Wanted to know your thoughts on (for lack of better terminology, I apologise) “using the unique traits of being d/Deaf as an everyday ‘super power’
eg. Being able to lip read a conversation through a glass window, which reveals vital info to advance the plot. Or communicating via sign between prisoners held captive
just wanted to check this isn’t seen as a harmful or cliched trope? I remember a few years I saw a tv drama that received good reviews about a deaf lady (played by a deaf actress) who gets brought in by police to lip read a crusty CCTV recording
Hi!
So in the Deaf community, these perks are called Deaf Gain :) [smile face] They're things d/Deafness and Deaf culture provide that hearing people don't get. That includes talking underwater or over long distances/through barriers, not being bothered by loud environments, and chatting while eating.
Communicating while being held prisoner is not one of them. Deaf people signing is often treated as aggression or gang signs, which wouldn't help in a hostage situation. Especially taking into consideration that a kidnapper would likely wear a mask, Deaf people are at high risk for violence in that type of scenario.
The problem with something like lipreading crusty CCTV footage is that lipreading is a game of guesswork at the best of times. Deaf people aren't magic lip readers, we just get a lot more practice than most hearing people, since we rely on it for daily conversation.
Out of context, it's hard to catch more than a few words. And it is discernibly harder any time your hearing changes, because you're getting different auditory clues. Even the best lip readers struggle if there are multiple speakers, the mouth is obscured, or the lighting is wrong. I don't think anyone would actually do well at lipreading grainy security camera footage.
The important thing to remember is Deaf people aren't superhuman. A lot of us are DeafBlind or DeafDisabled. There are perks to knowing and using sign language, and there are perks to Deaf culture, but they're not superpowers.
Mod Rock



















