TADC Criticism: 9 Episodes Was Intentional, But It's Not Enough
[THIS IS NOT MEANT AS HATE OR HARRASSMENT TOWARDS GOOSEWORX]
I have seen and heard the idea spreading around among fans that Gooseworx was 'forced' by Glitch to only have 9 episodes for her show, so criticizing the pacing and other writing choices is pointless because there's no world in which there could have been more or longer episodes to resolve these issues.
Gooseworx herself has said this is untrue:
9 episodes was an intentional decision by Gooseworx, who wanted to end the series on her own terms. The thing is, however, that TADC has shown itself to increasingly struggle with its 9 episode structure because it doesn't have enough time to explore its own plot and characters.
Screen time that could have been used for important character development or interactions that move the plot forward are instead spent on things like the intermission, the extensive acid trip scene, and the poorly rendered fish gag, among other things.
Due to the series' limited run, it needed to use its screen time carefully, which it did not do. Instead, we get the light implication that Something Happened off screen where nobody gets to see it.
Some examples:
In Episode 6's ending, Ragatha and Pomni are going to have an important conversation about their awkward relationship. The viewer is led to believe this will happen in the next episode. It doesn't.
In Episode 5's ending, Jax and Pomni are going to have a conversation about something in the hallway that brings them closer together. The viewer is led to believe this will happen in the next episode. It doesn't.
In Episode 7, Pomni is going to have a conversation with the NPC Abel that convinces and motivates her to trust him. Instead of seeing this conversation, we're granted several minutes of Jax nakedly drifting through space. You might argue, "But that was showing us how abstraction works!" Yes, but the scene did not need to be as long as it was.
Throughout the show, Zooble's arc of self acceptance vs their body dysphoria will supposedly be explored in more depth starting from Episode 3. It isn't. By Episode 7, they're apparently over it now. I don't remember when that happened. But wait no they're not because they can still be tortured about it.
I'm not saying that the show needed five more seasons, but it could've done with more episodes in its single season if we want to keep both the one off jokes like the fish gag and the seemingly inconsequential moments like the intermission, and spend time actually developing the characters.
Because, if I may be brutally honest, there is barely any character development in the show as is. (That is, for characters who aren't named Jax.)
Pomni spends more time reacting than acting, her motivations and feelings are repeatedly left unclear, she barely has any agency or depth due to the fact that her status as the protagonist steadily loses focus in later episodes, and her presence in later episodes often feels like a vehicle for Jax's character development more than anything else.
Pomni doesn't have very strong connections to anyone other than Jax, with whom she has a very casual relationship that was marred by interpersonal conflict that didn't actually go anywhere and now she spends most of her time with him making "I'm here for you!" smiley faces at him. We don't know why she's doing this other than "she's empathetic I guess", we just don't get to know that.
Gangle and Zooble are basically off in their own world separate from everyone else because they barely talk to anyone outside of each other. Gangle has had some development, but she's been a stagnant character since her focus episode and has barely had any lines.
Meanwhile, continuing from the above point, everything we know about Zooble has been left vague and unspecified. "I had dreams and goals! I'm not going to ever mention them prior to this scene or even tell you what they were, though." Okay.
Kinger's character exists to drop convenient lore dumps when he's lucid and to be sillygoofy when he's demented and nothing else. We don't get to know anything else about him other than that he was a programmer and had a wife who got fridged.
On that note, we barely know ANYTHING about the characters' lives before the circus outside of the barebones information given in episodes 3, 4, and 5 about Kinger, Gangle, and Ragatha respectively, or why four out of the six of them want to leave the circus so badly. Why does Gangle want to leave? Why does Pomni want to leave? Why does Ragatha, who has canonically been here for nearly a decade and has had more than enough time to get used to her situation and make peace with the idea of never getting out, want to leave? (Jax and Kinger are the exception because Jax pushed the "keep everyone trapped" button and Kinger seems the least convinced out of everyone that it's even possible to leave the circus at all.)
There's no significant fallout for any of Jax's actions ever because the show does not have enough time to explore any of it, not that it seems to even want to.
Caine's sudden turn into an active and knowing tormentor towards the humans feels less 'intentional' and more 'random and forced for the sake of conflict' in Episode 8 because the build up to his crash out and villainous turn was not built up to well enough for it to feel justified.
Because of the lack of time needed to develop characters and their dynamics with each other, a lot of moments in this show fail to feel earned, the biggest example being Zooble's "You're one of us too, Jax" line in Episode 8. What led Zooble to the point where they're willing to say that to Jax, when three episodes earlier they said they outright hated him, two episodes earlier they were giving a speech to Gangle about her not being Jax's toy, and one episode earlier they were just barely making a connection with him out of practicality more than anything else? Guess we don't get to know that!
Neither Zooble nor Ragatha have episodes focusing on them. What's commonly referred to as Ragatha's episode, Episode 5, was more about Jax than Ragatha herself.
These are just a small handful of examples.
Gooseworx says, "I'd rather not waste people's time with filler." But what critics call 'filler' can actually serve an important narrative function. Slower episodes allow characters to interact and give audiences time to process critical emotional developments. Without these moments, character arcs and dynamics risk feeling underdeveloped.
But at the same time, filler episodes, if done poorly, can be completely useless for the story. For example, there was a small bit of character development, but let's be real - most of Episode 5 is spent doing basically nothing.
Ultimately, the problem is not that the show is only 9 episodes. A tightly written nine episode story could absolutely work. There have been plenty of miniseries with around the same amount, if not less, episodes who do it right. The issue is that the show often spends its limited runtime on extended jokes and inconsequential scenes that serve little purpose to the narrative while pushing important character moments off screen or skipping them entirely. When a story is as constrained as TADC is, every minute matters, and those minutes should ideally be spent deepening the characters and their relationships.
And to be entirely clear, I'm not trying to say the show is unwatchably bad for this. If it was, I wouldn't care anywhere near as much as I do about the show. (And I wouldn't be rewriting the story to have more room to breathe.)
In other words, The Amazing Digital Circus doesn't need five seasons, but the story it wants to tell doesn't always fit comfortably inside the nine episodes it chose to give itself. When key character moments are skipped while jokes and spectacle take center stage, the result is a series that feels like it's constantly hinting at depth rather than actually exploring any of it.
