Out of Reach (joel miller au)
“She didn't step away but instead she looked up at me. We looked at each other for a second and both started moving in. Letting everything we just said go to shit. I was just thinking about her and I wasn't sure who would be the first to move.”
wc: 4.8k
an: 2 chapter for my children today:)) enjoy💋 we have a little special guest this chapter.
masterlist (18)
eighteen
I left the office to go to a site. I didn't need to go but it was a better alternative than being stuck in that office with her. I didn't even hear the door click shut behind me over the sound of my own heartbeat. Didn't matter. What's done is done.
And for once, I was glad she shut me out. Glad she didn't try to argue or cry or ask me why. I saw that tear, yeah but I also saw the way she squared her shoulders after. The way she pretended I was just a boss, just another asshole with a title. She was quick about it, cold in that way she didn't usually let herself be. I hated it but I needed it.
We'd finished the week. She'd get her hours. and then we'd both move the hell on. That was the deal now.
By the time I got to the job site, I felt lighter. Not good, but lighter. I walked the perimeter, checked in with the foreman, barked out a few corrections on framing measurements that had been pissing me off for a week. The guys gave me space, they always did when I came in tight like this.
By the time I wrapped up and got back to the office, the sun was already slanting low. I pulled into the lot, half-expecting her car to still be there.
It wasn't.
I looked toward her desk and saw the neat stack of papers, everything in order. Final job listings, organized by deadline. A printed summary of contacts, notes from a guy we hired the week prior and a list of tasks she'd scheduled out in the project manager for the next three weeks.
Didn't say goodbye. Didn't leave a note. Just dropped everything off like she couldn't stand to be in the same room another second longer. I'm honestly surprised she left everything so neat. It felt like I deserved to come back to my office wrecked.
I sat at my desk for a while, flipping through the papers like they mattered more than they did. In reality, I didn't read a single word. I decided it was best to head home before I let my mind start to wander again.
The house was quiet when I got in. Sarah had left a note on the fridge "Out with friends. Don't wait up. Love you.". She always left me notes like this. That same casual handwriting .
I dropped my keys on the counter, peeled off my shirt, and made my way down the hall without turning on a single light. The weight of the day hadn't hit me until I stood in the bathroom, door shut behind me, the only sound was my own breath.
I turned the water on hot. Let the steam rise. Then stepped in.
It was a relief, more than anything. The kind that sinks into your bones and slows everything down. My shoulders dropped for the first time all day, the heat pulling the tension out inch by inch. I tilted my head back, let the spray hit my face.
But I couldn't stop seeing her.
She'd stood right here. Arms raised, eyes closed, water running down her chest, her stomach, her thighs. The way her hair clung to her skin. The way she used to look at me like I was the only man alive.
I used to stand here and watch her. I used to trace her with my eyes like I was memorizing every curve, every freckle, every goddamn breath she took.
I pressed a hand to the tile. Let the water beat against my back. It felt relieving. Like maybe I could scrub the memory off me if I stayed in here long enough. I knew I was lying to myself.
I got out once the mirror fogged over and the bathroom felt too warm to breathe in. Toweled off slow, dragged a hand through my hair, still half-lost in that space between numb and remembering.
I picked up my phone knowing it wasn't the best to be alone tonight.
You around tonight? Could use a visit.
Tommy replied quick.
On my way.
I tossed the phone back on the counter and grabbed a clean shirt from the laundry room.
I didn't want to be alone tonight. Not with these ghosts. Not with the feel of her still stuck somewhere in my memory.
Tommy showed up about twenty minutes after I texted, six-pack in one hand, that look on his face like he already knew I wasn't doing great. He let himself in door and shut it behind him with his boot.
"You look like hell." He said looking up at me.
I didn't bother denying it. Just cracked open a beer and leaned against the counter. "Feel it. Thanks for the warm welcome."
"You sleepin'?"
I didn't answer.
He took a sip and tilted his head. "That's a no."
We moved to the living room, quiet for a while, just the low buzz of some late-night sports show I didn't bother muting. Tommy kicked his feet up, leaned back like he had nowhere better to be.
We caught up on work and I let him know Sarah was in town. He perked up and immediately started making plans. If there was one thing Tommy and I had in common, we loved that girl. After a few beers, tommy opened up about his personal shit.
"I've been seein' someone," he said. "Sorta. I don't know. Met her at the bar near that job we had in Houston. Kinda fiery. Got that look like she knows how to hurt a man and enjoy it."
I let out a dry chuckle. "Sounds like your type."
"Yeah, well, turns out she's also real fond of her ex. Calls me his name in bed."
I raised an eyebrow. "Fuck."
"Exactly. I told her, next time she does that, I'm walkin'. She said maybe I should take it as a compliment."
We sat in silence after that, both sipping our beers, both pretending like that wasn't sad as hell.
Eventually, I ran a hand down my face.
Tommy glanced over. "Alright. Your turn."
"What?" I answered caught off guard.
"You didn't invite me here just to listen to my shit, Joel. Spill it."
I hesitated. I didn't want to tell him or anyone in the first place. It feltlike if I started, I wouldn't be able to stop. Still, I didn't look at him when I spoke.
"You remember Theo?"
"Your buddy from the old crew? From Austin?"
"Yeah. Him."
He gave a nod. "Sure. Family guy."
"Had a daughter," I said, and the minute I said it, I felt the weight shift. "Olivia."
Tommy squinted, thinking. "Wait... was she the quiet one? Used to hang around with Sarah all the time."
I gave a faint nod. "That's her."
He blinked. "She can't be more than..."
"Twenty-two."
That shut him up for a second.
"She came back this summer," I went on. "College internship. Theo reached out, asked if I could bring her on part-time, show her some of the ropes."
Tommy didn't say anything, but I could feel him watching me.
"It started out innocent. Professional. She was curious. Didn't just do the work. She asked questions, wanted to know why things worked the way they did."
I took another sip. My mouth was dry anyway.
"She got under my skin. Not in a loud way. Just... little things. The way she looked at me when she thought I wasn't payin' attention. The way she listened."
Tommy leaned forward slowly. "Dammit Joel."
"I know," I snapped. "Don't say it. Just...don't."
He backed off, held up a hand. "Alright."
"I didn't plan it," I muttered. "Didn't mean for anything to happen. But it did."
He sat there for a second, eyebrows drawn together. "Happen how?"
I gave him a hard look.
His jaw clenched. "You slept with her?"
I didn't answer, but it was enough.
Tommy stood up, started pacing. "Jesus, Joel. You realize what kind of trouble that could cause?"
"I know."
"She's your friend's daughter."
"I know."
He stopped pacing. "And she's young. Like—young young."
"I said I fuckin' know," I snapped, sharper than I meant to. Silence fell between us like a hammer.
He rubbed a hand down his face. "Alright. Okay. You didn't bring me here to yell at you. I just...shit. This is a lot."
I looked down at my hands. "You think I don't know that?"
He sat again, slower this time. "So what, you in love with her?"
"I'm not talkin' about that."
"Because you don't know, or because you do and you don't want to admit it?"
I stayed quiet.
Tommy sighed. "Alright. Look—I'm not saying it's right. Hell, it's messy. But if you really care about her..."
"I already let it go."
Tommy's brow furrowed. "You mean you ended it?"
I nodded once. "Had to. Told her it couldn't happen again. Told her it was over."
He looked at me for a long beat. "She take that well?"
I let out a breath. "She didn't beg. Didn't cry. Just... shut me out. Got real quiet, real fast. Packed up my work, left the office like I was a stranger."
Tommy whistled low. "Damn."
"I figured it was the right thing to do. I mean—hell, it is the right thing. She's too young. There's a hundred reasons I shouldn't have gone near her."
"But?" Tommy asked, already knowing there was one.
"But I can't stop thinkin' about her," I admitted, barely above a whisper. "Still see her face every time I close my eyes. Still hear her laugh when the house is quiet."
Tommy didn't say anything. Just listened.
"And Sarah almost caught her."
That made him sit up. "What?"
I nodded, slow. "I sent her home that morning, early. We'd spent the night. She stayed over, and I—I was stupid. Got caught up. Sarah pulled up out front and I damn near threw myself out the back door."
Tommy leaned back in his chair, shaking his head. "Man..."
"Yeah," I said. "Tell me about it."
"You ever think about tellin' her the truth? Sarah, I mean."
"No." My answer was immediate, solid. "That'd break her. I already crossed one line—draggin' her into it would burn everything down."
Tommy ran a hand through his hair. "So what now?"
I didn't answer right away. Just stared down at the floor.
"I don't know," I finally said. "I tried to end it. I really did. But she's still in my head. Still feels like she's everywhere, even when she ain't here."
Tommy nodded, slow. "You know... I give you shit, 'cause I'm your brother and it's easy. But I know you, Joel. You don't lose your head like this unless it means somethin'. And maybe this ain't what you wanted. Maybe it ain't even what makes sense. But if you keep tryin' to pretend you don't feel it? It's gonna eat you alive."
I swallowed hard. Didn't say anything. Couldn't.
Because deep down, I already knew he was right.
"And you need to figure out what the hell you want, and soon. 'Cause if you don't? You're just gonna tear both of you apart tryin' to pretend it didn't happen."
"She's probably over all of this already." I said trying to knock the idea from my head.
"You're a grown man and you're feeling this way. You think the 20 year old girl is over it?"
I chuckled, realizing maybe things could get better. I finished the beer and let the bottle rest on my knee. My voice came out low.
"She was the only thing that made me feel anything like that in a long time."
Tommy looked at me for a beat, softer now. "That's all you had to say."
I didn't reply. Just stared at the TV like it held answers I wasn't gonna get tonight.
But it felt better. Not good but lighter. And that was enough, for now.
Tommy cracked another beer, this one slower. His mood had evened out some. Mine too. The air between us had settled, heavier but clearer. Like dragging everything out into the open let us both breathe again.
We didn't say much for a while, both of us staring at the TV like the score of a game we weren't actually watching had any real meaning.
Then the sound of the front door opening cut through the quiet. Keys hit the hook on the wall. Footsteps padded in, light and familiar.
Tommy sat up straighter, already grinning. "That her?"
"Yeah," I said, just as Sarah stepped into the room, hoodie half-zipped, and her hair a little messy.
"Hey," she smiled, stopping in the doorway when she saw Tommy. "No way."
Tommy stood and opened his arms like she was still a little kid. "There's my girl."
Sarah laughed and walked right into his arms, wrapping around him like nothing had changed. Like she still remembered sitting on his shoulders at state fairs and begging him to sneak her treats when I said no.
"You didn't tell me he would be here tonight." she said to me over his shoulder.
"Didn't know he was gonna be. He just shows up sometimes."
Tommy pulled back, giving her a once-over. "Yeah right."
Sarah flopped onto the couch between us, like it was all hers. "So what're y'all doing? Solving the world's problems?"
"Somethin' like that," I said, and Tommy chuckled.
Sarah smiled, but it was softer now. Quieter. She looked between us, two men worn down by life, beer bottles on the table, the TV humming low and I swear, for a second, I saw something settle behind her eyes. Like just being here with both of us made her feel safe. Like this room still felt like home.
"You guys always look like this when you talk?" she asked. "All broody and serious?"
Tommy laughed. "Only when your dad's confessing deep emotional turmoil."
I shot him a look, but Sarah just smirked. "Sounds about right."
She leaned back into the cushions, let her head fall against my shoulder. Like when she was little and couldn't sleep unless she knew I was right there.
Tommy tilted his beer toward Sarah. "You keep this one grounded, alright? He's a mess without you."
Sarah smiled, eyes half-closed already. "Always have."
I looked down at her, at the girl who still managed to remind me who I was without ever trying. Then up at Tommy, who'd sat with me through the worst of it tonight without flinching.
It didn't fix anything. Not really. But it reminded me of who I had. Who I still was, underneath it all. And maybe that was enough to hold onto. For now.
Tommy ended up staying the night and I headed up to bed once I saw him dozing off. I actually slept well after ending off the night with both of them. The comfort of us being together again made me forget about my racing thoughts.
——————————-
Driving in felt heavier than usual. I was starting to feel like every morning for the rest of the week was gonna feel like some kind of performance. I rubbed a hand down my face, sighed, then got out and walked in.
She was already at her desk.
And of course, she was wearing a tight black skirt again. The kind that clung to her. The kind that made me wonder if I ever actually had control around her, or if I'd just been telling myself that all along.
The blouse was silk or something close to it, a low neckline and soft enough to stick to her skin like it wanted to be touched. Her legs were crossed, one heel bouncing absently while she typed something. Didn't look up when I walked in.
Christ.
I dropped my stuff and stood there, watching her a second too long. Couldn't help myself. She was doing it on purpose. She had to be.
Or maybe she had plans. Maybe she was going out after. Seeing someone. That thought put a sharp crack through my chest before I could shut it down.
I cleared my throat, voice flat. "You got a date or somethin' after work?"
She paused, slow and deliberate, like she wanted me to know I'd interrupted something more important than me. Finally looked up at me through her lashes. Eyes sharp. A smirk pulling at her mouth.
"Why?" she said. "You jealous?"
There it was. The bite.
I clenched my jaw. "Just a question."
"And I answered it."
My hands curled into fists in my pockets. "Not really."
She cocked her head, leaned back in the chair like she was getting comfortable with pissing me off. "Maybe I do. Maybe I don't. What's it to you. You're just my boss right?"
My mouth opened. Nothing came out at first.
Because she was right.
Was I pissed because some other guy might see her like this? Touch her? Or was I pissed because I wanted her, even if I'd spent the last few days acting like I didn't?
She was watching me, enjoying the way I didn't answer right away. She knew exactly what she was doing.
"Wherever you're goin'," I muttered, finally, "hope he's got the sense to keep his hands to himself."
She smiled at that. Fake. "Doubt it."
Then she turned back to her computer, like that was the end of the conversation. Like she hadn't just lit a fire in my chest and walked away from it.
"Drop the attitude," I said, low.
She let out a short, humorless laugh. "You don't get to ask me that."
"I'm askin' anyway."
Another pause. I watched the tension move through her shoulders, the way her jaw tightened like she was trying to keep it together.
Then, softer, she said, "You fucked me over, Joel."
My chest pulled tight.
"I know," I said.
She glanced at me again, and this time there wasn't fire in her eyes. Just something duller.
"Well," she said, sitting up a little straighter, "doesn't matter much now, does it?"
Silence stretched out between us again, heavy and uncomfortable.
Then she exhaled. "But, fine. I'll drop it." She looked at me again, softer now. "I don't want to spend the next couple days pretending like we don't know each other. That's worse."
I nodded, a little too quickly. "Yeah. I appreciate that."
She gave a little shrug like it wasn't a big deal, but it was. I knew it was.
"I'll be good," she added, tapping her keyboard again. "Friendly. If you can handle that."
"Reckon I can," I said, but my voice was rough. I sat down at my desk, finally ready to start the day.
I sat down and leaned back in my chair. The awkwardness had lifted, even if just slightly. Felt like I could breathe again.
She was still typing, a rhythm I'd come to recognize over the past couple weeks. The silence between us wasn't uncomfortable anymore, and I was just starting to get into the mindset to work when I saw her stand up.
I glanced up, confused. "You heading out?"
She hovered for a second, arms crossed over her chest like she was bracing for something. "No. Just..." Her lips pressed together. She looked anywhere but at me. "Can I... can I have a hug?"
That pulled me back. "A hug?"
Her shoulders dropped. "Yeah. I've had a rough couple of days, and I think you owe me one."
I blinked, caught between being thrown off and feeling something in my chest crack a little. "Thought I was just your boss."
She gave me a look, unimpressed. "Shut up."
I stood slowly, meeting her in the space between our desks. There was hesitation in her eyes, the kind that made my hands feel like they didn't belong anywhere until she stepped closer. She didn't say anything else, just slipped her arms around my waist, face pressing lightly into my chest.
I froze for half a second then let my arms fold around her. Careful.
She felt warm and familiar. My throat tightened.
Her fingers curled lightly into the back of my shirt. "This doesn't mean anything," she mumbled, voice low against me. "Didn't say it did."
Fuck, it did.
I felt her take a breath, slow and shaky, and suddenly I wasn't thinking about work, or Sarah, or the million reasons I should've stepped away from this.
She didn't step away but instead she looked up at me. We looked at each other for a second and we both started moving in. Letting everything we just said go to shit. I was just thinking about her and I wasn't sure who would be the first to move.
The door opened.
Olivia stepped back so fast it felt like she vanished. I turned, pulse already hammering in my ears and there she was.
Sarah.
Holding her keys, dressed casual, a little confused, blinking between the two of us like her brain was still catching up.
"Hey," she said slowly. "Am I... interrupting something?"
Olivia straightened, gave this awkward, too-sweet smile. "Hi. Wow. Sarah, it's nice to see you again."
Sarah's brows shot up. "Wait. Olivia?"
Olivia nodded, her voice a little more careful now. "Yeah. I didn't know you'd be here."
Sarah turned to me next, eyes narrowing. Not angry, just surprised, like she was trying to fit pieces together that didn't make sense. "You said you didn't know her."
Shit.
I rubbed a hand across my jaw, avoiding both their eyes. "Didn't realize who she was. Not at first."
Olivia looked at me, a crease forming in her brow, but she didn't say anything.
Sarah gave a dry laugh, shaking her head. "You saw her Instagram. You said you didn't recognize her, and now she's in your office?"
"I wasn't lying," I said, too firm. "She started interning here for school."
"Right." She knew I was lying.
Olivia cleared her throat, stepping in, voice soft. "I should've said something. It's just been a long time, and I didn't want to make it weird."
Sarah let out a breath. "This is... a little weird."
"Yeah," Olivia said, nodding. "It is."
Sarah's gaze slid between us again, still reading the room, slower this time. "I just came by to grab my shoes out of your truck, left them there on Saturday "
"They're in the back," I said, already moving. "I'll go with you."
"No, it's fine. I can—"
"I said I'll go with you."
She paused, watching me for a second. "Okay. Um, nice to see you Olivia."
We walked out in silence.
The heat hit me the second we stepped outside, but it didn't do a damn thing to break the chill creeping up the back of my neck. Sarah kept pace beside me, quiet, but I could feel the weight of her stare like she was digging through every second she'd just witnessed.
My keys jingled too loud in my hand as I unlocked the truck and popped the back open. Her shoes were right there, shoved into the corner of the seat. I leaned in to grab them, kept my back to her longer than I needed to.
"You're gonna tell me what's going on?" she asked, voice calm. Too calm.
I handed her the shoes. "Ain't nothin' goin' on."
She blinked, gave me a flat look. "Right. So you're just hugging a girl you 'don't know,' who happens to be my childhood friend, who also happens to be working with you." I scoffed, and started to shut the door.
"I'm not stupid, Dad."
That stopped me.
She didn't say it cruel. Just honest. The way she always did when she knew she was right.
"It was already... complicated." I said, jaw tight.
Her eyes narrowed. "Complicated how?"
I looked away. "She's workin' with me. I'm supposed to be her mentor. Her dad trusted me with that. It ain't supposed to be anything else."
"But it is."
I didn't answer. I didn't have to.
She shook her head, one arm crossed over her stomach, clutching her shoes like she wasn't sure what to do with them. "Jesus, Dad."
"I didn't plan it, alright? It just happened."
"That doesn't make it better."
I exhaled through my nose. "I know."
There was silence for a few seconds, the kind that scraped at the inside of my skull. Then she said, more quietly, "Are you like dating her?"
"I stared down at the gravel. "Yea, well...not anymore."
Sarah didn't say anything for a long moment. Then finally "She's, like, twenty."
"Twenty-two."
She blinked. "Oh. Well, that makes it so much better."
I let out a bitter laugh. "I know how it looks."
"Do you?" she snapped, and for a second her voice cracked. "Because I really don't think you do. You lied to me. I showed you her picture and you looked me in the eye and said you didn't know her. But you did. And now she's working here, and you're hugging her in your office like—"
"I didn't mean for you to find out like this."
"No?" she said. "Then how were you gonna tell me? Or were you just hoping I'd never figure it out?"
"You know, I don't care if you're seeing someone," she said after a moment. Her voice wasn't angry.
I looked at her. That stopped me more than if she'd yelled.
"I mean it," she said. "It's not about her. It's just the way you lied. That's what feels weird. You could've told me. You didn't have to make it a secret. That makes it look worse than it probably is."
I leaned back against the truck, arms crossed, eyes on the ground. "I didn't know what the hell I was doin'. Still don't, if I'm honest."
She gave a small laugh. "Well... she's cute and smart. So I get it."
I glanced at her, brow raised. "Don't say that."
"What? She is. I remember even in high school all the guys were obsessed with her." She grinned a little. "You've got taste."
I shook my head. "Jesus."
"But seriously," she said, voice softening again. "You don't have to keep things from me. I'm not a kid. And if she makes you happy, even if it's weird and complicated, just be honest about it."
I looked at her, chest tight. "You're not mad?"
"No," she said. "I'm just surprised. And maybe a little weirded out."
"That makes two of us."
She gave me a little smile. "So. Are you gonna tell her you obviously still want her or just keep awkwardly hugging her in your office when you think no one's watching?"
I groaned. "Alright. Enough."
She laughed to herself and patted me on the shoulder walking to the car. "I'll see you at home."
I stood there a while after she left.
Just me, the heat, and the sound of the wind rattling through the parking lot.
Sarah wasn't mad. That should've been a relief. Hell, it was a relief. But it didn't make this any easier.
But maybe hiding it wasn't working anymore.
Maybe it was time to stop pretending this was just a job. That I could keep her close and hold everything else at arm's length.
I looked back toward the building, jaw tight.
She was in there and if I walked back in and pretended like that conversation hadn't happened, like Sarah hadn't seen what she saw, like Olivia and I were still playing it safe.
I'd lose her for good.
I knew that now.
So I took a breath, squared my shoulders, and headed back inside.








