Matt Gertz at MMFA:
Donald Trumpâs flailing performance at Tuesday nightâs debate triggered a multiday right-wing freakout at the ABC News moderators, punctuated by calls from the former president and his allies to target the network and its parent company with a regulatory crackdown, congressional investigation, and even prosecutions. Itâs a dark preview of the authoritarian tactics they could use if Trump returns to the White House and carries out his stated desire to retaliate against news outlets whose coverage displeases him. Trump used Tuesdayâs opportunity to address a massive national audience at the debate to spew nonsense incomprehensible to people who arenât familiar with the deep lore of the right-wing fever swamps and repeatedly take the bait offered by Vice President Kamala Harris. The result was such a disaster for Trumpâs campaign that he quickly called off future debates.
Trumpâs right-wing media allies reacted to his disastrous performance in real time by lashing out at ABC News moderators David Muir and Linsey Davis, who fact-checked the former president on a handful of occasions. While debate moderators typically come in for criticism from pundits who take issue with how they handled the high-profile job, it is difficult to blame Muir or Davis for a candidate picking up a racist and false fourthhand internet rumor about Haitian immigrants in Ohio and declaring, âTheyâre eating the dogs, the people that came in, theyâre eating the cats, theyâre eating the pets of the people that live there.â Moreover, the rightâs discussion quickly blew past mere critiques of ABCâs performance to far-reaching conspiracy theories about its purportedly corrupt behavior and calls for government retribution against the network. âRemove ABCâs broadcast license and criminally charge the moderators and executives for campaign finance fraud,â Sean Davis, CEO of the right-wing digital outlet The Federalist, declared on X the night of the debate. Trump himself began calling for the stripping of ABCâs broadcast license the following morning.
âABC took a big hit last night,â he said in an interview on Fox Newsâ Fox & Friends. âI mean, to be honest, they're a news organization. They have to be licensed to do it. They ought to take away their license for the way they did that.â Trumpâs remarks drew cheers from MAGA figures like Laura Loomer, who posted that âABC News deserves to be INVESTIGATED.â
[...] Trumpâs call for retribution has support from some Republican legislators. Sen. Roger Marshall (R-KS) said he would demand from ABC News and the Harris campaign âall correspondence, records, and potential coordination between the two parties ahead of Tuesdayâs presidential debate,â while Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT) is threatening to âre-examine the lawsâ he claims allow âthe leftâs near-complete domination of broadcast TVâ. Meanwhile, Trumpists like Eric Metaxas and Hugh Hewitt are floating boycotts of ABC parent company Disney, and Mark Penn wants an independent review of ABCâs internal communications to assess whether the network was ârigging the outcome of this debate.â
The credibility of Trumpâs call to strip ABCâs license is unclear. The Federal Communications Commission does not license broadcast networks â but it does license individual broadcast stations, including the eight owned and operated directly by ABC and the hundreds of additional affiliates. FCC Chairwoman Jessica Rosenworcel, a Biden appointee, responded to Trumpâs call by suggesting it runs afoul of the First Amendment, and Ajit Pai, her Trump-appointed predecessor, offered a similar response when Trump called for retaliation against NBC as president. That said, one of the goals of the Heritage Foundationâs Project 2025 is to ensure future Trump appointees are willing to prioritize his personal whims. Moreover, Trumpâs eagerness to use such tactics to halt critical coverage â and the rightâs support for them â is a dire sign for the future, even if the specific deployment of retaliatory FCC licensing decisions doesnât work out.
The right-wing whining about ABC's moderating of the debate on Tuesday is part of their authoritarian war on the freedom of the press, especially if Donald Trump gets back in office.
