#non!con

Though the comments only stay up for a few moments before they’re scrubbed clean, with the posters receiving warnings from the faculty about spreading harmful rumors, they still send you spiraling. Not just for Caleb who still doesn’t seem to understand the gravity of the situation despite this shitstorm, but for yourself too. People are asking questions about you, their curiosity to know more about this older sister that has fractured the image of the DAA golden boy is dangerous. If any of this leaks beyond the academy and reaches your coworkers at the Hunter’s Association, your job could be in jeopardy. The thought alone makes your blood run cold.

Caleb tries to tell you that none of it means anything and that it will all blow over soon. It fucking drives you up the wall. How can he still downplay the severity of the situation? People know now! Your lives could be ruined forever! What will it take for him to finally get it?

But to your shock and utter disbelief, he’s mostly right.

After the initial flood, the comments taper off. The deletions and warnings do their job. What remains are only occasional stray remarks here and there, quickly dealt with. Caleb has no shortage of admirers, and they quickly take over the narrative, painting him as the victim of haters who can’t compete with him, can’t have him, or are simply jealous of him.

Soon, the tide shifts back in his favor and his fans fawn over him even more for oh-so-bravely weathering this hate campaign. 

Caleb relays all of it to you in the hopes of convincing you that it’s all over now, but you know better. You know these things never truly die. You know people are still talking about you, just amongst themselves and behind his back.  But he doesn’t care. If anything it’s as if the idea of it spurs him on. He doesn’t shy away from mentioning you. He talks about you even more openly now, daring anyone to question him. Nobody does. And his college life carries on as usual. 

But you can’t do the same. 

Those comments were only a taste of what your life could become if your secret is found out. You would spend the rest of your days plagued by judgment and suspicion, even if no one ever learns the full truth—that seed of doubt is like a weed, once its roots have dug in, it’s impossible to get rid of.

If this ever breaches the confines of campus gossip and gets into the real world, would you be able to hold on to the few friends you've managed to make for the first time in your life? If Tara or Simone hear about this, what will they think of you? Will they understand why you’ve had to do it or will they absolve themselves of you? Will you be able to find a partner? How would anyone tolerate such rumors about their lover? Especially when all they need is to take one look at how Caleb behaves around you for all their suspicions to be confirmed? 

Yet despite it all, you know you can’t solely blame Caleb for this. You know this mess is as much your fault as it is his. You should have told him no that night. You should have ended the call as soon as you realized where he was and what he was doing. But you were hurt, your pride was wounded, and some ugly, starved part of you had wanted to be wanted so badly, you were blinded by it.

But it’s not just that. You shouldn’t have started any of this in the first place. The problem is, you can’t even pinpoint when it truly began. Agreeing to jerk him off that first time had pushed the floodgates wide open, but the water had been rising long before then. He had told you as much. Had it started in your teenage years? In childhood? Had the current always been there inside him, waiting to sweep you under? Or had you been the one slowly feeding it, drop by drop, until it could no longer be contained?

Your thoughts rise and churn, turning more tumultuous by the day, and yet Caleb isn’t the slightest bit phased. Once the worst of the storm had passed and he was still standing tall, he stopped trying to calm you. His tone shifted from flippant reassurance to reckless excitement, maybe even triumph.

“See, jie?” He says happily, pulling you into his arms with a bright smile. “Even if they know about us, nothing bad will happen. We can be together. No one will stop us. I’ll make sure of it.”

Your stomach drops. Nothing bad will happen? Is being ostracised as incesteous freaks nothing bad? Is the chance of losing any existing or potential meaningful relationship outside of each other nothing bad? Is spending the rest of your life whispered about, judged, and isolated nothing bad?

“I don’t want that, Caleb.” You answer in frustration. This is not what he’s supposed to learn from this. He’s meant to realise how wrong this is and snap out of it, not grow bolder in his delusions. “I don’t want to live a taboo life. I don’t want people smiling to my face and cursing me behind my back.”

“So this is what it’s really about, huh?” His tone turns accusatory. “It’s not about me or what’s best for me. You’re just ashamed of what being with me will bring.”

And so what? Are you not allowed to not want to be a pariah? Is that such a terrible thing to him? Must you throw everyone and everything else away to make him happy? You would lay your life down for him in heartbeat, but to be forced to live in ridicule and isolation… that may be too much for you to bear, even for your precious didi. 

“It’s about both of us.” You snap back defensively, “You’re fine with this now, smug even, but how long are you going to tolerate being ridiculed? Being abhorred? Having everyone look at you like you’re some disgusting freak?”

“Forever.” He says without hesitation, his gaze burning into yours. “As long as I get to have you.”

Guilt wells up in you at his simple answer. You hate yourself once for making your little brother this way, and twice for then not being strong enough, or selfless enough, to sacrifice everything for him the way he wishes you would. 

But this is for him. He may think he wants this now, but years down the line he will come to resent you. He will see everything he’s lost—all the love, relationships, and community he could have had, and he will hate you for it. And then neither of you will have anyone else to turn to. Your anger and bitterness will build and build until you—

You rub your forehead, a pounding headache throbbing behind your eyes. “I don’t have time for this. I need to get ready for my work social.”

“Then let me come with you.” He springs up quickly. 

“No.” You hiss at him with all the ferocity of a cornered kitten. “This is my work, Caleb. I can’t let you fuck it up.”

He regards you with offense, his jaw tightening. “You think I did it on purpose? I wouldn’t have even been there if you hadn’t forced me to do it under the threat of leaving me!”

“Oh, cry me a river, Caleb.” You retort, your frustration and guilt making you more unkind than you’d ever wish to be to your baby brother. “You could have controlled yourself until the next day. But that’s impossible for you, isn’t it? Golden boy Caleb can’t go a single day without getting off to his big sister.”

He barks out a bitter laugh. “I controlled myself my entire life living around you while you were flaunting your tits and ass in my face.”

You flush hot, the emotions burning through you so fierce they all meld together, kicking your instincts into overdrive. Here he goes giving voice to your worst fears again—It's all your fault. You did this. You've broken him and now you can't fix him. Dammit, why won't he let you fix him?

“Well, if you were fucking normal, you wouldn’t have been looking!” You lash out at him in your frenzy. 

“Normal?” He breathes out with a strained smile. “What am I then, jiejie? A freak? A disgusting pervert? Is that how you see me?”

The fire in you wanes and almost gutters out. “No, baby, you know that’s not what I meant—”

“But the apple doesn’t fall far from the tree, jie.”

You flinch back. “What is that supposed to mean?”

“If I’m a freak, what does that make you, jiejie?” His smile turns cruel. 

“Don't.” You warn shakily. You can't handle this right now, but Caleb doesn’t stop pushing. 

“You’re the one who raised me.” He says it like he’s delivering your sentence. 

“Stop it, Caleb.” You bite out, voice rising with panic.

“What kind of sister lets her brother sneak into her bed at night?” 

“You were having nightmares.” You justify yourself. What’s wrong with providing your baby brother comfort? Maybe it was more intimate than what most other siblings would have done but how could you have been expected to turn away his scared little face? 

“What kind of sister helps her brother shower into his teens?” He counters, and your breath hitches. Your defense sounds more tenuous this time. “You refused to clean up after basketball unless I helped you!”

He cocks his head to the side, and his teeth glint like fangs within his gleeful smile. “What kind of sister lets her baby brother suck on her tits?”

You feel yourself choke. The memories come flooding back unbidden. You had almost forgotten all about that, blocked those memories out of your psyche for the sake of your sanity, and hoped the years had stolen his away too. But the world isn't so kind, and neither is Caleb. 

You… you had both been so young. You weren’t sure what you were doing. You didn’t know the first thing about caring for yourself, let alone a baby brother. All you knew was that Caleb was prone to anxious fits. He would cry and cry sometimes over the littlest things. You knew from a young age that the only way to shut him up was to give him something to occupy his mouth. You’d witnessed it in the way he would suck at his own thumb, soothing himself despite your grandma's discouragement. He had been much too old for that even back then, but he never outgrew it, perhaps because as a baby he never got to experience the comforts that only a mother can provide, and he had to make do with what he's got—Josephine who was too old to give him what he needs and you who were too young to know what that was. 

For a long while he had contended himself with his self-soothing, but as he grew older and his world filled up with more than just you and your grandma, there were more things to stress him out—fear of failing a class, or losing a game, or someone else stealing your attention from him… 

And suddenly he didn’t know what to do with himself anymore. His thumb was a poor substitute for the nurture he needed. In his frustration, he started biting down on the digit, and pulling at his nail, trying in vain to calm himself down. When you had seen that first drop of blood, you’d panicked, replacing his finger with yours, and braced for the pain. But it never came. He didn’t bite you. Instead he sucked on your finger gently, and slowly settled down. 

You should have stopped there but the way he had looked at you then, like you were the solace he had been seeking, had you doing it again and again. For a long time, it worked like a charm, though you had to do it behind your grandma’s back after she scolded you harshly the first and only time she caught you doing it.

Until you started middle school and had to leave him behind to go to a different school. He fell into one of his fits again, worse than any you’d ever seen, and neither your fingers, nor endless promises of walking him to school, picking him up, and spending every after-school hour and weekend with him could calm him down.

Caleb had cried so hard, his face had turned red and his tears had gone dry, yet he still wouldn’t stop. You held him in your arms and rocked him for what felt like hours with no relief. His tears and saliva had soaked completely through your shirt when his listless mouth found one of your nipples through the fabric and latched on. Suddenly, he had quieted down, distracted with his desperate, hungry suckling as if he’d be able to pull something out of you if he tried hard enough. You would have said something—you should have said something—but he had cried so much, he had worn both of you out and you were just happy that you’ve finally managed to make it better. So you just held him close, stroking his hair and whispering that everything would be okay until he finally went to sleep.

For some time after that, it became your well-kept secret, your last ditch solution to calm him down, the only thing that could soothe his anxious fits when all else failed—though he had tried many times to get under your shirt at the smallest inconvenience or upset. 

Deep down, you always knew it was wrong. That's why you made sure your grandma never found out about it. The shame had burned hot in your chest even then. But it worked so well! He always became so calm, sweet, and obedient in your arms whenever you allowed it to him. He listened to you. He went to school. He did his homework. He attended his practice. It was like your secret weapon, and you used it more often than you’d like to admit. 

You only stopped when one day he had sighed into your chest and said something unthinkable. 

“You knew what you were doing.” Caleb scoffs, “You made me this way… mommy.”

Your hand flies up before your mind can catch up. Your palm meets his cheek with a loud smack, his head snapping to the side from the force. For half a second, he stands there frozen, head tilted to the side, a red mark blooming on his cheek. Then his head whips back around and he surges forward, kissing you hungrily, almost violently, as if he’s avenging himself. 

You push at his chest, trying to shove him away, but he’s stronger than you and it takes everything in you to get him off. His knees hit the bed as you push him back, and he topples onto it. You try to step back, but before you can escape, his arms fly out and grab onto you, pulling you on top of him on the bed.

“I am exactly how you raised me, jiejie.” He tells you miserably, “Why are you running away from me?”

You slap a hand over his mouth to silence him, but he opens his mouth and kisses your palm filthily. “Stop it.” You demand, almost pleadingly, but he ignores you, grabbing your hips and pushing you down against his hard cock. 

“This is what you’ve always done, Caleb.” You hiss down at him bitterly, “You never let me say no. You keep pushing and pushing until I give you what you want.”

He moans against your palm, as if proud of his doing, and his hips roll up again, rubbing his hard cock against you shamelessly.

“Are you listening to me?” You ask desperately, begging to be heard, but he just stares up at you with heavy, needy eyes—wanting, wanting so much from you, always wanting. 

“Fucking listen to me!” You snap, anger and despair taking hold of you, awakening your darkest thoughts and giving them grotesque shape. They puppeteer your body, making you surge forward and wrap your hands around his throat. 

For one terrible second you feel relief as he finally stops, his eyes flying wide open in shock. You’ve done it. He’s finally looking at you. He’s finally listening to you. 

“Jiejie?” He chokes out, and the vibrations of his voice, of the air struggling to pass through his windpipe, shock some sense into you. You blink and the haze of fury melts away to reveal your baby brother’s face, and what you see there—shock, worry, confusion, fear—smothers every tendril of rage licking up your body, freeing you from its murderous blaze.

You fling yourself away from him and stumble to your feet with a horrified gasp, your hand burning where it had just gripped his neck.

“I need to go.” You wheeze, your entire body shaking. But Caleb stops you, his fingers locking around your wrist as he too rises, chasing after you like a moth to flame. “Take me with you.”

“I already told you no.” You tell him raggedly. Please, please, get away from me. Just this once. 

“I won’t make a scene, I promise.” He begs pitifully, still seeking comfort in you despite the unforgivable pain you've inflicted. “Please… I can’t be alone right now. Not after this…” His hand drifts up to touch the sides of his neck where your fingers had been moments ago. “I’m scared, jie.”

You heave in a choked cry and reach out to cradle his face in your hands, your knees buckling when he flinches ever so slightly. 

“I would never hurt you.” You vow, guilt strangling you the same way you'd strangled your baby brother. “You know that. You just… frustrate me so much.”

He shakes his head. “You want to kill me.” 

“No!” The word bursts out of you in scream as if it could banish the troubling thoughts away. “No, never!”

“You keep pushing me away.” He insists, tears gathering in his eyes like storm clouds breaking the skyline. “That’s killing me.”

“Baby, stop it…” You plead, drowning under his tears. 

“If you leave me, I’ll die.” He tells you, his voice surprisingly steady in its condemnation. “You know that, jie. You know I can’t live without you.”

“You’re being so unfair.” You lament. All you want is a good, well-adjusted, happy life for him—a normal life where he has a lover and a sister that aren't the same damned woman.

“I don’t care about fair. I only care about you.” He says as if you ever needed to hear that. You knew it all too well, that Caleb will continue to fight that perfect future you dream for him every step of the way. 

_______________________

To your surprise, Caleb is on his best behaviour at the gathering. His tears have dried, leaving his pretty eyes shiny and full of stars, and his broken voice has taken on that boyish, inviting lilt that disarms everyone who meets him. 

He’s dressed up in one of his nicer shirts and a pair of tailored dress pants. They’re nothing fancy but you’re not used to seeing him in something other than his sweats and tanks or cargo pants with a million pockets and three jackets on, and you don’t like the way this unfamiliar outfit shows off his physique. The shirt emphasizes his broad shoulders and muscled arms and the fitted pants draw attention to his thick thighs and round bottom. Even his hair is slicked back neatly, revealing his forehead and thick eyebrows, and you wonder what the purpose of the new look is. 

To you, he still looks like your baby brother putting on a grownup’s skin, but to others he must look like an alluring young man they could sink their teeth into, because they gravitate towards him like flies. Most of them content themselves with stealing glances they think go unnoticed, however some braver ones—or perhaps more idiotic—gawk openly, while a brazen few come up to speak to him directly. 

Your coworkers take to him faster than they ever did to you, and you swallow back the complicated emotions that bubble in you in response, and that you refuse to name.

For most of the night, he stays close by your side, chatting up your coworkers who come up under the pretense of wanting to talk to you, only to end up directing most of their attention toward him. And when they learn he’s your brother, they coo and fawn, praising you for raising such a charming, well-mannered young man. 

Caleb keeps one arm wrapped securely around you the whole time, his smile growing wider with each compliment, and his chest puffed out as if he’d achieved some secret goal he’d set out to prove. 

“I like playing brother and sister more than boyfriend and girlfriend. But I think I’d like it more if I could kiss you right now.” He whispers in your ear the moment the two of you are left alone. “They wouldn’t mind right? Your friends all love me.”

“That’s not funny, you little shit. You promised you’d behave.” You scowl at him. So that’s why he’s dressed like this and acting this way. He thinks your friends liking him as your brother will make them accept him any more as your lover. It’s almost endearing how delusional he can be sometimes, his way of thinking so child-like it makes you wish you could protect him from his own misguided beliefs. 

“Besides,” You say with a sickening sense of deja-vu. ”They’re not my friends.” 

“Really, what about Tara? I thought she was your best friend.” He pushes back, recalling all the times you’d told him about her. “She loves me too. You saw how she invited me to come along on the camping trip next month.” 

“I’m going to text her tomorrow and tell her you can’t make it after all.” You glare at him.  Really, what was he thinking accepting her invitation? That he’ll impress them all so much, they’d overlook the fact that he’s your brother? That he’d be so amazing, they’d congratulate you for being with him? 

“But I want to come.” He whines. 

“And I said no.” 

“But jiejie—”

“I’m going to get a drink.” You snap at him, already turning away. He immediately starts to follow, but you put a hand out to stop him, pointing to the floor where he is standing. “Stay here.” 

“Jie—” He pouts but you don’t wait to listen to his whining. 

It’s probably not the smartest idea to leave him unsupervised and surrounded by a bunch of your coworkers, but you desperately need that drink if you’re going to survive the rest of the night and the whirlwind of emotions that bringing him into the your workplace have conjured up… and it’s not just because you’re afraid of what he might do and how he could cost you everything if he so wishes, but also because he’s once again invaded the one place that belonged only to you. 

Your little brother has never really been good at letting you have anything that didn’t also involve him. 

“So that’s your little brother, huh?” Simone’s voice makes you jump out of your skin as you’re pouring yourself a drink, and you almost drop the cup to the ground.

“Yeah.” You mutter, a little unfriendly, not really in the mood to discuss him when you’ve finally managed to get a couple of minutes away from him.

As if she can hear your thoughts, she laughs. “He’s… clingy, isn’t he?” 

You snort in response. “What gave it away?”

“Well, for one, he’s currently staring at you like a dog waiting for its owner outside of a shop.” 

You throw a glance back towards him, and his sad face perks up for a second as your eyes meet before you force yourself to look away. 

“He seems like a good kid.” She continues, and you feel a pang of guilt in your chest as you almost contradict her. Instead, you force out a small smile. “Yeah… he is.”

“Is everything okay?” She frowns, finally noticing your gloomy mood, and you kick yourself internally for failing to control your emotions.

“Yeah. He’s just a bit of a handful.” You wave her concern away. What can you even tell her? That he was a good kid up until he started demanding you give your body to him? That you don’t know how to control him anymore? That… your own little brother scares you a little bit?  

Instead, you plaster on a bright, fake smile. “But you’re not wrong. He’s like an overexcited puppy—very needy and high maintenance. He wouldn’t even let me come today if he didn’t tag along.” You spin it in a humorous way and she laughs again. “If he’s that needy, why don’t you get him a girlfriend so he’ll bother her instead?”

“Believe me, I’ve been trying.” You mutter, and pretend it’s the drink you’re sipping on that is the cause of your sour expression. 

“Is he into jiejies?” Her question catches you off-guard, and you choke on your drink, the alcohol burning your nose as you cough. “What?”

“Does he like older women?” She repeats with a knowing smile that almost brings you to your knees. But then she continues, “Because if so, I think Christine is trying to gobble him up.”

You snap your head to where she is looking to see your brother cornered by Christine, one of the Captains at the association, her hand gripping his bicep and her tits practically shoved against his chest. 

“Better go save him before the poor boy has a heart attack.” 

You barely hear Simone’s amused voice over the ringing in your ear. You discard your glass, uncaring that it topples over and ruins the tablecloth, and march quickly towards them. 

“Didi, there you are!” You exclaim, tiptoeing up on your already high-heeled feet to wrap an arm around his shoulders, pulling him down in an exaggerated sisterly manner. “What are you up to, you little rascal?” 

“Jie…” He whines as you mess up his hair. “Stop.”

But he’s smiling down at you, happy to have your attention again. You stare up into his bright eyes, his height still taller than you even with the uncomfortable hunch you’ve forced him into, and suddenly you’re pushing his hair down, fixing it back into the boyish banged look he has always sported, your anxiety only settling when he’s all patched up and back to being your baby brother. 

The sound of someone clearing their throat makes you jump, but Caleb’s own hands around your waist stop you from pulling away from him completely. That’s fine. You’ll let him have this for now. You have more important things to focus on, like pinning the older woman down with a fake smile.  

“Oh, hey Christine. I see you’ve met my baby brother.” You tell her pointedly, hoping she'd get the hint to back off.

"Oh, he’s your brother? I didn’t know.” She lies horribly, and you fight to keep the ugly scowl off your face. Bullshit. Caleb has been proudly proclaiming to anyone and everyone who will hear him that he’s your little brother. No way she didn’t know. 

“Gosh, you’re a pair of good looking siblings, aren’t you?" She chirps, and you don’t miss the annoyance in her eyes at you interrupting them, before her gaze flits back towards Caleb, sliding up and down your brother’s figure brazenly. And god how you wish you could throw your body over him to hide him away from her lecherous eyes. "Bet you're as popular with the ladies as she is with the guys."

You feel Caleb tense against you. 

"Is that so?" He turns towards you, still smiling but you can see the start of a fire in his eyes. "Are men bothering you, jiejie?" 

And suddenly you feel like you’re the one being warned.

"She's just flattering me." You wave your hand in the air, trying to dispel the tension you feel building up. But Caleb isn't satisfied with that answer, and Christine keeps running her mouth, "Nonsense. She's such a heartbreaker, your big sister. She’s got so many admirers but they’re all too scared to approach her because they know she’d coldly brush them off.”

What the hell is she talking about? Men don't approach you because you're not the type of girl they like. You’re not fun and bubbly like Tara, and you’re not cool and charismatic like Simone. You're not sweet or nurturing either—it’s hard to be when all your supply of those goes towards caring for your full grown brother. You just go to work and focus on your job and get on with your day. The only men who ever talk to you are Xavier and Nero, and that’s probably because they have to.

“Now I know why. She is just too busy spoiling her little brother.” The woman laughs obnoxiously, and you feel queasy by how close her little joke is to the truth. “Maybe I can keep her brother busy so she can finally have time to date."

"She's not interested." Caleb says curtly, no longer smiling. "She needs to focus on her work. And I also need to focus on my studies. I'm still in college, you know."

Despite her cluelessness, whether real or feigned, Christine gets a little thrown off by the sudden change in Caleb’s demeanor—sudden for her anyway. But it seems she doesn’t know when to quit. 

"But you're an adult, right?" She asks shamelessly, "Besides, she already seems to have her eyes on someone."

"Who?" Caleb barks, all pretense gone now, and you feel a dragging sensation in the pit of your stomach that you know isn’t just your nerves. 

Christine’s smile turns anxious, and you know she must feel it too. But she has no fucking survical instincts because she keeps going. "Xavier, her mission partner. They're always together, talking secretly about god knows what. The sparks are definitely flying."

"We're just discussing mission details. It’s classified intel." You interject, but the stupid woman rolls her eyes and winks at you. "Suuuure. Missions. Is that why you were grinding against him at the club the other day? Did his—ah!”

Her eyes widen as you feel the force of Caleb’s Evol crushing down on all of you. 

“We have to go!” You squeak, grabbing his arm and frantically attempting to pull him away, every step heavy as if you’re wearing boots of lead. “Caleb, stop it!” 

But he’s not looking at you. Instead, his eyes are darting all around, searching the crowd for a face he doesn’t know. “Which one is he?” 

“Don’t.” You plead with him, gripping his arm tightly. “Caleb, this is my workplace. You’re making a scene.”

"Oh, I haven’t even started yet, jiejie." He spits out and finally looks at you, his gaze dark and spiteful. "You wanted me to date so you can be free to fuck him, huh?"

You gasp, panic flooding your veins as a few curious heads turn in your direction. You quickly press your palm to his chest, catching him off guard and forcing him to resonate with you, allowing you to finally move him. You yank him toward the nearest exit, muttering hasty excuses to your concerned friends about your brother not feeling well and you needing to take him home right away.

The second you’re out of the main hall and away from prying eyes, Caleb pushes you against the wall, his breathing comes out fast and heavy as his large frame cages you, like a rabid animal waiting to pounce. 

“Did you fuck him?” He demands, the rage in his voice making you tremble, and you shake your head vehemently. “No.”

But your denial doesn’t calm him down. 

“Let him eat your pussy?” He asks and you flush. “No!”

“Sucked his dick?”

“Caleb, no!” You whisper furiously, mortified at his wild imagination that is getting him all worked up. “I did none of that!”

“Just grinded against him in front of all your coworkers?” He spits out and you cower, suddenly not feeling so righteous anymore. 

“We were just dancing.” You insist weakly, the fear of being caught by one of your coworkers with your little brother in this compromising position, and the mortification at having been caught by Caleb for your drunken fuckup twisting together so tightly around your throat until it’s hard to breathe. “She‘s exaggerating.”

“So you were dancing with him.” He latches onto the wrong part, his eyes narrowing down at you. “Why?”

“It was a work outing, just like this one. Everyone was dancing.” You try to justify yourself but Caleb will not let this grave sin against him slide. “You could have danced with Tara or Simone. Why did it have to be him?”

“I don’t know!” You lie, all the humiliation from that night flooding back in. “I was drunk, okay?”

“You were drunk?!” Caleb barks, incredulous. “You know how useless you get when you drink. Why the hell would you do that around strange men? What if you were so out of it, you didn’t even know what he was doing to you? What if he took you home and fucked you while you were passed out?”

“Is that why you used to try so hard to get me drunk?” You bristle, refusing to let Caleb chastise you. He has done so much worse than drink and rub against a coworker. He has forced you to defile him again and again, and now he’s mad at you for the one thing you shouldn’t feel guilty for. 

“And what if I did?” He sneers, not even denying it. 

You falter, shocked at how brazen he’s being. ​​”That’s disgusting, Caleb.” 

“That’s what I am, isn’t it. Disgusting.” His lips curl around the words bitterly, “But this isn’t about me. This is about you getting wasted and rubbing your ass against some other man in front of everyone.”

“I told you I didn’t do that!” You lie through your teeth. This is about him. Everything in your life has always been about him, even your stupid decision to dance with Xavier. 

A strange expression suddenly takes over your brother’s usually sunny face, and you have nowhere to run as he leans down, trapped as you are between him and the wall, unable to escape from the darkness in his eyes and the unsettling smile on his lips. “You think he’ll still want you if he finds out what you’ve been doing to me?”

You gape at him. What is he saying? Doing to him? Everything that has happened between you was to try to contain his desires. You didn’t want any of this. He made you. But who would people believe? The precious, little brother who loves and trusts his jiejie so much or the reclusive, unfriendly older sister who never had a man in her life and barely has any friends? You had to have been the one to latch onto him, to blind him so he can only see you, to sink your claws into his heart so it bleeds for you, to break his bones so he could only crawl into your arms. 

“Are you threatening me, Caleb?” Your ask, your voice wavering. “How could you?” 

“You’ve left me no other choice.” He says it like it hurts him more than it hurts you. 

“You’re unbelievable.” You hiss at him, feeling your heart stutter at his betrayal, and you know it would rather stop all together than believe he’d ever do such a thing to you. “After everything I did for you. I let this go on for so long because I didn’t want to hurt you, and now you’re threatening me?”

“Liar.” He snarls, “You’re hurting me! You don’t give a shit about me!”

“What are you talking about? I do!” You whisper harshly, “I care about you so fucking much!”

“You left me!” He cries, “You abandoned me again and again, and every single time I was the one who had to run after you. I was the one who followed you to your college apartment, and I was the one who followed you here, even though it takes me hours to get to you and back, yet I still do it every single week just so I can see you!”

“I didn’t ask you to!” 

“I know! Because you don’t care about me!” He says, eyes wild now as if he actually believes his own words. And you don’t know if you should be hurt for him because you’ve somehow made him doubt your love towards him or hurt for yourself because he refuses to see all the things you’ve done for him. “You never even tried to contact me after our fight. Would you have never talked to me again if I didn’t reach out first or if I refused to get into the DAA?”

“Don’t be ridiculous.” You scoff, “You’re my brother.” 

“And you sent me away!”

“So you could pursue your dream!” 

“My dream means nothing without you.”

“Don’t say that.” You protest. It can’t all hinge on you and this forbidden love. There has to be hope still. You need to believe it, otherwise you don't know what you'd do with yourself… or him. 

“Do you love me?” He asks and your reply is instantaneous. “Of course, I do.”

“Then how could you bear to force me to be with someone else?” 

“Because ours is a different kind of love.”

“Then I don't want any other.” He says with conviction, “You can be everything for me. You are everything for me.”

You shake your head. “Caleb, please. I am your sister. I can only ever be your sister. You need to get that through your head.” 

He scoffs and looks away for a moment, the pain clear on his face even with his head turned away.

“Baby—”

His eyes snap back to yours, and you take in a shuddering breath at the vulnerability you suddenly see in them. “Do you find him attractive?”

You hesitate for half a second too long. “I—”

His face twists in anger. “Did you let him touch you?”

“I told you, I didn’t.” You lie again. 

“How can I trust that?”

“Caleb, me and Xavier aren’t even together.” You try to convince him but he snorts derisively. 

“And we’re apparently not together but you’re letting me touch you.” He mocks, and as if to make his point, a hand comes up to palm your breast as he presses his body flush against yours. “If you’re letting your own brother touch you like this, why wouldn’t you let a man you find attractive do it too?”

“That’s low, Caleb.” You growl and try to push him away but he doesn’t budge. He’s using your over-indulgence of him against you, treating you as if you’re just giving it away to anyone, and not like it’s taken everything in you to give him what you thought he needed because you love him that much. 

“Do you love him? Is that it? You found someone better and now you're throwing me away?” He interrogates you, and the fury and pain you see in his eyes almost pull you under. “What do you like about him? Is it the way he looks? The way he treats you? His voice? His profession? I can change. I can be anything you want me to be, jie.”

But you can never not be my brother. 

“I don't love him.” You insist, pained at seeing the way your little brother is so willing to mangle himself in order to try to fit into a mould he thinks you might want. “We barely even talk, Caleb.”

“That’s not what that woman said.” He mutters accusingly and you frown. “It’s what I’m telling you.” 

But like anything you’ve tried to tell him lately, it goes into one ear and out the other. 

“I won’t let you make a fool out of me, jie.” He shakes his head, a mirthless smile twisting his lips. “I only hooked up with that woman because you forced me to. That doesn’t mean I’ll let you fuck around with other men.” He spits out, his gaze hardening. “If I find out you’ve been with him, I’ll—”

You feel it before he even finishes his sentence… the harsh, oppressive weight of his Evol pressing all around you, making your spine creak, your muscle ache, and the air in your lungs feel like water.

“I haven’t! I won't!” You proclaim frantically, not trying to defend your right to a hypothetical date you know would only end in disaster.

“Prove it.”

You look up at him helplessly, and croak out, “How?”

__________________________

“Caleb, please, I promise, nothing happened.” You plead, laid back on your bed with nothing but your underwear on. The same underwear he’s now tugging down your legs. 

“I don't believe you.” He grunts, peeling them off completely. The moment they’re off, you instinctively press your legs together, a rush of embarrassment flooding through you. But Caleb’s hands grip onto your thighs and shove them apart. “Let me see, jie.” 

You bite your lip and look away, squeezing your eyes shut as your heart hammers wildly in your chest. For a long moment, he’s completely silent. All you can hear is his heavy, uneven breathing as he stares down at your exposed pussy. You can feel tears stinging your eyes, moments away from flowing freely, exposing your shame to his greedy eyes as bare as he’s exposed your body. 

He hates it. He doesn't like how you look. He’s disgusted by you. 

But then his voice comes out soft and awed. “You're so pretty, jiejie. Better than I ever imagined.” 

You gasp, daring to sneak a glance at him, fully expecting to see a mischievous smile on his face as he mocks you. But he’s not looking up at you at all. Instead, he’s staring down between your legs like a starving man. 

“Look how wet you are.” He bends down, his warm breath ghosting over your sensitive skin, sending tingles racing up your spine. “Is that because of me? Or him?” 

You bite down on your lip harder, and stay quiet. 

“Tell me, jie. He demands, and you feel his fingers digging into the flesh of your thighs. “Or I’ll be really mad.” 

You shiver, recalling his threat from earlier. Swallowing harshly, you taste your own blood, metallic and nauseating, just the same as your shame. “It's you, didi.” 

A pleased sigh escapes him. “I knew it. I know you want me just as much as I want you.”

You feel yourself drowning in self-loathing as his fingers trace over your slick folds, unable to deny your unforgivable desire when the evidence of it is right at his fingertips that spread you open so he can commit every debauched inch of you to memory. 

“So pretty for me, jie.”

“Just get to it.” You squirm, your cheeks burning with a flush that spreads down your neck and into your chest at how closely he’s staring at this very intimate part of you—a part of you that no one else has seen before, and yet once again you’d given it away to your little brother. 

“So demanding.” He huffs as if you’re the one who wants it. But you don’t dare contradict him. You just lay there quietly and wait to be vindicated so you can finally put this behind you. You’ll never try anything with another man again, not until Caleb has moved on and whatever this is between you is dead and buried six feet under. 

Caleb gathers your slick on his fingers, coating them generously before pushing one inside of you slowly, only managing to get to the first knuckle before it meets a tight resistance that makes him groan low in his throat.

“Fuck, you’re a virgin.” He breathes, and you can hear both the relief and arousal clearly in his voice. 

“There you go. I'm untouched.” You mutter in resignation, feeling so mortified and helpless at having had to prove it in this humiliating way. But it's your fault really. You should have never danced with Xavier. And you should have raised your brother better. 

“You should be touched. You’re perfect. Prettier than any pornstar. I knew you would be.” He sighs dreamily. 

You open your mouth to scold him but you're cut off when he lowers his head between your thighs, his mouth descending on you eagerly, his lips enveloping your slick folds and his tongue dragging along the full length of your pussy. 

You feel more than hear him groan in appreciation, his lips and tongue working to lap up every drop of your arousal as if just that could sustain him for the rest of his life. 

“Caleb!” You squeak, flustered by the sight of your little brother between your legs, kissing your pussy the same way he kisses your lips. 

He looks up at you, not shying away from staring you dead in the eyes as he pulls his face back every so slightly so you can see how his tongue sticks out to flick at your clit, the wet sounds of his saliva and your juices squelching in your ears. 

“Baby, baby, wait—” You plead out, feeling yourself hurling towards a nauseating orgasm. You cannot handle the way he looks up at you, so blissful and hungry like he’s finally where he wants to be, and you fucking hate how sinfully arousing he looks doing it. 

Will any man ever want you as much as he does? Did you do this to him because deep down you knew it would be the only way to get the love and attention you so desperately needed? Is this a trap of your own making?

“Didi, I’m sorry, I’m so sorry!” You cry out as you cum, soaking him in more of your sin. But Caleb is not interested in your pathetic pleas for forgiveness. He feeds on your guilt and arousal like a ravenous beast come to collect your soul. 

And he keeps feasting even as your shameful cries of pleasure turn to sobs of pain. “Please, didi, stop, it hurts.”

It all hurts so much. 

He finally pulls back with a whine, taking his mouth off your pussy so he can climb up to kiss your lips, feeding you your own sin, the taste of it sour and bitter on your tongue but Caleb moans around it as if it’s the sweetest nectar.

“Baby, it hurts.” You repeat, whimpering when you feel his finger continuing to prod at your hymen, pressing against it again and again as if to make sure it’s still there.

“Yeah? It’s because you’re so tight, jie.” He blames you once again. “So tight I don’t know how you’ll fit my cock.” 

You squirm uneasily, trying to get away from his persistent finger. “Stop it, Caleb. I don’t like it when you talk like that.” 

But he’s not listening. He pushes your hips down with his palm, keeping you still. “It’s okay. I’ll make it fit. I was made for you,” 

And then he’s reaching for his pants, fumbling with the zipper in his haste as he stares hungrily at the spot where part of his finger disappears into your heat. 

“Caleb, no!” You cry out in panic and try to snap your legs shut, but his Evol slams down on you, making you yelp in pain as your legs are suddenly forced back open, your thighs spread for his scrutiny and his cock that now rests against your pussy. 

You’ve seen it many times before. It has always been impressive in length and girth, but seeing it resting on your pussy now, the length of it reaching all the way to your belly button makes you break out in a cold sweat. 

“Baby, what are you doing? Please, don’t do this.” You tear up as he rubs his cock along your slick folds, coating himself in your wetness, preparing for something terrible.  

“Caleb, stop it!” You yelp when he presses the large head right at your entrance, your pussy screaming in protest as he tries to force his way inside. 

“Shh, it's okay, jiejie.” He leans forward to kiss away the tears that escape you. “Just the tip, okay? Even your little pussy can take that.”

You shake your head harshly. “Didi, please, don’t do this. This is wrong.” You try to reason with him but your words only bring back that anger that started it all. “What's wrong is you sending me away and pushing me onto other girls so you can whore around with him.” 

“You—” You shout, but your words come out garbled as he shoves himself inside you, forcing your pussy to stretch around the flared head.  

“Stop, stop!” You hit his chest repeatedly as he continues to push, bullying more of himself inside. You feel him reach your hymen and then press further, the pain of it making your head spin. 

You stare up at your little brother, his angry face swimming in your vision, and you wonder if you’ve truly lost him. 

But true to his words, he stops. “F-Fuck, jiiieee. You—ngh—feel so good.” He moans, his head falling down to the crook of your neck as he pauses to catch his breath, his entire body shaking. 

“Why?” You croak out, the fire between your legs nothing compared to the ache in your heart. 

“I can't let anyone else—hah—have you, jiejie.” He pants, covering your neck in wet kisses. 

You shiver, and reach your arms out to wrap around him, seeking solace but knowing you can only hope to find it in the same boy, no… man, who hurt you. Your baby brother who used to cry if he even mistakenly upset you, has somehow turned into a man who takes what he wants regardless of how you feel. And he wants you intimately, profanely. “I told you I didn’t do anything with him. I proved it.”

“You only proved that he hasn’t had you yet.” He grunts, and pulls back to stare at your bodies where you're so precariously connected, his expression turning desperate as his eyes flick back to yours, and you feel queasy seeing the same look your little brother always gives you when he asks for something he knows he shouldn't, but also knows you wouldn’t deny him either. “Fuck, do I have to wait? I don’t want to wait. I want you so bad. What if I wait and you fuck him. I'd go crazy.” 

As if he’s not already there. 

“I won't, Caleb.” You promise with all the conviction in your rotten soul. You won’t. You won’t. You never want to see him like this ever again. 

“I wish I could believe you.” He murmurs sadly, his gaze locked with yours as he pulls his hips back only to thrust forward again, the tip of his cock barely slipping out before he's burying it back inside you. You don’t hold back your whimper of pain from him, and he doesn’t hold back his vengeance from you. “Holy shit…That woman said you’re with him all the time, hiding away from others. She saw you rubbing against him in front of everyone, yet you won't even let me kiss you in public.” 

“It’s not true, baby. She’s lying.” You deny, still hoping it would save you from an even worser fate. 

“Why would she lie?”

“Why would I lie?” You implore the part of him that trusts and respects his jiejie, hoping it's still alive. But the smile he gives you is not that of your doting little brother. “Because you know I'll chop his hands off and feed him his own dick if he touched you.” 

Bile rises in your throat. You can't tell if he really means it or if it's just the heat of the moment, and that fucking terrifies you. Would your brother really try to hurt Xavier if he finds out the truth? How far does his obsession really go? Is there any remaining hope at all?

“It didn't happen, okay?” You cower, unwilling to face the possibility of your precious baby brother doing something so violent, even as he unleashes some of that same violence upon you. “I promise, di.” 

“I want to believe you, jie. I really do.” He sighs, his hand gripping your chin tightly as he stares deep into your eyes, trying to seek out the truth. “I will lose it if I find out you’re lying to me.” 

You cradle his face in your hands and pull him down for a passionate kiss, coaxing him to soften for you. “I’m not, baby. I promise.” 

Let me in. Don't do this. Please, come back to me.

And he does, his face crumbling into the needy look you're so familiar with, his eyes shining wet and pitiful with yearning. “I love you, jie.”

You sigh in relief. “I know, baby. I love you too.”

“You don’t. Not as much as I do. Or you wouldn’t keep saying no to me.” He whines, and sits back on his heels, his hands gripping your hips as he resumes his thrusts, watching the head of his cock disappear in and out of your hole again and again. “I want you s-so much, jie. I wanted you before I even—hah—knew what my cock was for.” 

Because there is something seriously wrong with you, didi. 

And there is something seriously wrong with me. 

And I can’t tell which one of us had this sickness first. 

But the disgust that his confession brings up in you does nothing to dampen the pleasure you feel as your pussy slowly starts getting used to the intrusion, moulding around his cock in order to accommodate him. Every part of you will always yield to your little brother, even this. 

“You were made for me.” He moans and your pussy flutters around him in answer, producing more slick that makes the slide of his cock easier. It sucks him in hungrily, and suddenly you can feel just how empty you are inside. 

Do it. He can fill up that hole inside you. He feels it too. Just give in. Take what you both need. 

A voice calls out from deep within your mind, the sound distant and muffled as if buried under layers of rubble. Something in its enthralling tone seems so terrifyingly familiar to you, like a desire you'd long buried but has now returned from the dead to drag you to hell. 

But you resist its call. It’s not your little brother’s duty to fix what you lack. If you have influenced him to think he needs to then you must correct him before you ruin him completely. 

"Does it feel good for you too, jie? Tell me, please..." He whimpers, the anticipation and worry on his face almost have you spilling to reassure him. “It feels so good for me. This is where I belong. Fuck, do you feel it too, jie?”

His thumb brushes over your clit, the friction making your hips rock against his hand involuntarily, mindlessly chasing more of that pleasure.

“Please, say it, jie.” 

You shake your head, trying to rebuke both your brother's delusional pleas to join him in his lunacy and the incriminating demands coming from your own mind. 

This is not right. He should have never known what the inside of you felt like, let alone think he belonged there. It would have been less abominable for him to dig his hand into your chest and stifle the life out your heart that you'd already given to him so many years ago. 

Caleb sees your denial for rejection. “If you can’t feel it then maybe I’m not deep enough.” He grunts, his thumb flicking over your clit more roughly now as he pushes his cock further inside you, the head of it painfully stretching your hymen. “I need to go all the way inside you. I need to feel your blood that runs through my veins dripping down on my cock.”

You don't know if it's fear or arousal you feel at the thought of the blood that you both share staining your little brother's cock after he takes you in a way no other man has, and no brother ever should… but whatever it is, it pushes you over the edge. Your back arches off the bed as you scream, an overwhelming pleasure ripping through your body. 

“Fuck, jiejie—” He groans, his hips twitching as he tries to fuck your pussy, but it clamps down on him, mercifully preventing him from acting on his threats. “Shit—shit—you're milking my c-cock, jie. You're gonna make me cum… fuck, please, jie, please—I need—I’m cumming! I’m cumming!”

Amidst your violent orgasm and his frenzied reaction, a rational thought somehow makes it through the swill of shame and pleasure, and you yelp out. “Caleb, pull out. You need to pull out, baby. I'm not on birth control.” 

You hear nothing in return but his delirious babbles of ‘I love you. I love you. Jiejie, I love you so much.’

“Caleb, did you hear me?” Your voice rises with panic, “Pull out!”

Though his eyes are locked on you, he doesn’t acknowledge your frantic pleas. 

You feel his cock twitch.

Oh god. 

Your little brother is going to cum inside you. You're going to get knocked up with your baby brother's child. Your lives will be ruined forever.

But at the last second, he pulls out, and you feel his hot cum land on your pussy, covering you in his seed that thankfully wasn’t given the chance to take. 

“Fuck…” He groans, staring down at the mess he made of you as if mesmerized. “You… you bled a little.”

Your eyes snap down to see the ever so small streak of your blood marring his otherwise pearly white cum. 

He must have slightly torn your hymen when he tried to go all the way. Shivering, you think of how close he got… and that emptiness inside you yawns wider. 

“Shit, jie.” He sucks in a harsh breath, his fingers smearing his release over your swollen lips. “You came so hard on my cock. Did you like hearing what I want to do to you?”

"No, Caleb." You croak, voice strained as you shake your head weakly. “I didn't—I don't like it.”

“Liar.” He purrs, grabbing his still-hard cock and dragging the thick head along your soaked folds, coating himself in the mess of your blood and his cum. “I felt how tight you got around me when I said—”

“You were playing with my clit.” You snap quickly, “That’s why I came.”

Caleb shakes his head as he slides his cock lower and lines the blunt tip up with your entrance once more. “That’s not what happened. You want it, jie. You want your little brother’s cock—”

“Stop it, Caleb!” You push your legs shut and kick at his hips, trying to shove him back. “I don’t want to hear it. It’s fucking disgusting!”

He catches your legs easily, forcing them back down onto the mattress as he climbs over you again, caging you beneath his larger body.

“You can deny it all you want, jie, but I know the truth. I felt it.” He growls, and you cower into the sheets, but you have nowhere to run away from this frightful version of your little brother he blames you for. 

“Caleb, you’re hurting me.” You tell him meekly, and worry if that even means anything to him anymore.

“What about me?” Caleb counters, pressing his hips forward so the thick head of his cock stretches your sore entrance again. The burning overstimulation makes you whimper, your abused pussy clenching involuntarily around him. “You hurt me every time you deny our love.”

“Caleb, please… don’t do this.” You plead, the jagged pieces of your broken heart cutting up your throat. “Not this way.”

He glares down at you, his entire body taut as his wants and desires battle with his need for your acceptance and approval. 

“You don’t want your first time to be like this.” You press on, trying desperately to reason with him. 

“Our first time.” He hisses, jaw clenching so hard you can see the muscle jump. But, finally, he pulls his cock out, making you both shudder, and you tell yourself it's from relief. “You’re mine, jie. You can’t run from it much longer. You’re my sister… my best friend… and my mother.”

You frown, opening your mouth to protest, but he pushes his thumb between your lips, pressing down on your tongue to silence you.

“And one day soon, I’m going to take your pussy and make you my woman too. Then you’ll be all mine and no one will ever take you away from me. Not even you, jie.”

“SAM!”  Dean shouted as the younger brother was tripped by an unseen force and then thrown against a wall.  Dean pulled his gun out as he turned around, but it fell from his hand as the force slammed him into an opposing wall.

“Tsk tsk tsk,”  The witch shook her finger as she stepped out of the shadows.  “You boys are in an awful lot of trouble.”  She grinned menacingly.

“What are you waiting for, kill us already,”  Sam groaned as the forcing holding him to the wall got tighter.

“I don’t want to kill you,”  Elayne said looking between the two men.

“No, you just want to bore us with your monologue right, Pussy Galore?”  Dean taunted.

“How about you not talk?”  She brushed her hand over Dean’s mouth.  He looked at Sam, opened his mouth, and then closed it with a ticked off look to the witch.

“I know you’ve been hunting me,”  She said twirling the end of her hair absently.  “But I think you can help me.”

“We would never help you,”  Sam said seconds after Dean’s mouth opened again.

“No voluntarily,”  Elayne agreed, nodding her head.  “But that got me thinking.  You guys give you DNA away like candy.  Why wouldn’t you give it to me?”

“What are you talking about?”  Sam asked confused as he looked to Dean.  The older brother shrugged.  “Why do you need our DNA?”

“I need the DNA of a possessed human for a spell,”  The witch swatted the air in front of her like it was a stupid question.  Dean threw his hands up in the air.  “Fine, you can talk.”

“Thank you!  We don’t just go around throwing our DNA around willy nilly,”  Dean crossed his arm as he spoke, not seeming to care that his feet weren’t touching the ground.

“Oh! Really?  I must have you boys confused with other hunters then,”  Elayne laughed at her own statement.  “I’m sorry,”  She giggled one last time recovering her composure.  “I’ll make you a deal, if you spill your DNA anywhere I’m going to be there to collect it.  So if someone cuts you,”  She walked over to Sam and scratched a nail across his upper chest until there was a bright red line, but no blood.  “You won’t bleed but I’ll come to you and take your DNA then.  Prove me wrong and I won’t cast my spell,”  She looked between the brothers.  “You have one month.  Trick or Treat.”

The brothers fell to the ground and Elayne disappeared.

“What the hell?”  Dean asked when they had recovered.

“I don’t know.  But we should get out of here,”  Sam said.

“We need to stay in the motel,”  Sam said as they got back to their room.

“For the whole month of November?”  Dean asked in disbelief.

“Not only that,”  Sam said quietly as you came running and threw your arms around his neck.

“I was worried about you, what happened?”  You asked pecking him on the cheek.

“Nothing important.  But Dean and I are gonna challenge ourselves this month,”  Sam said feigning chipperness.

“We are?”  Dean asked unexcited.

“We are gonna participate in -ahem- No nut November,”  Sam said awkwardly as he gave Dean a pointed look and pulled himself away from you.

“Wait what?  Why?  You’ve never done anything like that before.  What’s really going on?”  You asked looking suspiciously between Sam and Dean trying to figure out who would crack first.

“No, Sam’s right.  We really want to do this,”  Dean said, trying to cover the monotony in his voice.

“Fine,”  You said with a snarl, hating to be left out.

True to their words Sam and Dean stayed in the motel room all the time.  You went out for food and even slept in a separate room.  Despite your best efforts, Sam would barely even look at you, and when he did he looked sad.  After not seeing the brothers for thanksgiving you’d had enough.  Something was going on and they weren’t telling you what it was.  You knew they had secrets but this was the last straw.  You called Sam’s cellphone and told him you needed him, claiming it was urgent.  You put on a see-through teddy and displayed yourself on the bed.

“I came as fast as I could, what’s wr- oh,”  Sam stared at you and let the door close behind him.  You spread your legs to give him a full view and watched as he swallowed hard.

“I needed you desperately,”  You whispered huskily.

“No- I can’t, I’m sorry,”  Sam said shaking his head.

“November is over tomorrow, I won’t tell Dean.  Just come here and see how wet I am for you,”  You tweaked a nipple through your clothes as Sam took a step toward you.

“Well, I guess the month is up,”  Sam took his shirt off.  

He laid with his face between your legs before lifting your hips.  He licked at your dripping pussy and suckled your clit, forcing a small cry to leave your lips.  You had never cum so hard on his mouth before, and your legs were red and tingling from his slight scruff.  It was obvious that he hadn’t been shaving very closely.

“Sam I want you so badly,”  You said as Sam crawled up your body and kissed you hard.  He groaned as you felt his cock against your leg throb.

“I can’t,”  Sam pulled himself off of your body and grabbed his shirt before running out of the room.

“What happened to you?”  Dean asked as Sam came back into the room panting.

“Nothing,”  Sam said fixing his shirt.

“You went and saw her didn’t you?”  Dean asked knowingly.

“What are you talking about?”  Sam asked looking at his brother.

“You missed a spot,”  Dean said pointing to his mouth and then at Sam’s face.  Sam’s face dropped and he wiped desperately at his face.  “I knew you wouldn’t be able to hold out.  At least she’s not suspicious about our job yet?”  When Sam looked at the floor Dean stood up.  “You get back over there and convince her everything is fine.”

“Fine,”  Sam said walking back out of the room.

“I’m sorry for rushing out like that,”  Sam said as he came back into your room.  You had curled up and rolled to look away from him.  “Can you forgive me?”

“Maybe,” you said twirling the end of your hair.  “Make it up to me?”  You got up on your knees and showed off your glistening cunt and backside.

“Fuck,”  Sam groaned as he palmed his crotch through his denim.

“That’s what I was thinking,”  You giggled.  Sam pulled his pants off and curled himself around your backside letting his cock press at your entrance.

“God you’re so big,”  You groaned as he started short thrusts to ease his way into you.  “Why did you wait so long to fuck me?”  You asked.

“Needed to get through November,”  Sam grunted as you squeezed him tight.  “It’s so close, I promise to make you cum, and then after midnight we can do this for real.”

“What?”  You asked incredulously.  

“What’s the matter?”  Sam asked pulling out and slamming back in.  “Is that not soon enough for you?”  He chuckled at his joke.

You pulled yourself off of him before spinning around on the bed and pushing him back.  He fell so that his head was hanging off the bed as you straddled him to keep him from falling off the rest of the way.

“It’s not soon enough,”  Elayne’s voice came from where you had been a moment before and she took Sam’s cock in her hand pumping him several times.

“You bitch,”  Sam said as he closed his eyes to keep himself under control.

“I’m a witch, thank you,”  Elayne said rolling her eyes.  “Why can’t you just give me what I want?!”

“Cause you’re a witch,”  Sam said breathing hard through his nose as Elayne teased him and did things to him that brought him closer to the edge than he thought he could be.

“You were so close when you were here with your little friend earlier, but then you changed your mind.  Apparently, she’s not enough for you and you need something more,”  Elayne snarled as she bent her head to lick at the crown of Sam’s cock.

“What did you do to her?”  Sam asked temporarily drawn away from his orgasm as you were mentioned.

“Cum for me and I’ll give her back,”  Elayne taunted as she took Sam’s cock all the way to the back of her throat.  Sam yelled in his sexual frustration.  He was so close and felt like he was going to explode, but he knew he couldn’t, even as Elayne moved to slide his full length inside of her.

“Get off of his you bitch!”  You cried from the doorway as Dean kicked the door open.

“Yeah, witch, what she said!”  Dean yelled awkwardly.

“He’s mine, it’s too late,”  Elayne grinned as Sam’s hips rutted up into her heat.

“Shit,”  Sam groaned as his control slipped.

“I’ve got her,”  Dean yelled as he lifted his gun and shot at her.  She disappeared into thin air and Sam cried as his orgasm was ripped away from his grasp with her.

“Sam!”  You sobbed as you ran over and covered him.  “You’re going to be okay.  I’ll help you,”  You whispered so that Dean wouldn’t hear.

“Yeah, I’m gonna go to the bar,”  Dean said as he looked at a clock that read 11:58 p.m.

The plan had been made, find Thanos, take the stones and bring everyone back but it didn’t go according to anyone’s plan. Thor left with his people as they settled New Asgard, Tony on a lake preparing for fatherhood, and the rest of you trying to find a sense of normalcy by going back to the compound, doing whatever any of you could outside of the one thing that was needed.

You turned to you side, the Egyptian sheets on the bed a welcomed luxury, facing Steve’s back the muscles tensing and relaxing sporadically giving away that he was awake. You watched his muscles dance while the same words repeating over and over in your head from the space ship months ago.

“I don’t know what I’m going to do if it doesn’t.”

You were both left with people you didn’t know anymore. The space between the two of you full of failure, loss and uncertainty. You went to reach for him but paused, the distance kept growing, both of you hurting but unsure how to piece each other back together, unsure it was even do able. He hadn’t kissed let alone touched you since it happened. Yet you both slept in the same bed, held shallow conversations, neither of you trying to push the other, afraid it’d all break. You were both so desperate for the habit you brought each other. You couldn’t live this way anymore though; either you broke and fell apart or you broke and built each other back up.

Without thinking it over much further you place your hand on his shoulder pulling him gently towards you. Within moments he was over you, with the offending wrist in his hand above your head, the forearm of his other arm pressed against your larynx. He his eyes wide but there was an unsettling vacancy in his eyes.

“St-Steve,” you gasped using you free hand to slap his forearm. The pressure on your larynx increased and you began to truly panic, your legs flailing on attempt to buck him off. This brought him back, he moved to his knees looking down at his hands in disgust.

“Steve,” your voice scratchy from the pressure, you slid your hands into his large palms. His head snapping up to look at you but he never wrapped his hands around yours. You went to entwine your fingers with his, so desperate to feel close to him. He pulled away and stood up from the bed, heading towards the door.

“Steven Grant Rogers do not leave me.” You tried to sound stern but it came out more of a desperate plea. His body stilled facing the door, silence reigned between you for far longer than you liked.

“I can’t,” his voice was gruff from disuse “I can’t fight anymore.” You felt your heart break at his words. You moved to stand behind him embracing him, pushing the side of your face into his back.

“You don’t have to fight,” you felt him turn in your embrace but you wouldn’t look up, you couldn’t see the look on his face. Burrowing your face into his chest this time you held him, unwilling to just let him walk away without talking.

He called your name out so gentle it was almost like a prayer. You shook your head not wanting to look up, but he called your name once more, taking a hold of your chin lifting your face up. You tried to blink away the tears threatening to spill unsuccessfully.

“I love you Steve, I need you. I need you to touch me. I need you to love me.” You were willing to let it break but you believed in all your heart you would build each other back up. He just had to know there was still something left to feel, something left to get up for.

His face contorted and the look his face took on made you increasingly uncomfortable, sliding your arms out from around him placing them at your side. It was predatory look that held no kindness, you took a few steps back, and he mimicked each one towering over you. There was malice and pain etched in that furrowed brow.

“You need me to touch you?” He sneered gripping your throat, titling your face up to him at a drastic angle, his head bent down to keep direct eye contact watching his pupils widen and the blue recede.

“You want me to love you?” his lips pressed against yours unyielding. He bit your lower lip using your gasp to his advantage shoving his tongue in your mouth. Taking command of you with every touch and swipe of his tongue, his aggressive touch awaking something within you as you dug your nails into his arms. His eye stayed open looking at you with a level of desire and intensity you couldn’t handle closing yours eyes you shivered.  

“Let me show you how I can love you,” he shoved you onto the bed eliciting a gasp from you when he pulled you legs apart and held your hands at the side of your head.

You became increasingly aware at your lack of clothing, his hardening cock in his pajama pants pressing against your underwear while your night shirt rode up your stomach. He returned to kissing you roughly pinned beneath him, you attempted to soften the kisses wanting to break though this rough exterior.

He growled at your efforts and ripped your shirt from the collar down for punishment. Your look of surprise was met with a devious smirk, both of his hands griping you exposed breasts roughly. Pulling and pinching your nipples, he continued his assault of your senses, biting at your neck harder than ever before. You were expecting to taste blood when he took your lips once more. Unwilling to be a bystander and letting this continue you slapped him, the force enough to pull his lips from yours, a red mark blooming on the offended cheek. The breath he heaved out was gurgling, his hands stilled on your breast and you began to panic.

He sat up between your legs and pulled your torn shirt off you, he ripped it completely in half. He took both your hands and placed your arms behind your back causing you to lie on your bent arms, using half of the tattered shirt he wrapped it around each wrist and tightened it with a well made military knot. Pulling on the fabric he grinned down at you satisfied with his work. “That should keep those hands to yourself.”

Without another word he flipped you onto your stomach and pulled you up to your knees at the same time, leaving you face down in the bed, completely exposed to him. You turned your head to the side, struggling against the bonds earning you a hard slap on the ass stilling you at the sting. He jerked your underwear down your legs, stopping at your knees. You heard clothing rustle behind followed by the warmth from the tip of his cock prodding your entrance. “You’re scaring me, please stop.”  

A dark chuckle fell from his lips “Oh, now you want me to stop?” he replied while dragging the head of his cock up and down your slit; pressing against your clit then dipping down to your unprepared opening but going in no further.

“I thought you wanted me to love you?” He trails the head back up to your clit, circling around arousing you despite your fear. Your body on auto pilot; only knowing to respond to his touch with arousal despite your growing fear.

“Make up your mind, doll face,” the normal term of endearment full of sarcasm and dark intentions. He continued rubbing your clit with the head of his cock, causing an unwanted moan to pull from your lips. You couldn’t control yourself; he chuckled once more at your response.

You wanted to tell him no, you wanted to plead with him that this was your fault for pushing him and he could stop before. Your words failed you. He moved the head of his cock back at your entrance spurring you to struggle again, rocking your body side to side in attempts to delay him. He took one hand and gripped the back of your neck, the other held the make shift rope around your wrists pulling your arms up to almost painful stretch stilling your movements.

“This is all I can give you but you,” his voice was deceivingly soft and you squeeze your eyes shut trying to will this whole mistake away. He began sliding in and it burned the little arousal he gave not enough to prepare you for his size. “You will give me everything.” he pushed the rest of the way in without any pause pulling a cry of pain from your lips.

Your body went slack, only being held up by his grip. He let out a hiss as he slowly pulled back. “You’re so tight,” he gritted his teeth, and then slid back in faster provoking a moan from your lips. Despite the pain, the feeling of him inside you always felt so good, that stretching and sense of full that he gave you.

He removed his grip on the back of your neck, you could hear him lick his fingers then felt them on your clit with soft gentle movements at first as he slid in and out at a slow pace. You lifted your head up moaning out, all your weight bearing down on your shoulders and knees. He chuckled deep in his gut and used your tied hands to pull you back and forth faster your growing arousal easing the movement. The sound of your skin slapping against one another increasing in tempo, he quickened his ministrations on your clit causing the pressure to build up faster than you anticipated.

He leaned over your body, caging you beneath him, his other hand letting go of your tied hands to support his weight on his bent elbow. He slammed into you so rough, the pace unforgiving and force punishing.  It was suffocating, in a way you had never felt with his hand around your neck. He was taking possession of you, commanding your body out of desperation instead of love and you would give it to him, give him everything just as he demanded.

Before you knew was happening you felt the snap, crying out in pleasure into the mattress, you could faintly hear him talking to you as his pace became erratic. You could feel that telling sensation of him swelling inside of you. Both of you chasing a feeling that felt foreign now. His cum rushing into you pushed a whimper past your lips, the feeling of it leaking down your thighs as he flooded you a welcoming familiar sensation.

Steve sat back up on his knees, remaining inside you, still hard, the lack of intimacy between the two of you leaving him ready once more. You whimpered this time in fear instead of pleasure. You weren’t sure you could take the brutality again. Without a word he laid you both on your sides, pushing your back and tied arms against his chest, never leaving your tight heat. You whimpered as the pain radiated in your arms, you wanted to ask him to untie you but he hushed you and quickly untied your arms. The release of your muscles in that uncomfortable position ached relentlessly.  

You pulled your arms in front of you trying to soothe the ache around your wrists by rubbing them. He gave you this moment so he could pulled your underwear completely off your legs. You tried to curl into yourself but he quickly slinked his arm underneath you and around your neck keeping the pressure gently but pulling your head up. His other hand took your top leg and brought it backwards to wrap around his thigh, giving him the advantage to piston into you once again, the force still rough but with a languid pace.

The slow pace was dragging you into sensory overload, your body trying to come down but he sought to keep the pleasure coursing through you. Not willing to fight the pleasure any longer, as it was inevitable you grinded back into him, his breath hot on your face as he groaned out your name.

“That’s it,” he murmured into your hair, rubbing his face into you inhaling your scent deeply as his thrusts jarred your body, his hand on your neck keeping you in place. You closed your eyes tightly, chasing the growing feeling inside you; you didn’t care anymore if he didn’t want you, if he didn’t love you. You were his. Reaching a hand back you gripped the back of his head pulling his hair. He growled and returned to his punishing pace. You began to slam your hips back into his and he surged forward each time. You knew you were moaning too loud by now, too far gone and hurt to care you pulled at his hair more, trying to will him to give you what you needed. You didn’t know where you would land once this was over but one thing was certain, you finally found out what Steve would do if he failed to bring everyone back.

The grip around your neck tightened and he began to rub your clit, pulling you from your thoughts back to him. It was always him. You cried out around his hold, his attention wearing your body down and keying it up all at once. You could feel his grin against your head, his brutal stride continuing to batter and satisfy you all at once.

You felt the coil snap inside; you couldn’t and didn’t care to stop the scream that tore from your lips at its intensity. This felt better than anything in the past five months. You convulsed and his grip around your neck lessened, Steve continued his pace as he neared his own end. He was whispering something over and over; you could barely make out his words as you slowly came down.

“I love you, I love you,” he was chanting it into your hair only to stop and pull you back into him with his hand while thrusting into you one final time, he flooded you once more. You let go of your hold on his hair and began to gently pat his head. He convulsed around you this time, softening inside you but not pulling out. When he curled up he pulled you deeper into him enfolding you around his arms. The warmth of his body and the exhaustion setting in lulled you to sleep quickly as he kept murmuring the same words into your hair.

-

Staring in the distance of thick forest beyond the compound your arms wrapped around yourself trying to fight off the dusk chill setting in. You didn’t know how long you had been sitting on the bench in front of the lake staring off into the distance. All you knew was you couldn’t go back to that room.

There had been that growing darkness in him since Siberia. His touches rough, trying to imprint something on you, there had been that desire to impregnate you for a while which brought on a hard pill to swallow when you both learned your chances to conceive were slim. He had continued though, convinced he could do the impossible. You had worried back then he was trying to use a child as a tool to keep you by him always after he lost himself following the Accords fall out. He anchored who he was on you, and if you weren’t his or him yours who was he, who were you for that matter? Bucky being around had helped but he was gone, so many of them were gone.

You sneered as you realized you got what you wanted, you two certainly broke.

You heard foot steps behind you, dread set in. You weren’t ready to face him yet, not after both of your actions last night. The footsteps stopped beside the bench; weakly you turned your head trying to prepare yourself to face him and the consequences of your actions.

A sigh of relief escaped your lips, it was Rhodey. Without thinking you jumped up and wrapped your arms around his neck hugging him, needing some kind of gentle touch. It took him a few seconds but he wrapped his arms around you one around your back the other patting your head.

“Hey, it’s okay,” his words hushed trying to calm you down, when did you start crying? It didn’t matter anymore as you felt your body convulse in sobs.

It was a bit until you calmed down enough to let go of him. Rhodey smiled at you wiping your cheeks. You both sat on the bench, leaning your head on his shoulder he patted your hands in your lap. You could feel a small sense of peace taking you over, crying helping you release some of the pain over what had occurred in the past 12 hours.  

“Let’s get you back to your Cap, I think you need that golden boy treatment.” The words were a slap in the face but you worked hard not to express it outwardly. You wouldn’t let anyone know what happened last night, not sure if that was more for Steve than for you. Refusing to go back to him would raise suspicion but could you see him again so soon? What would you say to him? What would he say to you? You left before he woke up, and hadn’t been back inside since, spending most the day walking around the compound grounds or just staring. You hadn’t eaten since dinner last night. The thought of food made you nauseous however maybe you could use this an excuse to not see Steve just yet.

“You know,” you paused and clear your throat as your voice was rough from being silent all day. “I think I’ll get food first. I suddenly have a big appetite after that good cry,” you pushed forth a smile, keeping eye contact hoping Rhodey would buy it.

“Oh-okay.” He sounded half convinced but unsure if he should press you further given your delicate state. You wanted to frown at that, most men really couldn’t handle the intensity of emotions whether theirs or others. You hugged Rhodey one last time before thanking him and walking back to the compound.

-

You sat at the kitchen bar, picking at the plate of leftovers in front of you. Natasha’s voice could be heard muffled in the back doing some kind of debriefing. Natasha had taken lead, Steve unsure of returning to a leadership position of any kind since the Accords. Given his behavior last night that might have been the smartest thing he had done in the past 2 years. Shaking your head to push away the reminder of last night you took small bite of food, breathing deeply to keep it down. You would stay there all night slowly eating if it meant you could delay the inevitable.

Unaware of how long you had been sitting there Natasha pulled you back to reality calling out your name.

“Hm?” You looked towards her with a soft smile, but she gave you a concerning look.

“I was saying that I was disappointed it was a left over night and not a fresh cooked meal from our own personal chef.” You blushed at the compliment of your cooking skills. You were certainly not a chef but definitely the only one who could cook anything beyond macaroni and cheese at the compound. You had taken upon yourself as people came and went to cook, and keep leftovers in the fridge of home cooked meals.

“Oh Sorry Nat, I just wasn’t feel myself today.” She nodded in agreement.

“Yeah you were outside all day, I didn’t even see you give Steve the signature kiss goodbye when he left,” your eyes brightened at this thought, he was gone. “Oh Steve left?” Natasha’s eyes narrowing at the joy in your voice.

“Yeah…” she leaned over the kitchen bar across from you staring intently. “He’ll be back soon, so if you’re trying to avoid a certain super solider you better make yourself scarce quick.” A forced laugh came out trying your best to play the part of what you thought would seem normal right now.

“That’s funny Nat, why would I be hiding from Steve?” Looking down at your food and picking at it again hoping against all hope to have convinced even the best human lie detector if not then at least yourself.

“Why indeed,” she muttered before going to the fridge for her own dinner. Just then you heard a distant door opening, you scrunched your eyes shut knowing who it was.

“Nat I barely ate any of my food, why don’t you finish my plate? I think I’m going to go-” before you could finish your sentence he was there, walking to the kitchen dressed in civilian clothes, always the damn checkered button ups. Natasha looked between the both of you, sizing up the situation.

“Go do what?” Nat turned to you raising her eyebrows in expectance of an answer. With him near you, any lies or convincing fronts were lost to you.

“Just going to go,” you nodded your head quickly and began walking out of the room purposely the opposite direction Steve had come from. You heard him call out your name but you just shook your head and kept walking.

“I don’t know what you did Cap, but you better fix it,” you could hear Nat scolding him but his reply barely registering as you began to run. How could either of you fix what happened? You had pushed, broke the both of you, and he took everything as the pieces of you two fell on the floor.

Before you knew it you were back outside, running and running. It felt liberating, the cold night air pushing against your skin so much that it almost hurt but it didn’t stop the freeing feeling. As the forest came in your eye line you picked up your pace with determination, you just wanted to feel this freedom a little bit longer.

-

It was late when you finally came back to the compound, no late wasn’t right, it was early. You could hear the morning birds beginning their songs while making your way inside. Being so deep in nature had let you look back with a clearer head. You walked up to the door of your shared bedroom, the light  shining out from under the door signaling he was awake in there. You could feel your body shake lightly, adrenalin beginning to surge through you as you prepared for whatever would come between the two of you after this.

Squaring your shoulders with a deep breath in through your nose and out your mouth you opened the door. When you entered he was sitting in on the bed, his legs stretched out, hand over his face. You cleared your throat causing him to sit up straight in shock looking at you with blood shot eyes, your name fell from his lips so softly that it almost hurt to hear. You took a step towards the bed but kept a safe distance from outside of his direct reach.

“I’m leaving,” he inhaled sharply eyes full of agony. “And you aren’t coming after me and you sure as all aren’t going to look for me. I need to know that you understand.” You could see him start to stand up, you quickly moved to across the other side of the bed near the closet and a window, tears threatening to spill. Your plan of exit already calculated if he tried anything.

He stared at you, with that hurt puppy dog look he was so good at. The look that normally would make you run to him and sooth his pain but you couldn’t do that for him, not anymore.

“I-I found a group therapy meeting, I listened mostly,” you waited for him to continue. If he was talking he was within the realm of reason still. “I talked a little but not about us.” You nodded your head.

“I’m glad you found that, I hope you keep going, maybe it can help you with whatever I clearly couldn’t.” you tried not to sound bitter but it was hard. He let out a small laugh looking down at his feet.

“You always did help me though, it wasn’t until after…” the silence was resounding, you wanted him to say it wanted him to acknowledge what happened. “After I forced myself on you that I realized all you ever did was try to help me and I just kept taking.” You nodded your head. While he had given everything of himself to the world, in return took everything from you to make up for his loss. It wasn’t hard to see, but you were glad he could see though it now but it didn’t change what happened. It never could.

“I’ll never ask you to forgive me,” he looked up at you, there were tears in his eyes, had he been crying just as much as you had? “But I will apologize and try to make amends in whatever way you will allow me.” Your hands balled up into fists at your side, how dare he think he could atone for this?

“What kind of man loves like this, Steven?” Your voice was forced even tone, trying so hard to not let yourself cry in anger or worse in pain. “What kind of man takes everything a woman has and what’s left after that too?” He takes a few steps towards you but you put a hand up, and as if you had some kind of physical force he abruptly stopped.

“A lost man, a broken man, a man who can’t love them self let alone someone else.” You answered your own question. “You were my habit and I was just as much yours but after Thanos,” with your eyed closed tight the tears started to fall, matching the ones continuing down his beautiful face. His stupid beautiful face. You sniffled and opened your eyes once more.

“After Thanos the habit didn’t work anymore so I’m leaving. I’m admitting I’m addicted to you and I am leaving that addiction because that’s what healthy people do Steven. They heal.” You walked up to him, framing his face with your hands you began wiping away his tears with your thumbs you couldn’t help the sob that escaped your lips watching his face softens with content at your touch. You pulled his hair back from his forehead, his hands gently holding your bent elbows, you were grateful he didn’t touch you anywhere else, not sure you could handle it.

“I love you Steve, more than I ever thought possible but we got lost along the way and there’s no way back to each other. So let’s say goodbye, okay?” His brows lifted in panic and he tried to shake his head no but you held his face still, petting his face again trying to calm him down. “Don’t make this any harder than it already is,” you choked out, feeling your strength cracking at the raw emotions unrelentingly swirling within you.

“I don’t know if I can let you go,” his voice wavered more tears trailed down his cheeks. You wiped them away too; you always wanted to wipe away his pain.

“It’s okay, because I can do it for both of us. This is the last thing I can give you Steven.” You lifted up pressing your lips to the corner of his mouth, tasting the saltiness of his tears. You pulled away, and dropped your hands to your sides, his hands lingered on your arms for a moment but he soon after they fell to his side as he sniffled.

“Do you need help?” Caleb wanders closer, peering over your shoulder at the bubbling pot, and you throw him back a smile. “Nope. You’ve done enough. You don’t have to stay. I’ve got it all handled.”

He ignores you, stepping right up behind you until his chest brushes your back. “Surely that’s not right.” He hums, breath warm against your ear. “My big sister is preparing this nice dinner for us… At least let me keep you company.”

You roll your eyes, even as you feel your body stiffening up. “Whatever.”

His arms slide around your waist, pulling you back against him in a tight hug. “Hmm… smells good.”

“It’s your favorite dish.” You say hoarsely as his nose nuzzles into the side of your neck. “Yeah… it is.”

You clear your throat. “How has work been treating you? Are you sleeping well? Getting enough rest? Any big missions coming up?” You blabber, your last question choked out as one of his hands drifts slowly down your front.

Caleb chuckles, the sound vibrating from his chest into your back. “Couple of missions next week, nothing too intense. After that, I’ll have some time off.” His voice is sweet as his fingers play with the waistband of your leggings. “Girlfriend’s been talking about taking a weekend trip to some cabin up north. She thinks it’ll be romantic.”

“That sounds nice.” You manage, mouth dry as you shift in his tight embrace, the anxious energy making you squirm against him immediately snuffed out when you feel his hard length poking against your ass. 

“Mm, yeah. She’s been really excited about it.” His hand slips inside your pants, warm palm pressing over your underwear first, then sliding beneath the fabric. You bite your lip and grip the edge of the counter. “She seems good for you.”

Caleb hums, circling your clit in lazy strokes. “She is sweet.” His voice stays perfectly casual, as his fingers play with your pussy, and when they dip down to gather the unbidden wetness weeping from your hole, you jerk, thighs pressing together instinctively.

“Easy.” He chuckles, nudging your legs apart with his knee. “Clumsy jiejie.”

“Caleb, honey… time’s running out.” You say, voice strained as you clutch the counter tighter. “You gotta go pick up your girlfriend.”

“Hmm… in a bit. She texted earlier saying she might be a little late. ” He grunts, pressing a kiss just below your ear. “We got time.”

Still, he withdraws his hand anyway and you let out a sigh of relief. But it’s short-lived, quickly replaced by dread as hooks his fingers into your pants and underwear, shoving them down just past your hips. You hear the sound of him spitting into his hand before he presses it between your asscheeks, rubbing the spit around your entrance for a second then sinking two thick fingers into your pussy. The sudden stretch stings, but you’re no stranger to the pain. Your little brother has put you through worse. 

“She wants me to meet her family properly soon, you know.” He continues, his voice growing huskier as he pumps his fingers in and out of you, scissoring them to force you open. “Thinks we’re getting serious.”

Dread bubbles in your chest and your pussy tightens around his fingers as you hear the sound of a zipper being undone.  Then you feel the hot press of his cock against your ass, the tip smearing precum as he rubs it over your skin.

“Yeah?” You whisper, barely able to focus on the conversation. “That’s good, didi. I’m happy for you two.”

“Are you now?” Caleb scoffs, withdrawing his fingers from you and your heart rate spikes up. You know what comes next. 

“The food is almost ready.” You speak up quickly, “You should go pick her up now or you’ll be late and the food will get cold.”

“Don’t worry, traffic’s light this time of evening.” He brushes you off, lining his cock up with your pussy from behind. Before you could protest again, he pushes inside you in one harsh thrust.

Your eyes squeeze shut, a broken whimper slipping past your lips as he forces you open on his cock. He’s always been big, and no matter how many times he does this to you, your body never quite gets used to the stretch. You feel every inch, every vein, as he sinks deep until his hips are flush against your ass, buried inside you to the hilt.

“I won’t let your effort go to waste, jiejie.” He promises, voice already a little shaky. Your mouth falls open in a silent cry as he starts moving in deep thrusts that drag against every sensitive spot inside you. Your pants and underwear are still bunched around your thighs, trapping your legs and making you feel even more exposed and helpless.

Caleb leans back slightly, one hand leaving your hip before you hear the soft click of his phone unlocking, followed by the unmistakable sound of the camera shutter.

It's not the first time he's done this. His phone is filled with hundreds of pictures of you going back years. 

“Just a little keepsake.” He whispers cheekily, “For when I’m missing my favorite girl.”

You don’t say anything as he puts his phone away and leans over your again, chest pressing flush to your back, caging you against the counter. It’s always better to let him do whatever he wants. Makes it go quicker. 

“Fuck… you feel so good.” He groans, the words slipping out between thrusts. His breath comes out hotter now as his pace picks up, rocking you forward with every snap of his hips. “So tight for me… even when you’re pretending you don’t want it.”

You bite down hard on your lip to keep your mouth shut. Just let him say what he wants. Don’t contradict him. Be nice and quiet and this will be over soon. You repeat those words in your head like a mantra. They’ve gotten you through so much worse. 

But Caleb isn’t satisfied with your quiet surrender today. One of his hands slides up under your tank top to squeeze your breasts roughly, while the other slips between your legs, playing with your little clit the way he has mastered over the years. 

“Right now, she’s probably back home trying to pick out a nice dress to impress her boyfriend’s big sister, all while you’ve got me balls deep in your tight pussy.” He pants, mouthing at your neck in wet, stinging kisses. You’ll have to wear a high collar tonight. It’s okay. You’ve got a collection of them thanks to your didi who is fucking you more roughly now, his pace turning punishing at your continued silence. “You like that, don’t you? Like proving who I really belong to.”

You shake your head despite yourself, and immediately regret it. You know better than this. 

Caleb’s hand fists in your hair and yanks your head back. “Don't lie to me. Look at what you're wearing. You wanted it.”

You let out a helpless mewl. You know you should've changed. You're such an idiot. 

You bite down on your tongue, tasting blood as you hold back from shaking your head again. He scoffs, driving into you harshly, making your knees buckle as the strength goes out of your body. He catches you easily, arm wrapping around your waist to hold you up as he drives into you faster, and angles his hips to hit that spot that makes stars burst behind your eyes. 

“Still won't admit it? You like to pretend I'm taking you against your will? Is that what turns you on, sister? I can feel how wet you are around me, dripping down my balls.” He mocks and you wish he would just cum already. Why is he being so cruel today? “But it hurts my ego, jiejie. Hmm… maybe I should cancel that weekend trip and spend it with you instead. We won’t go anywhere, just stay here and I can fuck you on every surface of this damn apartment until you admit it. How does that sound, jie?” 

You panic. “No, Caleb. We had a deal, remember, baby?”

“I remember. Do you?” He asks gruffly, hips still snapping into you. “You were supposed to let me visit once a week, but you kept cancelling. Wouldn’t even answer my calls or texts. I almost called the whole thing off.”

So this is what it’s about.

“No, no, I’m sorry.” You whimper. “I was just busy—”

You weren’t. You had hoped that now that he got a longterm girlfriend that you can finally start to wean him off his sick fixation on you. Clearly, it was too soon. 

“Liar.” He whines, suddenly sounding like your precious little brother that you’d do anything for. Anything. Even let him cross a line that should never be crossed between siblings. “You were being a bad jiejie. Trying to get out of your duties to your little brother.” 

“I’m sorry, baby. Sorry for being bad. I won't neglect you again, I promise.” You choke out, your pussy burning from the rough way he’s treating you. Luckily, you know how to push him over the edge and end it. “I missed you, baby… I missed your cock inside me. Please, won’t you cum inside jiejie and fill her up?”

His hips stutter.

“Yeah?” He groans, leaning over you, breath hot against your ear. “You want it, jie?”

“Yes, baby.” You moan, giving him exactly what he craves. “I want to take care of you. Let go for your big sister.”

“Okay, jiejie.” He whimpers, “Whatever you want. Gonna give it all to you.” 

Caleb’s thrusts grow erratic, his hips snapping against your ass desperately, until finally he buries himself deep one last time, his grip on your waist tightening painfully as a loud groan tears from his throat

“Fuck, take it. Take every drop.” He rasps against your ear.

You feet the hot, thick pulse of his cock as he comes inside you, rope after rope of warm cum flooding your pussy. Your walls flutter around him helplessly, your own orgasm hovering just out of reach, leaving you trembling and needy, but you’re not going to ask him for release.

“Fuck, I love you, jie.” He moans, turning your head to the side and slotting his lips against yours, his tongue pushing past your lips. You let him kiss you, drooling into your mouth as he grinds against your ass, his cock hardening again inside you. 

“Baby… baby, the dinner.” You plead desperately against his mouth and he grunts in dissatisfaction, biting down on your bottom lip punishingly. You flinch back with a hiss of pain, feeling a warm drop of blood trickling down your chin. His eyes fixate on it, pupils blown wide as he leans in and licks it away, groaning at the taste, his cock twitching inside your cum-filled pussy.

“Caleb.” You repeat, trying to sound firm but your voice comes out shaky. You know you can’t let him lose himself again. 

He huffs in frustration but finally pulls out. The wet, obscene sound of his cock leaving your soaked hole makes your cheeks burn with shame, as does the maddening emptiness it leaves inside you. You barely have a second to steady yourself before he yanks your underwear and leggings back up your thighs, tugging them into place haphazardly. The fabric presses tight against your dripping pussy, trapping his warm cum inside.

“Don’t shower, okay?” He tells you, voice still rough from his climax as he tucks himself back into his pants and zips up. “Keep it all inside you.”

You balk, eyes widening in horror. “I can’t sit across from your girlfriend like this!”

Caleb turns you around and pins you against the cabinet with his body, one hand reaching up to gently brush a strand of hair behind your ear. He has a serene smile on his face, but his beautiful sunset eyes are dark and stormy, and it makes your heart ache. Oh, how you’d give anything to bring sunshine back into his eyes. 

“You will.” He says, thumb tracing your swollen bottom lip. “Because you’re the one who wants this little show to continue.”

You open your mouth to speak, but he pushes his thumb between your lips, pressing down on your tongue to silence you.

“After we have dinner and I go to drop her off, you will wait for me in your bed. You can pretend to be asleep all you want, but that won't stop me. And if I come back and find you’d cleaned up…” His voice drops low, and you shiver. “I’ll send her the pictures of you stuffed full of my cock.”

Your stomach turns with dread, and you stand there paralysed as he pulls his thumb from your mouth and replaces it with his tongue, more gentle this time. When he pulls back, his voice is soft again.

“Be good for me tonight, okay? You’ve got a lot to make up to me, jie.” He brushes his wet thumb across your cheek, then flashes you a sweet smile when you nod obediently. 

“See you soon, jie.” He presses one last soft peck to your lips before he turns and walks away. The front door clicks shut behind him, leaving you standing alone in your kitchen, pants still slightly crooked, thighs pressed together, and your brother’s cum slowly seeping out of your aching pussy.

You had no idea how long you had been laying in the bed for when the door to the room opened and Sam came rushing in.

“Hey, are you okay?”  He asked, placing a hand on your back.

“No, please, I want to sleep,”  You were exhausted and your body ached.  You felt limp and heavy.

“What happened?”  Castiel’s voice rang from the door, as you felt arms lift you from the bed and carry you out of Dean’s room.  “Where’s Dean?”

“Dean’s gone,”  You whimpered as you curled into Sam’s shoulder.

“It’s not your fault,”  Sam whispered.  “Did he hurt you?”

“It is my fault,”  You said as Sam laid you down in the infirmary and inspected for obvious damage before pulling a sheet over you.  “I let Michael in.  Dean saved me from him.  They are going to fight Lucifer.  Sam, you need to be there,”  You squeezed Sam’s hand before giving him a gentle push away.

“I’ll stay with her,”  Castiel nodded at the younger brother before Sam left the bunker in search of Dean and Michael.  “Tell me what happened, everything,”  Castiel said after a time.

“Michael promised to fix me so that Dean and I could have a baby,”  You said to hurt and angry to cry any more.

“Did he?”  Castiel asked looking at you through the sheet.

“He claimed to, something about a promise was a promise,”  You huffed.  “He said there would be side effects,”  You looked at Castiel, eyes widening as you thought about everything that could mean.  “Am I going to die?”

“No, don’t think like that,”  Castiel said placing his hand on your forehead and brushing hair out of your face.

“Michael he… and Dean,”  You were crying again.  “I think I’m pregnant, and I think it’s Michael’s,” the words rushed out of you and you looked away from Castiel ashamed.

“What did he promise you?”  Castiel asked.

“He promised to fix me so that Dean and I could have a child,”  you said.  Your eyes met Castiel’s as you searched for the reason behind his line of questioning.

“You’re not having Michael’s child,”  Castiel said after a moment.  He stood and paced slowly.  “Like demons, angels must keep their word.  He agreed to heal you, and you and Dean having a child together.  But we should keep an eye out.  There is likely something else going on.  Did he say anything else other than the promise or there would be side effects?”

“He asked why I thought he would let me have Dean’s son,”  You said quietly.

“Hmm, that’s very vague and ominous.  It means something but I’m not sure what,”  Castiel said.  “I’ll walk you to your room so you can get some sleep, you are probably very tired from the possession.  I’ll fill Sam in when he gets back,”  Castiel helped you stand and place an arm around you to get you down the hallway.

“Michael agreed to let Dean go after he killed Lucifer, so that means that Dean will come home with Sam if they win right?”  You asked as Castiel laid you on the bed.

“Right,”  He agreed soothingly.  You were pulled into a deep sleep and Castiel left you alone.  Sam was sitting in the war-room when you woke the next day.  He was badly beaten and alone, desperately searching for answers in some books.  Dean was nowhere to be seen.

“What happened?”  You asked, as you gingerly took a seat at the table.  Sam explained the fight between Dean and Nick at the church and how Michael had taken Dean away after that.  You stared at him in shock, unable to process his words.

“Cas said you think you're pregnant?”  Sam asked, looking at you with the sisterly love he had always shown you.  “Something about a promise Michael made you.”  You broke down crying as Sam held you.

It was three weeks before Dean returned to the bunker, seemingly freed from Michael.  You had opted to wear sweat pants or dresses, since your jeans had become uncomfortably tight, and you had started to spend your mornings in the bathroom throwing up.  Michael had been right, things were not normal.