The little monitor in our heads by Emily Nagoski: "...Sex isnât a drive. Please tell everyone you know. âbut emily, sometimes it feels like a drive!â
Some of you will be wondering, âSo how come there are times when sexual desire feels like an unpleasant internal state? How come it feels like a drive?â And the answer is: The same thing that makes Groundhog Day a funny movie. In the movie, Bill Murrayâs character wakes up each morning in the same hotel, to the same radio show on his alarm, on the same despairingly familiar day: February 2, Groundhog Day. He is forced to live the day over and over and over again. After asking for help, to no avail, from his producer, from a doctor, from a psychiatrist, and finally, while drunk at a bowling alley, from two random guys in flannel shirts, he concludes that he can do whatever he wants because there are no consequences. Hijinks ensue. And eventually he decides to seduce his producer, played by Andie MacDowell. Groundhog Day after Groundhog Day, he woos her and courts her and memorizes French poetry, trying to get her into bed and gradually falling in love with her . . . and Groundhog Day after Groundhog Day, he ends up getting slapped in the face. Over. And over. Again. He keeps failing at his goal, a goal that is becoming increasingly important to him, until at last he gives up in despair. And so he kills himself. Over. And over. Again. He canât even die. A bunch of other stuff happens and I donât think Iâm spoiling anything if I say it has a happy ending. Itâs a good movie, I recommend it, but what does it have to do with sexual desire? The brain mechanism firing Bill Murrayâs efforts to find his way out of Groundhog Day, to win Andie MacDowell, and to die is the same brain mechanism that makes sexual desire feel like a drive. Hereâs how it works. Imagine a little monitor, like a referee, sitting next to your brainâs emotional One Ring [nagoski's name for the emotional center of the brain through which all emotions pass]. Sheâs got two jobs, this monitor: 1. She watches to make sure the world is behaving according to her expectations (expectations set by all her previous experience with the world). 2. She directs the investigation when there is any discrepancy between the world and her expectations. When the world is meeting her expectations, the monitor feels satisfied. Nothing is lacking. But sometimes there is a gap between the world and the expectationsâsome ambiguity needs to be resolved, some novelty needs to be explored to see where it fits in the expected order of things, or some very appealing stimulus needs to be approached and obtained. When this happens, she goes into command mode. She makes reducing the discrepancy her purpose in life. Her entire world is made up of these three things: ⢠The goal state of closing the gapâwhich might mean resolve the ambiguity, explore the new thing, approach the incentive, or simply complete the task ⢠The effort youâre investing in the pursuit of that goal stateâthe attention, resources, and time youâre allocating to it ⢠The progress youâre making toward that goal state In Bill Murrayâs case, the goal state is, among other things, Andie MacDowell; the efforts he invests are all the hilarious things he tries, like memorizing her favorite drink and toast (âTo world peaceâ); and the progress he makes is absolutely nilâuntil the very end, of course. When sex feels like a drive, the goal state is the sexually appealing incentiveâusually a partner, but if you have a very sensitive accelerator, the world might just be a turn-on all the time. The efforts you invest are all the pitching woo and initiating and seduction you can muster. Exactly what this is varies from culture to culture and from person to person. (Thereâs the old joke: Whatâs foreplay to an Irishman? âBrace yourself, Bridget.â) And your progress is how much closer you get to engaging sexually with the appealing incentive. So the little monitor keeps track of how much progress youâre making in relation to how much effort youâre investing. She tallies your effort-to-progress ratio, and she has a strong opinion about what that ratio should be. This opinion is called âcriterion velocity.â And this is where it gets really interesting. When the monitor feels that youâre making good progressâwhen youâre matching or exceeding the criterion velocityâshe is satisfied, motivated, eager. But when the monitor feels that youâre not making enough progress, she begins to become frustrated, and she prompts you to increase your efforts to get closer to your goal. If you still arenât making enough progress to satisfy the little monitor, she begins to get angry . . . and then enraged! And eventually, if you continue to fall short, at a certain point the little monitor gives up and pushes you off an emotional cliff into the âpit of despair,â as the monitor becomes convinced that the goal is unattainable. You give up in hopeless desolation. Bill Murrayâs little monitor goes berserk. Boy howdy, is the world not following the rules, and nothingânot even dying!âis effective in reaching the goal. What the hell?! When youâre continually failing to reach a sexual incentive, your little monitor grows frustrated and then angered and eventually despairing. And thatâs why it sometimes feels like an unpleasant internal experience. Itâs not the desire itself that feels unpleasant, itâs your criterion velocity being unsatisfied. In other words, itâs not how you feel . . . itâs how you feel about how you feel. When I teach about the little monitor, my studentsâ eyes widen and their jaws drop. The little monitor is a crucial part of your sexual wellbeing, but she shows up in nearly every domain of life. If youâve felt the thrill of winning a race or a game, thatâs your little monitor having her criterion velocity satisfiedâeffort-to-progress ratio met or exceeded! If youâve experienced road rage, thatâs your little monitorâs how-long-this-trip-should-be-taking criterion velocity going unmetâeffort-to-progress ratio much too large! If youâve ever collapsed in a hopeless heap in the face of failure, thatâs your little monitor reassessing a goal state as unattainable, uncontrollable. The little monitor and her opinions about how effortful things should be is the foundation of a wide range of frustrations and satisfactions, sexual desire not least among them. impatient little monitors Our culture absolutely teaches us to have impatient little monitors, with criterion velocities set as small as they can be, which means many of us are easily frustrated, enraged, and eventually despairing when we canât get what we wantâincluding sex. We can extend this, too, and notice how responsive-desire folks feel about their âlackâ of desire: If you feel like you should want sex, but you donât, youâll begin to get frustrated . . . and will that frustration make you more likely to want sex? Quite the opposite. The little monitor is a gremlin of irony. Unlike the One Ring and the brakes and accelerator, we can create intentional change in the little monitor. Actually, humans may be the only species that can do something deliberate about this kind of frustration, and I bet if you think critically about it for a minute you can work out how to do it. There are three potential targets of change, right? Thereâs the goal. For spontaneous folks, the goal is the object of desire, and for responsive folks, the goal is the desire itself. Thereâs the effort youâre putting in. And thereâs the effort-to-progress ratio that causes you to feel satisfied or dissatisfied, the criterion velocity. So that means there are three questions to ask yourself when youâre experiencing frustrations around sexual desire: ⢠Is this the right goal for me? ⢠Am I putting in the right kind of effort, as well as the right amount? ⢠Am I realistic in my expectation about how effortful this goal should be? In terms of managing sexual desire in your relationship, the key is to differentiate between the desire and your feelings about the desire."










