#poly!smut

A day was decided amongst the three of you. And consent was affirmed again the night before and then again, the morning of. You also went over your safe word: avocado toast.

The fantasy was free use and this was how the dynamic worked: if either of the men should become horny at any time (which happened a lot), they were allowed to do a range of things to you without having to ask. Your exact words were, "For that day, I only exist for your pleasure." While you had given blanket consent, there was an agreed upon understanding that you could withdraw consent whenever you wanted to.

The appeal for you, was the trust and honesty about each other’s desires; it wasn’t just the inherent appeal of fucking someone the moment the mood striked (though that did play a part).

**

It started simply enough.

You were in the kitchen, brewing coffee and plating pancakes from the griddle. You had freshly showered but remained in your oversized t-shirt. You were at the sink soaking some dishes when you heard Rafael from behind you.

“Buenos dias, mi tesoro.”

“Good morning Rafael.” You hadn’t turned around as you knew what was about to happen and your heart was racing with anticipation.

Rafael lifted your shirt and reached down to spread your ass cheeks, revealing the butt plug that was flush against you. You gasped as Rafael wiggled the toy, until it started to come out. He pushed the plug back in and then out again, teasingly fucking you with it. Rafael left the plug in and then dipped his fingers into your already soaked pussy. Rafael played around with your wetness, stroking your folds before sinking his fingers inside your warm sheath. He did it a few times before withdrawing. You were already so hot and ready to be filled.

You heard the sound of a lid clicking close followed by a slick sound. Rafael hugged you from behind and you leaned into the embrace when all of a sudden you are filled and stretched with Rafael’s thick cock. You let out a gasp which quickly turned into a moan as Rafael didn’t wait for you to adjust, just pounding into you. You gripped the lip of the sink, your head falling forward as Rafael’s cock dragged against your walls. Rafael’s fingertips dug into your hips, gripping hard. You could feel his balls slap against your pussy.

“Is that what my dirty slut needs? To be filled with cock all the time?” Rafael asked. You reached down to rub your clit, your fingertips brushing against his balls.

You let out a whine as your orgasm quickly approached. Rafael let out a grunt as he stiffened, coming deep inside you. He bent over and nipped your shoulder before withdrawing. He left your T-shirt up over your hips and then bent on one knee to pull your pussy lips apart to watch his load drip down your thighs. He scooped up some of his release and then approached you and shoved his finger in your mouth. You sucked his finger clean and let out a content hum. Rafael removed his finger and then made way to grab a mug. He poured himself a cup of coffee before moving to sit at the breakfast bar to read the paper that had been delivered earlier.

You went back to soaking and cleaning dishes when you heard Bryan enter the kitchen. He must have just woken up because Rafael made a retort about how slobby he looked.

You grabbed a dishrag to wipe down the sink when you felt Bryan’s monstrous cock slide into your cunt. “Who needs lube when this pussy is already so full of cum?”

Bryan pulled you upright against him and reached to grab the hem of your shirt while he was still notched inside of you. You helped him pull it over your head and then tossed it to the side. Bryan’s hands were immediately on your breasts, squeezing and groping. Bryan moved one hand around and down to your back, pushing you down. You were fully bent at the hip, your hands gripping your own legs as Bryan fucked you. From your upside down vantage point, you saw another pair of legs and you realized Rafael had decided to join in.

“Couch.” Rafael commanded. Bryan let out a grunt and then withdrew. He gave your ass a smack and then pushed you towards the couch.

You braced your arms on the couch arm and jutted your hips out. Bryan wasted no time, thrusting his cock back inside of you. You let out a moan which quickly became muffled as Rafael shoved his cock inside your mouth. Rafael’s hands entwined into your hair, holding you in place as he fucked your mouth.

Bryan smacked your ass and then grabbed a handful of flesh, squeezing. The sounds of skin on skin filled the apartment. Rafael removed his cock from your mouth to smack your cheek with it, leaving a smear of pre-cum.

“Does our pretty girl like to get fucked like the slut she is?” Rafael rasped.

You nodded. “I want my asshole pounded and destroyed. It feels so good having that big cock in my tiny asshole! Oh fuck, harder, harder!”

Bryan hocked a wad of spit where his cock was disappearing. He used two thick fingers to slide it up and over your ass hole. “Want it harder?” Bryan asked. He didn’t allow you to answer as he pressed his cock into your ass. You cried out at the sudden fullness, “Bryan! Oh fuck yes!”

Bryan slammed into your ass while Rafael kneeled on the floor. Holding your legs by your thighs, he raised his mouth to your now free pussy, his tongue lapping at your wetness and his prior release.

Rafael made sounds of content as he ate you out. He stroked his cock furiously as he wanted another go with you.

“Shit I’m gonna cum!” You cried out. Rafael continued to mouth you as you came, your juices squirting all over.

Rafael stood up and leaned over to kiss Bryan, sharing your taste with him. Bryan held Rafael’s face with one hand as he kissed his lookalike.

Rafael broke the kiss hesitantly. “Let me get some of that ass.”

Bryan nodded and withdrew, causing you to whine at the loss. Bryan plopped himself on the couch, stroking his cock, covered in your juices. You straddled Bryan and slid your pussy back onto his cock. “Fuck!” You cried out as you sank fully onto his lap. Bryan took one of your tits in his mouth, as Rafael drizzled lube over your ass cheeks. He massaged some into your ass which was already loose from Bryan’s cock. Rafael pushed his cock into you. You let out a wrecked last moan. “Fuck you’re so big in my tiny asshole.”

“God that ass is so tight.” Rafael groaned as he began to slowly thrust. He withdrew and admired how your asshole stayed opened. Gazing upon that gaping hole made him feel primal, like he was a sexual beast. Rafael gripped his cock and then slid it in again, sinking slowly in before withdrawing once more, again watching how your asshole gaped, blossoming like a beautiful flower. “So pretty.” Rafael murmured. He then slid his cock back in slowly inch by inch until he was fully seated, his balls nestled against you.

“You take my cock in your ass so well. Tell us how much you love getting fucked by two cocks.” Rafael began to thrust, this time a bit faster.

Bryan joined on the thrusting, both men quickly finding a rhythm. “Such a whore that you need two cocks to satisfy you, hmm?”

“Yes!” You cried out. “Yes! I need it! I need to be filled. Use me, use my holes!”

Rafael reached over you and shoved both hands into your mouth, keeping your mouth pried open as he and Bryan fucked you.

The men grunted and groaned as they wrecked your pussy and abused your ass. Saliva dripped out of your mouth and onto Bryan’s chest and abdomen. When Rafael released your mouth, Bryan gripped your chin, his fingers nearly slipping due to the saliva that had looked out.

“All you’re good for is to be our fuck toy.” Bryan growled.

You nodded desperately. “Yes, oh fuck! I feel so full!”

You pussy throbbed with need and you were so close to the precipice again. Just a few strokes on your clit by Bryan and you were done. You wailed both their names over and over again as you came, your pussy gripping Bryan’s cock and your ass clenching Rafael. You completely dissolved into pleasure as your orgasm rippled through your body.

Rafael stiffened as he came again, grunting your name. You could feel his release drip out of your ass. He took a step back, trying to catch his breath.

“Gonna go shower.” Rafael panted as Bryan continued to pound you. The cum that was already notched inside began to leak out of you and down Bryan’s cock. Rafael’s cum dripped down Bryan’s balls

Bryan slowed his thrusts and reached up to swat your face, bringing you back to focus. “And what do we say to Rafael?”

“Thank you for fucking me.” You replied breathlessly, but smiling. You had a fucked stupid look on your face - your face was vacant, tears streamed your cheeks, your jaw slack.

“And I’m not done with you yet.” Rafael called out as he sauntered off.

It was just you and Bryan. He flipped you over, so your back was on the couch cushion. He withdrew from you, you could vaguely see his cream coated cock from where you were. He pulled you by the calves of your legs and rested your ass slightly on the arm of the couch. Your legs rested on his shoulders and he slid his cock back in your pussy, all soaked and swollen.

“I wish you could see how pretty you look right now.” Bryan groaned. “Taking daddy’s cock so well.”

Bryan was relentless in his fucking. He was really into the free use idea. It required an inordinate amount of love and trust. You had been living with him and Rafael for a few months. He had sometimes worried that you would want to be out of this polyamorous relationship but you just affirmed over and over again that you were theirs and they were yours. And today proved it. It was enough to make an old curmudgeon’s black heart thaw.

Bryan felt himself about to cum, his balls tightened and he withdrew again. You whined, disappointed. He made his way to your face and began to jack himself. You rubbed yourself to completion while Bryan pumped his fat cock. With a string of expletives intermixed with your name, he came in thick, hot, creamy white ropes all over your face. Your mouth was open so you caught some of it on your tongue and you swallowed it. You made a big show of showing off your tongue before and after swallowing, knowing it was one of the things you loved - showing off for them.

“My gorgeous little cum dump.” Bryan praised. He walked over to your legs again, and dropped to his knees, burying his face inside you. You were completely over stimulated and when you tried to wriggle away, Bryan wrapped his arms around your thighs and pulled you closer onto his face. You bucked your hips into his mouth as he plunged his tongue in and out, writhing inside you. His tongue lapped at you, tasting how sweet you were. He couldn’t get enough and he made that well known as he made obscene sounds while eating you out.

Your body was shaking; you lost count at how many times you had already come and it was still the morning. Bryan moved to take a bite on your thighs and then slapped your pussy with his hand. He then grabbed your swollen lips between his slick fingers and pinched them, your flesh puffing through.

Bryan then jammed three fingers inside of you and began to jackhammer them in and out of you. With his free hand, he rubbed your clit haphazardly and roughly.

“Yes, more, don’t stop!”

“Never!” Bryan replied. “I want you to squirt for me baby girl. You can do that, right? Can you do that for daddy?”

You couldn’t even formulate words as pleasure erupted out of you like a volcano. You squirted all over Bryan’s face. He swallowed your juices before sucking on your clit. Waves of pleasure coursed through you as you came hard again in Bryan’s mouth, sobbing.

Bryan slowly lapped your pussy through your orgasm, running his tongue over your clit, sucking it back into his mouth. You jerked back, overstimulated. Bryan took your cue and stopped.

“Going to go shower with Raf. Rest for now. Do you need anything?” Bryan asked as he crouched by your head. He stroked your hair, pushing your sweaty hair off your forehead.

You barely murmured an “no” as you laid there, a complete fucked out wreck. Bryan pressed a kiss to your lips. “Doing so well princess. Do you want to stop?”

“No.” You sighed happily. “I know our word. I’m okay.”

**

You woke up to the sensation of someone eating you out and the feeling of a cock being shoved into your slumbering mouth. You stretched your jaw to let whomever it was all the way in, while rubbing the sleep out of your eyes. You realized that it was Bryan who was softly fucking your mouth while Rafael was eating you out.

You let out a muffled moan, pressing your hands to your tits squeezing them together. Bryan leaned over and smacked your tits, before pinching your nipples hard.

Rafael paused to suck a mark in your inner thigh. He looked up at Bryan. “Hey, I have an idea.”

Bryan locked eyes with Rafael as he kept thrusting in and out of your mouth. “Yeah?”

**

The swing was an impulse purchase made when the three of you visited the high end sex shop one rare weekend when both men were off the clock. It was a loud pink color and it hadn’t been used yet, just assembled and waiting.

Now was the perfect time.

Bryan and Rafael helped you onto the swing - one strap was behind your mid-back and the other behind your ass. You placed your legs atop Bryan’s shoulders and gripped the straps by your arms.

Bryan grabbed the lube and slicked your asshole before pushing two fingers into you, prepping your ass. He used the pad of his thumb to rub your clit as he pushed the head of his cock into your ass.

You let out a moan as your head fell back. Rafael stepped forward and shoved his cock deeply into your mouth. and was being choked with Rafael’s cock. The propel motion from Bryan aided in you taking Rafael’s cock deeper. Rafael groped your tits roughly. You were certain come morning you’d discover bruises and marks all over your body.

Wanna know what we were doing while you were sleeping?” Bryan asked, slowing his pace.

Rafael removed his cock from your mouth, allowing you to take a deep inhalation. “What?” You whined as Bryan slowly rubbed your clit.

Rafael walked around to Bryan and gave him a hard and filthy kiss. He turned to look down at you.

Bryan withdrew from you and Rafael stroked his cock.

“I was fucking Rafael.” Bryan growled. You let out a whimper at the image.

Bryan let out a grunt, “Shit. Oh, that feels good. Suck my cock now.”

Rafael dropped to his knees and began to blow Bryan with enthusiasm. You watched the show, gripping the straps of the swing tightly. Bryan gripped the fellow attorney’s hair as he bobbed along his length. Rafael stroked his own cock while he lavished Bryan’s.

Eventually Rafael stood and they switched sides.

Each man took turns fucking you in the swing with their thick cocks, in every position you could stand and filling you with multiple creampies. Rafael and Bryan helped you get on your feet. You were wobbly and had a dazed, fucked stupid face. Their loads dripped out of you and landed with an obscene splat on the floor.

The room permeated with the scent of sex, your skin coated sweat, lube and fluids. The men were t that far off, despite having showered.

“I think I need a shower and some food.” You replied, tiredly.

“Are you saying..?” Rafael asked.

“Yeah, avocado toast.” You replied tiredly.

Each man nodded. Rafael scooped you up and you wrapped your arms around him. You nestled against his chest and stroked his chest, fingering the chain of his crucifix. “Good thing you’re both snipped or otherwise we would have a problem.”

The men laughed. “Very true.” Bryan replied. “Can’t have that happening.”

“I’ll get the bath going.” Rafael told Bryan. “Why don’t you order the food. Y/N wanted from the Japanese place. Put it on my card.”

Bryan nodded and grabbed his robe. “Sounds good.” He tied it and then reached for his phone, but not before pressing a small kiss to your forehead. “You did so well. So proud of you, daddies good girl.”

You gave him a dazed, fucked out, blissful look and then looked at Rafael similarly.

“When can we do that again?”

Tags: @mgarner1227 @madpanda75 @tropes-and-tales @dreamlover31 @beardedmccoy @youreverycolor @neely1177 @witches-unruly-heart @mrsrafaelbarba @skittle479 @ottosuricato @garturbo @sass-and-suspenders @mommakat32 @dreila03 @beccabarba @lovebishoplosamiguelgalindo @imjustreallynosy @sweetsummertime99 @prurientpuddlejumper @whyissvuruiningmylovelife @differentshadesofgray @annabelleb49 @redlipstickandblacktea @zoeykaytesmom @misssirenlove @catnip987 @storiesofsvu @teamsladsandgents @detective-giggles @esparza-army @sassyada

Rafael watched as his lookalike slowly stroked his massive cock. You released Rafael from your mouth and looked up. “See, I told you he must have been stuck!”

Rafael glared at you. “Do you want to come later?”

Your eyes widened and you nodded hurriedly.

“Then back to it.” Rafael growled. You turned to Bryan and mouthed a ‘sorry’ to him which was accompanied with the tiniest of shrugs.

You turned back to Rafael and dipped your head to pay attention to his balls, sucking the sensitive, velvety skin with firm but light suction. You used a hand to jerk him.

Rafael sucked in a sharp breath and threw his head back. Bryan kept stroking his cock, letting out a grunt of pleasure as he picked up the pace. He focused on your ass, thinking about the last time he gave you a good pounding in your tight little hole and how he came hard, filling you up.

Precum leaked from the tip of Bryan’s cock and he moved one thumb in a circle, smearing it over the head and down his cock, down the thick vein on the underside.

Rafael at this point, pulled you up so you were sitting in his lap. Your face was a mess, saliva covering your chin and your mascara smeared. Rafael gripped your chin and kissed you hard. “Turn around, let’s show Bryan what he is missing.” Rafael pushed you into a standing position and then stood himself, undoing the remainder of his clothes.

You bit your lip at the sight of Bryan’s cock. You knew how full his cock made you feel and your pussy clenched in response. Rafael grabbed your hand and led you so you were closer to Bryan. He then pressed down on your shoulders. “Fours.”

You nodded and dropped one knee at a time before adjusting so you were all fours. Rafael settled behind you, running his cock up and down along your slit, coating his cock in your juices. You let out a moan as the head of his cock pressed into you. You instinctively rocked back, but Rafael pressed his hand on the small of your back, stilling you.

Finally, Rafael bottomed out, filling you up with his full length. You let out a throaty moan in response. Rafael ran his hands over the curve of your ass, which were snug against his thighs. His fingers dug into your hips as he began to piston in and out of you. With every propel forward, you realized you were mere inches from Bryan’s cock. If you stuck your tongue out, you could try to blow him. Rafael must’ve read your mind because he pulled you back and you felt the carpet burn on your knees.

“No, no. Bryan doesn’t get rewarded.” Rafael retorted as he held you there, his cock notched deeply in your pussy.

Bryan glared at Rafael. “You’re such a dick.”

“Says the one who has his dick in his hand.” Rafael replied as he resumed fucking you.

“Am I being used… as - oh, fuck!” You cried out. “Used as a pawn … in your sexual game?”

Rafael laid a spank on your ass. “Yes - is there a problem with that?” He reached around again and his hand found your clit, slick and swollen. He began to rub in concentric circles.

You groaned at the sensations it gave you. “Oh, oh fuck! I - I just wanted to - fuck, yes! Make sure we were all on the same p-p-page.”

Rafael gave you a couple of hard, punctuated thrusts, causing you to cry out and reach for Bryan for stabilization.

Bryan watched your face contort with pleasure.

“Fuck this. I’m not watching anymore. I need to fuck someone and I need to do it now.” Bryan growled. He made way to Rafael and tugged him towards him, which caused him to slip out of you. You tumbled forward slightly but caught yourself and turned around to watch the two men battle it out for dominance.

Bryan pushed Rafael down so he was on his back and then pressed his legs up. “Lube?”

Rafael nodded. “Y/N?”

You stood on wobbly knees and made way to your purse and found the bottle of lube you always kept in your purse, just in case. You tossed it over to Bryan who poured a generous amount over his hand and cock. In that instant, Rafael leaned up and pushed Bryan down.

Bryan’s eyes widened at Rafael’s move. “Oh someone came to play.”

Rafael snatched the lube and took some to pour on Bryan’s hole, before slipping a finger in to stretch him. “If anyone else is getting fucked, it’s you.” Rafael growled as he slid his cock in. He didn’t wait for the adjustment and pushed in deeper, bottoming out. His balls were snug against Bryan’s ass. Rafael withdrew slightly, squirted more lube and pressed in again.

“Y/N, get that pretty pussy over on Bryan’s face, but face me.”

You nodded. “Yes daddy.” You mock saluted.

You lowered yourself so you were over Bryan’s face, facing out to Rafael. You let out a gasp as Bryan gripped your thighs and pulled you down. His mouth found your needy cunt and began to eat you out with fervor. You pressed your tits together, tugging on your nipples as Bryan proved as to how he got to be so silver tongued.

You rode Bryan’s face, rolling your hips forward, grinding against his face. His tongue delved between your folds and found your clit. He lapped at it, circled it with his tongue. You were already overstimulated from when Rafael was fucking you, so your orgasm began it’s ascent easily. You felt it wind and pool in your belly.

Don’t stop, so close,” you groaned. Bryan’s hands grabbed at your ass, hard before he laid a spank on it.

You lost your steadiness and fell forward slightly, bracing yourself on his chest. Bryan used the opportunity to spread your lips apart with his fingers and he slipped a thick digit inside of you. Your thighs trembled as he finger fucked you, sending you over the precipice. Your eyes squeezed shut as you completely dissolved into pleasure.

As you began to come back into your body, you were aware of Rafael really pounding into Bryan. He was grunting and groaning, sweat dripping off his face.

Bryan lightly tapped the back of your thigh, signaling you to climb off, which you did. You could tell Rafael was close. Bryan’s cock looked painful, red with cum weeping.

“Shit, I’m going to come!” Rafael growled. He withdrew himself and stood over you. You closed your eyes and opened your mouth. You felt Rafael’s hot cum land on your face and you reached down to rub your clit. You opened your eyes and gave him a wicked smile as you made a show of licking and cleaning.

“Is everyone going to come but me?” Bryan snapped. You turned your attention to him and climbed onto Bryan. You took his cock in your hand and gave him a few strokes before lining him up with your entrance. Bryan was more hung than Rafael and you let out a moan as you sunk down onto him. You closed your eyes as you seated yourself fully. It felt as if his cock was splitting you in half and you reveled in the feeling of pain because you knew it would soon eek into pleasure.

“God, I love riding you.” You gasped as he started thrusting up, hitting deep, making you cry out.

Bryan gripped your hips, digging so hard you knew in the morning you’d have bruises. Both men knew you bruised like a peach and they used that to their pleasure - marking you in many ways - sometimes in ways that made it difficult to hide. You were their toy and they made damn sure everyone knew.

Bryan planted his feet on the ground and began to jackhammer into you, your tits bouncing, the sound of your ass clapping against his thighs filling the room.

Rafael stroked himself as he watched you meet Bryan stroke for stroke, coming down harder. “Good girl.” Rafael rasped. “You look so pretty taking Bryan’s cock. And you take it so well.”

You made a keening sound and turned to where Rafael was. He pulled you into a messy kiss before dipping his mouth to your tits, sucking one of your pert nipples, before providing equal attention to the other.

Rafael plucked your nipples and you whimpered in response. You loved having your breasts played with. Your head fell back and you sped up, bouncing on Bryan’s lap, matching him thrust for thrust.

Your pussy tightened around Bryan’s cock. You’ve come once already and you’re less patient now for the next one.

Bryan watched where his cock disappeared into you. “Damn baby girl, look at all that cream just dripping down my cock.” He praised.

You couldn’t respond - you were too lost in ecstasy. You were barely aware of Rafael being behind you and squirting lube all over your asshole. Bryan slowed his pace and pulled you down for a kiss, which allowed Rafael to push his cock into your ass.

Rafael slid into you and you gasped as he filled you up completely. Rafael pressed small, delicate kisses along the knobs of your spine, murmuring praises of how you were such a good girl taking both cocks. You felt so wonderfully full. The two men waited for you to adjust and then fell into a smooth rhythm, with Rafael’s cock sliding in you and Bryan pulling out. It was a carnal scene as their bodies moved with one another as they thrust inside you. You were trembling as they fucked you, letting out pathetic whimpers as you clung to their sweaty bodies.

Bryan tried to hold out but the way your pussy gripped his cock so tightly, he just couldn’t last. His teeth gnashed together as he tried to focus on anything but the pleasure coursing through him but he couldn’t. He let out a string of swears as he stiffened as he came. His load painted your walls before dripping out of you and pooling where you were both intimately connected.

Bryan’s cock softened but he held you tightly, his hands playing with your tits as he swallowed your cries as you quickly followed, coming yourself. Rafael let a deep rumble before pulling out. He stood at the side of you and Bryan, rubbing his cock furiously and then came himself with a grunt. You had sat up and creamy ropes of cum landed on Bryan’s lower abdomen. Bryan scooped some up with his fingers and presented it to you. You took his fingers and sucked them clean, letting out a hum of pleasure as you did so.

Rafael was slumped on his couch, catching his breath as he watched you both. Finally, you swung off Bryan and on wobbly legs made your way to the couch where you sat next to Rafael, your head on his shoulder. You both had equally relaxed smiles.

Bryan groaned as he sat up. “Ugh my back.” He bemoaned.

“You okay there grandpa?” You asked which earned you a glare from the Chicago litigator. Rafael chuckled.

“That was fun but how about we finish this at home? I know I could go a few more rounds.” Bryan replied as he gathered his clothes. “But I could do without the floor.”

“First dinner, I’m starving.” You replied as you reached for Bryan. He pulled you up and pressed a kiss to your lips.

You both turned to Rafael, anticipating his response. He nodded. “Absolutely - Bryan, if you thought you were off the hook yet, you are sorely mistaken.”

Bryan let out a deep laugh. “No objection here, Your Honor.”

FIN