Cut Man
Synopsis: Matt can't be reached and you're stuck doing damage control. The peculiar FBI agent may not be as bad as you thought. w.c. 3.8k.
cw: alcohol consumption, platonic relationships, Reader exists outside of the DD plot (is this a warning?), she investigates a murder-mystery, a bit of Reader's lore, a bit more Dex interaction, not completely proofread
<- last chapter/next chapter ->
You laid awake in the dark of your apartment, staring at the corkboard hung by your dining area. Notes, news clippings, and red string connected everything in chronological order. Post-its were spread around in questions you still couldn't crack. Aveline Academy for Girls. An older boarding school in Manhattan; prestigious in every sense of the word. Within the last decade, the institution allowed mutants and children of mutant parents into their halls. Within the last month, a typed letter arrived to the mansion that described the truly terrible conditions behind gilded doors. No signature.
Even if it was some sick prank, you did your due diligence and dug deeper. All you found were allegations, rumors, and old forums created by concerned mothers that were discontinued. The academy seemed to have great PR and an even better legal team. That was when you found it. An article by the Bulletin dating to the first week of this month, written by Ben Urich. Two girls were reported missing to NYPD a year ago and one of their bodies was discovered deceased. Your stomach churned as your eyes skimmed the words. Both students of Aveline Academy for Girls. One still missing. An edit was made the day after the initial release to include a generic statement from the school. You can only guess who authored the letter to the mansion.
The lack of attention was alarming. Considering Duncan reached out, his department had caught wind of something themselves. You wanted so badly to investigate the institution in person, making it your best interest to work with the feds on this one. You idly rubbed your neck, feeling the raised skin of the scar that wrapped around.
There was another matter at hand. Special Agent Benjamin Poindexter. Why did he throw you off so much? He was simply doing his job by providing insight with his partner, Ray. What was stranger was how he approached you after. He was quick to offer in escorting you out of the building and before you could politely reject him, Duncan practically pushed both of you towards the elevator. You held your notes tightly to your chest the entire time.
When you chanced a glance as you hit the lobby, he was already looking at you. He guided you out with that smile again, but the sharpened edges smoothened to something approachable. He even walked you all the way to your car and sent you off with a, "Have a good day, Miss Howlett." You saw him in your rear view mirror, even as you peeled away from the parking lot. It almost felt like he was trying to overcompensate for something.
Doubt warred with your gut feeling. Were you…imagining things earlier?
You thunked your head on the wooden table to snap out of it. No use in lamenting over it. You looked out your window at the dark sky. You grabbed your phone and purse, heading straight out the door with one destination in mind.
You stood outside of Nelson & Murdock and, unsurprisingly, saw a hint of light inside. You quietly opened the door and saw Karen rummaging around the front desk. You were elated by how quickly you two got along when you met at the Italian place. Her head turned to the door in alarm, only to relax once she saw it was you.
"(Y/N). Do you…always come by this late?" She spoke quietly as she returned to looking through boxes. You smiled as you approached her, "I try not to, but it's not hard to predict these two working late."
Your eyebrow furrowed in concern, "Hey, they're not making you—"
She cut you off with a wave of her hand, "No, no, nothing like that. I…want to be here and lend a hand. Besides, you really think they'll unpack all of this?" She gestured to the many boxes of documents and who knows what else littering behind the desk. You facepalmed, readying an apology for the two men before your train of thought was derailed by…singing?
You and Karen froze as you stared at each other. Foggy's passionate sea shanty ricocheted the office. As any good friend would, you whipped out your phone and pressed record. The camera pointed towards his office as you bit your lip to hold back your laugh. Her hands pressed over her mouth to hide her smile before she called out, "You know I'm still here, right?"
The song immediately ceased and a clattering of items rattled behind his door before he yanked it open. Karen waved at him cheekily. "Could you…could you hear me just now?"
"Nope!"
He looked at her first before he stared straight into your phone's camera. You cut off the recording then, bursting out into raucous laughter. Foggy's ears reddened and he tried to swipe your phone. You grinned as you moved backwards, rounding the desk to put the blonde between the two of you.
"The correct answer is, 'Yes, and you sound amazing.'" Karen stuttered out a response, face torn between an amused smile and a neutral expression, "W-Well, of the two lies, I took the lesser."
Foggy looked past her to glare at you, pointing. "Who let you in?"
"I let myself in."
"Give me your phone."
"No."
Karen moved around you to continue with unloading the boxes. Foggy's irritated look softened into one of curiosity as he looked at her, "I thought you went home. What are you still doing here?" She stood straight, "Uh…I could ask you the same." She grabbed a box that she left on her chair and scoot it under the desk. She turned her attention to another that was on top.
"Yes, but I am a partner at a prestigious law firm with very important documents needing to be documented," he paused, before gesticulating, "…so we can start generating some revenue, while you are…"
Karen held a document as she stared with a disbelieving smile, waiting for him to finish. Foggy quickly realized his mistake and tried to backtrack, "…also very integral in your own special, manager—" He cut himself off with a sigh and she chuckled at his embarrassment, hand on her hip. You buried your face in your hands in mortification.
He looked genuinely remorseful as he cringed, "I dug myself in too deep and I can't climb out."
Karen responded with her smile still in place, "You need a hand with that?"
"Please."
"Oh! Not gonna happen." She smirked, looking back down at the document she held.
You nudged one of the many boxes with your shoe, "I thought you were a lawyer." Foggy rolled his eyes, "I don't want to hear it, Frosty." He looked at Karen again, "Seriously, what are you still doing here?"
"I have work to do." Karen didn't spare a glance as she sorted through the same box.
"What work? We don't have any clients yet."
"Well, your shit's not gonna unpack itself." Karen put down the document she held in a frustrated motion, hands moving to gesture at the mess. Foggy moved towards the desk, "This box of vital import will be here in the morning." He made a point to smack his hands on top of it as if to prove it's tangibility meant that it wouldn't disappear any time soon.
He drove his point home as he gestured towards the dark sky, "You should be out having a life, doing poppers and flapper dancing! I…don't know what kids do these days!" His outstretched hand landed on you, "Or a girls night! Women still have those, right?"
Karen let out a laugh as she responded to his ranting, "We're the same age, Foggy."
That made him pause. "So you're saying I shouldn't be here, either?"
"Yeah."
"Fair enough." He put a hand in his pocket as he spoke matter of factly, "But I'm awkward and unfashionable." His tone softened as he met her eyes, "Those things don't seem to apply to you." You gaped from your spot behind Karen where you crouched to snoop through a box. Third wheeling was the last thing you expected coming here.
Karen was speechless for a moment at his sincerity before tilting her head down, "I just don't feel like going home…ok?"
Foggy nodded in somber understanding before perking up, "Well, we can't stay here. Not enough money in the kitty to keep the lights on past midnight." His tone and expression turned into something mischievous as he sat at the corner of the desk. "So let's hop a few bars, not think about it."
Karen's demeanor immediately brightened, smiling, "Yes. Big fan of the not thinking." Foggy stood, clapping his hands victoriously, "You will fit in right in here!" You tried sneaking away, you really did. Until you felt the back of your shirt get snagged by a hand, "Hey!"
"All of us, (Y/N). C'monnnn, it's always fun!" Foggy's grin made you scowl. You knew exactly what your role was going to be when you saw that glimmer in his eye. Karen gathered her items, "Should we call Matt?" Foggy dragged you towards the door like a disgruntled cat, "Sure. Yeah, let's see what he's up to." They both dialed his number and even you humored them by dialing him. No response. For some reason, you felt uneasy.
About five bars later, it only made sense to end at Josie's. Foggy, with his free hand, left Matt another voice message, "Matt, it's me again. Where are you? (Y/N) and I are introducing Karen to Josie's, and I have high hopes it's going to go terribly." He whisper-yelled the last of the message, "Climb off whoever you're on and get down here."
He pulled you onto a stool and he sat next to you. Karen, despite the alcohol in her system, still managed to look around warily at the dimly lit and, admittedly, rundown bar. She sat down next to him, "You saved the best for last, huh?" Foggy didn't even try to pretend as he grabbed three shot glasses over the counter, "Oh, yeah, this place is a shithole…but it's our shithole."
He continued with a self-satisfied grin, "The city's tried to shut it down half a dozen times, but I helped Josie with the liens, and as a result, we get to drink for free!" He looked over pointedly at the disgruntled Josie. The woman gave a sarcastic smile as she pushed a bottle towards him, "You absolutely do not get to drink for free."
Foggy, undeterred, took the bottle, "Let's agree to disagree!"
Josie then pushed another bottle towards you, "But this little missy does." You strained a smile, "Oh, no, Josie, I couldn't—" She rolled her eyes as she popped it open, "Good grief, girl. Accept generosity every now and then, will you?" She stepped away to attend other patrons and you met Karen's curious eyes.
"It wasn't that big of a deal, y'know? I just…helped this side of the city from a rampaging Juggernaut. Josie's was just one of the places I kept him from destroying." You almost felt bashful, the back of your neck starting to feel warm. Foggy scoffed loudly, pouring alcohol into his and Karen's shot glasses.
"So not fair. Not all of us can be cool superheroes, y'know. G-Get it? Cool? Cuz you're—"
You patted his shoulder to at least try to get him to shut up, "Yes, Foggy, I got it." You met Karen's still curious look again. You've seen that shine in her eyes in others and steeled yourself for the incoming questions. She leaned in slightly.
"So you're really—"
"Yes, I'm an X-Men. I was raised in Xavier's School for Gifted Youngsters."
"Do you know—"
"Yes, I know many other X-Men members and have worked with them."
"Are you—"
"No, I'm not biologically related to Wolverine. He's my adoptive father." Despite your lax attitude, you felt a bit of tension welling up in your shoulders. Karen's eyebrows furrowed. "Adoptive?"
Foggy smoothly cut in as he shoved her glass into her hands, looking at her expectantly, "Cheers!" Karen was tipsy to the point that her attention span was short enough. She clinked her glass against his and they tipped their heads back. You felt yourself relax just slightly at the shift. As Karen gagged and coughed at the hard liquor, you glanced down and saw a layer of frost spider-webbing where you were gripping the bottle. Great.
Josie had popped up again and shook her head at Karen with a pitying smile, "You can do so much better, love." Foggy, at the insinuation, resisted an eye roll as he poured into the shot glasses again. His voice was thick with sarcasm, "Thank you, Josie, but this is my employee…for your information, and we are not on a date." He paused briefly as he looked at Karen.
"Are we on a date?"
"Definitely not."
The only sound from you was you thunking your forehead against the rim of your untouched bottle.
Foggy matched Karen's playful tone, "Okay, good…because I was starting to worry you might be in love with me." That was when you stood, the feeling of intruding getting too much. "Bathroom break! Be right back!" You ruffled Foggy's hair and squeezed Karen's shoulder as you passed by. You spent a long while locked in the bathroom. You took out your phone at some point and stared at Matt's contact. You breathed in quietly before pressing on it. You watched it ring, and ring, and ring…right to voicemail.
"Hey, Matty, uh…just…hope you're safe. Wherever you are. Karen and Foggy are three sheets to the wind right now. But I know they're worried. You'll probably see their calls and the rest of mine. Foggy's also doing a terrible job at flirting and Karen's eating it up anyway. Help."
You ended the voice message with a smile. You looked at yourself one last time before stepping out. As you walked back to your friends, you felt an incoming headache as the two were barely able to sit. You caught Karen by the arm before she tripped and hauled Foggy up. "Nope. Nope. That's enough for tonight."
Unfortunately, drunk adults are the equivalent to toddlers as they only giggled and beeline towards the exit. Foggy screamed cheerfully as he shoulder checked the already busted door, "Let's go see Matt!" On the way to the man's apartment, you prevented at least three car crashes and seven collisions against inanimate objects. Your nerves were shot by the time you arrived to Matt's door. Foggy smacked his hand on the wood in a rhythmic knocking, yelling, "Matt!"
You held Karen up as she giggled at nothing, her arm over your neck and yours around her torso. You hissed quietly at him, "Foggy, be—"
"MATT! Come ON! Get up!"
You closed your eyes in resignation. Foggy broke into a fit of giggles, "I drank the eel." Karen, in response, let out a snort and even more laughter, "Oh, no." His glassy eyes turned to where she slumped over you, "Not a euphemism." Foggy smacked his hand again, "MATT I KNOW YOU'RE IN THERE! GET UP!" Karen halfheartedly pushed his arm to shush him, only to giggle again. Foggy stepped to the side, looking at you two.
"Here, you talk to him." He leaned forward as he very loudly whispered, "Pretend I'm not here." Your lips thinned as you stared at the wooden door. Considering he's gone radio silent, was he even here? You withheld a sigh, "Matt, it's (Y/N). Karen's here, too. I wouldn't come out if I were you." Karen then yelled out, laughing, "I think I also drank the eel!" You caught her as she bowed forward, "Karen—!"
Foggy made a clawed motion with his hands, which did nothing to quell her drunken amusement, "And we are FILLED with mighty eel strength!" They both kept calling his name loudly and you were trying to shush them. You half considered letting Karen fall to the floor. Your admonishing was drowned out by Foggy's proclamations of going to the fish market. The click of a door opening had you whipping your head to Matt's neighbor that lived across from him. An older woman named Fran.
Karen also turned her head and she slapped her free hand over her mouth, "Oh, no. Oh, Foggy." Foggy turned and it almost looked like he sobered up, "Oh, hi, Fran…" They both apologized and you really thought that'd be the end of it and everyone would go home.
"You wanna go to the fish market?"
You looked at him with a murderous expression. You definitely were posting that video.
The morning after felt like you were the one out getting shit-faced. Your head pounded the moment you woke up and you groaned into your pillow. The feeling of your phone buzzing against your shoulder had you twisting to look at the Caller ID.
Frederick Duncan.
You shot up and ignored the dizziness from the sudden movement, "Hello?"
"Miss (Y/N)! How are you this beautiful morning? I do apologize for taking so long to get back to you. This may be a hassle, but…can you swing by the office today by noon?"
You blinked in surprise and glanced at the clock in your bedroom, "Yes, I can…um…does this have to do with the case?" At your question, you felt his pleasant mood shift to something serious, "Yes, it does. If I may be frank with you, the sooner you arrive, the better." You stood up from bed, eyebrows furrowed.
"I'll be there soon."
"Good. When you're here, step into the conference room from last time."
With that, the line went dead. You stared at the black screen of your phone, your reflection pinched with worry. You dashed around to get ready, but right before you stepped out of the apartment, you realized you skipped a vital duty. You posted Foggy's video on social media with a caption before nodding in satisfaction.
You arrived to the office in record time. You smiled politely at the front desk lady and she returned it, "Miss Howlett. Please, go ahead. Mr. Duncan stepped out and he will be back shortly." You nodded in response and walked towards the frosted glass doors. You can make out the warbled figure of someone already inside. You opened the door and your heart sank. Dark blue blazer and slacks, perfectly pressed white button up, and combed over dirty blond hair. Dex, professional as ever, sat on one side of the long table. You smiled politely as you closed the door behind you.
"Dex. Good morning." You sat across from him and felt unnervingly aware of yourself with his sharp gaze. He returned your smile. Did it change again? You set down your notepad and dug for a pen in your purse, "Will Ray also be joining?" A large part of you hoped that he would to make this less awkward.
Dex was chipping at your character bit by bit. The most obvious facts about you were that you were professional, tidy, inquisitive, and a little too observant. All characteristics required for your position, he surmised. You stiffened when presented with something you couldn't solve immediately. He handed you a pen from his blazer's pocket and your face went from surprised to grateful. Your expression almost made his skin crawl with insecurity. How can you be so genuine? You didn't put up a front and you spoke truthfully. His other hand twitched where it rested on his thigh.
"Thank you."
"No problem, Miss Howlett."
You met his gaze, fiddling with the pen, "You can call me (Y/N). It's only appropriate, don't you think?" You saw the way your request registered in his head. It was like an advanced machine taking less than a second to reboot before he nodded, "Of course. (Y/N). Ray's held up on another case so he won't be joining us today."
"I see."
You put down the pen before you made a fool of yourself by having it fly to a corner of the room. You laced your hands, posture relaxing as you accepted that you had to grow up and communicate with the man, "How long have you been FBI?" Dex didn't let it show that he was thrown off by the small talk. He leaned against his chair in a casual stance, hand inside his pocket, "Two years now." That made you pause.
"Oh! That's…I'm a little surprised, actually." You chuckled under your breath. Dex's head tilted in question, "Surprised?" You sat up straight as you realized how your words may have come across, "I-I just mean, y'know, I think back to when we first met. You were so well spoken—not that you aren't—and the way you see things are refreshing. You're a very intelligent and capable man, so, I figured you must have a wealth of experience in the FBI. You must really be amazing to have gotten the attention of Mr. Duncan and be put on this case with only two years." You ended with a sheepish smile.
Dex stared at you with an eerily blank look and your heart twisted. Did you say something wrong? Why did he look at you like that? Before you could say anything else, Duncan walked in with an apologetic smile, "Sorry about that, folks. I was pulled into an emergency directors meeting." He sat at the front of the table, between you and Dex. He grinned as he set down his leather briefcase, "If you ask me, it could've been an email."
You forced a smile at his joke. You dismissed your worried thoughts as you focused on the updates from Duncan, scribbling on your notepad and asking follow-up questions. Dex asked his own, seemingly having returned to normal. Once the meeting ended, Duncan was running off again for another meeting. You gathered your stuff and handed Dex's pen back to him.
"Here. Thanks, again."
"Keep it. I have plenty."
You blinked then smiled, "Sure." He beat you to the door as he held it open, "I'll walk you out." Your previous worry subsided at his offer. Maybe you didn't totally kill your work relationship. You found the confidence to ask more questions, partly due to feeling bad from earlier. You weren't sure yet of what, though, but the feeling was there.
That night, Dex sat on his dining room table. His blazer was off and his sleeves were rolled to his elbows. His hands were clasped together as he stared at them. His thoughts were going a mile a second, rattling in his skull. Intelligent. Capable. Amazing. You, with your honest nature, was awed by who he tried so hard to be. You, who was a hero in every sense of the word, praised him. He smiled shakily as a tremor threatened to overtake his hands. He was doing good. He instinctively glanced at the picture framed by his door. The group of people stared back at his hopeful gaze, but his eyes were glued to one person. A red head with the brightest smile. Would she see that good, too?
TAGLIST: @gojoswaterbottle @m4ngo15













