#matizkraw

On page 38 when Asriel shoots fire towards Frisk, he is NOT trying to kill them!

Even with Chara demanding that Asriel kill Frisk, and Frisk being an easy target, he chooses to block Frisk’s path with fire instead of attacking them directly.

Thank you for asking! First, @karebear221​, as far as an epilogue goes, we originally intended to put the 10 year timeskip at the end of Chapter 11 into an epilogue. However, considering how vital it is to Chara’s arc, we opted to make it a part of the final chapter instead. It really works best there! As far as an epilogue after that, well, maybe you’ll see some art in the next couple of weeks...

Now for the endings; as I always say, you have to get the bad ideas out of the way to get to the good ones. Here are the simply awful rejected endings:

1. Frisk escapes

In this ending, Frisk absorbs Asriel’s soul at the end of their climactic battle with the Horrible Beast. However, they can’t bring themself to leave things as they are, and they reset instead of leaving through the barrier. Due to--uh--magical bullshit, there ends up being two copies of Asriel’s boss monster soul. One that Frisk absorbed before the reset, and one that is still inside Asriel when Frisk undoes his death. Since Frisk now has a boss monster soul, they are able to pass the barrier and leave the Underground.

This one is so bad for so many reasons. First, it relies on some cheap magic time-paradox nonsense to get Frisk out of the Underground. Second, it ruins Frisk’s arc. Running away got them INTO this mess, so it’s thematically a poor writing decision to have it end with them continuing to run away. (There’s not much for them on the Surface anyway.)

2. Asriel Absorbs Chara’s Soul

Second terrible idea: After Chara dies of old age, Asriel absorbs Chara’s soul which causes him to transform into a hideous beast. However, this time Chara is nice about it and the two of them work cooperatively in their shared body. Asriel does not leave the barrier immediately, but it’s implied that they may do so someday.

Ugh, I hate this ending! Chara gets what they want, but it’s a terrible ending for Asriel, who ends up being stuck with Chara FOREVER. Asriel is put in a vulnerable position with literally NO boundaries between him and Chara, AND there’s is no proof that Chara has truly let go of their evil ambitions. This one was quickly scrapped since it sent a bad message and didn’t allow Chara and Asriel to change much from the beginning.

We did include an homage to this ending, when Chara comes up with a “better” plan at the end of Chapter 10. Even if it’s less violent, it still is dependent on controlling Asriel. You’re going to have to do better than that, Chara!

3. Breaking the Barrier with the Captured Souls

Third awful ending, and similar to ending two: After both Chara and Frisk die, Asriel absorbs their souls along with the five children’s souls that Chara harvested. He acquires godlike power and breaks the barrier, freeing monsterkind.

For a while I was really stuck on there being an option to break the barrier by the end of the story. The monsters going free was the goal of the original Undertale, so I assumed that would be the best ending for this story as well.

Unfortunately, this meant that despite everything, Chara, Frisk, and the five other children would be sacrificed in the end. It just felt wrong. In the original game, Frisk helps the monsters but NEVER goes as far as giving up their soul. And because Flowey is a vessel (not a monster) he is able to borrow the human/monster souls to break the barrier and then returns them. The sacrifice isn’t permanent. In the Caretaker AU, that option isn’t available.

There is also the moral issue of Asriel and Frisk being stuck with Chara for all eternity, and it’s unfair to the other children who never wanted any part of this.

The True Ending

Eruto was the one who came up with the idea of Chara freeing the human souls to close their redemption arc. My first instinct was to argue against it; after all, freeing the souls meant there was no chance of breaking the barrier in the near future. But in this AU, breaking the barrier was NEVER the goal. It was a part of Chara’s goal, and that goal is what caused them to commit terrible crimes and emotionally abuse everyone around them. In order to show that Chara had truly changed, they had to let go of the souls (and Asriel) of their own free will.

This ask took me back to 2018 when everyone had so many theories about the timeline. (We even had a tag just for time theories.) Here’s the short answer:

It’s not an oversight. In this AU, there is a huge time discrepancy between the Surface and the Underground. This is because Chara’s reloads ONLY effect the Underground. Chara rewound time SO much that by the time Frisk fell it was 2112 on the Surface and 2035 in the Underground. Good job, Chara.

So Chara was born in 1999 (one year after the Nose Nuzzling competition), and fell into the Underground in 2012. They spent almost their whole life messing up time down there.

Frisk was born in 2100 and climbed Mt Ebott in 2112 (exactly 100 years after Chara!). When Frisk fell, they fell into an Underground that was only in the year 2035.

As for the Royal Guards, canonically we don’t know exactly how old they are, but they are probably over 100 years old! In our AU they are about 70 years younger.

Good eye. Originally we were going to say that Frisk never turned back time in that year, but as disciplined as Frisk is, it just seemed unrealistic. If you have the power, something is going to happen that you can’t help but undo.

The first time they turned back time was when they were playing with some friends after school in Waterfall. The kids were jumping off of a rocky overhang into a deep pool of water. One of the monsters was too scared to jump, so Frisk gave them a playful push. Unfortunately, this did not work as intended and the monster hit the side of the cave wall on the way down. They were injured (not killed) and Frisk felt awful. They undid the whole day and stayed home out of guilt. They struggled to decide on whether that was a justified use of their power, and told themself they wouldn’t use it to escape the consequences of their actions again.

Thanks for joining the stream! The “I already ruined so much” line is intentionally cryptic, but what Frisk meant is that they feel responsible for their own parents’ deaths. When Frisk overhears the Dreemurrs speculating that Frisk had abusive parents, the guilt of both indirectly causing their parents to die AND giving the Dreemurrs the wrong idea about them is a terrible burden to bear.