The Not-So-Secret-Santa (pegtha)
Summary: When one has the trademark loudmouths, Thomas Jefferson, Hercules Mulligan, and Alexander Hamilton, in on a game that requires secretiveness⊠letâs just say, things donât go as planned. Prompt: Secret Santa Beginning Notes: more christmas gays!
When Angelica Schuyler walked into the coffee shop her group of friendsâand little sistersâfrequented, she commanded attention. Especially judging from the way a scowl painted her gorgeous features, and her eyes seemed narrowed into thin, angry slits. Now, it may just be James Madisonâs imagination playing tricks on him, but the young man is almost a thousand percent sure that the entireâextremely busy, what with it being colder than a well diggerâs ass outsideâcoffee shop goes silent when she enters.
âAngelica!â Eliza says, looking up from where sheâd been texting Alexanderâwho, out of their merry band of friends, was the only one not in attendanceâand waving her sister over. âOver here!â
Angelica maneuvers her way through the crowd of peopleâbut not before stopping briefly at the cash register to order a coffeeâand joins the group sitting in the back. Theyâve somehow managed to crowd themselves into the only booth big enough to fit all twelve of themâand even so, several people have pulled chairs up to the table in order to fit comfortably. Angelica takes a chair from Lafayetteâwho goes to drape themselves over the laps of Hercules and Georgeâand slams her coffee cup down onto the table.
âWhere the hell is Alexander? And Samuel, King and Charles?â she asks with an edge to her voice, noticing the absence of bickering that usually went on between her brother-in-law and his frenemies. None of them were anywhere in sight. âI thought I told you that I need all of you here.â
âAlex got caught up at the station,â Eliza says, pausing to take a sip of coffee. âAnd those three had to go and meet Charlesâ parents for lunch. Sammy just told me to text him whatever you needed to tell us and heâd relay it to the group.â
Sighing at her friends total inability to follow simple instructions, Angelica looks around at the people that were there. Thomas, James and Aaron had all managed to show upâwhich was a feat in and of itself. For a polyamorous couple, it seemed very rare that anyone managed to catch more than two of them together at a time. There was always one out of the three missingâat work, running errands, out of town.
George was there, as well, which was pretty shocking. He was so busy with being a congressman most of the time that he was hardly ever aroundâso much so that for the first year of his relationship with Hercules and Lafayette, Angelica had thought it was just those two. She hadnât even known that George was a part of their romance until she attended a housewarming party for Peggy and accidentally walked in on three of them getting hot and heavy in a closet.
And Peggy. Peggy always seemed to be working at her actual jobâshe worked at the very cafe that Angelica told them to meet inâor on her youth programs. Sheâalong with John Laurens, who seemed very zoned out on whatever he was doodling on the cafe napkinsâwas an activist that ran several non-profit charities for youth. Big Brother, Big Sister mentoring guides for LGBTQ+ kids, scholarship programs for inner-city kids and all-girls empowerment summer camp for preteen and teenage girls. The poor woman was so busy with all of these endeavors that it was rare that Angelica and Eliza were able to get together with her, which is why Angelica chose her lunch break during work to meetup with the gang.
âWhatâs up, Angie? Whyâd you need us all here?â Thomas asks, snapping the woman from her reverie. Angelica exhales, looks around at the group one last time before making sure to turn her attention to her sisters.
âMom and Dad called me last night. They said we wonât be having our annual family Christmas like usual,â she pauses here to gauge her sisters reactions, and is surprised to not find the level of distress that she thought she would. Both girls seem pretty bummed, but not as devastated as sheâd expected. âSo, I was wondering if the rest of you were busy this Christmas, and if not, if we could plan something for us here. Like a family.â
âWell, my Dad doesnât want me bringing these two back if I go down to Virginia for Christmas, so Iâm pretty freed up,â George says, adding a packet of artificial sweetner to his coffee in an attempt to look boredâthough everyone sitting at the booth can tell just how hurt he is at this. âHercules just has James here and Marie said she canât go back to France.â
âMy grandmother⊠when I told her I was trans, she uh⊠she told me that she never wanted to see my face again. However, Adrienne is coming into town. If I celebrate with you all, can she come as well?â Marie asks, leaning her head on the heel of her hand. Angelica waves her hand in dismissal, though she can tell by the way Marieâs eyes light up that sheâs made her friend extremely happy.
âThatâs absolutely fine, hon. What about you guys?â Angelica nods towards the end of the booth, where Thomas, Aaron and James were chatting quietly amongst themselves. They all look up in confusionâmaking it obvious to the woman that they hadnât been paying attention. âDoing anything for Christmas?â
âWell,â Aaron begins. âI usually spend my Christmasâ watching Lifetime movies and eating takeout, so⊠no. Iâm free.â
âEver since Herc and Iâs parents passed, I just spend it doing whatever Hercules does. Why?â
âIâm not going back to Virginia this year, my mother has a new boyfriend and I donât really feel like being around all that mess.â
âGood. Youâre spending the holidays with us. Alright, Iâve got Marie, Thomas, Adrienne, James, Hercules, George, and myself. Eliza, Peggy?â Angelica begins scribbling the names down on a notepad from her purse, formulating a guest list so that sheâd know how much cooking sheâd need to do for the holiday at hand.
âIâm down, but can I bring Martha? Sheâs like the Scrooge of Christmasâhates the holidays. I wanna show her true Christmas joy, yâknow. Itâll be romantic. Might even get laid.â John audibly groans at how cliche Peggy sounds, before reminding her that sheâs talking about his stepsisterâso show a little decorum. The woman sticks her tongue out at him, and Angelica laughs at the two before agreeing.
âWell, since Martha is going⊠John you might as well go,â Eliza says, looking to her boyfriendâwho wrinkles his nose. âCâmon. Alex and I are definitely going, and you know you donât want to go back to South Carolina for Christmas. Itâll be fun! We can do Secret Santa!â
âOoh, yes!â Marie exclaims, removing her sketchpad from her satchel. She flips to an empty page and begins scribbling everyoneâs names down. âOkay⊠Angelica, let me see your beanie.â
Angelica hands over the hat, eyebrow raised. With careful and precise fingers, Marie rips the paper with the names into small little shredsâeach shred of paper holding someoneâs name. She folds them in half before dumping them all into the beanie.
âIâm adding Charles, King and Sammy in here⊠Eliza, you can pick for the three of them and text them who they got,â Marie says, dumping the shreds of paper into the hat and mixing them around. âJohn, you pick for Alex but donât look at who he got, alright? Just give him the paper when you see him. Rules for the Secret Santa? You obviously canât tell the person youâre buying for that itâs you, no going over thirty dollars for materials, no buying gift cards, and you have to make it.â
Thereâs voices of protest at the last rule, but the look Marie sends the group could rival Angelicaâs. It doesnât, of course, because Angelica is the queen of glaringâbut it could.
Marie takes a slip of paper from the hat before passing it to Hercules, who repeats the motion. The beanie goes around the table until it ends with George removing the last piece of paper.
Angelica grins at the name on her piece of paper. Â Eliza and Thomas both groanâprobably because the people they chose are difficult to shop for. Peggy does a fist pump, John smiles wistfully, James, George and Aaron seem to be indifferent either way, and Hercules gives a smile that says âoh, this will be very funâ.
âWho did you get?â John asks his girlfriend, as he, Eliza and Alex push their cart around the crafts shop. Theyâd all agreed to go shopping for their materials at the same time, in the same placeâto save money, and gas. However, the young brunette sitting in the cart is quickly becoming to regret agreeing upon thatâseeing as this is the sixth time John has asked her this question, and Alexander had asked twelve times before. Eliza looks up at him with an expression that can only be described as a mixture between âoffenseâ and âexhaustionâ. âWhat? Iâm just curious!â
âYeah, and curiosity killed the cat,â she teases, before directing him to turn down the aisle that has yarn. âIâve already said this, John! I canât tell you! Itâs called a Secret Santa! What if you tell them that Iâm the one making their present? Geez, I know youâre a rebel, but it canât be this hard for you to follow the rules.â
âWow. Youâre really passionate about the doâs and donâts of Secret Santa, arenât you?â he asks, as she directs him to put some navy blue yarn in the cart. She nods her head just as Alexander comes bolting towards them with arms full of markers, crayons, colored pencils and pens.
âAlex! Youâre supposed to be shopping for materials for your Secret Santa, not thing you like,â Eliza chastises playfully, before squeaking in indignance when he dumps all the materials on her.
âShut up. Iâm making John a poster,â he says.
âAlex!â Eliza whines, and John laughs loudly. Well, at least he could trust that his gift would be made with love.
Lafayette sits cross-legged in the middle of their living room, hands gently maneuvering the clay on the pottery wheel. Their eyes are concentrated on the machine, all of their attention focused on the design of the clay to make the shape they want.
âLaffy, Iâm sorry darlinâ, but Iâm curious. Who in the hell would want a homemade clay pot?â George asks, looking down at them from his spot on the couch. Heâd been focused on CNN news, but the gentle whirring of the machine had drawn his attention several minutes ago and the curiosity had been eating at him. Lafayette doesnât offer a response, simply shrugs their shoulders and continues to gently knead the clay on the wheel. âI canât think of anyone in our group that would find use for that.â
âThen youâre not thinking hard enough,â they respond calmly, reaching their hand into the opening in order to manipulate the shape even further. George opens his mouth to retort something equally as sassy, but Hercules enters their apartment at that very momentâarms filled to the brim with varying colors of yarnâsoft pinks and blues, bright neon greens and yellows⊠and just as George is confused as to who in their circle of friends would want a flower pot, he is confused as to who would want all those colors clashing together.
âYâknow, mo chroĂ, youâre an awfully hard person to drum up ideas for,â Hercules says, dumping the materials beside George on the couch to press a kiss to their forehead. Lafayette gives a squeal of annoyance at Hercules having revealed who he was Secret Santa-ing to; and by relation having revealed who Lafayetteâs Secret Santa is.
âHerc, mon coeur! It was supposed to be a surprise, non?â they exclaim, finally tearing their eyes away from their pottery. âYouâve ruined it for me!â
âAw man, Iâm sorry, Laf!â Hercules responds, plopping down beside them on the floor. At first George believes heâs being sarcastic, but when his eyes land on his boyfriendâs face, he can tell that heâs genuinely apologetic. Itâs cute, how he recognizes the importance of this to Lafayette and respects that. âThis Secret Santa thing slipped my mind.â
âHey, darlinâ, the surprise isnât entirely ruined,â George pipes up, easing down onto the floor with the other to. âYou donât know what heâs going to make. I promise, Iâll help Herc hide whatever heâs making for you, so that you can be surprised on Christmas. Sound good?â
And though Lafayette is still pouting, both men can tell that this considerably makes it better.
âI donât even know Maria that well!â Thomas exclaims for what seems to be the billionth time since they got who theyâd be making presents for, as he scrolls through ideas for gifts on Pinterest. âWhy canât I just buy her something? Itâd be so much easier!â
âFirstly, Thomas, the whole point of Secret Santa was for us not to know who youâd be making a present for,â Aaron reprimands, for what seems to be the billionth time in response to Thomasâ complaining. Heâs making what seems to be personally designed coffee mugsâusing blank templates and markers designed for ceramic art to design them. Heâd been pretty good at hiding who his present was for, though Thomas can just barely make out a âGâ on one of the mugs. âSecondly, youâre supposed to make it because itâs supposed to come from the heart. These arenât just our friends, theyâre our family, too.â
âThatâs lame,â the Virginian huffs, tossing his phone onto the coffee table. He dramatically drapes himself over the armrest of their couch, tossing his arm over his eyes like the drama queen he is. âWhy canât I just pay someone to make something for me?â
âCan I pay someone to kick your ass? Maybe then youâd stop complaining,â Aaron murmurs under his breath, picking up another marker to doodle something on the coffee mug. Surprisingly, heâs met with silenceâuntil his phone chimes with a notification. Curiously, Aaron picks up his phone to read itâfinding that itâs from Facebook.
Thomas Jefferson â with Maria Reynolds, Angelica Schuyler and 15 others.
Need help coming up with ideas for Mariaâs Secret Santa present⊠anyone care to help out?
âGoddamnit, Thomas, itâs supposed to be a Secret!â James yells from the other roomâobviously having got the notification as well. Thomas gives a groan of annoyance at this, probably remembering that tagging the person youâre going to be Secret Santa-ing for is not the smartest idea.
âBut keeping it secret is hard!â
âLooks like I wonât have to pay anyone to kick your ass,â Aaron chuckles, setting his phone down and glancing towards his boyfriend. Both Thomas and Aaronâs phones are blowing up with notificationsâthough neither of them need to check them to see itâs probably their group of friends reprimanding him on sharing who he was supposed to be the Secret Santa for. Thomas quirks an eyebrow, and his lover finishes with, âAngelica is probably going to do it for me.â
By the time Christmas Day rolls around, most of the people in the group participating know who their Secret Santa isâand those that donât know for sure at least have some sort of inkling. What with loudmouths Alexander Hamilton, Hercules Mulligan and Thomas Jefferson letting everyone know not only who their gifts were for, but who their spouses gifts were for and gossips Peggy and Maria spreading around rumors as to who made presents for who⊠yeah, the whole idea of the Secret Santa actually being a secret was moot.
And Angelica was quick to let the perpetrators know just how disappointed she was in them for not being able to hold water.
âWell,â she says, after theyâve all retired to her living room following a pretty amazing Christmas dinner. Her eyes travel over their facesâand at least most of the culprits have the decency to look ashamed. âThis was supposed to be a Secret Santa, but thanks to a select few that canât seem to let anyone enjoy anything⊠you might as well tell you who brought your gift for that it was you. Iâll start.â
Crossing over to the Christmas tree, Angelica removes a small wrapped box and hands it to Peggyâs girlfriend, Martha. âI looked up how to transfer photographs onto wood, and then I got this picture from Peggy. It didnât come out as good as I thought it would, but I figured you would like it.â
Itâs a professionally taken photoâprobably taken by Charles who was a photographer. The two women were on the beach, and Martha had her arms draped over Peggyâs shoulders. Peggyâs hand came up in the photo to hold Marthaâs, and her head was turned just slightly to the side to press a kiss against her cheek. Martha had that picture posted across all of her social media accountsâit was her profile picture for Instagram, Facebook, Twitter⊠sheâd told Peggy countless times that it was her favorite photograph.
âAw, Angie, I love it!â Martha exclaims, taking the block of wood from her adopted sister. âThank you, so much! Iâm going to put it up in my office.â
After hugging Angelica in thanks, Martha goes over to the tree to get the present that she made for Peggy. Except, she didnât make it. Itâs a small box, wrapped in gold wrapping paper, and when she presents it to Peggy she drops onto one knee.
Everyone in the room either gasps or goes deathly silent.
âI admit, I cheated,â Martha chuckles, looking up at her girlfriend as she removes the wrapping paper and flips open the lid on the box. The ring inside is gorgeousâand it has two birthstones on it, with a small engraving that no one can really read. âI didnât make this. I bought it, from George. I um⊠Iâve been dating you, Peggy, for about two years. When I first met you at Johnâs birthday party, something told me that Iâd need to do anything to keep you in my life forever. From your big heart to your sweet soul⊠I knew you were the one for me. And day in, day out you prove that to me. So Iâve decided that I need to do something to prove it to you. And this is it. Will you⊠will you marry me?â
Peggy is speechless. She opens and closes her mouth several times, eyes watering with tears, before finally she throws her arms around her girlfriendâfiancee nowâand simply nods her head.
Well, at least some secret presents could be kept.
Translations
mo chroĂ â my heart (Irish)
mon coeur â my heart (French)








