As mentioned in my previous post, I decided to try to edit Shin from the teaser a small amount to see if what I rambled about had any true ground to stand on.
Original -
VS
My minor edits -
Was this worth the time spent to edit this? Does it actually look better or am I delusional? Feel free to let me know!
Section below is just me rambling about what I did and why for the edit but basically to summarize, less is better in this case.
So obviously not a whole lot of changes.
The main ones being removing the light spot on his forehead and removing some of the darker shadows such as under his mouth. The forehead spot is still lighter but I reduced it heavily as well as feathered the edges out immensely
I do have a version where I just simply lightened the under mouth shadow rather than fully removing it.
I could say I removed it cause I don't think it makes sense for it to be that pronounced given the direction of the lighting or that I don't recall the anime ever adding that shadow there even when lighting was more prominent during season 1.... but truthfully those are just justifications after the fact. I simply just didn't like it lol
I moved the eyebrow shadows a little and overall feathered the edges of some shadows with the airbrush tool. Its more noticable of a change on the left side though not by much and truthfully I think that shadow still is very much wrong.
I did remove one of the smaller shadows by his eye as I felt the line there did enough that it was not needed at all. I considered adding more lines around the eyes like the manga but ended up not doing so because I am just doing this all on my phone rn and also because I would worry about overdoing it like I felt the shading here was.
Last not very noticable change was that I changed the color of the nose shadow to match the color of the eyebrow shadows. It bothered me how the bottom of the nose kinda blended in with the shadow. The colors aren't super different but to me the other shadows have a more purple tone comparatively.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
I have watched the teaser so many times now every time it pops up on my feed.
Still very hyped and it looks great and I love the fact they keep improving the animation
But I won't lie my main concern with the new emphasis on the more dramatic lighting/cel shading shown on the teaser is that it'll be overused.
Take for example these two screenshots.
I kinda don't really like how the shading looks in these two. Nagumo's scene is slightly better because it doesn't linger too much but it does feel slightly off and I think its in part cause of the shading.
I think this is even more noticable on Nagumo's shirt. The first is from the teaser we got at the end of cour 2 and the 2nd is the newest teaser. Obviously lighting has been changed inbetween these two scenes but the shading on the shirt is uhhhh... a lot
I tried to go back to find any screenshots of more dramatic lighting done in season 1 to try to showcase the difference in how much sharper things feel in the newest teaser comparatively.
Of course gonna be using Shin screenshots for this as he is one of my favorite characters that have enough screentime to do so.
Here is Shin in an earlier episode though this example isn't the best as the lighting isn't particularly harsh. This shows off what I mean by a more duller shading. They really liked the textured almosy lines in the shadows during cour 1. I am so glad they didn't keep up with this as much during cour 2.
Baby Shin here showcases more harsh lighting but as you can see some of the shadow's edges are blurred out. It doesn't feel as sharp as the new teaser.
Again if you look closely you can kinda see that texture I talked about in the first image though I think the texture I am talking about is honestly best seen on Sakamoto during cour 1.
And then we have cour 2 which experimented with more colors to set the environment better I noticed which I absolutely loved. Shin vs Shinaya is a good example of this. The purple tone here is chef kiss.
While the shadows are sharper with less feathering on the edges, there aren't multiple different shades to them. Shin's eye bags and wrinkles are portrayed using just lines, no extra shading needed.
Lastly, here is Shin using his future sight for the first time which is probably the closest dramatic lighting wise to the teaser. The main thing though is they didn't go overboard trying to portray every wrinkle or plane of his face.
Using all that is discussed in this post, I decided to procrastinate what I should be working on by editing the screenshot from the teaser which I will include in a different post cause this post is very rambling and long and I think I hit image limit lol
These last few episodes of Sakamoto Days have been so good omg. Shin poor baby... but like also though I love the angst/hurt keep it up haha. All my favorite characters must suffer so that way they can be comforted after.
I might just die with next week being the last week of new episodes.
I hope they announce season 2 quickly. I'm not expecting it to release quickly, I just want confirmation and a date pretty please
Got a new job (as well as 2 weeks before it having such intense stress about said job that my brain just shut down and I bedrotted so hard lol) so haven't had time to finish any WIPs but istg I will this weekend finish at least 2 of my drawing wips.
I have like 4 other sketches that I've started just not at a stage I want to share too so if nothing else just getting those to that stage lol
Sob why do I have to work, if only I could just keep drawing my favorite characters all day and procrastinating finish them still instead haha
Okay I'm now done spamming skdy reblogs for the day. Now time to disappear off tumblr for another month before I remember about it and get addicted to scrolling through it once more
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
This weekend I'm gonna try to lock in and do stuff. What exactly? I have no idea. But I will be doing it and not just sleeping all weekend I swear it lol