The Nature of Dickinson, #1
September 24, 2013
Recently I have been posting my “Top Ten References to Nature by Emily Dickinson.” So far I have posted entries 10 through 2, so below is numero uno. However, before any drum roll and the unveiling of my top-rated reference, let me say a few words about two poems by E. E. Cummings.
In the past, when I introduced poetry units to students, I would always start by using two works by E. E. Cummings, “l(a” (see my blog post HERE) and “old age sticks” (see my post HERE). Students always love the innovative approach Cummings used with the structure and placement of words and letters to create effect and understanding beyond the surface meaning. Students are always excited by his inventive use of language, and they are inspired by their own varied interpretations. To maintain their enthusiasm and interest, I often follow the lessons on Cummings with an exercise centered around a poem by Emily Dickinson, the top-rated poem on my “Top Ten References to Nature by Emily Dickinson.” Before I actually share the poem with them – or even the first line – here’s what I do: I project a picture of a crescent moon, and I challenge the class to see if they can figure out the exact image that Dickinson used to describe it. The students are intrigued and begin to offer ideas which could suggest a crescent moon: a canoe; a banana; a hammock; the letter “C”; an apostrophe or comma; and so on.
What does a crescent moon look like to you?
In my experience, the list of ideas can grow quite extensively, but students never guess that Dickinson’s crescent moon is a chin — an image that works beautifully as her metaphor progresses: The Moon was but a Chin of Gold A Night or two ago— And now she turns Her perfect Face Upon the World below— That image – the face of the moon turning full-on toward the Earth – tops my “Top Ten” list.
I will admit, though, that when presenting this poem in its entirety there can be issues with vocabulary and comprehension. However, that’s where the shared experience of reviewing Cummings’ “l(a” comes in handy because the students will easily recall the lesson learned about taking time to appreciate and consider concepts that are not entirely obvious from the start.
Here’s the entire poem:
The Moon was but a Chin of Gold A Night or two ago — And now she turns Her perfect Face Upon the World below — Her Forehead is of Amplest Blonde — Her Cheek — a Beryl hewn — Her Eye unto the Summer Dew The likest I have known — Her Lips of Amber never part — But what must be the smile Upon Her Friend she could confer Were such Her Silver Will — And what a privilege to be But the remotest Star — For Certainty She take Her Way Beside Your Palace Door — Her Bonnet is the Firmament — The Universe — Her Shoe — The Stars — the Trinkets at Her Belt — Her Dimities — of Blue —









