Pairing: Poly!Wolfstar x Reader
Summary: Sirius says yes to a six-week tour before the phone's even back in his pocket, then falls apart on the kitchen floor at 2am â and you and Remus have to learn what you look like without him in the room.
Tags: family issues, separation/distance, angst, hurt/comfort, established relationship
The call comes at half seven on a Tuesday, and Sirius says yes before he's even thought about it. You should've guessed he would. He's never once in his life let a good idea sit still long enough to be thought about properly.
You hear it happen. You're at the counter doing nothing in particular, and Remus is at the table with a paperback held open against the sugar bowl, not really reading it, and Sirius comes off the phone with his whole face rearranged, wild, like someone's lit a match behind his eyes.
"That was Marlene," he says, already up and pacing, already talking too fast, "we got it, we got the tour, six weeks supporting â six weeks, can you believe that? Can you actually believe that?"
You can. You've heard him play. Still, your stomach does something complicated and doesn't stop doing it.
By midnight the excitement's worn thin enough to see through, and by two in the morning he's not pacing anymore, he's sitting on the kitchen floor with his back against the cupboard â the floor, not a chair, like he needs something solid under him to say the next bit â and the flat, restless brightnes has gone out of him altogether.
"I could ring Marlene back," he says, "tell her I've changed my mind, it's not â it's not too late â"
"You're not ringing Marlene back," you tell him.
"I've never been away from you two for six weeks. Six days is a stretch, and even then I text you both like a lunatic, don't I?" A laugh that isn't one. "What if I go and it all just â comes apart? What if that's what happens?"
Remus is in the doorway with his arms crossed and a look on his face that gives almost nothing away â which, you know by now, is exactly how much he lets show when something matters to him. "You're not ringing Marlene back," he says, and doesn't raise his voice to say it, doesn't need to.
Sirius looks between the two of you like he's checking for a catch. "You'd both say that regardless, though? Wouldn't you? Even if you didn't mean it?"
"We're not you," Remus says. "We don't say things we don't mean. Ask literally anyone who's ever met me, they'll tell you I'm hopeless at it."
That gets a proper laugh out of Sirius, wet at the edges. He scrubs a hand over his face. "I keep thinking â if I go, and something breaks while I'm not here to watch it â"
"You're not the only thing holding this together," you say, and you believe it more than you sound like you do.
He doesn't answer that straight off. He's never been good at sitting with something true when it's aimed at him, would rather deflect it with a joke or a grand gesture than let it land, and you watch him nearly do it now, watch the smart remark queue up behind his teeth. He swallows it instead. "Family," he says finally, like the word costs him something, "we weren't taught to leave well. In my house, leaving was how you lost people. You went, and that was that, you were cut off, gone."
"You're not your family," Remus says. "You've spent ten years proving that."
There's a chair at your kitchen table that's always been Sirius's, the middle one, the one that puts him between the two of you so nobody has to work out how to talk without him doing the talking for both of you. Nobody assigned it to him. It just happened, the way things do around Sirius â he takes up the space that's going, and you let him, gladly, because he's better at filling silences than either of you has ever tried to be.
It isn't that you don't love Remus without Sirius in the room. You do. You have for years, quietly and completely, in a way that's never once been in question between the three of you â nobody's ever had to ask who loves who, or how much, or whether it's equal, because it plainly is, all three ways at once. What's never happened is the two of you holding that love up on your own two feet. Sirius has always been there to say the thing you're both too careful to say first, to turn a look into a joke into an excuse to reach out. Take him out of the room and neither of you is entirely sure what's left standing, not because there's any doubt in it, but because you've never had to find out.
Six weeks. That's how long the middle chair sits empty.
He leaves on the Sunday in a fluster, half his gear still not in the van, hugging you both on the pavement too hard and too long, like he's trying to store up enough of it to last. "Ring me," he says into your hair, "every single day, I mean it â and don't go quiet on each other, will you? Promise me. I couldn't stand it if you went quiet on each other."
You promise. You're not sure, yet, that you can keep it.
The first few days, you and Remus circle each other like two people who love each other perfectly well and have simply never had to be in a room together without a third voice keeping the conversation moving. You eat dinner at opposite ends of the table, the middle chair sitting there like a fact neither of you wants to mention. He asks if you want tea and you say yes and he makes it, properly, the way he does everything, unhurried, and you say thanks and that's the whole conversation. He reads. You watch something with the sound too low to actually follow. Both of you go to bed early, because sleep, unlike silence, doesn't ask anything of you.
Sirius rings from a service station somewhere past Sheffield. "How's things," he says, "you two getting on alright? Talking and everything?"
"Fine," you say, and it isn't a lie exactly, it's just smaller than the truth.
"You're being weird," he says, "I can hear it down the phone, you're both being weird at each other, aren't you?"
"We are not being weird."
"You are being weird," Remus calls, not looking up from his book, and there's something almost like a laugh underneath it, and that's the first crack in the thing that's sat stiff between you since Sunday.
It doesn't mend all at once. A few nights later you're both still up, him with the same book he's been not-reading for a fortnight, you with the telly on low, and you say, into the quiet, "Is it always this awkward? Between us? Or is that new?"
Remus considers that properly, the way he considers everything, turning it over before he'll commit to a shape for it. "It's not that it's awkward," he says. "It's that we've never had to build the thing ourselves. We've always had him laying the bricks. Doesn't mean the love isn't there. Just means we've never had to carry it without help."
"D'you think that's a bit sad? That we've been together three years and I still don't know how to just â talk to you, when it's only us?"
"Bit sad," he agrees, "yeah. Or it just means we've had it easy up till now. Doesn't mean we can't manage the harder version. I'd hope we could, given everything else we've managed."
You glance at the middle chair. Empty, obviously â it's been empty a week and a half now. "Suppose we're finding out, then."
"Suppose we are." A pause, and then, dry, not quite looking at you, "Try not to enjoy proving me wrong too much, though? I've got a reputation as the pessimist to maintain."
It's slow after that, but real, and none of it is new exactly, more like a room in your own house you've never had reason to walk into. You already know he takes his tea strong enough to strip paint. What you learn is how he sounds when there's no one else to perform ease for â quieter, more careful, apologising for things that don't need apologising for, taking up the armchair, having an opinion, being tired, like he's checking, every time, whether he's still allowed to just be here without Sirius to vouch for him. You start saying, gently, that he doesn't have to say sorry for that, and watch him try to believe you. He learns, or relearns, that you go quiet when you're working something out, and that it isn't a bad quiet, it just wants room, and that you've always gone quiet like that, he's just never had to sit with it alone before.
One night you fall asleep on the sofa with your head against his shoulder and wake at two, and he's still awake, careful and still under you, like he didn't want to move and wreck it.
"You could've woken me up," you say, half laughing, apologising with your whole face.
"Didn't want to." Simple as that. "You looked comfortable. Thought I'd let you have it."
"You're allowed to want things too, you know. You don't have to just â hand them over to everyone else."
He doesn't answer that one straight off either. Runs true to form.
Sirius, meanwhile, is learning his own frightening thing.
He rings most nights from lay-bys and motorway hotels with the telly bolted to the wall, and at first he sounds like he's checking a wound, careful questions, are you alright, are you both alright, is it â is it actually okay there, without me? You tell him it's more than okay and watch him not quite believe it down a signal dropping from three bars to one.
Then, somewhere around week three, something in him settles.
"Played to two thousand people tonight," he says, and there's a wonder in it that's got nothing performed about it, which is rare for him. "Nearly threw up beforehand, and then I looked out and just thought, they came for us? Actually came for us?"
"Course they did," you say. "You're brilliant, you idiot."
"Miss you," he says, "miss you both, it doesn't ease off, I thought it might by now."
"You don't actually want it to ease off, though, do you?" Remus says, leaning into the phone over your shoulder. "That'd just mean you'd stopped caring."
A pause, one that costs him something to sit through, which for Sirius is unusual â he's not a sitter, he's a mover. "It's strange," he says eventually, "being away and not falling apart. Thought I might. Thought the whole thing might come loose without me stood in the middle of it going, look at us, isn't this brilliant, aren't we brilliant?"
"We're not that fragile," you say.
"Never said you were fragile. Said I thought I was the glue." Quieter now. "Turns out I'm not, though? Turns out you two have always loved each other perfectly well. Turns out I was never holding that up, was I. Just standing in front of it, mostly."
"You're allowed to be the loud one," Remus says, and there's no edge on it at all. "We like the loud one. Doesn't mean we fall over without him. Doesn't mean what's between us needed you there to be real."
You can hear something in Sirius's breathing that might be him working very hard not to cry down a payphone in a car park in Leeds, and not quite managing it.
Week four, and something in the flat has changed shape, though none of it is new, not really â you've loved Remus since before you could properly date it, and he's loved you the same, both of you have known that for years, it's never once been in question between you. What's new is doing something about it without Sirius stood there to cue the moment. It happens over the washing up, the way it might have happened a hundred times before if he hadn't always been the one to start things â Remus's hand finds yours in the sink, and you both go still, and there's a beat where neither of you moves, because usually there's someone else in the room deciding for you. Then he decides. Leans in. Kisses you properly, like he's confessing to something.
"I've been wanting to do that without an audience for longer than I'd like to admit," he says after, quiet, "and talking myself out of it every time, in case it felt wrong, somehow. Doing it without him here."
"Why would it feel wrong?"
"No idea," he says. "Seemed a safe enough thing to assume, though," and that, you understand, is the whole of Remus in one line, braced for the worst quietly enough that nobody thinks to argue with him about it.
You kiss him back properly then, and something in you settles that hasn't settled in longer than you can say â some part of you that's been braced, this whole three years, for the third leg of the stool to be the one keeping it standing.
"Should we tell him?" you say after, foreheads together, both of you a bit undone by yourselves.
"Tonight. He'd never forgive us if we sat on it." A beat. "He might worry, if we don't. Best ring him now."
You ring him from the sofa, the middle cushion between you where the middle chair's shadow seems to have followed you home, and you tell him, and there's a silence down the line long enough that you both start to worry.
"Sirius? You still there?"
"I'm just," he says, voice gone thick, "I'm just really glad, that's all. I've been sat up here worrying you'd go the whole six weeks being polite at each other, and instead you've gone and worked it out on your own, haven't you? Knew you would. Knew you had it in you, the pair of you."
"You're not the reason it's there," Remus says. "You never were. You're just usually the one who says it out loud first. We only had to learn how to say it ourselves."
"Save me a seat," Sirius says, half laughing, half not, "middle one. I'm having the middle one when I'm back, don't let anyone else nick it."
"Wouldn't dream of it," you tell him.
The last fortnight goes quicker, the way time does once you've stopped bracing against it. You and Remus settle into something that stops feeling unfamiliar and starts feeling like what it always was, underneath, waiting for the noise to clear enough to hear it properly. Sirius rings less about missing you and more about the gig in Manchester, the sound engineer who's a nightmare, the bassist who's started calling him "the frontman" like it's a joke that's stopped being one and he's not sure how he feels about that yet. He sounds, if anything, more like himself than you've heard him in years â looser, less braced for the floor to go â like six weeks of being trusted to carry his own weight has straightened something out in him that's been bent since he was a boy.
He comes home on a Sunday, the van pulling up outside looking like it's been to war, and he's out of it before it's properly stopped, and then â this is the bit that surprises you â he doesn't run at the house. Doesn't crash in like a returning storm the way you'd braced for. He just stands on the pavement a second, looking at the two of you stood together in the doorway, closer than you were six weeks ago, and something in his face goes still and sure all at once, which is not a look you're used to on him.
"There you are," he says, and you're not sure which of you he means. Doesn't matter. Both, probably.
Inside, he sits down at the table, and none of you moves for a second, and then he pulls the middle chair out â his, still, always going to be his â and drops into it like a man setting a bag down after a very long walk. You and Remus take the seats either side, the way you always did, except the shape of it's different now, because the middle chair isn't holding you apart anymore. It's just where he sits.
"Go on then," he says, reaching for both your hands at once, greedy the way he's always been with the two of you, and not sorry about it, "tell me everything I missed. All of it. Don't leave anything out, I'll know if you do."
You do. It takes hours. He listens like it's the best thing he's ever heard, interrupting to say I knew it and about time too and did I not say â and later, much later, in the dark, tangled together in a bed that's finally the right size again, he says it plain, no dressing it up, "I was so sure I was the thing holding you two together. Turns out you were always holding each other, weren't you, same as you hold me. I was just never out of the room long enough to notice."
"Softer thing to find out," Remus says, into his shoulder.
"Better thing," you say, and mean it, and outside the window the sky's doing its slow turn from black to grey to something almost gold, and none of you are asleep yet, and none of you mind, and the middle chair sits downstairs in the dark, exactly where it's always been, only fuller now for having been empty a while.