I really donât like talking about social justice, and I certainly have never written a post myself relating to the subject, but letâs git er dun, boi.
In case you havenât heard, a site called HeartMob recently opened, which aims to âsave the Internet.â How does it try to accomplish this, you ask? By attempting to provide support for people who have been victims of online harassment.
This isnât necessarily a bad idea, but their promo video certainly raises a few questions.
First of all, anyone who has been on Facebook (the social network the person in the video is apparently using) for more than a year can tell you that harassment to that sort of degree is almost nonexistent. Can anyone tell me why a group of people would explicitly target someone on a social network which requires you to use your full name? Iâve never even seen someone commenting on someoneâs selfie with something like âyouâre uglyâ or âplease stop taking pictures of yourselfâ. The worst case of online harassment Iâve ever witnessed is the case of Zamii, which ironically happened on Tumblr.
Second, if you listen to the guy talking whoâs supposed to be harassing her, he says âI know where you live.â If someone is making threats against you, IRL or online, and you feel that the threats are legitimate (and that you have a good sense of the culture of the site you are on, someone on /pol/ saying that theyâre going to kill every LGBT person they meet is obviously bluffing), then you should definitely seek help from the police, and report the person to the admin of whatever site they made the threat on. But on HeartMob, even though you can include âThreatsâ in the case of harassment, whatâs the point? What are the staff at HeartMob going to do about it? Are they going to politely ask the perpetrator to stop? Your first stop for reporting threats of violence should be the police, not HeartMob.
Lastly, it seems that HeartMob is the very definition of a hugbox. That meaning, someone says something mean to you, you put up a post about it, and people that know nothing about you say things like âDonât worry, youâre awesome!â It just seems so empty, what else would they say on a site meant for positvity? They know absolutely nothing about what you look like, your interests, your friends, or your personality. And while I donât think that people you only know online are incapable of cheering you up, I wouldnât want my first interaction with someone to be âDonât worry youâre beautiful.â If youâre feeling down and want some support, I feel that itâs a lot better to get support from someone you have a relationship with, either IRL or online.
Also, this site could actually be kind of dangerous in a number of ways. First, there are undoubtedly going to be trolls on this site, who will probably go a bit further than telling people that theyâre ugly. Second, someone who decides to do quite a bit of âsupportâ posts on the site might start thinking that theyâre capable of helping people with things like depression. I donât really need to discuss this any further to show why itâs a really, really bad, albeit unlikely, situation.