#poly xreader

Nico di Angelo and William Andrew Solace were the reason why you loved and hated life so much right now. Every time you saw them you wanted to hold them, tell them to love you, please! But why would they ever love you? How stupid could you be not just loving one, but two guys? Leave out the fact that they are already dating each other. You were hopeless, oh so hopeless.

“Hey, (Y/n), we have a favour to ask you.” The golden boy occupying your thoughts interrupted the waves of text that were going through your head. “What’s it? Need me to cover your shift at the infirmary again?” “Well, no, but Nico and I wanted to do a movie night in the Hades cabin and-“ Wills eyes shifted seemingly to look anywhere but to you. His hands fumbled a bit and a blush rose to his face. “And we were wondering if you would like to join us?” You looked him in the eyes. A fuzziness invaded your upper chest, but you pushed it down. “Do you need me to chaperone your date night? I know Chiron forbade for 2 people to be alone in a cabin but sure you can find a way around it,” you shrugged, “And I wouldn’t want to be the reason why you two can’t be comfortable. I know Nico isn’t that used to me.” And third wheeling the two boys you liked for an entire night just did not seem good for your mental health.

“It’s not chaperoning us (Y/n), we want you there. So, please?” No, you were not going to do this. There is no way – You looked at Will and he had this begging look, there is no way you could resist is there? “Alright, where do we meet?”

You felt odd, like you were not supposed to be in this room. You weren’t – apparently Nico and Will had still not asked for Chiron’s permission, so you had to sneak into the Hades cabin. Nico was all settled in his pillow fort of a bed, Will standing right in front of you. How were you three ever going to fit there with all these pillows? Better yet, how did these boys obtain all these pillows? “Alright, (Y/n), just go sit next to Nico, I’ll be right with you. Just have to grab the snacks!” Will shooed you towards his boyfriend. Oh right, his boyfriend. Not yours. You slowly made your way to the bed and carefully sat down next to Nico, who was all propped up against the wall. Was it just you, or did Nico seem more tense then usual? It was probably you; you were the reason he was tense.

“Uh, sorry.” You mumbled as you accidently touched his hand. You retracted your hand and look away.

You did not notice how Nico had a small blush. Inner Nico was scolding himself for being so tense. He and Will had revised this plan, and now you’re here and he just- why did you have to accidently make him feel so loved? His hand was still warm from your touch and the way your shoulders brushed had his heart beating out of his chest. It was Will idea to put you in the middle of them, and gods bless and curse his boyfriend for this.  If only he could just relax and tell you to not be sorry and it’s fine, you are allowed to hold his hands if you want. Nico would love that.

“Snacks have arrived, now scooch over! I still need to fit on here.” The sunshine boy finally showed his face, holding a bag which presumably was filled with food. “Are you sure it will fit?” You asked, “I can just sit on the groun- OOF” Will, at that moment, had decided to sit down more on you than on the bed. Oh gods you were getting squished by your crushes – why? A cold hand grabbed your arm, and you were pulled up from underneath Will. “You alright?” Nico asked you, still holding on to your arm. You nodded as you felt your head empty itself from any thought. Instead of letting go, Nico’s hand found its way down to yours and his cold fingers intertwined with yours. You looked up from your hands to see a very small, shy smile adoring Nico’s face.

“Ah, sorry (Y/n)! Didn’t mean to squish you! Are you alright?” Will asked you as he scanned your body for any signs of injury. “I am fine doctor. Just don’t jump on my like that again!” You managed to bring out. Will’s face seemed to turn red, however it was getting harder to tell in this lightning. “Sorry!”

“Why would they enter the basement!” You screamed out. Will laughed loudly, “Mortals can be so stupid sometimes.” Somewhere between the start of the movie and now Will had manged to get a hold of your other hand, and in addition to that your whole arm. This left you in no position to move – not that you ever wanted to leave the embrace of these two boys. Nico had cuddled up to your side, his head on your shoulder. Every time you talked you could feel his hair move against your neck. Out of your sight Nico was smiling constantly, a contend look on his face.

Will however had taken the job up of feeding you candy every now and then, for with the two boys holding you tightly, there was no way for you to grab anything yourself. “Come on (Y/n), open up that beautiful mouth of yours.” Will said as he held a candy worm up to your lips. You opened your lips and he put the worm in. His hand lingered on your lips as he moved away. Although this may have been your own thoughts making up facts.

For Will this night was going great. Sure, it was no longer the vibe he wanted to confess in but he was holding you so close and feeding you? His fingers so close to your lips if only he could find that last bit of courage to put his hand on your cheek and kiss you. The frustration in your eyes whenever the people in the movie did something stupid, the way you felt free enough to share these frustrations with them. And then – oh.

The way his boyfriend looked so, so in love right now. Nico looked so comfortable cuddled up to you and it all seemed such a perfect fit. You, him, and his boyfriend. If only they could call you theirs. The bright laptop light seemed to get brighter every time you laughed.

“Hey, Will, why are you glowing?” the boy had fed you a worm and next thing you knew he was, how would you describe it, glow-in-the-dark? You felt Nico stifle a laugh and Will only seemed to get brighter. “Uh – I- Ah,” The yellow light started to turn red. “Oh my gods, Will I didn’t- “and you burst out laughing.

Your laughter was the best thing that happened to these two boys all night.