( Creepypasta question ) I saw one of your post with a Male!Reader point of view of how a male would handle being in the mansion. But how would the other proxies and the other creeps find out that Male!Reader is bi/Gay and has a crush on them. Would they react negatively? Positive? Or both?. Also I love your writing You deserve snacks
Aww,thank you!
Creepypasta Confession Headcanons [Male!Reader]
Warnings: homophobia and a little suggestive in Masky's part
Masky
Disgusted and aggresive at first. After he spills out his entire vocabulary of insults,his brain starts to slowly work. Is he confused? Is the closet glass? Is the tought of him being on top of another male turning his ego on fire? Perhaps you're his free card of trying new things as long as you keep your mouth shut about it with others and open when you're with him. This crush of yours is also beneficial to him,he will use it to his advantage to have an extra hand to help him out with missions and other extra help to get what he wants in the mansion.
Hoodie
He would already know. His ability to read people is better than his ability to let go of opportunities. Much like Masky,he would use your crush to his advantage to get you to do things for him. He will give you false hope for a relationship and might even be passive aggressive by telling you that the others will be completely repulsed if you would confess yourself to them. You're lucky he's the one to accept you,now,wouldn't you help him with the tasks The Operator gave him?
Toby
Confused. He had a lot of crushes in his childhood but their faces are blurred. He might've liked a boy back in High School that looked just like you. Or was it a girl? Either way,the tought that of someone,anyone,likes him is giving him a sense of belonging. He suddenly doesn't mind if Masky will catch the two of you or if the whole mansion will know. Someone likes him and that means the world to him.
Clockwork
Her words doesn't match her feelings of acceptance towards you. Don't take her inappropriate questions as insults,she means no harm,really! Much like some other creep,she would suggest to keep your sexuality a secret in here tough.
Jane
She's okay with you,after all she's into girls herself. You might even form a friendship with her if your romantic feelings are not as strong as your need to have an ally in this mansion. If your heart betrays your brain then she would most definitely keep her distance to not give you false hope.
Liu
Empathetic. He would STRONGLY suggest you to keep your sexuality a secret in this hell hole tough. Sully would be a problem,a really big problem if you aren't good at fighting. Despite Liu's advice,his other personality might snitch on you to cause harm but don't worry,as long as the true owner of the body takes over you have an ally with you.
Jeff
Flattered? Offended? Confused?? He would think he's the hottest shit in the world after another man just confessed to him but why would a man confess to him? "Heck yeah I attract both genders"
Jeff would throw some casual homophobic slurs but with a friendly tone instead of being aggressive,as if the two of you are friends. He's passive and might be a little curious about his sexuality as well,if you do really like him then you might have a chance after dealing with the 10 walls you have to break to get to his heart.
Eyeless Jack
Sad. You just ruined his day. He hates himself enough to push you as far away from him as possible,not because he's disgusted by your identity but because he doesn't want a human to love him. He would try to keep you away by ignoring you and might even fake some crude remarks,not because he's hateful towards you but because he doesn't want to get you involved with him.
Nina
She likes people who likes her. Even if she didn't have feelings for you before,she would definitely start to develop some after your confession. She's the most understanding of your sexual orientation and would most likely think you're her soulmate one week into the relationship.
Ben
I headcanon him as either Bisexual/Curious. He would poke a shit ton of jokes and reference from who knows what cursed piece of media he saw over the internet to you. Altough he's a cheeky bastard,he means no real harm to you.
