes to the stopped caged carriage up ahead. "Play it cool."
You and Arthur exchange glances before he made his way from your left to your right. A barrier between you and the law for whatever reason.
"Hello gentlemen." Came a mellifluous voice from the metal bars, grabbing everyone's attention.
"Well!" Came a surprised chortle from Dutch. "Look what the cat drug in."
"Ive seemed to have gotten myself in a spot of bother." You hadn't caught it before but now the smooth accent of a brit plastered his words.
You had not a clue who this man was or how he knew the gang. It was only so long that you would find out however.
"Quiet back there." Grumbled the lawman from upfront, his fist hammering down on the metal to rattle the cage.
Dutch examined this for a moment, "lets see if we cant sort this out."
The small talk that commenced turned into the talk similar of a lawyer. Defending the "silly fancy fop." Clearly, he was important if this was worth the trouble.
The other imprisoned men in the back took Dutch's distraction and started picking at the lock, providing entertainment for you and Arthur who sat there watching.
Dutch didn't get finished before the man had the lock off and the creaky doors opening, the other three men following with no hesitation.
"Shit!" Exclaims the sheriff, his and his partners eyes wide as their captives latched onto the train now departing. "The Anderson boys! I cant have more scandal!"
"Allow us to help, my friend." Dutch offers, his gaze not waiting a moment longer to send you and Arthur off. "Arthur... y/n."
Arthur sighed, "chase wanted men?" He confirms, ushering you on with a glance.
"And-" he points to the lawman's partner, "take Archibald with ya."
You followed, your horse already springing into action, your adrenaline not short after that.
"Just what I signed up for..." Arthur clearly discontent with what he got to be volunteered for. "Come on, big guy."
He helped Archibald up on his horse and took off beside you and after the train. The sight of the men on the back of the train and your chasing brought you back to the very day that was the reason you were here now.
Archibald hollered from the back, encouraging you forward with jarring words. "Keep your guns holstered, we need them Anderson boys alive."
You clicked your tongue, pushing your mare forward, surprised at the speed in which the train was already traveling.
Archibald nagged again. "Come on hurry!"
His words were met with swift retort of displeasure from Arthur. "All right."
"Come on, we're losing them!"
"Will you relax? We're not losing 'em!"
"Faster, come on! What's your name, sir?" Archibald seemed to have a speed in mind that a horse would have trouble reaching with two riders on its back. "And how about you, lady?"
"Arthur. Arthur Callahan." Replied a grumpy Arthur. Although you didn't have much sympathy for him, it made you smile in the face of this situation.
"Y/n Callahan." Without a fake last name in mind, you copied Arthurs.
"Faster, Mr. and Mrs. Callahan, please. My neck is on the line here!"
"I get it. We're doing our best." Arthur grunts. His eyes were trained on you, curious that you copied him.
The last of the four was dangling off the back of the train, struggling to pull himself up. His buddy fortunately came back for him.
"You sure I can't just shoot him?" Arthur asks, disregarding what he had been told moments earlier.
"No. Did I not say that?" Archibald scolds, watching the men escape further up the train.
"You've said plenty." Arthur was on his last straw and you appreciated the help from Archibald.
"So long deputies!" Came a man monkeying around on the roof of the final cart, teasing and whooping.
The water tower in the back posed a quickly approaching threat to the completely oblivious man who was but too quick to celebrate his victory.
You cringed back as the harsh smack of the back of his head met with funnel to the water tower. Your horse barely missing his body now knocked clean out on the tracks.
"Idiot. Now get after the others, come on!" He shouted at you and Arthur, keeping your minds trained on the ones who were conscious.
The train started slowing as it passed the big red building that was the station, which Archibald pointed out.
Your horses now were more of a match for the speed and you both came up alongside the train.
"You think you both can jump on there?"
"She can." Arthur outs you with non-existent hesitation. "But why me?"
"Because you ride like my grandmother!" Insisted Archibald, which would have you chuckling right in Arthur's face had you not been distracted.
One of the men started throwing bottles, one would've hit you if the man wasn't so bad at judging distance, the glass shattering in the distance that you covered quickly.
"Now he's throwing bottles. The lowdown bastard!" Archibald squealed, dodging one heading right for him.
You took the liberty of joining the Anderson boys on the train first as you were ahead of Arthur and Archibald. Arthur not mere moments fore he was behind you.
You caught your breath for a second, catching another bottle hurled at you while Arthur faced him head on.
The man atop the cargo on the train managed a good kick on Arthur who fell to the side. His neck quickly subject to the squeezing of the Anderson boy's hand.
"You bastard!" Screamed the man as he held onto Arthur with vigor.
You felt a strange sense of anger wash over you as you made for Arthurs aid, grabbing a good fistful of cloth and heaving the man off with Arthurs help.
"Thats it!" Came Archibalds encouragement from the side lines. In his hands were your horses reins. Kind of him, you thought, to bring your horse.
You helped Arthur up and both of you started for the rest of them, although admittedly, without a gun, you'd have to let Arthur do most of the strong arming.
"Come on, both of you! I'm relying on you guys!" Archibald was certainly one for constant reminding.
The sprinting on the train felt counter productive, it was certainly more work than just regular running.
Arthur made sure to be in front of you, he was like a big shield and ran surprisingly fast for how large he is.
"You hold it right there!" Arthur shouts at the other two men who were barely in sight ahead of you.
You had to jump atop the roof and Arthur, the gentleman that he is, helped none.
This normally would not have been a problem, but with your weak arm, it left you struggling.
Arthur had pushed through it despite his shoulder and was ready to go off and leave you but he didn't. He stood above you and held out his hand.
"Let's go, Mrs. Callahan." His face gave away the fact that he enjoyed this activity with you. Also by the fact he was picking on you again.
"I'm coming, grandmother." You were sure to tease back. His hand gripped yours and with the strength of not a grandmother, pulled you up with ease. He gave you a scoff before continuing on after the Andersons with you.
"Come on, shitbags!" Mocked one of the men from ahead. Jumping from cart to cart and down again to keep ahead of you both.
The second time you both needed to climb Arthur just grabbed you and heaved you up, his shoulder clearly bothered him as a pained grunt was heard from behind you.
Atop this car one of the men was right there, but your mind was on helping Arthur instead. As you gripped under his arms and pulled, footsteps pounded behind you.
The guy came right back around and started coming for you, which was not good. To say the least.
"You're the law?" He scoffs, your not so threatening appearance seemed to spur him on more. "We're runnin from you?" He hadn't seemed to notice that Arthur was also hot on his tail.
He was large and he was not letting up. His heavy footsteps thundering toward you shook the metal roof under you.
Your hand instinctively brushed the gun at your hip but Archibalds multiple requests lingered in your mind.
He was quick to be on you, throwing out your arms to brace yourself and push him away from you as his hands met your shoulders, trying to wrestle you off the train car entirely.
His strength was clear as you both struggled, your body wobbling closer and closer to the edge.
"Not so scary now, huh?" This man derides before his eyes widen at the friend you had in tow.
Arthur pulls him off and throws him to the ground, his back meeting the hard metal with a thud.
You take the chance to continue after the other, perhaps just threatening the man with your gun would do. You felt like you weren't being of much help, which hit you right in the gut.
"Damn bastard!" Hollers the man now at Arthurs mercy from behind you. "Get away from me!"
That was his final spew of nonsense before his consciousness loses itself to Arthur's fist.
Ahead was the final member of this gang that was in need of a catching. You had to jump down and get inside of the car he had slipped into.
The running came to a halt, the final cart being cold and the smell of fresh meat filled your nose. A particular pleasure that wasn't all that pleasurable.
"Quit runnin'. You ain't got much of a chance anyway, Anderson."
"Yeah? And what are you gonna do little lady?" He jeers from his cornered position at the front of the train cart.
"Don't worry your head about me. It's him." You point back to the man behind you. It wouldn't be like that had you been able to use your gun. It certainly felt strange being so powerless but not unfamiliar. Arthur always reminded you.
"Do we need to bother?" Arthur groans, rolling his shoulder with a wince.
"Let me go!" The man demands, his aggressive stomps closing the distance between him and Arthur.
"I can't do that." Arthur replies, holding up his fists. The man had a knife, which worried you slightly as you watched this fight ensue.
The sudden halting of the train threw all three of you forward suddenly, the man caught off guard, was doubly caught off guard by Arthur taking his chance to take him on.
They wrestled around, the sounds of fists hitting bodies were apparent. Despite Arthurs effort, the man kept getting closer to where you stood, which then had you counting your options on what to do if he changes his target.
His knife went clean through Arthurs forearm, who in turn gasped in pain. You wanted to do something, but getting in Arthurs way would do more harm than good.
He stumbled back from Arthur, his proximity to you no less than an arm length, it presented an opportunity. With your good arm and the back of your gun, you brought it down hard on the back of the man's head. Not enough to knock him out but enough for Arthur to.
You and Arthur stared at each other for a moment before hunching over to catch your breath. The spontaneity of this situation finally hit you and the realization made you laugh breathily. Arthur gave you a look before he couldn't help but give a small chuckle as well.
Motioning for his bleeding arm, you tear off the remaining cloth from his shirt and shape it into a decent enough improvised gauze.
"Can't fix my shirt now, I guess." Arthur observes the obvious but he didn't seem to be genuinely mad by the prospect of it.
"All this blood of yours ruined it already." You shake your head, tying the torn cloth gently around his arm gently.
"Suppose you're right." He admits, a conceded smile drawn on his face.
"That's how it always is." You tease, not being sure what to do with your hands now that they have blood on them. "At Least you got him."
"That's also how it always is." He repeats in a voice that sounded like it was suppose to be a mockery of yours.
"I expect no less from you, grandma dearest." You praise, even if it wasn't exactly that.
"Leave out grandma, please." He shakes his head, his laugh turning into a tired smile.
"Just dearest?" Your eyebrow raises with a teasing smirk.
"Just dearest." He confirms, meeting your eyes with an equal look on his face.
Despite him saying things like this before, you haven't found yourself any more prepared for it than the time previous. "If you're going to flirt, at least try."
"Okay then." He stands upright and as he gears himself up for the "flirting" a loud, galling voice comes from the outside of the cart.
"Hello? Is everything alright in there?" For the past minute, Archibald had vanished from your mind, only to return at an unsatisfactory time.
Arthur was audibly and visibly displeased as he reported back to the lawman, "well... I don't think he's dead... but I think we won the fight."
Arthur picked up the downed man, and Archibald pulled the door open to finally see what happened. "Bring him out here."
"Deputy." Arthur nods with a greet as you follow out behind him.
"Sounded like quite a commotion. Is that him?" The lawman examines the blonde Anderson to check.
"I sincerely hope so." Grumps Arthur. His temporary humor gone from just moments ago.
"Old Anders Anderson." Scoffs Archibald with a look of scorn.
That there was the head man, a surprise that he didn't have more in him. Though in all fairness, he got ganged up when you joined Arthur for a second.
You all mounted, following Archibald to where you needed to go take this man not unlike you and Arthur, to the can.
The ride basically amounted to nothing more than a tour from Archibald. He spoke of the Gray's and the Braithwaite's. One, a respectable family. The other, not so much.
Arthur kept glancing at you while you both listened to him talk about these families, their fortune and their feud. You both knew it sounded like something Dutch and Hosea would love to hear about.
The road brought you lot into town quickly, greeted by a fairly large saloon, sure to be mentioned was that it was owned by the Gray's. As most things were said to be in this town. Rhodes, so it was.
Hosea sat outside of the sheriff's office, greeting you all as you rode up and it wasn't long till Dutch barged out of the door behind Sheriff Gray.
"I told you Arthur would deliver, man has a passion for justice." Dutch exclaims behind the sheriff as he meets the rest of everyone back outside.
Sheriff Gray thanked you and Arthur for the help, setting Trelawny free from his imprisonment in return for the task you had completed.
All of this for a man you'd never met. Though as much as you thought about it, there was no regret. Running alongside Arthur and the two of you on that train together had been a surprising amount of fun.
Dutch and the Sheriff exchanged conversation for a short while before warning Dutch to keep Trelawny out of trouble.
Now quickly did you find that Trelawny was quite the talker.
"And you are?" He coo's with a slight bow and a hand shake.
"Y/n l/n." You nod, returning his hand shake.
"How lovely to meet you, Miss l/n." He kindly nods before spinning back around to lead the group of you.
Trelawny reiterated the story of the Gray's and Braithwaite's. Long standing feud, gold that was fought over, cousins marrying cousins or not marrying cousins. It was strangely interesting.
"I want you guys to check that out later." Dutch was sure to mention, directing it towards you, Hosea and Arthur.
Trelawny warned of all the talk, 500 miles around, north and south, "super agents" or sorts of that matter.
Dutch laughed with disbelief. "Super agents? All talk."
"Oh, no doubt." Trelawny agreed before turning back around to face all of you. His words were that of departure, which surprised you, having just met this man no less than five minutes ago.
Dutch shrugged when Hosea looked at him, even surprised, nodding a goodbye to Trelawny.
As your group of four made way back to your horses, Dutch brought up the rich families.
"Hosea, I want you to check out the Braithwaite's. Arthur, you and y/n sniff around the Gray's place."
You nodded your agreement and Arthur his. "Our friend Archibald showed us the Gray's place earlier." Told Arthur, recounting your recent ride.
Dutch and Hosea now chattered together up ahead, leaving you and Arthur to walk together behind them.
The two of you were so close together your shoulders brushed but neither of you seemed to care enough to make any distance.
"So who was that?" You ask Arthur curiously.
"Oh, Trelawny? A slippery con man of sorts. We've known him for a good while."
You hum your acknowledgement, "he's not a part of the gang?"
"He is. Just, that's why he's slippery. Doesnt stay nowhere too long."
You give it some thought. The man looked like a high fligher and in towns like this, spelled trouble. You had found that out before you had become particularly opinionated against the law.
You rubbed your sore arm, the scab formed around the wound was sure to leave a scar. It hurt everytime you prodded at it too much but admittedly it became a bad habit.
"How's your arm after that?" You guessed he was referring to the man you had scuffled with no less than an hour ago.
"It's not bad." You dismiss with a wave of your hand. "Your shoulder is more worrisome, that cut too. Think you should rest it for a while."
Arthur looked over at you with a subtle look of sarcastic shock. "Worried for me now, are ya?"
You bumped into him with your shoulder, your discontent frown unable to stay for long as a smile crept up on you.
As close as that man could get to giggling was what he was doing.
"Quite the fishin’ trip, huh?" Arthur proclaims ahead to Hosea and Dutch.
"The fish weren't so easy to catch neither." You sigh, tired from all that runnin you had to do.
"No, that they weren't." Dutch laughs in agreement, talking like the one who gladly had to do none of the fishing. "There's still time. I'm up for it."
"How about you two?" Hosea questions, looking you and Arthur up and down. "Or have you had enough of the chase for one day?"
Arthur meets your eye, seemingly checking if you'd want anything to do with it first.
"Pearson will need something for the soup." You agreed, pushing down the unsavory idea of handing over your catch for the stew Pearson would cook up.
"Yeah alright then." Arthur adds, agreeing with the rest. Hosea, happy with this, mounted his horse behind Dutch and Arthur.
Amongst the riding, Hosea and Dutch told stories of the past, ones involving Trelawny. Everyone in the group had a good laugh at these stories, and for this moment, you had not a care in the world. Not even the feeling of being an outcast haunted you as you and your fateful friends - perhaps, if you could call them that, made your way to your planned fishing trip.
----
So far, just a fishing trip is never actually "just" a fishing trip. Just a dangerous date.
















