If you’re from this corner of East Tennessee, then you might be familiar with the folklore of this rather ominously named region of the Citico Creek Wilderness Area–Jeffrey’s Hell. Jeffrey’s Hell is located opposite from Fall Branch Falls, ironically descending into a rhododendron and mountain laurel infested thicket that we locals refer to as “hells”. Technically speaking, Fall Branch Falls lies within this strange realm, a jungle of sorts in the higher elevations of southeastern Tennessee.
According to local legend, Jeffrey’s Hell received its rather unusual name after an unexplained disappearance that occurred sometime during the 1800s. An ornery old man by the name of Jeffrey went hunting in the Citico Creek Wilderness Area one day with a buddy of his, whose name is never mentioned. After a day of hunting, the two men were getting ready to turn around and head for home. However, Old Man Jeffrey’s hunting dogs were nowhere to be found, lost within the deep tangle of the hells, their barks echoing throughout the mountain. Understandably upset, Old Man Jeffery begins to frantically call for his dogs, but no avail, his dogs never returned. Bound and determined to find them, he resolves to find them himself, despite the warnings of his friend, who reassured him that the dogs would eventually find their way home.
As he walked into the dense tangle of mountain laurel, Old Man Jeffrey turned around to face his friend for one last time, his words seemingly sealing his fate,
“I’ll go to Hell and back to find these dogs if it’s the last thing I do!”
That was the last time anyone had seen Old Man Jeffrey. His body was never found, perhaps swallowed whole by the very hell he damned himself into.
They say that this area is haunted by the spirit of Old Man Jeffrey, who searches endlessly in vain for his missing hunting dogs. Some say that he can be spotted, carrying a lantern on the night of a full moon. Others say that his frantic calls for his dogs can be heard, sounding throughout the laurel thickets as the muffled sound of barking can be heard in the distance.