Caught in the middle
Summary: Toby and Cody are sent out on a recruiting mission. āFind the girl and bring her back hereā The Operator said. It was simple. Finding themselves now enrolled as college students as a cover up they find the girl. But, little do they know thereās so much more then meets the eye.
Warnings: female reader, she wears glasses, reader kinda has a pre established story but itās not an oc, mentions of abused (reader and Toby), mentions of murder, Iām bad at writing stutters so please give me tips, also tips on how to write tics would be helpful, fanfic logic on how college works (aka itās poorly written), I do believe thatās it!
āI canāt believe we have to do this.ā
āQuit yer bitchinā. Th-The Operator said w-we have to do it, so weāll do it.ā
āDoesnāt mean I have to like it.ā
Cody retorts, shrugging Tobyās hand off his shoulder. He looks around the campus. Watching as all the students bustle around heading towards their classes. He rolls his eyes at the jocks tossing footballs as the cheerleaders giggle like bimbos.
The only thing worse than highschool is college. Why? Because now their all legal and can fuck without hiding it. Students make out in the hallways and girls suck dick in the boys bathroom. College is basically highschool but with less strict teachers and way more drugs.
The two boys never had much luck with school and socializing. Hence why theyāre in the business theyāre in now. They were often mocked and made fun of. The laughing stock of the school.
Toby was often bullied for his stutters while Cody was often called a geek for his interests in science. No one ever understood them, until they found each other. From then on if someone laughed it would fall on deaf ears. The pair didnāt need anybody but each other. They were brothers, and they had a bond stronger than diamonds.
Their brotherhood was stronger than most real families. Not to say that the bond they had wasnāt real. Itās just they werenāt blood relatives. Toby had found Cody one night while wandering through the woods and well, the rest is history.
They had been close since the beginning. Always looking out for one another. Always making sure the other was safe. They were best friends. Not anything or anyone could get between them.
Until her.
The pair walked down the hall to the school office. There at a desk sat a young woman typing on a computer. Her eyes squinted at the screen as she read every word she wrote. Toby and Cody share a glance before looking back at the girl. Was this really her?
The operator had sent the two boys out to find her. A girl he had been trying to recruit. Heād shown the boys a picture and sent them on their way. Giving them a new life and new identities just for the sake of the mission.
Toby clears his throat to grab the girl's attention. She jumps slightly at the sudden noise, so lost in her train of thought she didnāt see the two boys standing in front of her. Cody speaks first resting his arms on the counter as he sits down in one of the chairs in front of the desk.
āWe were told to come here and check in. Weāre new.ā He says blankly, leaning back in his seat as his knees part in a man's spread. The girl's eyes darted from each boy back to her computer screen. āNames?ā Her voice was light and calm as she spoke.
āTobias and Cody Rogers.ā She nods briefly before typing away at her computer. Her eyes scan the screen as her glasses slide to the tip of her nose. Toby and Cody share another glance. Secretly communicating through their eyes.
āYouāre the Colorado boys, right?ā She asks, looking up from the screen to meet their eyes. Still typing away at the computer as she brings up their student portfolio. āWe f-famous or somethinā?ā Tobias retorts flatly.
She bites back a smirk at his words, looking back at her computer screen. āNah, Ms. Davis told me you guys would be coming in either today or tomorrow.ā āSo, weāre famous to you.ā āTry āinfamousā.ā
Cody smirks quizzically at her words, tilting his head ever so slightly. āWhatās that supposed to mean?ā āOh nothing, just that you have a bit of reputation from your old school.ā āOh yeah? Like what?ā Cody leans forward, resting his arms on his knees.
āLike vandalizing school grounds. It says in your files that you sprayed painted..dicks all over your old school. As well as āI <3 MILFs ā
ā¦
Stupid fucking elf. Of course heād say all that. Shouldnāt never let that bastard be in charge of making their new identities.
āWe were f-framed.ā Toby says through gritted teeth, meanwhile Cody rolls his eyes and pulls out his phone. Most likely yelling at Ben for his ridiculous comments. āYeah, totally.ā The girl smiles, raising her eyebrows teasingly.
She stands up and walks towards the printer on the other side of the room. She grabs two papers before rounding the counter and standing in front of the two boys. āHere are your schedules. I can show you your classes before first period starts if youād like?ā
The boys look at each other for a moment before looking back at the girl. Codyās expression holds a hint of amusement while Toby looks intrigued. Although he's been silent throughout most of this ordeal he's been watching. Observing the girl and her mannerisms.
He watches the way she chews on her nails, biting and picking at the skin so much that it looks raw. He watches the way she pulls at her hair, so much so that her ends are split and uneven. He watches the way her knee bounces rapidly. The way she always makes sure her sleeves are pulled down all the way. The way she overtly conscious not to take up too much space.
It was all things he did back when he was still at school. Back when he still lived at home. Toby and Cody have a lot of things in common. But, Cody would never understand what it was like to be physically abused.
Codyās birth mother was shitty. A criminal who cares more about scheming than raising her own son. But, Cody got out. Went to an orphanage for a little while before being adopted. He got a good father, a nice one.
Heās the reason why Cody is the way he is now, why heās a genius. Toby never got that. Sure, he had a good mom and great older sister. But, Tobiasās father was a scum of the earth. A piece of shit abuser who thought it was okay to hit women.
Toby could handle the beat downs from his father. But to put his hands on his mother and sister? God, it pissed him off to no end. That's why he killed him. To save what was left of his family.
āSure, lead th-the way.ā Toby says, his expression softening ever so slightly. The girl nods and hands them their class schedules. She leads them out of the office and down the hall. āThe school tried to keep most of your classes together, as per requested.ā She begins, āI think thereās only a few you donāt share only because of your selected majors.ā
She continues down the hall, pointing out classes. āThis is Ms. Meyers classroom, this is your first period math class which you share. Then, over here is Mr. Andrewās class which is your shared second period literature class.ā The girl smiles softly, waving at teachers as she passes them. āI actually have Mr. Andrew for my second period as well, heās very nice.ā
āOver here is Mr. Austin, this is yours and my own 3rd history class whichāā āāWe share?ā āYes.ā She laughs softly as she turns down a second hall. āThis is our science hall. Cody this is where most of your classes will be because of your major. Sadly, the two of you donāt share a science class because youāre on different levels.ā
The girl then turns to point to a hall adjacent to the science hall. āHowever, Workshop is right next to it where you, Toby, will be spending most of your classes because of your major. So, because of how you arranged your schedules, youāll always be close to each other. The school tried their best to accommodate your needs.ā
Cody tilts his head curiously. āOur needs?ā āYeah, in your notes it said the two of you have separation anxiety. That itād be best to keep you two together. You guys also share a dorm, just the two of you.ā She says, gesturing towards the exit door near the path to the dorm building.
The two boys share a look. Another thing that Ben put it, although probably for the sake of mission it still felt like a jab to their codependency on each other. Cody nods firmly, speaking once more. āRight, we appreciate it.ā The girl smiles and claps her hands together.
āWell, first period will start soon. And my first period is on the other side of the building so I will leave you guys here. After all your classes come back to the front office and ask for me. Iāll show you to your dorms. I hope you guys have a good first day!ā She smiles softly before beginning to walk away.
āH-Hey, w-w-wait!ā Toby calls out. She turns and looks at him with a quizzical pout. āH-How will w-we know who t-t-to ask for?ā Her eyes widen slightly before she begins to laugh, shaking her head softly. āRight! I totally forgot. My nameās y/n. Itās nice to meet you both.ā
She says, waving to the two boys before continuing down the hall. Toby and Cody share another look. Smirking to themselves. This mission just got a lot more interesting. Maybe it wonāt be so bad after all.
















