Beneath the Smile
Joel x Y/N Fanfiction
Y/N POV
The air in my apartment was still. Too still. The kind of quiet that felt heavy, suffocating, as though something unseen was lurking just beyond the shadows. I couldnât shake the feeling of being watched, even though I was alone. I glanced at my phone, my fingers hovering over the screen. It had been days since I last saw Joel. Days since he had started acting⌠strange.
I had known Joel for yearsâever since we met at the precinct where he worked as a cop. He was the kind of guy who kept his emotions hidden behind a calm, cool exterior, but he was kind. Dependable. Someone you could trust with your life. We had been close for a long time, skirting the edges of something more than friendship. But lately, there was something different about him. Something that sent a chill down my spine every time I saw him.
It started with the small thingsâodd comments, distant stares, and then there was the smile. That eerie, unnerving smile that didnât reach his eyes. It was like his face had become a mask, hiding something dark beneath it.
I shook my head, trying to push the unsettling thoughts away. Maybe it was just the stress of his job, the cases he worked onâespecially that last one. I had overheard bits and pieces of it, some weird chain of suicides, people claiming to see something before they died. It sounded insane, but Joel had been different ever since.
My phone buzzed, snapping me out of my thoughts. It was Joel. A message.
âI need to see you.â
There was no explanation, no reassurance, just those four words. A shiver ran down my spine, but I texted back quickly.
âCome over. Iâll be here.â
Joel POV
I sat in the car outside Y/Nâs apartment, gripping the steering wheel so hard my knuckles turned white. My heart pounded in my chest, the rhythm erratic, as if something inside me was trying to crawl out, take control. It had been days since Iâd felt like myself, since Iâd felt human. Ever since I saw itâthe thing that shouldnât exist, the thing that was now haunting me.
It started after that damned case. Rose⌠poor Rose. She had been a friend, a colleague. I couldnât get the image of her face out of my mindâthe way she smiled before she died, like she was relieved, like it was all part of some sick joke only she understood.
And then it happened to me. I saw it.
I glanced in the rearview mirror, half-expecting to see the thing lurking behind me, its twisted grin hovering just above my shoulder. But there was nothing. Not this time. I wasnât sure how much longer I could outrun it.
Y/N was the only person I could think of. The only person I trusted. She didnât know what was happening to me, and I didnât want to drag her into this nightmare, but I couldnât stay away. I needed her.
Taking a deep breath, I got out of the car and headed up to her apartment, each step feeling heavier than the last. When I reached her door, I hesitated, my hand hovering over the doorknob. Could I really do this? Could I really expose her to the horror that had taken over my life?
I knocked, the sound sharp in the silence of the hallway.
The door opened almost immediately, and there she was. Y/N. Her eyes widened in concern when she saw me, her soft features creased with worry.
âJoel⌠you look terrible,â she said, her voice full of concern, but she stepped aside, letting me in without hesitation.
I stepped into the apartment, the familiar scent of her space calming me, if only for a moment. But the darkness was still there, lingering just beneath the surface, waiting to claw its way out.
Y/N POV
The moment Joel stepped into my apartment, I knew something was wrong. He looked exhausted, like he hadnât slept in days. His skin was pale, his eyes sunken, and there was a wildness about him that made my heart ache with worry.
âJoel, whatâs going on? Youâre scaring me,â I said softly, trying to reach out to him, but he stepped back, avoiding my touch.
âI canât⌠I donât know how to explain it,â he muttered, running a hand through his hair, his voice low and shaky. âItâs like⌠thereâs something following me. Something I canât get rid of.â
I frowned, stepping closer to him despite the warning bells going off in my head. âWhat do you mean? Is someone threatening you?â
He shook his head, that eerie smile tugging at the corner of his lips for just a second before vanishing, like he was fighting it. âItâs not someone. Itâs⌠something. Iâve been seeing things, Y/N. Things I canât explain. And Iââ
Suddenly, he grabbed my hand, his grip tight, desperate. âI donât know how long I have left before it⌠before it gets me.â
His words sent a cold chill through me. âJoel, youâre not making sense. Whatâs going to get you?â
Before he could answer, he flinched, his gaze darting to the corner of the room. His eyes widened in terror, but when I turned to look, there was nothing there. Just empty space.
âJoel?â My voice trembled, fear creeping into my chest.
He pulled his hand away from mine, backing up until his back hit the wall. His breathing grew ragged, his eyes locked on something invisible. Then, slowly, that twisted, unnatural smile spread across his face againâonly this time, it didnât go away.
âJoel, stop,â I whispered, my heart pounding in my chest. âYouâre scaring me.â
But he didnât respond. His eyes were glassy now, fixed on something I couldnât see, and that smile⌠it wasnât his. It didnât belong to him. It was like something else had taken over.
Joel POV
I could feel it. It was inside me now. Crawling under my skin, twisting my thoughts, making me see things that werenât thereâor maybe they were there, but not for her to see. I didnât want to smile. I didnât want to show her the thing that had been haunting me, but I couldnât stop it.
I looked at Y/N, my heart breaking. I didnât want to hurt her, but I was losing control. The smileâit wasnât mine anymore. It was its.
âIâm sorry,â I whispered, my voice barely my own. âI didnât mean to bring this to you.â
She took a cautious step toward me, her eyes wide with fear but filled with determination. âJoel, we can get help. You donât have to do this alone.â
Help? There was no help for me. Not now. Not when it had its claws deep inside me. But maybe⌠maybe I could keep her safe. Maybe I could keep the thing from getting to her.
I grabbed her shoulders, pulling her close, my voice urgent. âYou need to leave. Get out of here. Donât come back.â
She shook her head, her hands gripping my arms. âNo, Joel, Iâm not leaving you like this. We can figure this out.â
The thing inside me laughed, a low, hollow sound that echoed in my head. It was getting stronger, its influence suffocating. I could feel my body betraying me, moving against my will. My hands dropped to my sides, and I took a step back.
âNo,â I said, my voice trembling. âItâs too late.â
Y/N POV
Panic gripped my chest as I watched Joel, his body rigid, his face twisted in that horrifying smile. It wasnât him anymore. I could feel it. Something dark, something evil had taken hold of him, and I didnât know how to fight it.
âJoel, please,â I begged, my voice breaking. âYouâre stronger than this. You can fight it.â
But his eyes⌠his eyes werenât his anymore. They were empty, cold. The warmth that I had known in him for so long was gone, replaced by something monstrous. His lips parted, but the words that came out werenât his own.
âIt wants you too,â he said, his voice low, taunting. âYou canât run from it.â
My heart raced, fear clawing at my throat. I wanted to run, to scream, but I couldnât leave him like this. Not Joel. Not the man I loved.
Suddenly, the lights flickered, plunging the room into momentary darkness. When they came back on, Joel was standing unnervingly close, his face inches from mine, that haunting smile stretched impossibly wide across his lips.
âYou should have left when you had the chance,â he whispered, his breath cold against my skin.
I stumbled back, my heart pounding in my ears. The room felt like it was closing in, the shadows creeping closer, swallowing us both.
And then, just as quickly as it had started, Joelâs body went slack. The smile disappeared. He collapsed to the floor, his chest heaving as he fought to regain control.
âY/NâŚ,â he gasped, his voice weak. âIâm⌠sorry.â
But I knew. Deep down, I knew this wasnât over. The thing wasnât gone. It was lurking, waiting, and it wouldnât stop until it had taken everything.
Joel POV
I felt the darkness
slipping back, retreating for now, but I knew it would return. It always did. Y/N was crouched beside me, her hand on my shoulder, tears in her eyes.
âIâm sorry,â I whispered again, my voice hoarse. âI couldnât stop it.â
She shook her head, wiping away a tear. âWeâll find a way. Weâll figure this out.â
But I didnât believe her. How could I? The thing inside me was getting stronger. It had taken Rose. It had taken others. And soon, it would take me too.
As I looked up at her, the last remnants of control slipping from my grasp, I forced one final smileâa real smile. One that was mine.
âRun,â I whispered, before the darkness swallowed me whole.
Y/N POV
His smileâit was real for a split second, before that twisted, eerie grin took over again. And this time, I knew there was nothing I could do.
I backed away slowly, my heart breaking as I watched the man I loved disappear behind a mask of evil.
And then, I turned and ran.
But I could still feel it. The smile. Watching. Waiting.
And I knew, deep down, that it would never let me go.
End










