I’ve decided every time I read some stupidity like “he was obviously in the LWOM for ten years before meeting Emma,” I’m going to compress the known timeline of his age a little bit more.

I’ve got him down to fifteen years and three months to Emma’s seventeen. I can probably shave off a little more so that they celebrate his fifteenth birthday after getting together.

When Neal first sees the swan keychain, he compromises the whole heist just to steal it for Emma. As a swan, the keychain acknowledges Emma's last name, her independence and identity before she met Neal. As a keychain, it contains the keys to the Bug, their present temporary home. And together, it is a stable and meaningful gift that represents their future. Overall, the swan keychain is a symbol of Neal’s feelings for Emma and his understanding of her struggles. It shows his desire to support her, to be a part of her life, and to offer her something real and lasting.

After Neal left Emma, he gave everything he had of value (except for the dreamcatcher) to August to give to Emma. This included money, the bug, and the swan keychain. He sacrificed everything in the hopes that Emma could continue on without him.

Emma received the swan keychain when she found out the results to her pregnancy test, another sign of the family that she and Neal could have had together. Although Emma gave Henry up for adoption, she kept the Bug and turned the keychain into a locket, wearing it around her neck for eleven years, showing that she never fully let go of Neal or Henry (the family she could have had).

The first time Emma removes the keychain is when she finally reunites with Neal. In that moment, she's letting go of the future they could have shared, releasing herself from the emotional weight of holding onto him. By returning the keychain to Neal, she’s placing the responsibility on him, giving him the opportunity to rebuild their relationship with the full awareness of all the pain and history they share.

Afterwards, Neal keeps the swan keychain on his person until his death, representing his love for Emma and his profound guilt and regret over their separation. The keychain becomes a physical manifestation of his emotional state, a reminder of the love he never truly let go of.

The keychain remains with Neal as he travels across realms (from the Land Without Magic to the Enchanted Forest, to Neverland, to the Land Without Magic, to the Enchanted Forest, to the Land Without Magic again), symbolizing the unshakeable nature of his love for Emma. When Neal dies, he returns the Swan keychain to Emma, a final gesture that serves as a reminder that his love for her will never fade, even in death.

Teen Swanfire ‘Tallahassee’ aesthetics