Young Szeth might have been a budding Truthwatcher
Thereās not much in canon to support this theory, but there are hints that something was going on with Szeth in his youth. In chapter 92 of Oathbringer, he has an exchange with Nightblood that really sounds like he was in the process of bonding a spren when he was young.
Szeth tells Nightblood that he knew a voice like its once. Nightblood asks if Szeth is talking about the whispers and screams he hears in his mind, and Szeth says something like, āNo. A single voice in my mind when I was young. I hope things go better this time.ā The conversation ends there, and weāre never told more about that potential bond in any of Szethās point of view sections after that moment.
Iāve thought of that moment from Oathbringer a lot over the past few months, and Iāve wondered what order would have fit young Szeth best. Thatās hard to answer, since we know almost nothing about his personality before he was made Truthless and exiled from Shinovar. Oathbringer gives more insight into Szethās current personality though, and that, combined with things Iāve gathered from the other books, has helped me make some guesses.
I wasnāt really getting anywhere with speculating about what Order young Szeth could have potentially joined, then a conversation with friends on Discord made me consider the Order of Truthwatchers. I donāt remember the conversation or the context around it. I only remember a sphere lamp coming on in my brain as I realized that Szeth pre-exile could have been a Truthwatcher.
Information about Truthwatchers:
The Coppermind has several things to say about Truthwatchers, so Iāll point out the things that stand out to me the most.
āThose who join the Truthwatchers generally subscribe to a philosophy of finding the ultimate truth and sharing it.ā
This could be an interesting thing for Brandon to explore in Szethās past, especially given modern Szethās difficulty with discerning the truth for himself. We do know that he spoke up and told the leaders of the Shin what he believed, which definitely goes along with this aspect of the Truthwatchers.
āThe order is concerned with the fundamental truths of the universe, and whether or not those in power are being truthful with the people they lead.ā
Again, this could be a great contrast with modern Szeth. Before, he didnāt push back or challenge the leaders. Now, heās going to return to Shinovar to (violently) do exactly that. This sentence might not be the strongest support for past Szeth being a potential Truthwatcher, since we know that he followed the things the Shin leaders said so exactly. That might have been a contributing cause to the budding bond being broken, which Iāll touch on more in a little bit.
āThe order will make their opinions known loudly and forcefully, particularly if they think someone in power is abusing that power or lying about fundamental truths. They tend to attract scientists, scholars, or thinkers of all types.ā
I donāt know if Szeth has ever been loud or forceful, but again, he did speak up when he was younger. That could mean that he once shared his opinions and beliefs more readily than he does currently. He didnāt hold to his convictions strongly enough though. If he had, his life would have gone much differently.
Iām more interested in the second sentence of that last quote. Oathbringer shows that thereās an element of curiosity and desire to learn in Szethās personality that we didnāt really see before. Before that book, we just know that heās good at memorizing palace layouts and lists of orders heās been given. In Oathbringer, though, we see Szeth actually asking questions and trying to understand things around him. He asks the Skybreaker Masters about things related to the Order, the Ideals, and the various tests heās given. We even see him ask Nale a few questions. He also asks Nightblood about its nature, saying things like, āCan you actually see things, Sword-Nimi?ā And, āDo you count yourself as a man?ā These are deep and thoughtful questions from someone who we almost never saw ask things before.
We also see that Szeth is highly observant and able to put pieces together to work out things that have happened. Heās a very intelligent and thoughtful person, and I donāt see that being much different in his past.
All of this is based on my understanding of information weāre given about him in canon. We still know very little about modern unenlightened Truthwatchers, so I canāt say much about things related to that. What I can do is speculate on what might have happened with Szethās budding bond to a Radiant spren.
At some point before becoming convinced that the Radiants and Voidbringers would return, Szeth starts interacting with a strange kind of spren that talks to him, saying things about old Oaths needing to be spoken again and a coming danger. Spren seem to have some kind of religious significance in Stone Shamanism, so Szeth is probably confused and in awe. Maybe it takes the Mistspren time to convince Szeth of what theyāre saying. Szeth swears the First Ideal at some point. He probably has at least a partial understanding of whatās going on, because the Shin obviously maintained some kind of knowledge about the Surges, Radiants, Heralds, and Honorblades.
The Mistspren encourages Szeth to share the truth of whatās coming, which will be his Second Ideal. Szeth probably pushes back for a while, knowing that whatās happening is blasphemous and goes against everything his religion teaches. The spren is persistent, though, so Szeth eventually approaches the leaders and speaks of his convictions. The leaders say heās wrong, that heās a liar, and that the Radiants and Voidbringers are no more. They bind him to the Oathstone, and exile him from Shinovar.
Szeth doesnāt hold to what he knew to be true, which is the first thing that leads to the bond being broken. Another is the way that he unquestioningly accepts what has happened to him. He abandons his truth, believing what the leaders told him.
If there was a conversation or exchange between him and his spren that caused the bond to break, maybe it went something like this:
Mistspren: āRemember what is true. You can still hold to that, even if you werenāt believed.ā
Szeth: āI am Truthless. The Oathstone is my only truth now.ā
Mistspren: āDo you deny that this is true?ā
Szeth: āYes. I was wrong to ever question.ā
The bond breaks, leaving Szeth Truthless with Jezrienās Honorblade. Events go on from there until we see him in the Way of Kings prologue.
Since Iām thinking that Szeth was only at the First or Second Ideal, the Mistspren wouldnāt have become a deadeye. They would have been deeply wounded, but maybe would have been able to eventually recover and form another bond if they wanted.
Iām sure there are things Iāve missed here, but writing this out actually convinced me more of my own theory. I donāt know if anyone will agree or have thoughts/angles/details I overlooked. Regardless, Iām looking forward to reading Szethās flashbacks in book 5, and learning what really happened with his broken Radiant bond.